China’s Internal Contradictions

I recommend you read George Friedman’s analysis of Chinese policy at RealClearWorld. Note in particular his map of China which highlights factors of which too few Americans are aware, in particular the relatively narrow slice of the country along the coast where its population is concentrated. Here’s a snippet:

In the event there was an economic falling out with the U.S., China had to consider the possibility of a military confrontation. But the key issue was the ability to guarantee China’s access to sea lanes. In this, China had a major geographic problem. The South and East China seas are ringed with small islands, spaced in such a way that passage between them can be blocked with relative ease. The U.S. Navy is far superior to the Chinese navy, and the Chinese were concerned that in some unforeseen crisis the U.S. would block access to their much needed sea lanes. Those small islands were now at the center of Chinese national interest. The Chinese could claim the entire region, but they were not in a position to seize it.

At the same time, the Chinese devised a political solution to their strategic problem. If a country like Indonesia or the Philippines aligned with China instead of with the United States, access to the global sea lanes would be assured without having to confront the United States. The problem here is that the two strategies undermined each other. Aggressive assertion of Chinese power in the regional waters and finding accommodation with regional powers were inconsistent approaches. What’s more, they could only work if the United States was not present. And, of course, it was.

China had one other option for getting around potential U.S. actions: creating an alternative export route through Asia to Europe. This was the One Belt, One Road concept. But it, too, was flawed. First, the cost of building the requisite infrastructure was staggering. Second, it would run through countries that were unstable and, for the Chinese, unimportant customers. Add to that the speed with which One Belt, One Road needed to be enacted, and this was more posturing than policy.

China, therefore, is caught in a set of interlocking problems. Its economic miracle has matured into more normal growth rates. It has a vast population that lacks the ability to consume all that it produces. It has to contend with global stagnation and competition from other producers – and competing with high-tech producers is no small task. It is therefore afraid of internal instability and has imposed a dictatorship designed to maintain a vibrant economy without social costs.

Read the whole thing. These are the sorts of things that I’ve been referring to when I write about China’s internal contradictions and why I’m not overly concerned about China. China has plenty of problems of its own to deal with. The One Child policy has meant that their military is composed largely of only children who are the sole support of their elderly parents. It’s a military much better suited for projecting power internally than externally. The rapid industrial development without adequate civil infrastructure, i.e. political and legal, has resulted in air, soil, and water pollution of resources that are vitally needed. And so on.

But that also explains why the Chinese are inclined to ignore the North Koreans. They have so many problems of their own.

2 comments

Wages That Don’t Grow

In his piece at Slate on the sluggish growth in wages in the United States Daniel Gross’s two paragraphs recapping how we got where we are are good:

Corporate America went into survival mode and took an axe to what, in most instances, was its largest single cost: labor. Between January 2008 and February 2010, private-sector companies slashed 8.8 million jobs. At the same time, they slashed the wages and benefits of the workers they continued to employ. This was the playbook for getting through the worst financial downturn since the Great Depression. And as the economy began to expand, companies remained parsimonious on wages and benefits, and continued to push the obligation and cost of training onto workers.

They were able to do that in part because there was immense slack in the labor market. The unemployment rate peaked at 10.0 percent in October 2009. And so for a long period of time, companies became accustomed to getting all the labor they needed at the (low) price they wanted to pay, and managed to hold onto staff despite not raising wages. This mentality hardened into something like a permanent mindset, incorporated into business models and pro forma projections. In an era when overall economic growth was slowing, companies simply couldn’t countenance raising wages consistently.

That’s a fair recap with one quibble about the first sentence. I would have written “Corporate America acted as though it were in survival mode”. I wrote about this at the time. There were sharp job cuts even in industries that weren’t seeing sharp declines in demand. In some cases businesses cut workers because they could do so without incurring scrutiny.

Additionally, there’s a factor unmentioned in his account. Businesses actually cut their payrolls a lot farther than that and brought workers in to replace the workers they’d fired from overseas who were willing to work less than the workers they’d displaced. That’s still the case.

There is a sort of fear in many workplaces today. Workers are afraid to ask for wages and skulk around trying to avoid being noticed because they don’t want to be fired and replaced by someone cheaper who won’t make waves. That’s a real change from years ago.

So, if you’re wondering about the lack of dynamism and energy in today’s American economy, look no farther.

1 comment

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

Russia Russia Russia 

 Natalia Veselnitskaya, Magnitsky Act, Russian hackers, Putin’s tentacles, you name it…

 Forum: Will Media Outlets Like CNN Ever Practice Journalism Again? 

 Amerisclerosis

 Michael Brown: Punishment 
 

 CNN’s White House propagandist claims Trump delivered ‘white America’ speech in Warsaw. 

 Everybody wants you — flattering and overwhelming 

 Baltimore: Clueless 

 Face the Nation: US Ambassador Nikki Haley on Trump and Putin’s G-20 meeting 

 Testing Tyranny, Part 4 

 [VIDEO] Being a millennial: “self-responsibility is a form of cruelty” 

0 comments

First Do No Harm

There’s an article at the web site of Chicago’s public radio station, WBEZ, that does some back-of-the-napkin calculations on how expensive it would be to implement a jobs program that would in their words “eliminate a significant amount of violence” here in Chicago. Here’s their bottom line:

That final price tag, $1.1 billion for the program’s first year, is no small sum. But, just for context, it’s around the planned cost of redeveloping Union Station downtown. It’s also roughly what Illinois spends to keep its violent offenders in prison for one year.

And, while we’re considering cost, it might be a lot more expensive to allow Chicago’s shooting surge to continue. For starters, there’s the policing, incarceration and medical care. The violence is probably also a factor in the city’s population drop — a drain on the tax base. Another drain is simply having those 30,000 at-risk people jobless.

Now just for the record I think they’re making some bad assumptions, especially thinking that full-time $13/hour jobs would have the impact they’re projecting but let’s go with them on that. I have a few additional observations.

First, a very large percentage of Chicago’s homicides take place in a very small number of neighborhoods. Rather than looking in 26 of the city’s 77 community areas, I’d suggest they concentrate on the 15 that account for two-thirds of the homicides. Presumably, doing something about the economies of just those areas would have the most impact at a lower cost than in 26 neighborhoods. Heck, a third of the homicides take place in just five neighborhoods. Wouldn’t those be a good place to start?

Second, I’m going to suggest something that some people will view as argumentative. We’d be better off promoting economic growth on the South and West sides of the city than we would adding additional police officers. I’m not even going to try to prove my claim. Chicago already has the highest ratio of police officers to population of any major city. I see no reason to believe that increasing that ratio will change anything.

Finally, just as a bare minimum doesn’t it make sense for the Illinois legislature, the Cook County Board, and Chicago City Council to stop taking actions that will reduce economic activity? Some examples of such recent actions: the recent income tax hike, property tax hikes, and sugared soft drink tax. First do no harm, people.

5 comments

Survivor

The more I read about cases like this of a Missouri woman dying of a newly-discovered tick-borne disease the more convinced I become that I’m a survivor of such a disease and that explains my lifelong chronic pain.

3 comments

Grant Me Chastity

Perhaps I’m misreading the editors of Bloomberg View’s take on President Trump’s Election Integrity Committee. On the one hand they acknowledge the need for such a committee:

One in eight voter registrations is invalid or inaccurate, according to a 2012 study. That includes 1.8 million dead people still on the rolls and nearly 3 million who are registered in more than one state. There are also non-citizens on the rolls.

I believe that drastically understates the problems with voter registrations. I doubt that the gravest abuse is non-citizens voting or outright fraud as in somebody casting a vote in a name other than their own although I have little doubt that those abuses take place. I think there are probably hundreds of thousands or even millions of people who are registered in multiple jurisdictions and vote in more than one of them—once in person and one or more times absentee.

They also suggest a justification for the committee:

The Help America Vote Act of 2002 requires states to create “a single, uniform, official, centralized, interactive computerized statewide voter registration list” with a unique identifier for each voters, and to coordinate their lists with other agencies. They’ve done a poor job of it, and it’s clear that more interstate coordination is needed.

But they’re suspicious of the motives of the members of the committee:

Straightening out this embarrassing muddle should be a national priority, but Trump’s commission lacks the credibility and expertise to do it.

Its vice-chair is Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, a Republican who has led a partisan push for strict identification laws for registration and voting. A federal court recently fined him for making “patently misleading representations to the court” after refusing to turn over a voting memo he delivered to President-elect Trump.

Equally problematic, identifying ineligible voters — and avoiding false positives that could disenfranchise properly registered voters — involves a level of technical expertise that the commission has shown no sign of understanding.

To me that smacks of modern day Donatism. Donatism was the heresy that held that priests needed to be in a state of grace for sacraments to be valid.

There will be no perfect solution as long as the attitude towards voter registration (basically more is better) that prevails today continues. Any commission’s motives will be suspect.

Let’s not make the perfect the enemy of the good. If you genuinely want to increase confidence in our system, you should want the process to be as good as we can make it from end to end. That includes voter registration and validation of registration.

The reference in the title of this post is to the famous quip by Augustine of Hippo: “Grant me chastity but not yet.”

10 comments

Before and After

You may have heard that the Chicago area has received quite a bit of rainfall over the last day or so. Libertyville in the northern suburbs, for example, has received nine inches of rain. Roads are closed. Underpasses are flooded. There’s local flashflooding in some areas.

Here in Sauganash we’ve received about two inches of rain.

As I’ve mentioned before we had drainage control installed in our backyard recently. It’s working. Here’s a picture of our backyard after about 2 inches of rain before we’d installed the drainage control:

and here’s what our backyard looks like after our recent rain:

It’s working.

5 comments

Not So Friendly

At The Diplomat Guy Plopsky asks a very good question—why is Russia pointing its missiles at China?

In early June 2017, Russian media reported that yet another Ground Forces missile brigade received the dreaded road-mobile 9K720 Iskander-M missile system (known in Russian military parlance as an “operational-tactical missile system,” or OTRK in short). The brigade in question is the 29th Army’s newly established 3rd Missile Brigade, based in Russia’s colossal Eastern Military District (MD). Formed in December 2016, this brigade was initially armed with the aging 9K79-1 Tochka-U tactical ballistic missile system, and became the Eastern MD’s fourth missile brigade to be re-equipped with the Iskander-M as part of the Russian Defense Ministry’s plan to phase out all Tochka-Us by 2020. The district’s three other brigades — the 107th, 103rd and 20th — received their Iskander-M OTRKs in 2013, 2015, and 2016, respectively. As a result, there are presently more Iskander-M brigades in the Eastern MD than any other district; Russia’s other three military districts (Central, Southern, and Western) currently house two Iskander-M brigades each. What, then, is the purpose of these four brigades?

Whereas the task of Iskander-M OTRKs being deployed in Russia’s Western MD is to hold U.S. and allied forces in the Baltics and Poland at risk, the systems stationed in the Eastern MD appear to primarily serve a different purpose: strengthening both Russia’s conventional and nuclear deterrence against China. Indeed, while an Iskander-M system stationed in Russia’s Kaliningrad Oblast allows Russia to target a wide range of NATO military assets, including the Aegis Ashore ballistic missile defense (BMD) system in Poland, an Iskander-M stationed in Russia’s Far East has very limited ability to threaten U.S. forces deployed in the region.

Read the whole thing. I doubt that this will assuage the concerns of those who fear a Chinese-Russian combine against the U. S. but it should at least make people think. The Russians have a lot more missiles pointed at China than they do at us or our European allies. If Russia and China are so chummy, why is that?

As I’ve said before, Russia and China are natural enemies while the U. S. and Russia are naturally uninterested in each other. Russia and China have territorial disputes and are competing for power and influence in the same regions. All we need to do to defuse tensions with Russia is to stop waving the Russophobia flag.

I don’t deny that Russia has been engaging in disinformation and, worse, information campaigns intended to influence American elections. As they say, payback is a bitch.

IMO blaming the Russians for a loss of confidence in our system is extraneous and unnecessary. We’re doing a fine job of that ourselves.

1 comment

The Resource Curse

The first thing I thought of when I read this post at Political Calculations on U. S. oil exports to China was is the U. S. experiencing the “resource curse”?

2 comments

Blood From the Stone

I actually agree with the message of Crosby Smith’s op-ed in USA Today:

Illinois pensions are modest, just $32,000 a year on average. Since most public service workers aren’t eligible for Social Security, our pension is all many of us will have in what should be our golden years.

Politicians ran up our state’s pension debt over decades by using our retirement funds like credit cards. Instead of raising revenue or cutting costs, they skipped or shorted pension payments.

A pension is a promise that shouldn’t be broken. My life savings shouldn’t be taken to let politicians avoid tough choices. The Illinois Constitution agrees, saying pensions can’t be cut.

That’s only slightly misleading. Here in Chicago CPS teachers start at $50,000 per year for a nine month job with a median of over $80,000 while police and firefighters average in the low six figures when you include the overtime that’s nearly always available. When a teacher, police officer, or firefighter retires, he or she is eligible for a pension that’s 75% of ending salary.

But I agree that the state’s politicians are the primary culprits and that retirees should receive what they’ve been promised. Why those politicians are re-elected term after term with the support of Smith and Smith’s peers eludes me.

Here’s the proposed solution:

Our state’s fiscal problems stem from our low, flat income tax that allows rich folks to avoid paying their fair share, while two-thirds of Illinois corporations pay no income tax at all. To fund schools and other public services while paying the state’s bills, we need to close loopholes and enact a fair, graduated, tax.

Two-thirds of Illinois corporations pay no income tax because they’re small and aren’t making any money. Any tax that raises more revenue will at the margins drive businesses and individuals out of the state. Illinois’s population and economy are shrinking. What Illinois needs most is economic growth. Higher taxes won’t accomplish that.

Here are some alternative proposals for straightening out Illinois’s finances:

  1. Immediately convert Illinois’s public employees from defined benefit pension plans to defined contribution pension plans. Illinois’s problem is not that we’re not taxed enough. It’s that Illinois’s politicians didn’t kick in to the public pension funds as they’d promised.
  2. Cut the pay of present Illinois public employees. There was a huge run-up in public pay here during the Aughts. The state can’t afford it especially when pensions are yoked to pay.
  3. Reduce pay and eliminate pensions for state elected officials. Reduce expense budgets for elected officials.
  4. Impose term limits on all Illinois state politicians.

Those are remarkably similar to Gov. Rauner’s proposals which have received no consideration from the state legislature at all.

Illinois can’t meet its present let alone its future commitments with a shrinking economy. Sooner or later (probably sooner) Illinois will be unable to borrow to pay its bills. You can’t get blood out of a stone.

4 comments