In his New York Times column Farhad Manjoo fumes over the Equifax data breach:
If a bank lost everyone’s money, regulators might try to shut down the bank. If an accounting firm kept shoddy books, its licenses to practice accounting could be revoked. (See how Texas pulled Arthur Andersen’s license after the Enron debacle.)
So if a data-storage credit agency loses pretty much everyone’s data, why should it be allowed to store anyone’s data any longer?
Here’s one troubling reason: Because even after one of the gravest breaches in history, no one is really in a position to stop Equifax from continuing to do business as usual. And the problem is bigger than Equifax: We really have no good way, in public policy, to exact some existential punishment on companies that fail to safeguard our data. There will be hacks — and afterward, there will be more.
There’s a simple, practical solution to that conundrum: let the courts decide. All that needs to happen to solve the problem is for Equifax to be held responsible for the costs, direct and indirect, of the data that it held’s becoming public and the problem along with the company will go away.
Holding vast amounts of private and sensitive data is a business model. When the profitability of the business model depended on inadequate controls as seems to be the case, why should the federal government act or not act to prop up that model? If the functions that Equifax performed are so vital to the functioning of our society as seems to be claims, perhaps we should not depend on a private company to perform them?
As to the executives who are alleged to have sold large blocks of their stock in Equifax prior to the announcement, the question will become what did they know and when did they know it? If they knew about the breach in anticipation of selling their stock, they should be indicted for insider trading and, if found guilty, subject to the maximum penalty—20 years in prison and a $5 million dollar fine. That will open the floodgates for what promises to be the largest class action suit in history.
We need to come to the understanding that size itself can be a problem. A company that is too large to be allowed to fail is too large to be allowed to exist.






