In this centenary year of the Russian Revolution (there were actually two of them—the February Revolution and the October Revolution) much is being written about it. The New York Times, following in a long-standing American tradition, cf. Ten Days That Shook the World and the movie inspired by it, Reds, is romanticizing it. In his article at The Week Ryan Cooper probes into a lot of the political machinations and minutiae of the Russian Revolution in an exploration of how the revolution went wrong:
But it is simply not the case that Marxism — an arid and over-elaborate doctrine, very interesting in some ways and clearly mistaken in others — is some turn-crank formula for purges and dictatorship. All the European labor parties were officially Marxist for decades, which led only to generous welfare states and some experimentation with government-owned industry. The Nordic countries became the most decent nations that have ever existed through policies that have direct roots in an early 20th century socialist movement that was fervently Marxist.
So if Marxism didn’t doom the Russian revolution, what did?
The obvious culprit is the incomprehensible chaos and brutality of its circumstances. Immediately before the revolution, something like three million Russians had died in the First World War. The rapid collapse of Tsarism and the Provisional Government empowered the most hardline and radical factions on all sides. Immediately after the revolution, the Bolsheviks had to fight a civil war against virtually every other faction in Russia, many of them murderous reactionaries armed by Western powers. Winning required yet more brutal tactics and fighting, killing roughly 10 million more people in the process. It’s at that point when truly awful authoritarianism started to set in.
Make no mistake: the revolution was a colossal failure. Regardless of the dreamy suppositions of its supporters, particularly here in the United States, it did not usher in a workers’ paradise. It resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of Russians and stunted Russia’s economic, political, and social development for most of the last century.
What doomed the revolution was the revolution. Although they may carry the guns and wave the pitchforks, revolutions are not started or won by peasants and workers. They are always internecine warfare, pitting one group of elites against another. That has been true of every revolution from the Glorious Revolution 400 years ago to the American, French, and Russian Revolutions, Mao’s Long March, and the Cuban Revolution of 60 years ago.
William of Orange, George Washington, Marat and Robespierre, Lenin, Mao, and Castro were neither workers nor peasants.
Russia had no group of even more or less benign but decisive liberal democrats waiting in the wings to assume power. They had the corrupt, brutal aristocracy or the corrupt, brutal intelligentsia.
In the case of the Russian Revolution a group of intellectuals led by Lenin replaced the Tsarist aristocracy. The mechanics of the revolution and human nature ensured its failure.







