Summary

At Bloomberg View Clive Crook neatly summarizes the state of American politics:

There are two main theories of Trump’s support. One is that a large minority of Americans — 40 percent, give or take — are racist idiots. This theory is at least tacitly endorsed by the Democratic Party and the mainstream liberal media. The other is that a large majority of this large minority are good citizens with intelligible and legitimate opinions, who so resent being regarded as racist idiots that they’ll back Trump almost regardless. They may not admire the man, but he’s on their side, he vents their frustration, he afflicts the people who think so little of them — and that’s good enough.

The former group are presently deploying the strategy of continuing the beatings until morale improves. I can only concluded that they believe that by mobilizing large numbers of non-existent voters they can prevail. Maybe time is on their side. I suspect that’s probably how it looks from California.

4 comments

Let Crises Go to Waste

I want to ask a question. Is it moral to capitalize on catastrophes to achieve political objectives that will do little to reduce the losses of the present catastrophe or deal with its aftermath?

I think it can be only justified on instrumental grounds and instrumentalists have the problem that they do not have enough information to make the judgments they must make.

I think it’s immoral because it makes persons into means rather than ends.

20 comments

Lacking Core Competence?

The article on the spate of naval collisions lately at Military Times should warm the cockles of your heart:

The problem is years in the making. Now, the current generation of officers rising into command-level billets lacks the skills, training, education and experience needed to operate effectively and safely at sea, according to current and former officers interviewed by Navy Times.

“There is a systemic cultural wasteland in the SWO community right now, especially at the department head level,” said retired Navy Capt. Rick Hoffman, who commanded the cruiser Hue City and the frigate DeWert and who, after retirement, taught SWOs ship handling in Mayport.

“We do not put a premium on being good mariners,” Hoffman said. “We put a premium on being good inspection takers and admin weenies.”

I doubt that we have by far the largest and most expensive military in the world to produce more “admin weenies”. But that would be consistent with the rest of our government at all levels. We don’t need to spend more money. We need to get more for the money that we spend. For that there will need to be a change in incentives and culture and that will take time, sustained attention, and energy. Translation: it won’t happen.

Update

This article at Defense News on the other hand points the finger directly at something I’ve mentioned in the past as a possible culprit—operational tempo:

In 2015, the Government Accountability Office reported that the high pace of operations was taking a heavy toll on ships forward-deployed to Japan.

Among the findings was that the break-neck pace of operations was robbing those ships of needed training and maintenance. Ships stationed in Japan spent on average 42 more days out to sea than their stateside counterparts, the GAO found.

“GAO … found that the high pace of operations the Navy uses for overseas-homeported ships limits dedicated training and maintenance periods, which has resulted in difficulty keeping crews fully trained and ships maintained,” the report read.

And that wear-and-tear has taken a significant toll on the condition of the ships that come back to the states from Japan after a rotation forward.

It could be both. We need to right-size our military for what we’re willing to spend, get more for the money that we do spend, and constrain what we ask our military to do. All at the same time.

6 comments

The View from Another Vantage Point

I want to commend a post at Pat Lang’s blog by long-time diplomat and scholar William R. Polk on the history of Korea from about 1920 to the present to your attention. It certainly present a dramatically different view than the one you’ve been deluged with on practically a daily basis. It’s long and the first of two parts (the second part hasn’t been published yet). The abbreviated version is that there are no clean hands in this story.

2 comments

The Last Sentence

The only part of the Wall Street Journal editors’ editorial on President Trump’s premature pardon for Joseph Arpaio with which I can agree wholeheartedly is the last sentence:

The Arpaio pardon is a depressing sign of our hyper-politicized times.

I think that outrage on all sides about it has been highly selective. I don’t think that Trump should have issued the pardon but I find the concerns expressed over it exaggerated and hypocritical. I look forward to the proposed legislation put forward by a presumed Democratic Congressional majority and submitted for a Democratic president’s signature to amend the Constitution to limit the president’s pardon power.

5 comments

The Last Nail

In his regular Washington Post column Robert Samuelson makes a pitch for driving the last nail into the coffin of the economic expansion by raising taxes:

The truth is that we need higher, not lower, taxes. When the economy is at or near “full employment,” the budget should be balanced or even show a slight surplus. At 4.3 percent, the jobless rate is surely close to full employment, while the deficit for fiscal 2017 is reckoned to approach $700 billion, about 3.6 percent of the economy (gross domestic product). Both figures are expected to increase, despite continuous (assumed) economic growth. The gap can’t be blamed on the business cycle.

We are undertaxed. Government spending, led by the cost of retirees, regularly exceeds our tax intake. In the past, I have advocated a carbon tax — introduced gradually to minimize any recession risk — as a pragmatic way to pay for the government we want, while trying to cope with global climate change. Letting the federal debt buildup continue is an exercise in self-serving optimism. It presumes that the possibly adverse consequences (the crowding out of private investment, a currency crisis) will never materialize.

He’s right that tax cuts don’t necessarily cause economic growth to increase but the converse is not true. Tax increases practically by definition reduce private sector economic growth while expanding the public sector will increase deadweight loss. No carbon tax proposed by anybody to date would make our tax system less regressive over all. Quite the opposite in fact.

No foreseeable increase in income taxes will bring revenues into balance with spending, especially not one that falls only on the top 1% of earners.

With an economy so dependent on consumer spending as ours is a national sales tax in any form, especially one on top of the income tax rather than a replacement for it, will have catastrophic results.

What is really needed is a Wayback Machine. We’ve made some bad choices. The time to increase taxes is before you’ve entered what’s called “the mature” part of an expansion and such an increase needs to be lot more adroit than anything our system has ever managed.

What our economy needs is higher wage growth for ordinary people rather than for just the top 3% of earners. No proposal presently on the table will accomplish that.

So we’ll have increasing debt as far as the eye can see. That, too, will decrease real private sector economic growth but it will do so more silently and invisibly.

0 comments

The Rains Came

For the last day we’ve been in frequent contact, via text, with friends in Houston. Initially, they’d decided to ride the hurricane and the rains that followed it, out. Boats came to evacuate their next door neighbors a little while ago and they’re reconsidering that decision.

I fear that Houston is just beginning its travails. Much of the Houston area is quite low—20 feet or lower above sea level—and marshy. When it was first developed in the 1830s and 40s it wasn’t a natural port. It was built on a bayou which in some parts was filled in and in others dredged to form the Port Of Houston.

Consequently, even after the rains end it may be some time before the water is cleared.

Our thoughts and prayers are with our friends and all of the people of Houston.

Update

They tell us the waters are receding and they’ve decided to hang in.

7 comments

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

African-Americans need a Great Awakening to repair their broken culture 

 President Trump Is 100% Right – The Media’s Feeding Hate And Division 

 The Bookworm Beat 8/23/17 — Leftist insanity, August edition 

 What Happened: The Delusional Handmaid’s Tale

 Colin Kaepernick – The New Social Justice Poster Child 

 The Bookworm Beat 8/25/17 — the illustrated edition and open thread 

 Professor Ghodsee and superiority of socialist female’s orgasms 

 If you’ve been having sex fantasies about Justin Trudeau, get this book 

 Get assigned to Cuba, go deaf 

 Movie Review: The Big Sick 

 Is our US Navy incompetent or did Obama seriously undermine it? 
 

0 comments

It’s Not Enough to Sit Down

I disagree with Foster Friess’s prescription for restoring civility to our culture, expressed here at RealClearPolitics, in one particular:

We are NOT a nation of negativity. The world looks to America, but–just like we are encouraged to put the oxygen mask on ourselves before we put it on our children in a domestic airliner–so too we need to get our act together as a nation before we can start rescuing the little kids outside Nairobi digging through the dump looking for food.

Perhaps, our Christian community can lead this mission using the Bible’s example: never return evil for evil, pray for those who persecute you, Forgive seven times? No, seventy times seven. Always consider other people more important than yourself. Vengeance is mine says the Lord.

We can see the impact of this world view through Mr. Heyer’s forgiveness toward the young man who killed his daughter. Despite his pain and sorrow, he chose to forgive. He is returning civility to our nation.

Charleston’s Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church provided our country with another example of civility. When misled hate shot and murdered nine innocent worshippers, their relatives and the church responded with forgiveness, and Charleston had vigils and hugs, not riots.

Contrast these two reactions to Ferguson and Baltimore, where in the latter instance the mayor said, “we needed to give them room to destroy.”

The only thing necessary for evil to thrive is for good men and women to do nothing. Each of us can decide to be a well poisoner, or someone who keeps their yard’s white picket fence well painted and retreats to the comfort of their home. Or, we can take a third route to being an encourager and someone willing to take the risk to confront evil.

So, here’s my challenge: invite someone to coffee!

While Mr. Friess’s prescription may be necessary it is not sufficient. It’s not enough to sit down to coffee. We’ve also got to stand down. Inviting someone to coffee only to screech at them how awful they are or use the opportunity to beat them with clubs or run over them with your car will not restore civility. My advice precedes sitting down. The actual pursuit of evil is quite rare. In real life people pursue good ends using evil means. If you can’t understand the good in the other guy’s views, lay down your weapon, go home, and think about it until you do.

Every person regardless of his or her views is entitled to respect simply as a consequence of their being human. Denying that respect is not merely politically counter-productive, it’s fallacious and sinful.

I believe our problems are varied including that social media act as a force multiplier for people at the extremes. I don’t think our problems are just those between left and right. I think the more grievous problems are between the radicals and the moderates. Radicalism admits of no compromise.

11 comments

The History of CPS Pensions

At the Wall Street Journal Alyssia Finley recounts the history of Chicago Public School pensions:

In 1995, amid financial duress, the state established a block grant to help Chicago pay for special education, transportation and nutrition programs. In 2017, Chicago schools benefited to the tune of $250 million. As part of the deal, the state handed control over Chicago teacher pensions to then-Mayor Richard Daley, who took a 10-year “holiday” from payments. According to the Illinois Policy Institute, this allowed the district to divert more than $1.5 billion from teacher pensions to pay and other perks.

In 2011 Chicago suspended pension payments again for three years to prevent massive teacher layoffs and benefit reductions. After teachers went on strike for seven days in 2012, the district awarded the union a 17.6% pay increase over four years.

A few years later, facing a $1.1 billion structural deficit, the Chicago Board of Education approved $1 billion in borrowing. Last summer, the district increased property taxes by $250 million to make an obligatory pension payment, but later agreed to a new contract boosting teacher salaries by 4.5%. Now pensions are underfunded by $11 billion.

Mindful of the investment risk, creditors are charging junk-rated Chicago schools a premium to borrow. To pay its bills the district borrowed $725 million at an 8.5% interest rate in March and another $387 million at 6.4% in June. In July the school district issued $500 million more in debt at a rate of about 7.25% to repay creditors. The Chicago Board of Education is counting on a state bailout to repay all of this debt.

Meanwhile, student enrollment is plummeting, and not only because more kids are attending charter schools. Crime, high property taxes and lousy schools—only a quarter of eighth-graders scored proficient in math on the National Assessment of Educational Progress—are to blame for an exodus of black families. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Chicago was the only major city to lose population in 2015-16.

While the status quo is unsustainable, the Chicago Teachers Union has demanded that state lawmakers hike property and business taxes to pay for their pensions. But even the union seems to realize that it has overplayed its hand. See its press release this week charging that “Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Gov. Bruce Rauner are knowingly sabotaging Chicago’s public schools” and “supporting a plan that will give money to private schools that could be directed to our public school classrooms.”

Let that sink in for a while. Chicago suspended payments to the CPS pension fund for 13 of the last 22 years, using the money to pay for raises instead which further exacerbated the pension problem.

In the column Ms. Finley is hailing Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner’s offer for the state to provide a temporary bailout to the CPS pension fund in exchange for implementing a voucher system:

Illinois sources say a deal supported by legislative leaders could be announced this weekend that will provide $100 million in tax-credit scholarships for low-income kids. This would represent the biggest first-year scholarship funding among any tax-credit program in the country. Each scholarship would be worth up to $12,280—roughly equal to Illinois’s average per-pupil funding. Special-needs students could receive more. Families with incomes up to 300% of the poverty line would be eligible, but lower-income kids and those attending failing schools would have priority.

The problems I see with this are many. The state doesn’t have the money to shore up the CPS’s pensions system; the city doesn’t have the money to implement the voucher system. Implementing either would require borrowing at the high rates that result from their poor credit ratings or raising taxes which would further erode their ability to pay.

I guess I shouldn’t worry about the plan going through since Illinois’s legislature, securely in the hands of Democrats, probably won’t allow the plan to go through. Ilinois House Speaker Mike Madigan has steadfastly refused to throw a bone to the CPS so far. After all, what’s in it for him?

1 comment