The Modern Micawber

Here’s the briefest possible summary of Warren Buffett’s Time op-ed:

Population increase .8% per year, GDP growth 2% per year, result happiness.

Population increase 3% per year, GDP growth 2% per year, result misery.

Over the last 30 years U. S. population growth has been about 3% per year, driven mostly by immigration. Recently, it’s been lower. The only practical way we can keep population growth below 1% per year is to constrain immigration.

16 comments

What’s In a Name?

If you’ve ever wondered why the Hellenic Macedonians and Slavic inhabitants of the country of Macedonia are bickering over the country’s name, there’a a pretty good primer at Euractiv:

The European Commission welcomed the action taken by the government in Skopje to end a 25-year stalemate on a name dispute with Greece and now hopes to see “concrete results”, a spokesperson told EURACTIV.com on Thursday (4 January).

Maintaining good relations between neighbours, including a negotiated and mutually acceptable solution to the name issue, under the auspices of the UN, remains essential, the Commission official underscored.

“In this regard, we welcome the steps taken by the government to engage in discussions with their counterparts in Greece to strengthen good neighbourly relations and we hope this will translate into further concrete results,” the spokesperson added.

And if you’ve been wondering about the name here’s a summary of how it all happened:

Ancient Macedonia (mostly in modern Greece) => Modern Greek Province of Macedonia

Ancient Paeonia => Incorporated by the Romans into their province of Macedonia => Part of the Bulgarian Empire => “Southern Serbia” (when part of the Serbian Empire) => Vardar Banovina => People’s Republic of Macedonia of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia => Republic of Macedonia

I assume that makes everything much clearer.

2 comments

What Are They Subsidizing?


At EconLog after posting the graphic above Scott Sumner observes:

So what does any of this have to do with progressivism? I see the progressive worldview as being based on these assumptions:

1. America’s “savage inequalities” can be addressed by spending lots of money on social programs.
2. American’s education inequalities can be addressed by equalizing spending between poor and rich school districts.
3. America’s poor infrastructure can be addressed by spending more money on infrastructure.

My view is that (at the current margin) more government spending does not solve these sorts of problems, it just ends up being wasted. Rather we should focus on boosting the efficiency of the economy.

That’s a pretty fair first order approximation of my views. To it I would add that I think that results are a better gauge of the results intended than stated goals. I’m not a New Yorker but here in Chicago city government is subsidizing city workers and civic improvement projects attractive to “creative class” Millennials while the city, long characterized as the most segregated major city in the country, is more segregated than ever and black neighborhoods have become shooting galleries. Chicagoans are leaving Chicago in large numbers (half of the domestic exodus from Illinois is from Cook County). Politicians enjoy lifetime tenure and all too frequently leave their notionally elective offices to their children. I don’t think that all of that can be an accident. It’s persisted too long to be accidental.

0 comments

Is Afghanistan a Wicked Problem?

I like and recommend Anthony Cowden’s post at RealClearDefense which purportedly asks questions about our present national strategy in Afghanistan but I would say is actually a critique of our lack of a practical strategy. Here are some of the questions he poses:

  • Is pride an appropriate national interest?
  • To what degree should past efforts be relevant in crafting a new strategy?
  • Are the consequences of a rapid exit predictable? Are they unacceptable?
  • What does history have to teach us about fighting in Afghanistan?
  • What are the conditions that the strategy is based on?
  • Is the U.S. seriously considering a negotiated settlement with the Taliban?
  • Why does the term “counterinsurgency” not show up in this strategy?

but it makes me uncomfortable, too. For one thing I believe that Capt. Cowden misuses the term “wicked problem” and does not establish that Afghanistan is a wicked problem. Here’s his definition:

However, Afghanistan is a wicked problem – one that is not simply complicated but also complex and with no clear solutions – and wicked problems tend to defy strategies.

and this:

Wicked problems are best addressed through leadership, and one of the core leadership skills necessary to address wicked problems is to ask a lot of questions.

is just plain wrong. With a wicked problem the best you can do is create a process. It’s not a matter of leadership. It’s a matter of objectives.

Wicked problems are problems without solutions, generally because the requirements change as the old requirements are addressed or because for one party caught up in a wicked problem to succeed the other party must fail and neither party has the ability to prevail outright. As an example I would say the dispute between the Israelis and Palestinians is a wicked problem.

Is Afghanistan a wicked problem? I don’t think so. Any problem from which you can just walk away is not a wicked problem. Our problem in Afghanistan is that we don’t want either to win or lose. That’s not a wicked problem. That’s pigheadedness.

2 comments

Harry Potter, Tory

I heartily recommend you read Ben Judah’s explication at The American Interest of how Harry Potter is a Tory:

To me, perhaps the most blatantly Tory strain running through the Potterverse is the portrayal of Wizarding Whitehall. Nothing good can ever come of the Ministry of Magic, whose bureaucrats are badgering nincompoops with names like Cornelius Fudge and Pius Thicknesse, men who talk down to the befuddled Muggle Prime Minister, informing him how things are really run through a portrait and a fireplace in Number 10 Downing Street, like a voice of a Regency Palace emissary.

Not only are bureaucrats goofy and gluttonous, but every intervention by the Department of Mysteries and the Department for Magical Accidents and Catastrophes makes things worse. Problems, in Harry Potter’s world, can only be solved by the Wizards themselves—by the Tory Big Society of chipper public spirited Wizards. All that can be hoped for, even under Minister For Magic Hermione in J.K Rowling’s latest 2016 theatre spinoff Harry Potter And The Cursed Child is for government to be less corrupt. Magic will never come to the masses.

When I started reading Harry Potter and the Sorceror’s Stone I was immediately struck by how much the book was Tom Brown’s School Days with magic and flying brooms, Hogwarts standing in for Rugby and quidditch for cricket. I haven’t read any English commentaries on the books but I suspect that they struck Brits as much nostalgic as magical.

Read the whole thing.

0 comments

Illinois Legislators, Take Heed

According to the Internal Revenue Service, in 2015-2016 Illinois experienced roughly $5 billion in net income outflow, $2.5 billion from Cook County alone. The average household income of the households leaving Illinois was $82,000 per household compared with a median household income in the state of about $60,000. In other words richer Illinoisans were more likely to leave the state than poorer ones.

That translates to something like a $200 million decrease in state income tax revenue between 2014-2015 and 2015-2016.

There are lots of reasons for taxpayers fleeing Illinois—the climate, other states have nicer scenery, there are places where the cost of living is lower and incomes aren’t a great deal lower. But big reasons are taxes, the regulatory environment, and the state’s lousy fiscal condition.

Illinois can’t tax its way out of those problems.

7 comments

The Pipeline

There’s an interesting article at Fox Business on the present shortage of high-end construction workers:

However, 50% of companies reported having a difficult time filling both craft and salaried worker positions. Over the coming year, 53% of companies told the AGC that they expect to continue struggling to find qualified applicants. These challenges come despite the fact that 60% of firms reported increasing base pay to retain or recruit professionals and 36% provided incentives and bonuses toward the same end.

and

The construction industry is already experiencing an influx of cash. U.S. construction spending rose to an all-time high of $1.257 trillion in November, the Commerce Department said on Wednesday. On Friday, the U.S. Department of Labor released the employment report for December. showing that the economy added 30,000 construction jobs last month, contributing to a total of 148,000 overall jobs created.

Meanwhile, the construction industry is potentially facing a 1.5 million worker shortage by the year 2020, Whyte said.

They attribute the shortage to the construction industry not being “sexy” enough and travel requirements. While those may be factors, I think other factors are at work as well. There has been relentless propaganda campaign over the period of the last 25 years promoting higher education. And you don’t just graduate from high school as a “craft professional”.

There used to be a pipeline for such workers. An apprentice would become a journeyman would become a master, each paid at a level appropriate for the lifestyle and life responsibilities of people in their teens, their twenties, and older.

I think that what has happened is that the payscales for entry-level jobs have fallen in real terms and the training programs have been eroded. I’d sure like to see some statistics on the relative importance of not “sexy” enough, travel requirements, lower entry-level payscales, unrealistic expectations, advertising, the availability of training programs and loans, and other factors in whatever shortages exist.

4 comments

The Peasants Aren’t Revolting

In his recent column at the Wall Street Journal James Taranto makes a very interesting observation:

Those old enough to remember the decades before the ’90s, then, may tend to see permanent majorities around the corner because they expect a return to normalcy. Mr. Fiorina, by contrast, argues that frequent shifts in political control are now the norm because of the way the parties have changed. He rejects the common view that American voters are “polarized.” Instead, he says, the parties have become polarized, in a process he calls the “sorting” of the electorate.

“We have these two now cohesive, different parties,” he says. Democrats and Republicans today are as ideologically distinct as “the Social Democrats and the Christian Democrats in Europe at the height of their power in the 20th century. And the problem is, we’ve got a much more heterogeneous country, and there’s only two of them, and they just don’t fit the electorate.”

He arrives with a PowerPoint presentation that visualizes the data behind his theory. A pair of bar graphs show the ideological distribution of lawmakers in the 87th Congress (1961-63) and the 111th (2009-11). In both eras Democrats were the liberal party and Republicans the conservative one. But the pattern is markedly different: In 1961-63, both parties’ lawmakers tended to cluster in the middle. In 2009-11, there were two clusters—Democrats to the left, Republicans to the right. “There’s no longer any overlap at all,” Mr. Fiorina says. “The center is empty. That hasn’t happened in the electorate.”

A line graph illustrates the electorate’s continuity. The share of Americans identifying as politically moderate has remained fairly constant—around 40%, and usually a plurality—since at least 1974. In the same period, another chart shows, independents overtook Democrats as the biggest partisan grouping. As the parties drifted from the ideological middle, centrist voters disaffiliated from the parties.

That creates what Mr. Fiorina calls “the ping pong pattern” of unstable majorities. One party manages “to win, narrowly, and then they immediately respond to their base. So Bush says we’re going to have personal Social Security accounts, and voters—some say, ‘I didn’t vote for that.’ Or Obama says we’re going to do government health care, and a lot of them say, ‘I didn’t vote for that.’ ” Lawmakers from the party in power “suffer for it in the next election, when they lose the marginal voters,” as Republicans did in 2006 and Democrats in 2010.

That certainly comports with what I’ve observed. Politicians align with their most ideological supporters rather than with most of their constituents. Progressives and conservatives are drastically over-represented while the views of most Americans are barely being represented at all.

There is a counter-argument. Maybe self-identifying as moderates doesn’t actually mean anything. Maybe the very notion of what it means to be a moderate is so fluid as to be meaningless. Maybe today’s moderates are yesterday’s radicals and vice versa.

IMO most people just aren’t particularly ideological and are best represented when their elected official aren’t particularly ideological, either. That makes it hard for politicians to raise donations from wealthy and ideological donors. Offhand I’d say the most motivated are also probably the most ideological.

2 comments

The Black Jobless Rate


I know that the most recent Bureau of Labor Statistics report found the lowest level of black unemployment in nearly half a century, as noted by the editors of the Wall Street Journal in a recent editorial. But I don’t know why and, unfortunately, neither the BLS nor the editors give me much help there. Here’s what the editors imply:

The jobless rate for blacks has always been substantially higher than for whites, and it tends to fall faster later in the economic cycle as growth picks up steam.

which I find neither convincing nor encouraging.

Why has the black jobless rate fallen? The generally low jobless rate? Faster job growth? Decreased Mexican immigration? Greater mobility? Lower black labor force participation rate? More discouraged workers? All of the above? Some of the above? Something else?

The graph at the top of the page, from the St. Louis Fed, illustrates the black unemployment rate. The graph above from the same source illustrates the black labor force participation rate. When the LFPR decreases, the number of discouraged workers who, consequently, vanish from the unemployment statistics, tends to increase.

1 comment

Bummer

For years I have been pointing out that our major political parties are in the process of swapping places and nowhere is that more evident than in states rights. As the editors of the Wall Street Journal observe the states that were formerly lauding incorporation and condemning states rights and nullification are now asserting states rights and nullification and rejecting incorporation with equal vehemency:

Attorney General Jeff Sessions is being lambasted as the uncool parent in Washington, and maybe the universe, for rescinding an Obama Administration directive that decriminalized marijuana in states that have legalized the drug. But even if you’re a legalizer, you should give the AG some credit for forcing a debate on the rule of law that Congress should settle.

The problem is the conflict between state and federal statutes. Eight states have legalized pot for recreational use, and more than half for medical purposes. But under the federal Controlled Substances Act of 1970, cannabis is an illegal schedule I drug along with heroin and LSD. Individuals found with even small amounts can go to prison, and making or distributing large quantities carry long sentences and stiff fines.

President Obama tried to dodge this conflict, as he so often did, with an executive diktat. After Colorado and Washington State voted to legalize pot, his Justice Department in 2013 instructed U.S. Attorneys to refrain from prosecuting marijuana offenses in states where the drug is legal. This let him side with the legalizers without taking responsibility for it.

Justice’s guidance expected states to “implement strong and effective regulatory and enforcement systems that will address the threat those state laws could pose to public safety, public health, and other law enforcement interests.” Its memo also ordered attorneys to prioritize preventing distribution to minors, diversion to other states or using marijuana as a cover for trafficking in other drugs.

In practice, this has meant few federal pot prosecutions in those states despite evidence of all of those problems and more. Colorado has the highest rate of first-time youth marijuana use in the country. Alaska and Oregon ranked third and seventh after they legalized in 2014. According to Smart Approaches to Marijuana, cannabis use among young people has increased by 65% in Colorado since legalization.

Drug traffickers have exploited the aegis of state laws, which has let the black market flourish. A police report in Oregon revealed that 70% of marijuana sales in 2016 occurred on the black market, and up to 900 tons more cannabis is produced than consumed in the state. Mexican cartels have moved into Alaska.

The Rocky Mountain High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area reported a more than 700% increase in postal marijuana seizures following legalization. The crime rate in Colorado has increased 11 times faster than in other large cities since legalization. A National Institutes of Health study has linked the density of marijuana dispensaries to increased property crime.

Many pot sellers evade state regulation because of hefty compliance costs and taxes. Law enforcement in California reports that only a fraction of pot growers have applied for permits. Drugged-driving fatalities doubled in Washington following legalization. Positive drug tests for marijuana in 2016 increased at more than double the rate in Colorado and Washington as nationwide.

We report all this because the legalization debate has been dominated by a haze of cultural sentiment largely devoid of facts, and the promises by advocates about reduced enforcement costs and crime haven’t materialized. Meanwhile, the failure to enforce federal law, and letting states ignore it, erodes confidence in the law and lets Congress duck a debate on legalization.

Federal law trumps state law under the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause except on core state powers, and the Supreme Court ruled in Gonzales v. Raich (2005) that the feds can prosecute marijuana offenses under the Commerce Clause. We disagreed with Raich, but it is the law and states can’t nullify federal laws.

See also immigration law. I do not believe that one can coherently make an argument for or against states rights on instrumentalist grounds so please do not tell me about the benignity of your motives. What matters is what happens and the benefits of marijuana legalization are presently being exaggerated as much as an ancestor’s virtue. In the past I’ve written tolerantly about marijuana legalization. That’s something that needs to be done at the federal level. Attempts to finesse the situation as the Obama Administration did will create more problems than they solve.

1 comment