Getting Used to Disappointment

Read Erik Goepner’s and Trevor Thrall’s post at War on the Rocks to understand why I am perennially disappointed in American foreign policy:

President Donald Trump has expanded every aspect of the war on terror he inherited from his two predecessors. In his first nine months Trump has ordered a renewed surge in Afghanistan, increased the tempo of drone strikes, and granted the military greater autonomy. Meanwhile, in Afghanistan, the Taliban now control or contest more districts than at any point since 2001. And last week four American soldiers died in Niger, an increasingly active front in the war on terror. Americans are now fighting — and dying — in at least eight different countries across the Middle East and Central Asia. The deaths of American forces are a particularly sobering reminder of the war’s high costs and should prompt people to ask whether the costs are worth it.

Unfortunately, the evidence of the past 16 years clearly indicates that the answer is no. Enough time has now passed since 9/11 to reach two important conclusions. First, the threat posed by Islamist-inspired terrorism does not justify such a mammoth effort. Second, the aggressive military strategy the United States has pursued since 2001 has not only failed to reduce the threat of terrorism; it has likely made things worse.

which is basically the gospel I’ve been preaching for the last 25 years. A good rule of thumb for what our foreign policy should be is look closely at what American presidents have done over the period of roughly the last quarter century and do the opposite. I’d push the timeline back farther than that to include the entire post-war period but at least we stood by and watched the Soviet Union collapse without actually going to war with it.

0 comments

The Real China

I want to encourage you to read Isaac Stone Fish’s disquisition on China today at the Los Angeles Times:

One time the veil fell for me. I was visiting Henan, a Chinese province with all the charm of a New Jersey and the educational competencies of an Arkansas. At a restaurant, a drunk man outfitted like a mid-level Chinese Communist Party official — zippered jacket, black leather shoes, a man-purse — approached my table, complimented my Chinese, and asked me how I liked his province. I lied and told him it was very nice. He beamed with approval and staggered away. When I called for the check, the waiter informed me that the drunk man had paid for it.

Outside, his wife propped him up. “Hey!” he slurred. “I paid for your meal. I work for the tax bureau. I’m the boss here. They at this restaurant have to be nice to me or I’ll shut them down.” I, and the Party — not the rules, or slogans or statements — we are what matters, he seemed to say. His wife, mortified, interrupted with the usual banalities. “Welcome to Henan,” she said. “China has 5,000 years of history, and Henan has several important historic sites. I hope you enjoy your visit to China.”

His point is how the opacity of the Chinese Communist Party makes being able to report on what’s actually happening in the country difficult if not impossible. It’s also why it’s better to rely on externally measurable characteristics rather than on official government announcements and press releases.

2 comments

Streamlining the Federal Government

I’m skeptical of Tim Rund’s proposal for using “shared services” to cut federal spending:

As the national debt clock spins towards the flashing red zone of 20 trillion dollars — a level greater than our gross domestic product — policymakers will need to find serious solutions to balance the nation’s books. The challenge ahead is one that will only be solved with a combination of policy changes, novel practices, and specific reform initiatives conducted over time. Fortunately, a handful of promising options are starting to emerge, which may help to broadly reduce federal expenditures and serve as catalysts for institutional change in government planning and execution.

One of these options is Shared Services — an increasingly attractive and sensible concept that is gaining interest in both the executive branch and Congress. Shared services is basically an administrative service designed to meet common, standardized requirements of multiple agencies with delivery of those services by third-party providers (public or private), often in the areas of information technology, business processes, or labor components. Though not entirely new, the idea of shared services in government is particularly timely and valuable now, given the pressing need to cut costs and reduce waste wherever we can. Beyond the obvious fiscal advantages, shared services also represents a data-driven, targeted, and fact-informed approach to reducing unnecessary government duplication, agency stove-piping, and other counter-productive inefficiencies that too often mark the operations of government. Shared services is not simply a way to save money, but a way to get government to work better for its citizens.

for three reasons. First, isn’t that exactly what the GSA is supposed to do? He doesn’t mention the GSA once in his op-ed. Is he unaware of what it does? Does he think its role should be expanded? Does he think it isn’t doing its job?

Second, the state of Illinois consolidates shared services under Central Management Services. I don’t believe its track record would show that it has saved money. In information technology terms it’s between one and two decades behind where most large companies are these days. IMO that’s no accident but inherent to the procurement and policy approaches inherent to government at all levels.

Third, a fundamental principle of optimization theory is that your best target for optimization is where there’s the most to optimize. In the federal government that’s health care spending, Social Security, military spending, and interest on the debt. Everything else is small potatoes in relative terms but all three of those are political hot potatoes.

2 comments

CBO Decides That Health Care Insurance Is Price Sensitive

Who’d a thunk it? If health care insurance is too expensive, people don’t participate. That’s what the editors of the Washington Post say about the Congressional Budget Office’s findings on the Alexander-Murray compromise:

The Alexander-Murray bill would restore the payments for two years. The CBO predicts that, though the damage has been done for 2018, the bill would restrain premiums and cut government spending in 2019. If the payments were continued beyond that point, the savings would presumably continue, as well.

But the Alexander-Murray plan contains much more, and the CBO’s findings on the bill’s Obamacare reforms are the most illuminating pieces of the new analysis. For example, the bill would allow all people to buy “copper” (as opposed to gold, silver or bronze) health-care plans, which would offer consumers less generous benefits at a lower monthly price. The CBO found that this provision would draw more healthy people into the individual market, lowering average premiums and saving the government $1 billion. Streamlining the process though which states can obtain waivers from Obamacare rules, meanwhile, would spur more state-based experimentation.

The causality goes the opposite direction from what the Reid-Pelosi Congress apparently believed. Lower costs result in more people being insured. More people being insured don’t necessarily result in lower costs.

If we genuinely want people to be able to obtain health care without being penurized by it, the name of the game is cost control. Affordability through subsidy is a sucker’s game. It will inevitably result in the prices rising to absorb any subsidy.

1 comment

The Neverending Story

Will the Washington Post story that the Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee paid for the notorious “Russia dossier” change the trajectory of the investigation presently under way?

Updated

The editors of the Wall Street Journal join the scrum:

It turns out that Russia has sown distrust in the U.S. political system—aided and abetted by the Democratic Party, and perhaps the FBI. This is an about-face from the dominant media narrative of the last year, and it requires a full investigation.

The Washington Post revealed Tuesday that the Hillary Clinton campaign and Democratic National Committee jointly paid for that infamous “dossier” full of Russian disinformation against Donald Trump. They filtered the payments through a U.S. law firm (Perkins Coie), which hired the opposition-research hit men at Fusion GPS. Fusion in turn tapped a former British spook, Christopher Steele, to compile the allegations, which are based largely on anonymous, Kremlin-connected sources.

Strip out the middlemen, and it appears that Democrats paid for Russians to compile wild allegations about a U.S. presidential candidate. Did someone say “collusion”?

It will be interesting to see whether these revelations change the tune of those who’ve been screaming “Collusion!” in their opposition to Trump. It doesn’t prove that the Trump campaign didn’t “collude” with the Russians but it does suggest collusion cuts both ways.

9 comments

What Happens After an Election Loss

I urge you to read Damon Linker’s essay at The Week on the ongoing Democratic meltdown. I agree with just about everything in it. Here’s a snippet:

For the first few weeks of the Trump presidency, legions of Democrats who voted for Hillary Clinton and hated her opponent attended protests at which they got to demonstrate publicly that they now hated Trump even more. That worked well as therapy and catharsis, but it did nothing to advance the Democrat Party’s electoral prospects.

Then Democrats spent much of the spring and summer fixated on Russian interference in the election, which conveniently allowed them to defer an honest reckoning with the misjudgments that had left Trump and Clinton close enough in the final weeks of the campaign that outside interference was able to make a meaningful difference to the outcome on Nov. 8.

Since then, efforts at a broader analysis have tended to emphasize racism as by far the most important factor in Republican victories — which ensures that Democrats won’t even try to win over voters from the other party, who are presumed to reside on the other side of a moral chasm that is both impossible and undesirable to bridge. It also ensures that this becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, since people usually avoid voting for a party when its members regularly hurl insults at them.

And that brings us to where we are today, with large numbers of elite Democrats preferring to rant impotently on Twitter about the president and the GOP agenda instead of doing the hard and at times painful work of overcoming that impotence at the ballot box.

As I’ve pointed out every so often over the period of the last 15 years here at The Glittering Eye this is what political parties do after particularly bitter defeats. They struggle for power within the party. There is presently a struggle going on between members of the erstwhile DLC and the progressive wing of the party. The latter is absolutely, positively convinced that appealing more strongly to the 10% of the country that they represent is a sure path to victory.

The reality of politics in the U. S. today is that where each party is strong it is very strong and where it’s weak it’s virtually powerless. Consolidating the California and New York vote will do practically nothing to help the Democrats any more than gaining a bigger Texas vote will help Republicans.

Meanwhile, I’ll continue the futile task of pointing out that there is no substitute for good governance. Illinois’s terrible, awful, corrupt Democratic Party casts the entire party into disrepute. Its feckless supine Republican Party doesn’t even make a pretext of challenging it. For reasons that elude me this is seen as a formula for success.

7 comments

The Pig Likes It

I would make an exhaustive list of everyone who’s been dirtied by the Trump-Russia-collusion investigation but I have limited time and space. James Comey. Robert Mueller. The FBI. The Clintons. The Podesta brothers. The DNC. Just about every, indeed, who’s touched it except Trump. Oh, well. Maybe later.

A reader reminded me recently of the old wisecrack about mud ‘rasslin’ with a pig. Apt.

4 comments

We Have No Allies

Arizona Sen. John McCain’s view of the world, as expressed in his New York Times op-ed, is quite straightforward. We have enemies, e.g. Iran. We have allies. He only mentions one ally by name: the Kurds, a people who have never had a country of their own and who are likely never to have one:

A web of Iranian proxies and allies is spreading from the Levant to the Arabian Peninsula, threatening stability, freedom of navigation and the territory of our partners and allies, including with advanced conventional weapons. Iran itself continues to test ballistic missiles, menace its neighbors and use its sanctions relief windfall to harmful ends.

Our Arab allies are absorbed in a diplomatic dispute with Qatar in the face of far more pressing threats. And behind all this is the shadow of Vladimir Putin’s Russia, which is re-establishing itself as a regional power broker actively hostile to American interests — and wholly unconcerned about human rights or civilian life.

This must be a very comforting view but it’s one I cannot support.

Let’s start with “threatening stability”. What country has created more instability in the Middle East and North Africa than any other? That would be the United States. We have overthrown or assisted in the overthrow of at least two governments there: Iraq and Libya. We have connived at the overthrow of Syria, giving support and training to groups antithetical to our interests. We connived at the overthrow of the Mubarak government in Egypt. We have assisted and supported Saudi Arabia in its illegal, aggressive, and genocidal war against Yemen. We continue to wage war in another half dozen countries in the region. We have interfered with elections.

Let’s move on to “allies”. I think he’s overselling the Kurds for reasons I’ve explained elsewhere but he mentions Arab allies. Who are they? I would offer a contrasting view. We have no allies in the Middle East and North Africa, only clients. We have precious few allies anywhere. And the very best thing we could do to increase the stability of MENA would be to stop fomenting instability.

2 comments

Okay, You Don’t Like M4A. Why?

I don’t honestly know how Steve Rattner came to be thought of as a Democratic Party pundit. I know he’s a strong fundraiser and general party apparatchik. Other than that I see few if any qualifications for the role.

This morning in an op-ed in the New York Times it’s clear that Mr. Rattner has two complaints about the party’s adopting support for “Medicare for All” (M4A) as a litmus for the party going forward:

As a centrist Democrat, I’m scared to see my party pulled into positions that are both bad politics and dubious policy. And I’m disappointed that few of our party’s moderates are willing to resist the freight train coming at us from the left.

I think he makes a pretty fair case that it’s bad politics. The closest he comes to making a case that it’s bad policy is it costs too much:

Spellbound Democrats should also consider the fate of past single payer proposals. In Sanders’s home state of Vermont, a single payer plan was abandoned after an analysis found that it would require a near doubling of the state budget (and increasing taxes similarly).

In Colorado last November, a whopping 80 percent of voters rejected a universal plan, again over taxes and costs. And for similar reasons, California recently shelved a single-payer proposal.

Amid the many complications of Medicare for All, the question of what would happen to the 157 million Americans who get their insurance from their employers and the 19 million who are enrolled in Medicare Advantage loom large.

That Vermont and Colorado demurred from adopting state level single player plans is actually a political argument masquerading as a policy argument. The last paragraph is about as close as he comes and it’s pretty weak tea, amounting to an observation that there are lots of details that would need to be worked out. That didn’t stop the Affordable Care Act.

I’m skeptical of M4A as policy but I have some clear reasons for it, namely cost, time inconsistency, the impossibility of limiting coverage, and bleak prospects for cost savings through streamlined administration.

Cost is obviously a problem. Health care costs in the United States are an order of magnitude (at least) higher than they were when any OECD country adopted its present health care system, whether single payer, national health service, or related. When the U. S. adopted the Medicare system utilization went up and we should expect the same with M4A. Simply put health care in the U. S. is just too expensive for M4A to be affordable. At the very least even its supporters should find the cost issue daunting.

To believe that the U. S. will impose cost controls after adopting M4A is to believe that the federal government will behave differently this time than it has in the past. All of the political signals point in the direction of no cost controls and I see little prospect for a sudden change of heart now. If the Congress had had the stomach to control health care costs in Medicare, we wouldn’t have seen “doc fixes” enacted year after year until the Congress abandoned the charade.

The United States also faces an issue which no other OECD country has: it has a 1,500 mile land border with a country with a median income a quarter of its own and in which the national interest favors an open border. Unless we’re going to limit M4A to citizens, something that I think will be politically impossible, we will be inviting the entire world here for health care.

Finally, some have pointed to Medicare’s low administrative costs as a reason it should be a model for the entire U. S. I think that’s far-fetched. IMO it’s likely that Medicare’s true administrative costs are buried. The reality is that administrative costs in the U. S. are higher. Look at our educational system.

8 comments

Identity Politics, Class, and Religion

There’s a thought-provoking post by Joshua Mitchell at City Journal on identity politics, class, and religion I’d like to commend to your attention. Here’s a snippet:

Sustained legalized slavery in America, over more than two centuries, sets African-Americans apart from all others who are now here in our country. African-Americans are not one “identity” among others. My father’s family, one example among millions in America today, came from Lebanon in the 1890s. His immigrant family was not treated particularly well, nor was he. (He nevertheless lied about his age, joined the Marines after graduating high school, and served in the Pacific theater during World War II.) Toleration and acceptance are hard-won and do not happen in a generation. In the identity-politics world, my father’s immigrant family would have been granted the fault-and-guilt debt points to which his immigrant identity entitled him. To which every immigrant family with a long history in America should say, “Nonsense.”

I’ve written about class here in the United States in the past. Mr. Mitchell is correct in that here in the United States class is different than elsewhere, determined by money. But we actually have more classes than he lists and which I’d delineate by source of income. If you punch a clock and are paid by the piece or by the hour, in general you’re working class—blue collar. If you receive a salary, in general you’re middle class. The rich are divided into two subclasses. One subclass is wealthy by virtue of owning assets; the other is wealthy by virtue of government subsidy.

9 comments