Question About Sports Parks

When did state and local governments start subsidizing the construction and/or refurbishing of sports parks? Yankee Stadium and Wrigley Field were built entirely with private funds. My hypothesis is that subsidizing the owners of athletic franchises is something that’s happened in the last 30-40 years. It’s corrupt.

12 comments

We Didn’t Invent It

When I read Austin Bay’s lament about Afghanistan at the Observer, this passage leapt out at me:

In 2017, many Americans seem to have forgotten that Afghanistan is where Osama bin Laden, the Soviet Union and the U.S. intersected. In 1979, Moscow saw the chronically weak Carter administration trapped in the Iran hostage crisis. An Afghanistan Soviet Socialist Republic would be a step toward obtaining one of the czars’ strategic goals: a warm water port on the Indian Ocean. After Afghanistan, the Russians would take Pakistan’s Baluchistan (western Pakistan) and Russian-controlled territory would split the Asian continent.

Outlandish? Perhaps, but many mad dreams in Moscow have led to war.

I know of no credible evidence that the Russians have ever harbored such ambitions. The Soviets were utopian millennialists and genuinely believed that a communist world was inevitable.

The claim usually relies on “Peter the Great’s will”, a 19th century French forgery used to justify Napoleon’s aggression against Russia. We didn’t invent anti-Russian propaganda, you know.

To the best of my knowledge Peter the Great’s longing for a warm water port ended in Iran and the Persian Gulf. And the Soviets did in fact advance that goal by occupying part of Iran during World War II. Something to keep in mind when you’re worrying about a Russian-Iranian alliance. They’ve hated each other a lot longer than they’ve hated us and with much more reason.

4 comments

Never Asking “Why?”

In his speculative article at Forbes on contact with extraterrestrial intelligent species why does Ethan Siegel never ask why such beings would travel the enormous distances between worlds to reach us? I can only think of one plausible reason: they live on their ships, need resources to survive, and probably won’t be overly scrupulous about taking what they need.

As to why we haven’t encountered aliens from outer space so far my guesses are:

  1. We have. They just haven’t bothered us whether through benignity or distaste.
  2. We are the elder race.
  3. There aren’t any.
  4. It’s just not worth travelling that far.

I lean towards #2, a depressing thought.

15 comments

The Reality of Athletics

When I read the caption of Gretchen Reynolds’s New York Times article, “Age Like a Former Athlete”, my immediate reaction was, you mean be in constant pain? Every real athlete places stresses on his or her body that result in injury and in many cases those injuries in turn result in continuing pain, particularly in old age. There’s a reason for the cliche of the elderly (age 50) prima ballerina hobbling around the young students in her ballet class, leaning on a cane. Those retired ballerinas were in pain.

Here’s Ms. Reynolds’s peroration:

But the broader message of the study, she says, could be that we may need to rethink what normal fitness is or should be in older people. The tables that doctors and other experts currently use to determine “normal” fitness have been constructed with data gathered from typical older people today, many of whom have been sedentary for years.

These men’s lives suggest that greater fitness is possible in old age, even for those of us who were not previously Olympians, Dr. Everman says. “These guys were not training hard” by the time they became septuagenarians, she says, and most already had eased back considerably in their workout routines by the 1993 testing, she says, when they were middle-aged.

But they never stopped exercising altogether, except during periods of illness or injury.

If the rest of us followed a similar workout trajectory during our lives, she says, we might wind up with a higher VO2 max than otherwise in our old age, resetting both our expectations about age-related fitness and the existing tables.

VOX2 max (milliliters of oxygen used per kilogram weight per minutes) is a lousy proxy for total health. There’s got to be some healthy medium between athletics and, as a recent study of the UK has found, people over the age of 40 not walking for ten sustained minutes per month. As another recent study (on diet) did we might turn to hunter-gatherer societies for guidance. In hunter-gatherer societies people routinely walk a lot but rarely engage in extreme exertion. That’s my theory and I’m sticking to it.

0 comments

Born to Eat Poorly

In an entire article at the Washington Post on how programs to get kids to eat any let alone more fruits and vegetables have fallen short, not once does the author mention that in every country, at every time, as long back in our past as we’ve been able to determine, human beings have preferentially sought out the highest fat food source in their environments. When you add that Americans are conditioned from birth to believe that large quantities of bland, mediocre food are to be preferred over small quantities of food with vibrant flavors and textures and is it any wonder that kids won’t eat even a single bite of apple?

1 comment

No Way Out

After recapping the many strategies that have been attempted and failed in Afghanistan, in his column at the New York Times Bret Stephens outlines the alternatives for future actions:

What can we do? With relatively modest troop increases, we can provide the elected Afghan government with sufficient military support to reverse some of the Taliban’s recent gains and ensure that it cannot seize Afghan cities or control entire provinces. With relatively modest troop numbers, we can also try to keep U.S. casualties relatively low over time, avoiding the political race to the exits when combat fatalities rise.

Bottom line: We need an approach that’s Afghan-sufficient, from a military point of view, and America-sustainable, from a political one, for the sake of an open-ended commitment to an ill-starred country from which there is no way out.

Now he tells us. Everything Mr. Stephens describes was apparent in 2001. Every decision by each president since then has been politically motivated and ignored the facts on the ground. President Bush invaded Afghanistan because he had to do something. The situation absolutely required a really futile and stupid gesture on somebody’s part and the somebody was us. The consequence of President Obama’s “Afghan surge” was that thousands of Americans were killed pursuing an unachievable objective or at least an objective unachievable with the level of force the president was willing to apply.

Now President Trump is reincreasing the number of American troops in Afghanistan, changing the rules of engagement to strengthen our military’s hand, not offering the Taliban the option of running out the clock, and brinksmanship with respect to Pakistan. It will be no more successful than the strategies of his predecessors.

As I wrote 15 years ago there has only been one successful invasion of Afghanistan in the history of the world and that was by Alexander. He settled a population there. Can you see our doing that? Me, neither.

1 comment

Starstruck

You might want to read Steve Malanga’s article at City Journal on the subsidies being doled out by state and local governments to have movies and TV shows filmed in their jurisdictions:

The rise of celluloid subsidies resulted from a sharp increase in the 1990s of so-called runaway productions—movies and TV shows filmed in foreign countries for cost savings. The number of U.S.-conceived and -developed movies and TV series shooting abroad rose to 285 in 1998, up from 100 in 1990, according to a study by the consulting firm Monitor Company. More than eight in ten of those productions were in Canada, where a roughly 20 percent decline in the Canadian dollar, plus tax rebates that the government offered to American producers, slashed the cost of filming by about one-fifth compared with a similar production in the United States. After the Monitor report, states took action. A few had launched modest incentive programs in the 1990s, but Louisiana changed the game in 2002 when it vastly expanded its effort, offering producers an exemption on sales taxes and an investment-tax rebate. Hollywood started shifting productions to the Bayou State, leading others to follow Louisiana’s lead.

For some states, it wasn’t only a matter of economic opportunity but also of pride. After Chicago filmed in Toronto, for instance, Illinois lawmakers started granting producers a 25 percent tax credit on wages paid to Illinois residents for movies filmed there. No sooner did that program go into effect in 2004 than high-profile productions, including Batman Begins and Ocean’s Twelve, arrived in the Land of Lincoln. In a tax-incentive version of the line “I’ll have what she’s having” from When Harry Met Sally, the number of states offering inducements grew from six in 2002 to 44 by 2010. States were giving away about $1.5 billion to Hollywood annually by then, up from less than $100 million in 2002.

There’s a lot of money involved and the return on these pricey investments is generally lousy. I can’t help but wonder if state and local officials aren’t just starstruck and are feeding their desire to hobnob with the beautiful people.

4 comments

A Failure of Computer-Based Training?

In an interesting examination of the “root causes” of ship collisions the U. S. Naval Institute proposes an explanation for the multiple ship mishaps that I haven’t seen elsewhere. Maybe computer-based training has flopped:

In 1961, the Naval Destroyer Officers School, the forefather of the present Surface Warfare Officers School Command, was established. This was followed in 1970 by the first Surface Warfare Division Officer School (SWOSDOC) class. For the next 30 years, this was how division officers were trained for their first tours at sea.

In 2003, SWOSDOC was shuttered, largely for financial reasons, but also in a mistaken attempt to create efficiencies. SWOSDOC was replaced by computer-based training (CBT). Instead of attending SWOS and associated billet specialty programs for upward of 12-14 months of rigorous training prior to reporting on board their first ships, new officers went directly from commissioning sources to their ships with only a packet of computer disks. Now it was incumbent on the ship’s CO to replace a year’s worth of intensive dawn-to-dusk training, in addition to his or her other considerable responsibilities.

Vice Admiral Timothy LaFleur, who as Commander, Naval Surface Force Pacific Fleet, was the author of this decision described the change as one that would “result in higher professional satisfaction, increase the return on investment during the first division officer tour, and free up more career time downstream.” First-tour division officers would still go to Surface Warfare Officers School Command, but only after six months into their first assignment and then for only four to six weeks (later reduced to three) as a kind of “finishing school.” Mostly CBT saved money, and it was estimated that $15 million would be saved by shutting down SWOSDOC and shifting responsibility to the ships’ COs.

Soon officers who opposed this change were excoriated for not “getting it.” A decision had been made, and it was not to be questioned by the rank and file. Silence and obedience were enforced.

Then, CBT failed and failed badly. Commanding officers simply did not have the capability, capacity, or time to replace basic surface warfare officer training in their respective commands. But the Djini was out of the bottle, and the costs to reestablish SWODOC, both in terms of money and embarrassment, were simply too great to bear. Band-aid solutions were found. Eventually, an element of classroom training was reinstituted with the establishment of a four-week course established to provide “3M, division officer fundamentals, basic watchstanding and leadership” to ensigns en route to their first ships.

We’d better hope that the spate of collisions have been a discipline problem rather than a fundamental failure of training doctrine. Remedying such a failure will be incredibly costly and time-consuming.

It seems odd to me that all of these mishaps have taken place in roughly the same theater of operations. Is the operational tempo there that much higher? More traffic? Other factors? Or just a command problem?

2 comments

Down the North Korean Rabbit Hole

George Friedman follows other pundits down the rabbit hole, imagines what a North Korea that would be willing to abide by any negotiated settlement would want, and suggests that:

Pursuing a nuclear weapons program, one meant to discourage any threat to the regime and thus ensure its survival, demanded a huge amount of resources. The North Koreans have not come this far simply to walk away with nothing to show for it. If they were to agree to abandon their program, they would do so only if another means of security were in place.

This would likely require a new regional framework whereby the U.S. would enhance North Korea’s position at the expense of its allies. The framework would also have to weaken U.S. influence in the region, perhaps by relinquishing its relationship with South Korea and withdrawing its forces from the peninsula, or perhaps by keeping its Navy out of the Sea of Japan. Maybe U.S. aircraft would be prohibited from flying near Korean airspace, and maybe Washington would have to rework its treaties with Japan so that its troops there did not threaten North Korea. In short, if North Korea must abandon its military capabilities, so too must the United States, or so the thinking of Pyongyang would go. The U.S. will not alter the regional balance of power lightly. And even if it did, it would have to consider the financial burden of propping up the government in Pyongyang. The United States is unlikely to accept this.

War is the one option the U.S. has to prevent North Korea from completing its nuclear weapons program – if it has not done so already – without giving up anything (except blood) in return. But, as has been widely discussed, this option would be difficult and bloody, and if success is measured by the elimination of all nuclear facilities, there is no guarantee that it would be successful. North Korea is not particularly keen on the prospect of war, either – it knows war introduces the possibility of annihilation. But it has come to read the fear in South Korea, which would likely bear the brunt of the war, as a check on U.S. intent. This dramatically reduces the chance of war.

I’d like to see the evidence that the North Koreans actually recognize and fear the “possibility of annihilation”. Quite to the contrary I think there’s sixty years of history that tells us that they don’t.

4 comments

Securing the Electrical Grid

At RealClearPolicy James Cunningham calls for securing the electrical grid. Here’s his proposed program:

1. A thorough and candid assessment of exactly where improvements and upgrades are needed, in order of priority, to be completed as soon as possible.

2. Development of a collective national plan, driven by Congress and the administration, in partnership with the full range of infrastructure entities, to drive key short- and long-term grid improvements.

3. Regulatory reform, including the North American Electric Reliability Corporation’s establishment of improved and consistent standards for the North American bulk power system adequate to the threats we face.

4. Identification of public and private funding mechanisms to raise the necessary financing in an equitable manner.

which highlights the scope of the problem. The complex web of private utilities, cooperatives, and public agencies that operate the electrical grid don’t have the mindset, culture, or resources to do what he’s asking and even if they did it wouldn’t secure the electrical grid.

Rather than the top-down centrally controlled plan he envisions what is needed is something more akin to the personal computer revolution and the World Wide Web. We need to decentralize rather than centralize and build resilience in rather than imposing it through national plans. The advantage is with the offense in issues of security. We can’t avoid attacks. The objective of securing the grid should be to mitigate the risk of an attack on part of the grid bringing other parts down.

0 comments