Post-Christian

The only comment I have on the kerfuffle du jour is that it illustrates how post-Christian we are. My advice is from 1 Peter 3:9:

Do not repay evil with evil or insult with insult. On the contrary, repay evil with blessing, because to this you were called so that you may inherit a blessing.

I guess that’s for suckers.

7 comments

The New Inquisition

At Worldcrunch João Pereira Coutinho explains how today’s lack of moderation isn’t solely a quality of American politics:

Today, Tim Farron’s case demonstrates just how modern liberalism has turned into a form of religion. A form of inquisition too: Whoever doesn’t sing from the same hymn sheet is a heretic who deserves to burn in the flames of progressive vanity. Politics is not a place for consensus between distinct views of the common good. It is a courthouse where sinners have to confess their crimes (on their knees) and embrace the Truth (with a capital T).

The problem with this medieval view of things does not lie just in the “intolerance” it reveals. It lies also in the quantity of “empty men” it promotes: creatures devoid of any interior life who defer, like robots, to whatever is in vogue.

Those who destroy individual conscience in the name of the “common good” are destroying the last barrier against arbitrary power. A barrier they might one day need if the pendulum of fanaticism changes direction.

The only disagreement I have with those paragraphs is the use of the word “if” in the last sentence. It should be “when”.

2 comments

Whistling Past a Graveyard

Meanwhile, in her Wall Street Journal column Peggy Noonan is whistling past a graveyard:

Franklin D. Roosevelt, in creating Social Security in 1935, knew he had to get Republicans behind it and owning it, or America would see it as a Democratic project, not an American institution. In the end he persuaded 81 Republicans to join 284 Democrats in the House. So too with the creation of Medicare in 1965: Lyndon Johnson wrestled and cajoled Republicans and got a majority of their votes.

Every president until Barack Obama knew this. He bullied through ObamaCare with no Republican support, and he did it devilishly, too, in that he created a bill so deal-laden, so intricate, so embedding-of-its-tentacles into the insurance and health systems, that it would be almost impossible to undo. He was maximalist. His party got a maximal black eye, losing the House and eventually the Senate over the bill, which also contributed to its loss of the presidency.

Is it fair that both parties must fix a problem created by one party? No. But it would be wise and would work.

What she’s missing is that today’s politics isn’t merely about getting what you want it isn’t even mostly about getting what you want. It’s mostly about ensuring that your political opponents lose.

Democrats won’t accept anything that looks like repeal of the Affordable Care Act; a significant minority of Republican senators won’t accept anything less. That’s an impasse; there is no room for compromise there.

3 comments

Radicalism in Illinois

The big news here in Illinois yesterday was that Christine Radogno, the Illinois Senate Minority Leader, has resigned, not merely from her position of leadership but from her job as a legislator. The Chicago Tribune reports:

The first woman to lead a legislative caucus left little doubt her departure was in part born of frustration over the partisan stalemate that has sent state government finances spiraling downward despite her efforts to reach a compromise that would satisfy a demanding Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner and a Democratic-led General Assembly.

“I will say that I feel strongly that the governor has the right agenda, but it’s not that easy getting there. We need fundamental change in this building, but we need to compromise in order to get there,” said Radogno, 64, of southwest suburban Lemont.

“We have to put aside personalities. We have to prioritize what we want. Nobody gets 100 percent, but what do you absolutely have to have? When you negotiate, you need to understand and get in the skin of the person you’re talking to,” she said, providing advice for the governor and other legislative leaders.

The position being taken by the legislature’s Democrats, particularly by Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan, is not a moderate one. They refuse to give the governor anything he’s requested.

They have no plan for fixing Illinois’s problems but they do have the votes. They could have enacted a budget without either Republicans or the governor. They’d clearly rather have the issue. They’ve decided to run out the clock.

Presently, here in Illinois we’re being inundated with TV ads for J. B. Pritzker’s gubernatorial campaign. A perusal of his web site finds he’s running against Gov. Rauner’s inability to enact a budget and for additional spending. There’s little in the way of explanations of how he plans to balance Illinois’s budget. We are left to speculate it’s by borrowing at the usurious rates required by Illinois’s near-junk credit rating and by increasing taxes. The last time taxes were increased in Illinois the legislature promised to put Illinois’s finances in good shape. Instead they gave raises to public employees and expanded spending, devoting very little of the additional revenues to straightening out Illinois’s finances.

0 comments

The Obnoxious Will Inherit the Earth

In his Washington Post column Michael Gerson lurches uncontrollably towards the point I made several years ago. Republican (small r) government is impossible without moderation:

Civility is not weakness. It is the native tongue of a successful democracy. What Stephen L. Carter calls “civil listening” allows people who are opponents to avoid becoming enemies. Civility prevents dehumanization.

Compromise is not surrender. It is the lubricant of a successful democracy. What Jonathan Rauch calls “a cardinal virtue” allows for incremental progress on difficult issues such as health care. It is a moral principle that elevates progress on the common good above ideological purity.

Moderation is not indecision or centrism (as important as political centrism may be). It is the mode or mood of a successful democracy. What Aurelian Craiutu calls “a difficult virtue for courageous minds” puts an emphasis on reasonableness, prudence and balance. It is a principle rooted in epistemological modesty — a recognition that no one possesses the whole truth.

Moderation takes more than one form. Garbing immoderate actions or policies in moderate language is not moderate.

There are many causes for the breakdown in civility, compromise, and moderation we’re witnessing today. Among them are the vast amount of wealth being concentrated in few hands, the necessities of political fundraising, variations kinds of isolation including physical, occupational, and social, the conviction that those who disagree with you are evil, the pernicious idea that those whom you deem evil should be suppressed, and, let’s face it, basic disagreement not just about ways and means but over goals.

0 comments

Generational Progress

For no particularly good reason, possibly prompted by looking through my dad’s photos as I did on Father’s Day, I began thinking about how my siblings and I have fared compared with my parents.

My parents were the first people in their respective families to graduate from high school. They both went on to attend and graduate from college and both obtained higher degrees. My siblings and I always assumed we would attend college—we never considered anything else. One of my siblings and I went on to a higher degree. A couple of my siblings’ spouses have as well.

Adjusted for inflation my father earned more in his last full year of life than any of us have in a year. My wife and I have a family income higher than my parents’ highest family income (again adjusted for inflation) as does one of my siblings. The rest of my siblings have never managed a family income higher than my parents.

With the exception of one of my siblings my siblings and I have found maintaining a middle class lifestyle a strain from time to time. We’ve been frugal.

Of my siblings, their spouses, and I all are retired except for me and several of my siblings’ spouses. I’ll probably continue working longer than any of them.

My nieces and nephews have all graduated from college. Roughly half have gone on to post-graduate education and I expect that more will. It’s early to say what their incomes will be or whether they’ll remain middle class.

Consider that everyone in my family has an IQ at least two standard deviations above normal (some of us considerably higher), we’re all industrious to a fault, and by and large we’re good-looking and personable. No substance abuse (as far as I know) and no criminal history. And we’re just getting by. You might think that people who are so hardworking and intelligent would prosper. You would be wrong. We just don’t have enough guile.

I can’t imagine how the vast majority of the people who don’t have our gifts and advantages manage. My guess is that many don’t.

9 comments

What Is a Military For?

I searched Mario Schulz’s post at War on the Rocks for an answer to that question in his post “Germans Should Accept What a Military Is For, or Get Used to Disappointment”. I was the one who was disappointed.

Clausewitz answered that question for us: war is the pursuit of policy by other means. The Germans are accomplishing their policy objectives without war and effectively without a military. Why should they bear the costs in blood and money (to coin a cliche) of a military? They’ll always have the United States to bear those costs for them.

1 comment

Remain Calm. All Is Well.

At RealClearMarkets Doug Kass collects a group of very dumb things said by very smart people some of which may surprise you. He concludes with a quote from Janet Yellen:

Would I say there will never, ever be another financial crisis? … You know, probably that would be going too far, but I do think we’re much safer and I hope that it will not be in our lifetimes and I don’t believe it will be.

What’s the smart bet here? I think that until and unless we change the incentives that are in place we’ll keep getting the results we’ve gotten. More quickly and more catastrophically with each turn of the crank.

5 comments

You Cahn’t Get The-ah From He-ah

At The Daily Beast Matt Lewis considers the history of the U. S. health care system:

During World War II, government intervention in wage controls had unintended consequences that are still being felt today. Businesses couldn’t woo top talent by offering them more money, so they instead sweetened job offers by adding fringe benefits, including health care. The result was a Catch-22: Because health insurance was paid for by a third party (your employer) instead of the beneficiary (you), there was no incentive to keep costs low. As a result, almost everybody had to be an employee—because health care costs were too high to pay for out-of-pocket.

We’re still living with the consequences today. As Sen. Rand Paul recently observed, “The reason capitalism doesn’t work in health care is the consumer is disconnected from the product… When you connect with the consumer, and the consumer cares about the price, guess what? The consumer will shop. And when the consumer shops, competition works. But we’re not really doing that in health care.”

And as Jeff Jacoby noted years ago, “Why is it that in every other field where enormous technological strides have been made, total costs have fallen over time, but in health care they have increased? The answer is simple: Health care costs so much because most of us pay so little for it. And we pay so little—out-of-pocket expenses amount to just 14 cents of every health dollar spent in this country—because a third party nearly always picks up the tab. For most working Americans, that third party is an insurance company paid by their employers.”

I think he’s overlooking something. If weavers had the kind of control over how weaving would be done in the 18th and 19th century that physicians have over how medical services are provided, none of us could afford to buy underwear. Employers are only part of the problem. A much larger component of the problem is that who should provide medical services, what services should be provided, when they should be provided, and at what cost is determined by those getting paid for the services.

I do agree with his conclusion. When the United Kingdom was adopting its National Health Service we were consigning the health care of American workers to their employers. Now health care is shared among employers, the federal government, and state governments. There are so many interests at stake it will be impossible to untangle them.

There’s an old joke about traveling in Maine. After wandering for hours along rural roads, some travelers stopped at a general store and asked those sitting on the porch for directions. After thinking for a while the Mainesters replied “You cahn’t get they-ah from he-ah.” That’s how it is with affordable, effective health care in the United States. We can’t get there from here.

The questions that should be asked are

  1. Does the proposed reform move us in the direction of a more affordable, more effective, and more just system?
  2. Does the proposal stand on its own? Or will it require frequent adjustment? Our history tells us we don’t have the appetite for that.
  3. Over what time frame do you anticipate the process of change to take place?

Those are the questions that should have been asked but weren’t in the mad dash to enact the Affordable Care Act in the first place and those are the questions that should be asked about the attempt to “repeal and replace” it.

0 comments

Thus I Refute the Thucydides Trap

In his Washington Post column, greatly impeded by a lack of knowledge or intuition into China (or the United States, for that matter), David Ignatius engages in a “thought experiment” to look at the idea that war between an established power and a rising power is inevitable AKA “the Thucydides trap” from the Chinese perspective:

  1. Economic and cultural power is no substitute for military power. China was a dominant economic and intellectual force when it first encountered European power, but it lacked technologically backed military muscle. Mistake.
  2. Weakness breeds contempt. Western powers made a show of pledging loyalty and tribute to China’s rulers and warlords, but this masked hostile intent. The Chinese were wooed and corrupted by the West’s influence. Mistake. Allison quotes Thucydides’ precept: The weak (and by extension, the corrupt) suffer what they must. Rooting out (or at least controlling) corruption is a central Chinese task.
  3. The West preached openness as the way for China and other Asian nations to absorb advanced technology and Western know-how. But the West exploited that openness to create dependence. Even Japan, which built an astonishing manufacturing base, remained dependent on Western raw materials and energy supplies. Mistake. The result was a catastrophic war.
  4. Networks of aid and assistance are good covers for expanding influence and military power. The Marshall Plan was a sublime scheme for spreading U.S. influence and blunting the Soviet Union, in the name of relieving humanitarian suffering. China is devising similar outreach through the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank and the cooperative development project known as “One Belt One Road.” The United States has done everything it can to prevent other nations from signing up to China’s initiatives. Mistake. Asian development is the handmaiden of Chinese power.
  5. The United States argues that transparency and an international rules-based order are the best guarantee of security for all sides. But what this really means, through modern history, is that the United States makes the rules and others obey the orders. Adherence to the “rules” would have checked China’s expansion into the South China Sea (allowing perpetual U.S. domination). And if last year’s Philippine arbitration ruling had been enforced, it would have rolled back China’s projection of power through reclaimed islands and military bases. Mistake. History teaches that China should proclaim that its intentions are limited, benign and non-military — even as its power expands and it creates the military bases that will allow it to challenge U.S. naval power in the South China Sea.

I wouldn’t be bold enough to put words in the mouths of the Chinese leadership but do they really put all laowai into one big bundle? That’s what Mr. Ignatius is doing in those paragraphs. He’s jumbling the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany, the United States and Europe, into one heap. I suspect that the Chinese leadership is intelligent enough and well-educated enough to recognize that’s an over-simplification to say the least.

The idea of “the West” has been propaganda for the last 2,500 years. Originally, it was used by Plato to distinguish between the Greeks and the Persians or the Egyptians. Its modern incarnation is about 80 years old and was proposed by the Germans to distinguish between themselves and Western Europe and the rest of the world. That alone should give us pause.

For most of the 19th century Americans were conflicted about their relationship with Europe in general and Britain in particular. We contrasted ourselves with the Europeans as frequently as we aligned ourselves with them but you’ll frequently find reference to a shared heritage.

In the late 1930s the Brits and their American admirers promoted the idea to attract the U. S. into the war on their side and it meant “Western Europe plus the United States” excluding Germany. After the war “the West” was used to distinguish between Britain, France, the United States, etc. and the communist east. Its present incarnation, which includes Poland but not Russia, is about 30 years old.

Said another way this “The West preached openness as the way for China and other Asian nations…” is hooey at best and circular propaganda at worst.

As to the “Thucydides trap” itself that, too, is hooey at best and propaganda at worst. If there were something inevitable about war between established powers and rising ones, why didn’t we go to war with Britain after 1812 which decidedly does not fit the model? In 1914 who was the “established power” and who the “rising power”? Germany a rising power? It is to laugh. Wannabes.

Whether Sam Clemens said it or not, that history doesn’t repeat itself but it does rhyme has it right. Human events across the ages have resonance with each other because they are human actions. Historical inevitability is a beard used to justify actions decided on for other reasons. If the Chinese think that war with the United States is inevitable, they’ll find a reason.

0 comments