When Gravity Fails

When I took economics classes lo! those many years ago, the Phillips Curve, the relationship between inflation and unemployment proposed by New Zealand economist A. W. Phillips based on his study of about 90 years of British history, was taught as gospel. It was considered a force of nature, as sure as gravity.

Like all economic laws, it was a rule of thumb and like all rules of thumb it holds true until it doesn’t. The Phillips Curve began to break down somewhat after I left school and for the last 25 years it’s been on life support. As Michael Owyang notes at the St. Louis Fed:

Over the years, economists have discovered that the Phillips curve appears to shift. These shifts are typically attributed to changes in inflation expectations and were thought to have contributed to the period of high inflation and high unemployment in the late 1970s.

Recently, economists have questioned whether the Phillips curve relationship has broken down. As the unemployment rate has fallen during the recovery from the Great Recession, the inflation rate has stayed low, below even the Federal Reserve’s target.

He goes on to propose some explanations for why the Phillips Curve just isn’t particularly predictive.

Comes Robert Samuelson to put in his two cents about the Phillips Curve in his column at the Washington Post:

Economists from the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) in Basel, Switzerland — a bank for government central banks — find that the pass-through from wage increases to price increases has weakened. If this is confirmed and continues, it implies that inflation will remain tame for some time even if the economy continues to grow.

Just what caused the breakdown of the old Phillips Curve relationship isn’t clear. Nor is it clear whether the shift is permanent. Arguably, it might just reflect an ongoing hangover from the Great Recession. Firms raise prices reluctantly, because they fear losing sales.

In a public presentation, Claudio Borio, head of the BIS’s Monetary and Economic Department, offered another explanation. It’s globalization: the expansion of so-called global value chains — supply chains that manufacture components for a final product in many countries.

Facing higher costs, companies can relocate production to countries with cheap labor or superior production technology, a.k.a. “automation.” In the past quarter-century, there has been a vast expansion of global labor markets, Borio noted. Businesses that are mobile have undermined workers’ bargaining power.

A solution better than trying to “calculate a new Phillips Curve” might be to realize that moving a single country’s economy in one direction or another, rather as a sailor changes the direction of his boat by tacking, is impossible in a global economy. The U. S. isn’t just importing goods from China; it’s importing deflation which the Chinese exchange for inflation. Now repeat that 200 times with 200 different actors moving in 200 different directions for 200 different reasons.

0 comments

Humans Don’t Make Purely Objective Judgments

In his latest Washington Post column Charles Lane makes a proposal I can support wholeheartedly:

We need a more intellectually honest minimum wage debate, one that acknowledges both the intuitive moral appeal of preventing exploitation of the least-skilled, lowest-paid workers — and the countervailing risk of a wage so high that it harms the very people it’s supposed to help.

and then proceeds to surround it with a barrel of claptrap, starting here:

The goal: a relatively objective process, as opposed to just picking a number that sounds good to Bernie Sanders or, for that matter, the restaurant lobby.

Undemocratic, you say? The author of the federal minimum wage, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, believed that this was an issue best left to technocrats. His first proposal for a minimum wage called on the Labor Department to fine-tune it, industry by industry.

Congress rejected that idea, sparing the country a bureaucratic nightmare while creating a political one: a federal minimum wage that can be changed only if lawmakers act.

FDR’s methods were clumsy, but his instinct was sound: If government is going to make a rule for the labor market, the least it can do is base it on facts about the labor market.

Congress should benchmark the minimum-wage level to historical data, then connect it to an independent adjustment factor, so that when it rises, it does so consistently and in response to shifts in the economy — not the political winds.

A basic fact about the “labor market” is that it doesn’t exist. What exist instead are multiple labor markets. Just as housing costs, health care costs, energy costs, and the price of an avocado vary from state to state and from county to county within states, so do labor costs.

Another basic fact about the price of labor: it varies based both on supply and demand.

Sadly, there is no practical, objective, non-political way to determine a just minimum wage for the entire country and simply trying to do so is simultaneously fatuous and itself an exercise in politics and posturing.

Let me propose a radical alternative: allow cities and counties to set their own minimum wages. That, too, will be agenda-driven fraught with bias, politics, and preconceived notions. That’s how it is when such things are set by human beings rather than archangels. The best you can hope for is that when there are multiple minimum wages, set based on local conditions, on average they will be just based on local conditions.

1 comment

Artificial Leaves

Scientific American reports on another example of the sort of technology I’ve promoted in the past as a strategy for removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere:

Recently, one group has demonstrated that it is possible to combine water splitting and CO2 conversion into fuels in one system with high efficiency. In a June 2016 issue of Science, Daniel G. Nocera and Pamela A. Silver, both at Harvard University, and their colleagues reported on an approach to making liquid fuel (specifically fusel alcohols) that far exceeds a natural leaf’s conversion of carbon dioxide to carbohydrates. A plant uses just 1 percent of the energy it receives from the sun to make glucose, whereas the artificial system achieved roughly 10 percent efficiency in converting carbon dioxide to fuel, the equivalent of pulling 180 grams of carbon dioxide from the air per kilowatt-hour of electricity generated.

The investigators paired inorganic, solar water-splitting technology (designed to use only biocompatible materials and to avoid creating toxic compounds) with microbes specially engineered to produce fuel, all in a single container. Remarkably, these metabolically engineered bacteria generated a wide variety of fuels and other chemical products even at low CO2 concentrations. The approach is ready for scaling up to the extent that the catalysts already contain cheap, readily obtainable metals. But investigators still need to greatly increase fuel production. Nocera says the team is working on prototyping the technology and is in partnership discussions with several companies.

I wish these project were closer to practical deployment. The key to these technologies is more often making them practical rather than making them work.

2 comments

Round 2

Round 2 in the major outbreak of “ransomware” attacks that began last month with the “WannaCry” virus seems to have begun. Reuters reports a second spate of attacks, whose targets include multi-national companies and governments, mostly in Europe but extending as far as to India:

A major global cyber attack disrupted computers at Russia’s biggest oil company, Ukrainian banks and multinational firms with a virus similar to the ransomware that infected more than 300,000 computers last month .

The rapidly spreading cyber extortion campaign, which began on Tuesday, underscored growing concerns that businesses have failed to secure their networks from increasingly aggressive hackers, who have shown they are capable of shutting down critical infrastructure and crippling corporate and government networks.

I’m afraid these sort of attacks will continue until companies and governments start taking them seriously. What would “taking them seriously” entail? First, there needs to be a general recognition that the flaws in Microsoft operating systems that leave systems running them vulnerable to attack are a failure of workmanship on Microsoft’s part which they should not be allowed to weasel out of.

Second, a cyber attack against thousands of targets is the equivalent of a serious terrorist attack.

Third, governments should get out of the business of producing malware. There’s considerable evidence that these ransomware attacks are based on code developed by governments. Without the incredible resources that governments can devote to such uses, attacks of this sophistication would probably not be possible and, as I’ve pointed out before, once the’re in the wild you’ve lost control over them. Sadly, governments have shown little ability to secure their own intellectual property.

As globally connected networks of computers insinuate themselves into every aspect of our lives including our homes and our cars, we’ll become increasingly vulnerable. The time to start taking the threat seriously is now.

0 comments

What’s the U. S. Interest in Syria?

Speaking of interests and threats at RealClearDefense Bonnie Kristian argues that we don’t have much interest in Syria and the best thing we can do is get the heck out of the way there:

The United States’ military intervention in Syria is a dangerous game indeed, creating a real risk of great power conflict with Russia and her allies. If that hazard was not obvious before last week, it is glaring now.

It is also unnecessary, for the United States has no vital national interest at stake in Syria. View the situation without the world police glasses the Washington establishment has worn for decades, and this becomes evident. The conflict in Syria is a monstrous fight, but that does not make it our fight, a point President Trump once realized. “What will we get for bombing Syria besides more debt and a possible long-term conflict?” he asked on Twitter in 2013 with insight that seems to be missing today.

Nor is there a plausible path to anything resembling “victory” for the U.S., even the unlikely best-case scenario—a tidy defeat of ISIS and ouster of Assad achieved without tipping into war with Russia—would come at enormous human and financial cost; produce a new, debt-funded nation-building commitment of massive proportions; and, if recent misadventures in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Libya are any guide, settle into a destabilizing morass of power vacuum, proxy fighting, insurgency, and surge.

Turkey and our other NATO allies do have vital interests in Syria and I wish them well in pursuing them. Our present course of action which largely consists of trying to prolong the agonizing Syrian civil war is immoral, illegal, and against our national interest not to mention increasingly risky.

2 comments

Assessing the Threat

At The Conversation Ronald Suny assesses the threat that Russia poses to the United States:

In reality, the most powerful country in history and on the globe at the moment, the United States, faces a considerably weaker adversary in Russia.

The Kremlin spends about 10 percent of what the United States spends on defense (US$600 billion). The United States spends more on defense than the next eight countries combined.

Putin slashed military spending a few months ago by 25.5 percent, just as Trump plans to increase American defense spending by more than $54 billion.

Russia’s economy pales in comparison to America, Europe, Japan and China. It has an economy roughly the size of Italy’s, but must provide for a larger population, territory and defense budget.

It’s true that a somewhat weaker power can annoy, pressure or even harm a stronger power. And while Russia has a huge nuclear arsenal and impressive cyber capabilities, it is seriously outmatched by the United States in terms of influence and power. Obama referred to Russia as “a regional power,” and Putin thinks of America as a “global hegemon.” There are important truths in both of their statements.

The primary threat that Russia poses is to that American global hegemony which the United States has repeatedly abused over the period of the last 25 years. If we stopped interfering in Russian elections and behaving aggressively towards Russia, perhaps Russia would stop interfering in ours. At the very least we’d have a less mealy-mouthed basis for complaints about bad Russian behavior.

That’s the awful thing about trying to complain from the moral high ground. To do it credibly you’ve got to behave morally which does limit your freedom of action.

0 comments

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

Another Win – Trump and India PM Modi Speak At The White House 

 Michael Brown: Eternal Martyr 

Julian Assange: “Why The Democrat Party Is Doomed” 

 Collins, Rubio Help Muslims Pass Senate Resolution 118 to Criminalize Free Speech 

 Forum: What Is Your Reaction To The Special Elections 

 The Actual War On Women, Part 1 

 Whadd’ya Know…Illinois is Bankrupt!

 Answers to my questions about America’s opioid crisis 

 The Secret behind Amazon’s New Bestseller On Palestinian History

 The Democrat party is hamstrung because it can’t tell the truth about itself

 ReasonTV: College Students ‘Think Freedom is Not a Big Deal’ 

 Venezuela: Leopoldo Lopez cries out to wife he is being tortured

 [VIDEOS] Paul Joseph Watson on Muslims and Leftists 

 Israeli Envoy: Anti-Israel Campus Campaigns ‘A Real War’ 

 The Expanse: Forget Star Trek and Watch This Show

 At a University of California campus, learning a life lesson about socialism 

California travel ban: Blatant hypocrisy about LGBTQ (etc.) rights  

0 comments

Point/Counter-Point

At NRO Jonah Goldberg declaims:

Meanwhile, the Democrats know that Obamacare has been a huge albatross for their party and understand that the best thing that could happen for them is if the Republicans agreed to keep Obamacare in name (i.e., abandon the rhetoric of “repeal”) but do whatever is necessary to make the thing work. But the GOP is doing the opposite. It’s largely keeping Obamacare in terms of policy (at least the really popular parts) but rhetorically its claiming to destroy Obamacare utterly. So, both the Democrats and the Republicans end up claiming this is a repeal of Obamacare when it’s not. It’s all a war for the best spin, not the best policy.

to which Kevin Drum responds:

Would Democrats be willing to support some conservative priorities—tort reform, HSAs, block granting Medicaid—in return for this? Beats me. But Democrats have sure made it clear that keeping Obamacare and fixing it is what they want. If Republicans truly have any interest in this, they shouldn’t have any trouble finding willing listeners.

which would sound as though they’re in material agreement. Except for one small detail. Does Kevin have any proposal for “fixing” the ACA that doesn’t involve shoveling ever-increasing amounts of money at it? It seems to me that’s a basic problem. The system as constructed (not as envisioned but as constructed) isn’t stable.

10 comments

Avoiding Fanaticism

In the bitter controversy (again) over health care reform I am constantly reminded of George Santayana’s observation that fanaticism consists in redoubling your efforts when you have forgotten your aim.

Does anyone want health care insurance? Or is it, as I suppose, merely a means to an end? For that matter does anyone other than a few mentally ill people want health care?

I believe that what is wanted is more health not more care or more health care insurance and we’re failing miserably at that. That more insurance will lead to more health is an article of faith the rational basis for which is dwindling. And we haven’t even talked about iatrogenic death.

We are devoting enormous resources to health care. We should be getting a lot more for our money.

4 comments

The Four Horsemen

At the Washington Post Jackson Diehl laments the lack of attention that famine in Nigeria, Yemen, South Sudan, and Somalia is receiving from the rest of the world:

Still, it’s shocking that so little heed is being paid to what the United Nations says is the worst humanitarian crisis since 1945: the danger that about 20 million people in four countries will suffer famine in the coming months, and that hundreds of thousands of children will starve to death.

Not heard of this? That’s the problem. According to U.N. and private relief officials, efforts to supply enough food to stem the simultaneous crises in South Sudan, Somalia, Yemen and Nigeria are falling tragically short so far, in part because of inadequate funding from governments and private donors. Of the $4.9 billion sought in February by the U.N.’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) for immediate needs in those countries, just 39 percent had been donated as of last week.

Let’s turn to a NPR feature on the famines. What is famine?

A famine is when levels of malnutrition in the population have passed 30 percent, where people are actually starving and dying. And it is a sign of failure because in all these cases famine can be predicted. So if you kick in with aid early enough, you can prevent famine. Drought you can’t prevent, but famine you can prevent.

That’s true as far as it goes. Like defining smallpox as a bad rash that develops into fluid-filled blisters. You can’t define it adequately without talking about what causes it.

Famine is always and everywhere a failure of government. Either by action or inaction the government prevents food from getting to hungry people or people from fleeing the area of the famine. In all four of the countries mentioned there is civil war fomented by Islamist insurgencies. Either there is no government (as in Somalia) or the governments’ priorities are in fighting the Islamists rather than helping the victims of famine.

The Saudis’ fingerprints are everywhere in all four countries. Rich Saudis have supported radical imams who have preached violent jihad to their congregrations. They’re actually making war in Yemen. In Somalia their anti-terrorism activities are probably doing more harm than good. The Sudanese president who has fomented the famine in South Sudan has received substantial aid from the Saudis. And so on.

Actually fighting famine will require some hard realizations and harder decisions. We can’t end the famines in those countries just by supplying food aid. That would be like applying calamine lotion to smallpox pustules.

11 comments