A Matter of Timing

In his gloomy long-term forecast on the return on investments at Forbes William Baldwin lost me a bit when he wrote this:

Stocks have returned a glorious 7% annually over the past century (total return, net of inflation). Continuing on the same course, they’d deliver very comfortable golden years to you. But they won’t do that. The stock market is now poised to deliver not even half its historical return.

because he perpetuated a widespread misunderstanding. Consider the chart of the performance of the Dow-Jones Industrial Average from 1915 to 2017, displayed above. It’s true that the average returns since the end of World War II have been about 7%.

What were the average returns from January 1966 to April 1995? They were zero over a twenty-nine year period. In other words if you started investing in a DJIA-indexed fund at age 35 in January of 1966 (if there had been such things at the time) and retired at age 64 your investments would have realized exactly nothing. Unless dividends were paid but that’s another story.

How about if you put money into a DJIA-indexed fund in December of 1999 and withdrew it in May of 2013? How much would you have realized. Again, zero.

The DJIA doesn’t increase in with smooth, dependable regularity but in fits and starts. Unless there’s a compelling reason to think otherwise we should expect that to continue for the foreseeable future or, in other words, we simply can’t predict what the value of an investment will be that far out. It depends not only on your acumen (or the acumen of your investment advisor—another topic for a post) but on your timing.

That’s why I believe that some form of social insurance is necessary. Putting your money into 30 year Treasuries is just about the equivalent of burying it in the ground and, unless you’re willing to accept higher levels of risk, the likelihood of your losing your money rises as you climb the “risk ladder” seeking higher returns. Some will be winners and some will be losers.

Unless you’re willing to allow the losers to starve, some form of social insurance is necessary. It also explains why I think the Fed’s strategy has been so damaging but that, too, is a topic for another post.

8 comments

October Surprise?

CNN has filed a story saying that special counsel Robert Mueller has received approval from a federal grand jury of the first charges in his investigation of Russian influence in the 2016 presidential election. No word yet on what the charges are or who they’re levied against. Also no identification of the source or sources for the story or independent corroboration from other sources or outlets.

12 comments

A Counter-Intuitive View of the Housing Numbers

You don’t have to look very hard for glowing characterizations of the numbers on housing sales for September. Jeffrey Snider provides a more dour view in his latest lengthy offering at RealClearMarkets:

The unadjusted sales estimate, that 52,000, was up almost 20%, too, but year-over-year rather than month on month. It sounds impressive but it’s actually more typical of the last few years, suggesting there wasn’t anything all that special about September’s builder activity. There really isn’t any good way, especially in a very noisy data series like home sales, to compare one month to the next.

There is much less for statistics in comparing September 2017 new home sales to those in September 2016, as I did above, or to those in September 1995. In fact, there were fewer new homes sold last month than in the same month twenty-two years ago; 52,000 vs. 54,000.

That’s the part to really focus on, and the one no one ever does in tying 20% growth to something it truly isn’t. The numbers that relate to the comparison, or should if there weren’t something else going on, are staggering. Between September 1995 and September 2017, the Civilian Non-institutional Population, the BLS’s estimate of potential laborers in the US, expanded by 56.6 million people.

How is it possible, then, that fewer new homes were sold in a “very good” month just recently than almost a generation ago?

By population alone there should have been something like 70,000 new homes sold in September (+56.6mm population represents a 28% gain, so 54,000 new homes sold in 1995 should lead to 69,300 new homes sold in 2017 for a constant demographic). The easy answer is the housing bust, meaning that twelve years ago and before there was a rush of new homes built that really should not have been; for some time, the US housing stock was overdone.

That explanation, however, doesn’t follow in the demographics, either. It has been, again, twelve years since that peak, and for almost all of those twelve years since then housing construction has remained at a rate well-below historical trends. By all counts, after so much time, the oversupply of those housing units has been absorbed and then some.

Basically, although the population has grown people don’t have enough money to buy houses, either because they don’t have jobs or because the jobs they do have don’t pay enough to buy houses.

To his analysis I would add one thing, something I haven’t mentioned in a while. When the factors of production are themselves portable Ricardo’s analysis of international trade is no longer operative. Comparative advantage no longer matters because what conveys that advantage may then move from country to country. All that matters is absolute advantage.

1 comment

To Ask Is to Answer

I didn’t even need to read Elizabeth Drew’s article at The New Republic, “Who Knew Trump Would Be a Weak President?”, to answer it. Anybody who’d been observing the presidency with an informed eye for any period of time knew.

In my opinion we’ve had at most four strong presidents in the post-war period, the strongest by far having been Johnson. Others I think were definitely strong presidents were Nixon and Reagan. Others can be argued.

I think it’s difficult to argue that we haven’t had three consecutive weak presidents, culminating in Donald Trump.

Can Trump recover? Can he become a strong president? Beats me. He claims to be a quick study but so far I haven’t seen it. I do not believe that any president can be a strong president without the ability to bend the Congress to his or her will and in the legal phrase, res ipsa loquitur.

A question for the interested student: are strong presidents good presidents?

10 comments

Everybody Loses

Yesterday I sketched out how the Democrats are responding to their election loss last year. What has not been sufficiently pointed out is that both political parties are behaving as though they lost the presidential election for a very simple reason. Trump was elected president because enough voters in enough states to elect a president repudiated the positions of the political establishments of both major political parties in specific policy areas.

Now both Democrats and Republicans are hurriedly trying to underscore their past errors. I’m not sure how they think this will benefit them but they apparently think it will.

2 comments

The Dark Corner of Government

Did you know that hiring contractors to augment the federal workforce was a felony? And that it has been since 1884? If not, neither did I and I learned that and a lot more by reading Robert J. Hanrahan Jr.’s post at RCPolicy:

The civil service’s growth is limited by the budgets enacted by Congress and executed by the president. But many federal agencies do an end run around hiring freezes by hiring contractors instead of federal employees to perform government work. The result? Bureaucracy expands rather than shrinks, congressional oversight is lost, ethical restrictions don’t apply, and government growth continues in defiance of known laws.

This is a purely political problem; by hiring contractors rather than increasing the size of the federal civil services the Congress can claim that they’re limiting the growth of government without actually limiting the growth of government.

I’m glad that more light is being shed on this dark corner of government. How dark is it? Nobody really knows how many contractors are presently being employed by the federal government. The first step towards honesty in government is honesty and the honest truth is that we presently demand lots of goods and services from the federal government—indeed, more than we’re willing to pay for. I’m on the record as being in support of sweeping civil service reform but, frankly, one of the byproducts of that reform will be a lot more civil service employees than we have now and a lot fewer contractors.

0 comments

Stick to Your Knitting

I agree with Fareed Zakaria’s latest column in the Washington Post:

Ever since China abandoned its Maoist isolation in the 1970s, its guiding philosophy was set by Deng Xiaoping. At that time, China needed to learn from the West, especially the United States, and integrate itself into the existing international order. According to Deng, it should be humble and modest in its foreign policy, “hide its light under a bushel,” and “bide its time.” But the time has now come, in Xi’s view, and he said the Middle Kingdom is ready to “take center stage in the world.”

Xi’s speech is important because this party congress made clear that he is no ordinary leader. He ascended to a second term in office without naming any obvious successors from the next generation of party officials, thus maintaining a grip on power far more secure than his immediate predecessors. More important, the party enshrined his thoughts in the constitution, an honor previously accorded only to Mao Zedong in his lifetime. (Deng’s thoughts were added, but only posthumously.) This means that for the rest of his life, Xi and his ideas will dominate the Communist Party of China.

and

Meanwhile, consider how the United States must look now to the rest of the world. It is politically paralyzed, unable to make major decisions. Amidst a ballooning debt, its investments in education, infrastructure, and science and technology are seriously lacking. Politics has become a branch of reality TV, with daily insults, comebacks and color commentary. America’s historical leadership role in the world has been replaced by a narrow and cramped ideology. Foreign policy has become a partisan game, with Washington breaking agreements, shifting course and reversing policy almost entirely to score political points at home.

in one particular. I think we should be worrying a lot more about our own problems, what kind of country we want to be, and how to become (or remain!) that country than we are about China or any other country for that matter. Every single pragmatic problem he lists, i.e. debt, investments in education, infrastructure, and science and technology,are much graver problems in China than here. China has problems of its own with which it has shown little inclination to come to terms.

0 comments

Defending the Tax Code

As I’ve written in the past, one of the reasons that reforming the tax code is so difficult is that every single provision in it has a constituency that will defend their pet provision strenuously. The editors of the New York Times leap to the defense of the deduction for state and local taxes, a subsidy to jurisdictions that depend on high taxes:

One change is getting a lot of attention: Republican leaders want to eliminate the state and local tax deduction. This would hurt many Americans, especially those who live in states like California and New York with high state and local taxes.

That group clearly includes many rich families, but more than half of this deduction benefited taxpayers with incomes of less than $200,000 in 2015, according to Government Finance Officers Association, which represents officials from local and state governments. Some of these people might do fine under the framework, but tax experts say many will clearly be hurt because their total itemized deductions exceed the new, higher standard deduction proposed by the framework – $24,000 for couples and $12,000 for singles.

They also provide some eye-catching infographics. One of those infographics shows the pictures of House Democratic and Republican leadership and the percentages of their constituencies who “use this deduction”. Unsurprisingly, the numbers vary from 20% “using” in Luke Messer’s Indiana congressional district to 48% “using” in Steny Hoyer’s Maryland district.

I wish they’d been simultaneously a little broader and a little narrower and shown us the percentages of all Congressmen’s districts who benefit by $2,000 or more per year from the deduction. I agree with the NYT editors that it’s puzzling that Congressmen would want to hurt their own constituents but defending deductions for the rich in the name of not hurting the little guy is equally “pathetic” to use the NYT editors’ word.

All of this illustrates why I’d support a revenue neutral reduction or elimination of the income tax on corporations in the interest of efficiency and increasing economic growth, balancing that with adding a new, higher personal income tax bracket above the presently highest one of 39.6% for those with taxable incomes above $418,400.

3 comments

Legal Questions

I have a couple of legal questions.

Here’s the first. Party A hacks into Party B’s email server and then, unsolicited, gives the information found to Party C. What crime if any has Party C committed?

Here’s the second. How far does attorney-client privilege extend? At what point does it become conspiracy?

5 comments

One Hundred Years Later

I suppose I would be remiss in not mentioning that yesterday marked the centenary of the October Revolution (in the Old Style calendar; in the New Style November 7). The Bolshevik Revolution was a thoroughgoing disaster for Russia. Tens of millions of Russians died needlessly and it set Russia’s development back by 70 years.

And the disaster is ongoing. When a country’s institutions are torn down as thoroughly as the Soviets tore Russia’s institutions down, they aren’t replaced overnight. The only institutions left standing when the Communist Party collapsed were the military, the KGB, organized crime, and the last vestiges of the Orthodox Church.

Those are the institutions ruling and sustaining Russia today.

27 comments