And Don’t Let the Door Hit You On Your Way Out

In her Washington Post column Anne Applebaum laments the loss of ascendancy of Wilsonianism:

In 1917, Wilson had called for the creation of an alliance, the world’s first to be based on democratic principles: He wanted the “free and self-governed peoples of the world” to oppose “selfish and autocratic power.” In 1918, he imagined a Europe without empires, a world in which “conquest and aggrandizement” had given way to open diplomacy, safe navigation and “the removal, so far as possible, of all economic barriers and the establishment of an equality of trade conditions.” Wilson also imagined a “general association of nations” that would offer “mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike.”

Even the most amateur student of history knows what happened next. Wilson’s Fourteen Points raised skeptical eyebrows in Europe (the French prime minister allegedly muttered that “even the good Lord had only 10” points). His offer of friendship to “the German people,” as opposed to the Prussian aristocracy, was ignored by the authors of the subsequent Versailles peace treaty, who demanded punitive German reparations instead. Free trade was replaced by tariff barriers; Wilson’s “general association of nations” became the League of Nations, which the United States never joined and which failed spectacularly. The new nations of Europe fought bitterly over their new borders, Germany and Russia sought to reconquer their old colonies and a new world war broke out two decades later.

But take a longer view, and that speech looks rather different. A century has passed, and we now find ourselves living in a thoroughly Wilsonian world. Ideas that were dismissed as far-fetched and even silly in 1918 have become reality. We really have lifted many barriers to trade and commerce; the continent of Europe really is composed of nation-states that determine, more or less, their own fate, and the same is true at least some of the time on other continents, too. Many conflicts really are resolved by open diplomacy instead of secret treaties. Multiple “associations of nations” really do operate in different spheres and on different continents, helping to smooth international relations.

For the moment, U.S. diplomacy and even the U.S. military are operating within a Wilsonian framework, too. “For our own part,” Wilson declared in January 1918, “we see very clearly that unless justice be done to others it will not be done to us. The program of the world’s peace, therefore, is our program.” At least in theory, American soldiers and civil servants are not in the business of pursuing “conquest and aggrandizement” for their own sake. Their ultimate aim, whatever the policies of the moment, really is “the world’s peace” — or, to translate into less embarrassing language, a world in which genocide and mass murder are reduced to a minimum, in which prosperity and democracy are on the rise, in which Americans can travel and do business according to predictable rules.

We can only hope. Over the period of the last several decades Wilsonian adventurism has produced chaos and misery in Iraq, Libya, Somalia, and Syria. Keep in mind that both neoconservatives and liberal interventionists are Wilsonians. Neither advocate war for “conquest and aggrandizement”. Both want to make war to make the world safe for democracy.
But they both want war. Trillions have been spent on these projects and we should never lose track of the fact that money is fungible. The money spent on bombs dropped, inadvertently or deliberately, on Somali schoolchildren won’t be spent on education or immunizations.

The problem is that good intentions aren’t enough. A war in pursuit of goals that are beyond our power to achieve can never be just. And the sad reality is that many of the people of the world do not want their worlds made safe for liberal democracy and will fight to the death to prevent it.

1 comment

Welfare for the Rich

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Elizabeth Bruenig complains about federal transfer payments made to people who aren’t poor:

The lion’s share of poor people are elderly, children or disabled persons; another chunk are caregivers. And while caregiving isn’t compensated as market labor, parents looking after children and people caring for elderly or sick family members are hardly shiftless layabouts. Being both a mother and a writer, I am well aware that the less compensated of my two jobs is the more demanding one.

But what about that small number of people who could work but, for whatever reason, don’t? Shouldn’t they have to? Well, before deciding whether it’s morally right for them to receive income without working, consider a far larger group that takes in far more money without toil: the idle rich. They soak up plenty of unearned money from the economy, in the form of rent, dividends and capital income. Salaries and wages — that is, money paid for work — only make up about 15 percent of the income of Americans making $10 million per year or more; the rest is capital income from simply owning assets.

And yet rarely do politicians inveigh against the laziness of the well-off. In fact, the government shells out huge sums of money to the rich every year through tax breaks and subsidies. As Syracuse University professor Christopher Faricy points out in his book “Welfare for the Wealthy,” the federal government is hardly generous with the poor alone. In 2016, for instance, Social Security kept 26.1 million people out of poverty to the tune of $911.4 billion paid out in disability and old-age pensions; during that same year, federal tax subsidies for the pensions of the more affluent totaled $179.9 billion. Faricy observes that the same pattern holds in health care and education: While the government spent some $200 billion on Medicaid that year, it also spent $120 billion subsidizing employer-based health insurance; and while students whose families make under $20,000 per year are the main beneficiaries of federal Pell grants, households that earn between $100,000 and $200,000 receive roughly 50 percent of the benefits of college tuition-and-fee tax deductions.

In principle I’m in agreement with her implied point. Public charity should be limited to the poor. Benefits like Social Security and Medicare should be means-tested.

As it turns out they are. Social Security and Medicare benefits are taxed on a progressive basis. That’s a de facto method of means-testing, explained in full here. I would go farther. I think that the ceiling on wages on which payroll taxes are levied should be raised, at least to the income level of those earning more than three standard deviations above median income, presently around $250,000. The same approach should be used with respect to the subsidies paid for employer-based health care insurance and Pell grants (if they aren’t already—I’m not an authority on either system). The same should be the case for the home mortgage interest deduction. Reducing the cap on the deductibility of home mortgage interest is one of the features of the tax reform bill recently signed into law and it’s an aspect of it of which I approve.

But the big ticket items are Social Security benefits, Medicare benefits, and home mortgage deduction. In other words Ms. Bruenig is arguing in favor of reforms which are mostly already in place. They just don’t show up in the way she’s doing her accounting. That’s one of the problems in having a system as complicated as ours.

We haven’t even touched on other important questions. There are public employees receiving million dollar public pensions. Shouldn’t those be capped at a much lower level? Medicare checks aren’t cut to beneficiaries—they’re “reimbursements” paid to providers. Should there be a cap on those, too?

0 comments

Why Do Americans Read the Mystery Stories We Do?

Inspired by Charles Lipson’s recent post on the difference between hard-boiled detective fiction and the gentleman/woman detective fiction we associate with the English, I’ve begun thinking about detective fiction—what it is and why we read what we read.

As I pointed out to Charles the distinction isn’t between British detective fiction and American but between drawing room and hard-boiled. The four best-selling American authors of detective fiction are Erle Stanley Gardner, Mickey Spillane, Evan Hunter (Ed McBain), and Rex Stout. Of those only one, Mickey Spillane, is associated with the hard-boiled style of detective fiction although I, personally, would more characterize Spillane as the “splat!” school. As Jean Kerr put it, Mike Hammer novels aren’t so much whodunits as “wit whats”.

Erle Stanley Gardner (Perry Mason) and Rex Stout (Nero Wolfe) fit neatly into the gentleman detective style although Stout cleverly split the difference between the gentleman detective and hard-boiled with Nero Wolfe as the gentleman detective and his henchman and amanuensis, Archie Goodwin, filling the role of the hard-boiled detective. Evan Hunter’s forte was the police procedural, a subgenre that’s come to dominate American detective fiction and which for some reason or other I associate with the French.

Why did the hard-boiled detective subgenre arise in the United States? My wife astutely noted that it grew up in the depths of the Depression of the 1930s when everything seemed to have spun out of control and it very much looked as though things would never get any better. That’s the world of the hard-boiled detective. Here’s how Charles Lipson characterized it:

Here’s my take. In the hard-boiled American genre, the whole world is steeped in evil sharpies. We aren’t totally focused, as we are in classic English mysteries, in finding the single person who committed the murder (given that everyone in a small, well-defined group has a plausible motive–and perhaps some clues pointing in their direction).

In the American genre, the whole underworld is implicated. Lots of them “done it.” The problem is not just finding one guy. It is unraveling the whole tangled mess of lies and crimes. Since the private eye must travel constantly in that underworld, his (or her) problem is maintaining a moral compass while all about him have none.

Why, then, have police procedurals become so important in the United States? I think that they grew up in the post-war world when the U. S. government was at its peak of repute, just having defeated the Germans and the Japanese (as we see it) nearly single-handedly.

Keep in mind that despite Americans’ fondness for Hammett and Chandler with their Sam Spade and Philip Marlowe, neither author even approaches either the 500 lb. gorilla of mystery, Agatha Christie, or the second in line, Georges Simenon, either one of whom have sold 100s of millions more books than any American writer of detective fiction.

0 comments

Spectre Is Worse

If this statement

Government agencies issued statements warning users about the vulnerabilities.

The U.S. Computer Emergency Readiness Team said that while the flaws “could allow an attacker to obtain access to sensitive information,” it’s not so far aware of anyone doing so.

The agency urged people to read a detailed statement on the vulnerabilities by the Software Engineering Institute, a U.S.-government funded body that researches cybersecurity problems.

The institute said that “fully removing the vulnerability requires replacing vulnerable [processor] hardware.”

is anything other hyperbolic claptrap Intel is in more trouble than I thought. Intel’s stock seems to be holding so fingers crossed. However, even after the issues have been patched and the lawsuits dealt with Intel’s problems won’t be over. First, recent stock sales by Intel managers are beginning to be scrutinized. From Ars Technica:

Brian Krzanich, chief executive officer of Intel, sold millions of dollars’ worth of Intel stock—all he could part with under corporate bylaws—after Intel learned of Meltdown and Spectre, two related families of security flaws in Intel processors.

While an Intel spokesperson told CBS Marketwatch reporter Jeremy Owens that the trades were “unrelated” to the security revelations, and Intel financial filings showed that the stock sales were previously scheduled, Krzanich scheduled those sales on October 30. That’s a full five months after researchers informed Intel of the vulnerabilities. And Intel has offered no further explanation of why Krzanich abruptly sold off all the stock he was permitted to.

They’re saying it was a coincidence but they would, wouldn’t they?

Additionally, diversifying the processor ecosystem is now being proposed as a risk mitigation strategy. That’s something I wrote about some time ago. That’s bad news for Intel potentially forever.

2 comments

Iran’s Basic Fact

A lot of columnists at the Washington Post are writing about Iran today. Fareed Zakaria notes:

Iran has the ingredients for a revolution. More than half of the population is younger than 30, many youths are educated yet unemployed, almost 50 million Iranians have smartphones with which they can learn about the world, and reformers have consistently raised expectations yet never delivered on their promises. But the regime also has instruments of power, ideology, repression and patronage, all of which it is ready to wield to stay in control. What appears likely for Iran is a period of instability — in an already volatile Middle East.

Michael Gerson remarks:

The Iranian government’s problem is no longer a matter of performance but of legitimacy. Routine corruption, vicious oppression and economic mismanagement are increasingly seen as essential to the regime itself.

The breadth of this sentiment is what distinguishes the current revolt from the Green Movement of 2009. Instead of mainly involving the upper-middle class, discontent has taken root in the lower-middle class — in the labor movement and among the unemployed. Instead of being concentrated in Tehran and a few other cities, the current unrest can be found across the country in smaller cities and rural areas. (If it comes to it, this would complicate the imposition of martial law, because Iran’s Revolutionary Guard Corps would need to be deployed more thinly.)

David Ignatius declaims:

The West certainly should be careful about statements that encourage Iranians to open rebellion. There’s moral hazard in such cheerleading. But silence is wrong. The West should urge Iranian protesters to remain peaceful (they’re more likely to succeed that way) and also warn the regime that it will be held accountable for violence against its citizens. If the government cracks down hard, as it did during the 2009 Green Movement, it must face real consequences.

They’re all missing something basic. Iran isn’t comparable with France at the end of the 18th century, with Poland in 1989, or with Egypt in 2009. It’s more like Russia in 1930 or the Soviet Union in 1954. Its rulers are successful revolutionaries. They have an army, supporters, the will to use them, and no Plan B. Those demonstrating in the streets have none of those things and most don’t remember any rulers of Iran other than the mullahs.

It will be another 10-15 years before the regime that put itself into power in 1979 but had been planning for it for decades can be replaced. Rather than preparing for an imminent overthrow of the mullahocracy, we should be trying to ensure that when the mullahs who overthrew the Shah die, the regime that replaces them is better than they were. That’s a task hard enough. Sufficient to the day, etc. Let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

7 comments

Captain Renault The WP Editors Declaim

The editors of the Washington Post are shocked, shocked to find politics going on in the Trump presidency:

AFTER ALL of President Trump’s bluster about his “great love” for “dreamers,” brought to this country as children through no fault of their own, it turns out he’s content to use them as leverage in a high-stakes game of political horse-trading. Mr. Trump seems willing to strip them of jobs, security and homes unless Democrats buckle on a range of Republican immigration priorities, including an even longer-standing object of the president’s ardor: a beautiful border wall.

You use your bargaining chips where you find them. If you like law or sausage, etc.

What in the world do the editors expect? Do they really think that the Democrats aren’t holding the DREAMers political hostages? A deal could be struck any time they cared to. They’d rather have the issue than a solution. That’s the basic problem with our politics today. The two sides despise each other so much there’s very little they won’t do to poke sticks in their opponents’ eyes.

As it is the harder the Democrats “resist” the more extreme Trump’s reactions will be. What a world, what a world.

5 comments

The Other Shoe Drops

As I anticipated yesterday, a federal class action lawsuit has been filed against Intel. From Courthouse News Service:

SAN JOSE, Calif. (CN) – Computer chipmaker Intel faces a major class action filed Wednesday night in what could be the opening salvo in a flood of litigation over two recently discovered security flaws that make most of the world’s computers vulnerable to hacking.

The security flaws, called Meltdown and Spectre, enable hackers to swipe data from personal computers, mobile devices and servers, including those that connect to cloud computing networks.

Microsoft Windows on Tuesday unveiled a security patch for the Meltdown flaw, which affects nearly all Intel microprocessors that make up more than 90 percent of computer servers.

The Meltdown flaw could enable hackers to bypass the barrier between applications and hardware to access a computer’s core memory and steal private information like passwords through cloud computing services.

According to a federal lawsuit filed Wednesday night, fixes offered by operating systems like Windows and Linux will “dramatically reduce the performance” of computers.

“Intel has failed to cure the defect or replace plaintiffs’ Intel CPUs with nondefective CPUs and offer full compensation required under federal and state law,” the 26-page complaint states.

The Meltdown fix could slow computers down by as much as 30 percent, according to recent cyber security reports.

The affected class is so large and the cost of remediation large enough that, again as I noted yesterday, this whole affair could constitute a near-death experience for Intel. Intel shares fell 2% yesterday. We’ll see if that continues today.

Swapping out processors isn’t something that can or should be performed by the typical computer user. Additionally, today’s processors won’t necessarily fit the same sockets as those made in 2008. A socket change means a motherboard change and a motherboard change probably requires a new operating system license. Intel is presumably hoping that the software remediation won’t decrease performance noticeably. That’s what the company’s official statements have claimed. If that doesn’t prove to be the case, they’re in trouble. If it does prove to be the case, expect stockholder lawsuits, too. Right now Intel’s stock is where it was in 2000.

Win or lose Intel faces millions or even billions of dollars in legal expenses. I suspect that’s what the small stock price declines reflect.

5 comments

So It’s Not Just Me

Apparently, I’m not the only one who’s noticed what may just be a coincidence but sure looks like a systematic policy. The Chicago Tribune reports:

Democratic governor candidate Chris Kennedy on Wednesday accused Mayor Rahm Emanuel of leading a “strategic gentrification plan” aimed at forcing African-Americans and other minorities out of Chicago to make the city “whiter” and wealthier.

“I believe that black people are being pushed out of Chicago intentionally by a strategy that involves disinvestment in communities being implemented by the city administration, and I believe Rahm Emanuel is the head of the city administration and therefore needs to be held responsible for those outcomes,” Kennedy said during a news conference about gun violence in North Lawndale.

“This is involuntary. That we’re cutting off funding for schools, cutting off funding for police, allowing people to be forced to live in food deserts, closing hospitals, closing access to mental health facilities. What choice do people have but to move, to leave?” Kennedy added. “And I think that’s part of a strategic gentrification plan being implemented by the city of Chicago to push people of color out of the city. The city is becoming smaller, and as it becomes smaller, it’s become whiter.”

The mayor’s office responded by trying to link Kennedy to two Republican politicians who enjoy little popularity in Chicago — President Donald Trump and Gov. Bruce Rauner, whom Kennedy wants to replace.

What do the cities—New York, Los Angeles, Seattle—that have been touting their low homicide rates have in common that Chicago, Baltimore, Detroit, and St. Louis do not? Fewer than 30% of their populations are black.

Chicago’s Mayor Rahm Emanuel seems to be engaged in a citywide experiment. If you make life miserable enough for black folk while providing amenities targeted at “creative class” whites, will the ensuing gentrification and “black flight” reduce the crime rate? Maybe it’s just coincidence but it sure doesn’t look like one.

11 comments

Meltdown

I find this story kind of interesting for a variety of reasons. If you’re not aware of it a microcode flaw has been discovered in all current Intel processors that potentially exposes their users to security breaches. The problems have been dubbed “Meltdown” and “Spectre”. Basically, they involve insecure practices being used by the processors in instruction lookahead.

Microsoft’s hand was forced on issuing patches for Meltdown by Google’s revealing the flaw and they’ve been pushing patches out. However, most anti-virus programs can’t handle the patches. From Bleeping Computer:

But Microsoft also warns that the Meltdown and Spectre security fixes are incompatible with some anti-virus products.

“During our testing process, we uncovered that some third-party applications have been making unsupported calls into Windows kernel memory that cause stop errors (also known as bluescreen errors) to occur,” Microsoft said in a compatibility note for yesterday’s security fixes.

“These calls may cause stop errors […] that make the device unable to boot. To help prevent stop errors caused by incompatible anti-virus applications, Microsoft is only offering the Windows security updates released on January 3, 2018 to devices running anti-virus software from partners who have confirmed their software is compatible with the January 2018 Windows operating system security update.”

“If you have not been offered the security update, you may be running incompatible anti-virus software and you should follow up with your software vendor,” Microsoft said.

In other words, if users are employing a third-party anti-virus product, they should first check if the AV has updated its anti-virus product to support the Microsoft patches.

There have been no reports of malicious groups using neither Meltdown or Spectre in real-world attacks, so Microsoft is also recommending that users give anti-virus vendors more time to update their products.

Microsoft says that when anti-virus vendors update their product to support the Meltdown and Spectre patches, they’ve been instructed to create a custom registry key on the OS, which will allow Windows to download and receive the proper security fixes (if the user also agrees to it).

If users aren’t willing to search their antivirus product’s homepage for such info, if they find the following registry key on their systems, the antivirus product has already been updated to support the Meltdown and Spectre patches.

Key=”HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE” Subkey=”SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\QualityCompat” Value=”cadca5fe-87d3-4b96-b7fb-a231484277cc” Type=”REG_DWORD”

A security researcher is currently keeping a Google Docs spreadsheet with the status of Meltdown and Spectre patches on various anti-virus engines. At the time of writing, only Microsoft, ESET, and Kaspersky AV engines support the patches, with others set to receive updates starting tomorrow.

The only anti-virus engines I use for my own computers are ESET and Kaspersky. I checked my desktops and laptop. All have had the patches pushed to them.

Here’s the part I find interesting. The patches and the firmware update that will be issued to complete the securing of these machines are expected to slow down these computers by from 10-30%.

I can’t help but wonder if these problems might induce a near-death experience for Intel. These microcode issues are pretty obviously failures of workmanship and Intel routinely publishes performance measurements of their processors. I don’t know about you but a 30% performance hit wouldn’t be much fun for me. I haven’t found records of any yet but I expect that Intel will be deluged with lawsuits.

7 comments

Bubbles Then and Now

I encourage you to read Jeremy Grantham’s analysis of historic bubbles (PDF). He’s tentatively predicting a near-term “melt-up” followed by a meltdown:

I find myself in an interesting position for an investor from the value school. I recognize on one hand that this is one of the highest-priced markets in US history. On the other hand, as a historian of the great equity bubbles, I also recognize that we are currently showing signs of entering the blow-off or melt-up phase of this very long bull market. The data on the high price of the market is clean and factual. We can be as certain as we ever get in stock market analysis that the current price is exceptionally high. In contrast, my judgment on the melt-up is based on a mish-mash of statistical and psychological factors based on previous eras, each one very different, so that much of the information available is not easily comparable. It also leans very heavily on a few US examples. Yet, strangely, I find the less statistical data more compelling in this bubble context than the simple fact of overpricing. Whether you will also, dear reader, remains to be seen.

Check out his graph Exhibit 13. Stocks have only been more expensive twice in American history than today: in 1999 and 1929.

3 comments