Increasing growth by 0.4 percentage points on a sustained basis might sound doable, but such an increase actually means raising projected growth rates by more than one-fifth and is unlikely to occur because of tax reform alone.
Certainly, policymakers should work toward enacting reforms to improve economic growth by as much as possible, and tax reform is one critical piece of a comprehensive growth plan. But the tax reform plan under consideration is unlikely to generate more than 0.1 percentage points of increased growth per year, and over the long run it may actually slow economic growth. Lawmakers should not pretend otherwise but should instead both work to improve the bill and enact other pro-growth policies, including improving the debt trajectory, entitlement reform, regulatory reform, and labor market improvements.
What is needed is much more targeted reform. Other reforms that should be considered include trade reform (more reciprocity), reforms specifically designed to encourage domestic business investment, and immigration reform.
I’ve mentioned it before. There’s a wonderful little book called “How to Lie With Statistics” that should be required reading (it was required reading at my high school). Justin Fox’s recent piece at Bloomberg View, comparing overall taxes paid with the costs of education and health care for various different countries could be a case study. Consider this graph, for example:
It has several problems. What is it measuring? Average tuition? Median tuition? There no way to tell. Additionally, three-quarters of American students attend public colleges and universities. What percentage of Japanese college students attend Japanese private college or universities? Israeli? There’s no way to tell, at least not from the information that’s provided. Worse yet it adjusts the numbers based on purchasing power parity. In other words the data are already adjusted to normalize costs among countries. With all of that finagling the graph tells you practically nothing. I would bet that American public university costs are a lot higher than Japanese or Canadian but that’s just a guess.
Or this graph:
It has a similar list of problems. For one thing what is “voluntary health insurance” in the United States? Isn’t there an individual mandate? Is voluntary health insurance in France the same as voluntary health insurance in the United States? I don’t think so. I think a graph similar to this would have told a clear story if it had been limited to out-of-pocket spending for health care but I think it could have told a very different story. Or if it had just compared Medicare spending with spending for people over 65 in other countries.
I believe that Mr. Fox is attempting to make the case that Americans could get a lot more for their money by channeling it through the federal government via taxes. IMO the reality is that healthcare and education are expensive in the United States because so much of them is channeled through government at all levels and government is very expensive here, Americans know that, and, consequently, are wary of big promises by big government advocates.
I think we can safely conclude that the editors of the Wall Street Journal very much support cutting taxes. They’ve got two editorials on the subject today. In the first editorial they point to the inadequacies of the present system:
Start with the fact that the GOP budget outline allows for a net tax cut of $1.5 trillion over a decade on a statically scored basis thanks to a deal brokered by Senators Pat Toomey and Bob Corker. Democrats and their media chorus are using that number to claim that reform will bust the budget and add to the federal debt. This comes with ill grace from people who cheered Barack Obama’s doubling of the national debt in eight years, but it’s also overwrought.
The actual budget hole is smaller than $1.5 trillion because the GOP budget is scored on a “current law†baseline. This assumes that tax breaks that are “current policy†will expire and more revenue will flow to Treasury. This is worth more than $400 billion over 10 years, which means the budget “hole†is closer to $1 trillion out of the $43 trillion the Congressional Budget Office projects in revenues over the next decade. In other words, this is a modest net tax cut even assuming no additional economic growth.
CBO’s estimates are inherently speculative because no one knows when the next recession might hit or what some future Congress might do. But CBO has typically underestimated the growth and revenue feedback from tax cuts. A classic example is the 2003 cut in the tax rate on capital gains. Dan Clifton of Strategas Research notes that in January 2004, eight months after the tax cut passed, CBO predicted $215 billion in capital-gains revenue through 2007. The actual figure? $377 billion. CBO underestimated economic growth and how much investors would cash in their gains.
CBO’s roughly $43 trillion revenue estimate also depends on a projection of average economic growth of 1.9% a year. But the U.S. economy has never grown that slowly for so long. CBO says that every 0.1% increase in GDP adds about $270 billion in revenue over 10 years. That means a mere four years at 3% growth—the U.S. historical norm—could fill a $1 trillion hole. An average growth rate of even 2.4% over the decade would more than fill the hole.
Nearby we reprint a letter from some of the country’s most distinguished economists making the case that the House and Senate reforms will significantly raise U.S. growth potential. The biggest boost comes from the reductions in the tax burden on capital, which should increase investment and thus growth.
One of the signers, Larry Lindsey, predicted in our pages this fall that economic growth under the GOP plan would accelerate to 3.2% for three to five years and then settle at 2.5%. The Tax Foundation predicts the Senate plan will produce more than $1 trillion in revenue, in part thanks to an investment catalyst from immediate capital expensing in the first year.
The left ignores all this and flogs as unrefutable whatever emerges from the Joint Committee on Taxation. But Joint Tax assumes the U.S. is a partially “closed†economy with little access to global markets. Its models assume that higher deficits will “crowd out†private borrowing and thus drive up interest rates and offset the growth impact of the tax cut. Yet a major goal of the tax reform is make the U.S. more competitive as a destination for foreign capital, and interest rates in a global capital market will be determined by far more than a modest increase in the U.S. budget deficit.
Another false charge from the left is that the GOP bills are merely a tax cut without any reform. But the bills eliminate trillions of dollars in loopholes, such as the state and local tax deduction. The House bill caps the mortgage-interest deduction at $500,000.
while the second piece outlines notions of how the run on effects of a tax cut in the form of an open letter to the Secretary of the Treasury signed by a list of economists and other worthies:
The present debate over tax reforms proposed by President Trump’s administration and embodied in bills that have passed the House of Representatives and the Senate Finance Committee has raised the basic question of whether the bills are “pro-growthâ€: Would the proposals raise current and future economic activity and generate federal tax revenue that would reduce the “static cost†of the reforms? This letter explains why we believe that the answer to these questions is “yes.â€
Economists generally think of fundamental tax reform as a set of tax changes that reduces tax distortions on productive activities (for example, business investment and work) and broadens the tax base to reduce tax differences among similarly situated businesses and individuals. Fundamental tax reform should also advance the objectives of fairness and simplification.
The quest for such fundamental tax reform has been pursued by policy makers and economists for decades. Examples include the Tax Reform Act of 1986, proposals for reducing the double taxation of corporate equity by the Treasury Department and the American Law Institute (enacted in part in 2003), the “Growth and Investment Plan†from President George W. Bush’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform, and arguments from President Obama’s administration to lower corporate tax rates. The proposals emerging from the House, Senate, and President Trump’s administration, fall squarely within this tradition.
Reducing Corporate Tax Rates, as Proposed, Will Increase Economic Activity
While the overall House and Senate tax plans contain numerous household and business provisions, we focus on the corporate tax changes, returning to other provisions before concluding. A key concept in this context is the “user cost of capital,†which essentially measures the expected cost to firms of making additional investments in equipment. A considerable body of economic research concludes that reductions in the user cost of capital raise output in the short and long run. Several of the proposals that have emerged in the current debate are key to lowering the user cost of capital. For example, expensing, which allows firms to deduct the full cost of investment at the time it is made, lowers the user cost of capital relative to depreciation over time. A lower corporate tax rate also lowers the user cost of capital, which not only induces U.S. firms to invest more, but also makes it more attractive for both U.S. and foreign multinational corporations to locate investment in the United States.
There is some uncertainty about just how much additional investment is induced by reductions in the cost of capital, but based on an extensive body of scholarly research, many economists believe that a 10% reduction in the cost of capital would lead to a 10% increase in the amount of investment. Simultaneously reducing the corporate tax rate to 20% and moving to immediate expensing of equipment and intangible investment would reduce the user cost by an average of 15%, which would increase the demand for capital by 15%. A conventional approach to economic modeling suggests that such an increase in the capital stock would raise the level of GDP in the long run by just over 4%. If achieved over a decade, the associated increase in the annual rate of GDP growth would be about 0.4% per year. Because the House and Senate bills contemplate expensing only for five years, the increase in capital accumulation would be less, and the gain in the long-run level of GDP would be just over 3%, or 0.3% per year for a decade.
Is this estimate of the growth effect realistic? According to one leading model using an alternative framework, the proposal would increase the U.S. capital stock by between 12% and 19%, which would raise the level of GDP in the long run by between 3% and 5%. Yet another model, this one used in the analysis of the “Growth and Investment Plan†in the 2005 President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform, found that a business cash-flow tax with expensing and a corporate tax rate of 30% would yield a 20.4% increase in the capital stock in the long run and a 4.8% increase in GDP in the long run. More conservative estimates from the OECD suggest that corporate tax changes alone would raise long-run GDP by 2%. In short, there is a substantial body of research suggesting that fundamental tax reform of the type being proposed would have an important effect on long-run GDP. We view long-run effects of about 3% assuming five years of full expensing, and 4% assuming permanent full expensing, as reasonable estimates.
Another advantage of the corporate rate reduction embodied in the House and Senate Finance bills is that it would lead both U.S. and foreign firms to invest more in the United States. In addition, U.S. multinational firms would face a reduced incentive to shift profits abroad, which would raise federal revenue, all else equal.
In the foregoing analysis, we assumed a revenue-neutral corporate tax change. Deficit financing of part of a reduction in taxes increases federal debt and interest rates, all else equal. For the House and Senate Finance bills, this offset is likely to be modest, given that the United States operates in an international capital market, which means that the impact of changes in interest rates resulting from greater investment demand and government borrowing are likely to be relatively small.
Lowering Individual Tax Rates Also Offers Generally Positive Economic Effects
The House and Senate bills also contemplate a number of individual tax provisions that can affect economic activity and incomes. In recognition of the fact that non-corporate business income is substantial in the United States, both bills would reduce taxation of non-corporate business income and increase the amount of capital expensing allowed. While difficult to quantify, as the bills specify different effective tax rates, these provisions would increase investment and GDP above the level associated with the corporate tax changes discussed above. Also on the individual side, both the House and Senate bills reduce marginal tax rates on labor income for most taxpayers, increasing the reward for work. Increases in labor supply, in turn, increase taxable income and tax revenues. One should note, however, that some taxpayers would face increases in effective marginal tax rates because of base-broadening features of the bills, such as limits on the federal tax deductibility of state and local income taxes. On balance, though, we believe that the individual tax base broadening embodied in the proposals would enhance economic efficiency by confronting most households with lower marginal tax rates. In addition, fairness would be served by reducing differences in the tax treatment of individuals with similar incomes, and simplification by reducing the number of individuals who itemize for federal tax purposes.
Confirming a Pro-Growth Objective Is Important for the Path Forward
You have consistently stressed that the objective of tax reform should be to enhance prospects for increased economic growth and household incomes. We agree with this objective, which is consistent with the traditional norms of public finance going back to Adam Smith. We believe that the reforms embodied in the House and Senate Finance bills would achieve this objective. The increased growth, in turn, would lead to greater taxable income and federal tax revenues, which would reduce the static cost of lost federal tax revenue from the reform.
We hope these analytical points of support for the growth effects of tax plans being discussed are useful to you and to the Congress as you complete the important economic task of fundamental tax reform. We would be happy to discuss our conclusions with you at your convenience.
I’ve already outlined my views on our tax system multiple times. I think that at the very least we should cut the corporate income tax so the nominal rates fall within OECD norms, preferably abolishing it entirely, and add a tax rate above present brackets to make up the difference. A more complete overhaul would abolish both corporate and personal income tax in favor of a prebated VAT.
I wish the Democratic Congressional leadership would present their views in a more complete way. Democratic arguments against tax cuts have tended to center around fairness, something for which I never recall their giving a real definition. A head tax meets intuitive ideas of fairness. They’re enforceable but highly regressive. What’s called a “flat tax” (single tax bracket) also meets intuitive ideas of fairness but it, too, is regressive.
Consider this graph:
Clearly, the present system isn’t fair. The lowest 50% of income earners pay too little; the top 1% pay too much. In the light of that graph and their frequent complaints about fairness I think it’s incumbent on the Democratic leadership to define their idea of fairness.
I also want to know how they’ll meet our future spending commitments at the very low rate of economic growth that prevailed under the Obama Administration or, alternatively, how they’d encourage economic growth. I find it amusing that the very same people who complained that the Republicans had no alternative health care reform plan in 2010 do not fault the Democrats for having no credible economic plan now.
I’m skeptical of the Republican view. I don’t think that we can achieve the level of economic growth they foresee as long as we import as much as we do, so much of GDP is based on consumer spending, and domestic business investment is so low. I also see little in their plans which would change any of that.
When I say “it’s complicated”, that’s what I mean.
There is one tiny fact missing from the Washington Post editorial calling for the Congress to allow those brought here illegally by their parents as children to remain in the country:
Democrats, having failed for more than 15 years to enact legislation to allow dreamers to stay in the country, now threaten to block a must-pass spending bill, potentially shutting down the government, unless the measure is amended to resolve the impasse. Republicans say that’s unacceptable.
Meanwhile, the clock is ticking on dreamers, most of them in their teens, 20s and early 30s. Owing to the administration’s decision to terminate Obama-era protections for them, about 30,000 will lose their protected status each month starting in March unless Congress acts. That means that in addition to becoming eligible for deportation, they will also lose permits under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which the Trump administration axed, that enable many of them to enroll in college with in-state tuition subsidies, work legally and obtain valid state driver’s licenses.
and that is that they are here illegally. It is in fact a misdemeanor under the U. S. Immigration and Naturalization Act for them to be here without presenting themselves to a duly constituted representative of the federal government.
The argument against deporting them is primarily that they lack a mens rea, i.e. intent. I believe that argument would find better support if all sides would acknowledge the simple reality and that the same argument cannot be made for the parents of the “Dreamers”. There is such a thing as moral hazard.
I’ve long supported some accommodation for the Dreamers but I also think that, whatever standards are decided on, they should be enforced rather than engaging in special pleading for every single illegal immigrant.
I only have a couple of remarks about David Von Drehle’s Washington Post column, “Time to take baby boomers off the ticket”. First, under his rubric almost all of the Democratic Congressional leadership would be out of bounds. Nancy Pelosi, Steny Hoyer, and Dick Durbin are all “Silent Generation”—the generation the preceded the Baby Boomers. Chuck Schumer is a Baby Boomer.
Also, Baby Boomers range in age from 71 to 53 or thereabouts. Most are far from senility and many are just entering their most productive years. The author of the column is a Baby Boomer, too. In fact most of the people you encounter who are in a position of leadership or influence you will encounter are Baby Boomers. Why not “take the bylines away from the boomers”, too?
I agree with him that it’s time for the Silent Generation to sail into the sunset. People like those mentioned above plus perennials like John McCain and Dianne Feinstein. The Baby Boomers are going to be around for a long, long time and the Gen Xers and Millennials probably should get used to it.
Reeves opens Dream Hoarders with a story to illustrate his point. In January 2015, President Barack Obama proposed eliminating a college savings program called “529s.†The 529 program, put in place in 2001, allows families to set money aside that grows tax-free so long as it’s used only for higher education expenses. The 529 program is quite generous, but it mostly benefits upper middle-class families. Since he doesn’t provide the statistics, I looked into it and found that a parent can save up to $70,000 a year—or $140,000 for a married couple—for each child. Thus, families with the means to save such substantial sums can and do save much more than what the typical (median) U.S. family earns, which was $56,516 in 2015.
In Reeves’s view, what happened next threatens everything that makes America great and fully illustrates the “favored fifth’s†privileges and how they protect them. President Obama proposed replacing this program with a tax credit that would benefit taxpayers of more modest means. The public outcry among highly educated elites was immediate. After complaints from a few members of Congress—particularly representing upper middle-class districts—the Administration backtracked; the 529 plans would not be touched. Reeves argues this furor over the proposed elimination of an educational privilege for the upper middle class demonstrates their chokehold on access to opportunity. He uses this story as a touchstone throughout the book to build his case that the members of the favored fifth are wedded to their privilege.
To my eye here’s the kernel of the piece:
In the Progressive and New Deal eras, low- and middle-income workers created a coalition with upper middle-class professionals to push toward a new vision of government. To be sure, there were some downsides, such as mandatory assimilation—requiring new immigrants to adopt American lifestyles, including the Puritanical ethic of abstaining from alcohol—and some glaring omissions, such as when the otherwise-pioneering Federal Labor Standards Act of 1938 excluded the primarily African-American domestic and farm workers from the protections of the law. Still, there was a compact between the highly educated professionals and the communities they sought to serve that focused on improving living standards for the broad middle class. Frances Perkins, the first woman to lead the Labor Department and author of much of the New Deal, is emblematic of this bond. She was a graduate of Mount Holyoke College, the elite liberal arts school for women, who spent her evenings and weekends at Hull House, the first so-called settlement house, working within the working class communities she sought to serve.
In other words via rent-seeking professionals and a big chunk of what used to be thought of as blue collar government workers have managed to create a substantial gap between themselves and other workers. Just to use Chicago as an example, the median Chicago public school teacher, Chicago cop, or firefighter is in the top 20% of income earners (many teachers, police officers, and firefighters earn well into six figures). How the city can afford that in the long time with neither the power to impose a graduated income tax or retain high wage workers within the city is anybody’s guess. IMO it’s a flawed business model.
So the enormous incomes and power of the top .1% of income earners isn’t our only problem. The entrenched power of the top 20% of income earners is major problem and you need do no more than look at who spends the most money on lobbying to discern their business model.
Democracy and I part company here:
The path forward requires that we rebuild that coalition.
The path forward is to restrain what can be accomplished via rent-seeking. Otherwise the numbers just don’t add up. When you’re subsidizing 80% of the population you aren’t subsidizing anyone.
Sears, like other companies, is failing in part because it did not understand that this is an age of visionaries, not administrators. The wildly successful companies of today, including Amazon, did not merely ride the waves of change that swamped the likes of Sears. They created them.
They succeeded by thumbing their noses at conventional wisdom. That has meant pouring vast resources into good ideas, sometimes not knowing how they’d make money. It has also meant cannibalizing existing lines of business on the understanding that if they didn’t do it, someone else would.
Sears is slowly disappearing because of catastrophically bad management over a period of decades. Here’s how the USAT editors characterize Sears’s first try at world domination:
Like Amazon, Sears used its retailing strength to expand into related industries. It launched its own merchandise brands, such as Kenmore and DieHard, created Allstate Insurance, and even ventured into the stock brokerage and real estate brokerage businesses.
That isn’t exactly what happened. What Sears actually did was capture its private label vendors by making excessive demands, accompanied by ultimata. Eventually Sears was their vendors’ only customer and they’d acquire the companies, proceeding to drive them into the ground and destroy whatever had been good about them to begin with. Just because you can run a successful retail operation doesn’t mean that you can manufacture furniture or design and produce garments.
But they’re right in one respect: Sears should be ruling the roost. The company cut its teeth on the catalog business, the 19th and early 20th century equivalent of online sales. What happened? They repeatedly did just the wrong thing at just the wrong time. Rather than cultivating their vendors, they acquired them in a bid to gain a horizontal monopoly. Rather than focusing on the growing suburbs and suburban shopping malls, stocking products that would appeal to that clientele, they concentrated on their inner city stores. When name brands were just gaining steam they doubled down on their store brands. Rather than creating an online catalog and payment operation, in the early 1990s they got out of catalog sales to concentrate on those brick and mortar brick and mortar stores. Basically, they did just the wrong things at exactly the wrong times. The only explanation I have for that is incompetent management.
Thanksgiving dinner went very well last night. After well over a half century of preparing them I may finally be getting the hang of it.
One of my siblings, spouse, and twenty-something son joined us as well as a long-time friend who’s been a guest at our Thanksgiving dinners for 30 years. I prepared my conventional menu: smoked turkey, my wife’s family’s dressing with sausage, black olives, apples, etc., brussels sprouts and chestnuts, the cranberry sauce recipe I’ve settled on, homemade dinner rolls, and pumpkin chiffon pie. I’ve posted the recipes for everything here over the years.
Every single dish came out just about perfectly and in some instances the best I’ve ever made them. Love my new smoker. My timing was with pinpoint accuracy.
Fire changed humans as well as the world. Eating cooked food transformed our bodies; we developed a much shorter digestive tract, meaning that more metabolic energy was available to grow our brains. At the same time, Homo sapiens became domesticated by its dependence on fire for warmth, protection and fuel. If this was the start of human progress towards ‘civilisation’, then – according to the conventional narrative – the next step was the invention of agriculture around ten thousand years ago. Farming, it is said, saved us from a dreary nomadic Stone Age hunter-gatherer existence by allowing us to settle down, build towns and develop the city-states that were the centres of early civilisations. People flocked to them for the security, leisure and economic opportunities gained from living within thick city walls. The story continues with the collapse of the city-states and barbarian insurgency, plunging civilised worlds – ancient Mesopotamia, China, Mesoamerica – into their dark ages. Thus civilisations rise and fall. Or so we are told.
The perfectly formed city-state is the ideal, deeply ingrained in the Western psyche, on which our notion of the nation-state is founded, ultimately inspiring Donald Trump’s notion of a ‘city’ wall to keep out the barbarian Mexican horde, and Brexiters’ desire to ‘take back control’ from insurgent European bureaucrats. But what if the conventional narrative is entirely wrong? What if ancient ruins testify to an aberration in the normal state of human affairs rather than a glorious and ancient past to whose achievements we should once again aspire? What if the origin of farming wasn’t a moment of liberation but of entrapment? Scott offers an alternative to the conventional narrative that is altogether more fascinating, not least in the way it omits any self-congratulation about human achievement. His account of the deep past doesn’t purport to be definitive, but it is surely more accurate than the one we’re used to, and it implicitly exposes the flaws in contemporary political ideas that ultimately rest on a narrative of human progress and on the ideal of the city/nation-state.
There are so many handicaps in a sedentary agrarian society by comparison with a hunter-gatherer society it makes one wonder why anyone would adopt one. On average members of hunter-gatherer societies are healthier, live longer, and don’t work as hard as those who live in agrarian societies. Let me provide several explanations for why one would go from something that is better to something that is worse.
First and possibly most importantly, hunter-gatherers can’t brew beer. There actually is some evidence that sedentary habits were adopted specifically to allow people to brew beer.
Second, hunter-gatherer societies don’t respond well to environmental change or success. Success can cause populations to grow beyond the environment’s carrying capacity. Hunter-gather societies commonly impose restrictions on reproduction for just that reason. That itself could be a reason to adopt an agrarian economy. And the one thing we can say with some confidence about the environment is that it will change. The species on which you depend for food may die. You may exhaust the resources of flint, obsidian, etc. on which you depend and your neighbors might not appreciate your encroaching into their territories for them.
The ability to store surpluses is quite limited. You may come across a bumper crop of berries in your wanderings. You must eat them now because you can’t carry them with you.
Finally, it may be that “we” didn’t adopt an agrarian economy, it was forced upon us. Agriculturalists, because of their ability to store surpluses, can afford to specialize and that means agrarian societies can have armies. And armies can compel erstwhile hunter-gatherers to adopt an agrarian economy.
After moving to Mission Viejo in late July, I frequently experienced brief moments of euphoria. Sometimes I would almost burst out laughing at how ridiculously convenient my life had become. Now that I’ve been here for 4 months, I’ve come to the view that southern Orange County has the highest living standards in the entire world, for any region of at least a million people. (Here I’m thinking of Orange County south of I-55.) As an aside, there are Tesla cars everywhere, at least 6 or 8 within a couple blocks of my house.
I base this claim partly on the fact that the region is affluent and very conveniently laid out. Other places that might have a similar claim to high living standards (say the northern suburbs of Dallas) lack the delightful climate and beautiful scenery of this area.
I’d guess that leaving Boston caused my living standards to improve as much as someone moving from middle class to upper middle class, or upper middle class to rich. It’s amazing how much more convenient life has become.
but finds any lessons that might be drawn from his experience elusive. I’d like to suggest a couple. First, it’s good to be rich. The median income in Mission Viejo is around $96,000, comfortably within the top 10% of income earners. The median home price in Mission Viejo is over $700,000. The Teslas he sees tooling around are $70,000 automobiles.
Second, there’s a distinctive sort of hypocrisy in living in Southern California. Present lifestyles there would be impossible based on the water and energy produced there. Now, I don’t think that everybody should be self-sufficient. I buy my groceries at a grocery store and my gas from a filling station.
But I don’t curse grocery stores and filling stations while I’m doing it and I don’t delude myself into thinking that I have some particular virtue because I don’t produce enough food to feed myself or enough oil to power my car. I haven’t saved the earth by my choices. I’m just instantiating Adam Smith’s view of specialization as the key to prosperity. They’re not reducing carbon emissions by not producing energy or by taking water from the Colorado. The emissions and water are just coming from somewhere else.
I would caution Scott that the lifestyle in Southern California is poised on a razor’s edge. It will be increasingly difficult to sustain as California and its surrounding states become more populous.