Question About an Oprah Run

Is being eligible for Social Security Retirement benefits now a prerequisite for seeking the presidency?

9 comments

The North Korean Tertium Non Datur

At the Wall Street Journal William Galston expresses the different views of North Korean motives pretty succinctly:

The success of nuclear diplomacy with North Korea depends on Pyongyang’s true motives for acquiring nuclear weapons, an issue about which the U.S. and China have long disagreed. Chinese experts and officials assert that the North has acquired a nuclear arsenal because the regime perceives a genuine threat from the U.S. and South Korea.

In a Brookings strategy paper, Fu Ying —chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee of the National People’s Congress of China and a former lead participant in the multilateral talks about North Korea’s nuclear program—urges Americans to understand the profound sense of insecurity that pervaded the North Korean leadership after the collapse of the Soviet Union, which was for decades the regime’s principal supporter. Beijing’s move to establish full diplomatic relations with Seoul in 1992 intensified Pyongyang’s sense of isolation and probably strengthened its determination to depend on nuclear weapons rather than allies for security.

The view from Washington is very different. Most U.S. experts in and out of government believe North Korea’s pursuit of nuclear weapons reflects aggressive intentions—to push U.S. forces out of South Korea and reunify the peninsula on Pyongyang’s terms. North Korea’s ostensible security concerns, they say, stem from irrational paranoia about U.S. intentions that no concessions could allay. And North Korea’s history of reneging and cheating on interim agreements underscores the difficulty—if not outright futility—of returning once more to diplomacy. If the U.S. interpretation is correct, the only choices are deterrence, which implies acceptance of North Korea as a nuclear-armed state, or a disastrous war.

Unlike those, presumably including Mr. Galston, who hold the view that he attributes to the Chinese, I take the North Koreans at their word. “They can’t possibly mean it” is not a sound argument. However, there’s still a course of action other than deterrence or war. We could just tell the Chinese clearly and simply what the consequences of North Korean aggression would be: we would destroy the Kim regime and probably most of North Korea utterly and the Korean peninsula would be reunited under South Korea as an ally of the United States. If they’re content with that, just let the North Koreans keep doing what they’ve been doing. If they don’t like it, stop the North Koreans themselves.

That isn’t deterrence as the term is usually used, either aimed at North Korea or China. It’s merely a statement of the costs.

4 comments

The Non-Solution

In his column this morning in the Washington Post Robert Samuelson speaks out in favor of Trump’s wall. His argument is that it’s relatively inexpensive as federal projects and would be well worth it if it solves the problem:

Democrats regard the wall as a colossal waste of money, citing the Trump administration’s $18 billion request to build or strengthen 700 miles of barriers over a decade. Actually, the price is cheap if it buys a solution to this stubborn problem.

From my point of view that’s an example of what I might call the “technocratic fallacy”—that government programs will be unfailingly, flawlessly and evenly administered. The reality is that a border wall will only be as strong as the weakest border agent. Sure, paying bribes will raise the cost of crossing into the country illegally a little and, consequently, at the margins will reduce the inflow of immigrants. Unfortunately, it will make it more likely that those coming into the country illegally will be criminals guilty of something other than immigration-related crimes.

A better, less expensive solution less susceptible to human frailty because controls could be built in would be serious, heavily-punished workplace enforcement. Mr. Samuelson provides the answer to support for Trump’s wall in his column:

The basic question here involves the nature of politics. Is it an exercise in showmanship, with each side more intent on demonstrating to its supporters that it won’t sacrifice strongly held beliefs even if that means policy paralysis? Their main idea is to look good, not to do something.

That’s exactly what politics is now. Showy exercises in meanness. There’s good waste and there’s bad waste. If you campaigned on it and it will make your supporters happy, it’s good waste. If it helps your opponent and/or his constituents, it’s bad waste. As Dana Milbanks noted, it all goes back to money.

1 comment

The Democrats’ Problem

In his most recent Washington Post column Dana Milbank seems surprised to discover that the Democrats have a problem:

The problem for Democrats is that the party is a collection of one-issue entities, which too often use internecine disputes for fundraising and, collectively, thwart any attempt at a cohesive progressive strategy.

It isn’t just the DREAMers, the main focus of Mr. Milbanks’s column. And it isn’t limited to the Democrats. At this point the Republicans seem to have a consensus on being anti-tax. But some Republicans are anti-immigrant, some want to expand immigration. Some are verging on isolationism; some want to solve every international problem with bombs. Some support same sex marriage; some are just anti-gay.

The DREAMers’ problem isn’t simply that they’re a one issue constituency. It’s what the issue is: if it were limited to enacting DACA into law the problem probably would have been solved long ago. Not flying Mexican flags at rallies might help.

The Democrats’ more serious problem of faction is that blacks are their most important voting bloc but have received short shrift in every Democratic administration of the last half century. Maybe their black constituents will be willing for that to continue indefinitely.

But note this phrase in Mr. Milbanks’s observation:

which too often use internecine disputes for fundraising

When you rely on the most committed for the lifeblood of politics and the most committed are also the most radical, that presents a fundamental problem for representative government which requires compromise to remain viable.

1 comment

Predictions Are Hard

This is just a casual observation. Once upon a time people wrote computer programs by wire wrapping backplanes. And for years people wrote computer programs by putting punches into cards.

Now for about 45 years most computer programs have been written by people typing at keyboards while staring at screens. The screens have changed but they’re still staring at them.

I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if within ten years that process were considered as obsolete as wire wrap or punched cards.

Additionally, I think we’ll always need to have people studying science and technology. But not to write computer programs.

3 comments

Amazon’s Vulnerability

I’m glad that people are arguing against the prevailing orthodoxy that Amazon will inevitably dominate the retail space. In this case it’s Allan Golombek at RealClearMarkets:

Those who fear Amazon is on the verge of becoming a monopoly that eats all competitors and locks up the retail market should take note of an announcement last week by Sears Holdings: The company will be closing another 100 stores this year.

Some will see Sears’ downward trajectory as proof that Amazon is on the verge of assuming near-monopolistic dominance of the retail market. In fact, it proves the opposite: No one can blithely assume that kind of power, at least not for long.

It would be easier for me to believe that Amazon will assume an unassailable dominance of retail if it were making more money in retail. And fifty years, the horizon mentioned by Mr. Golombek:

Fifty years from now, we may be reading about how a once-great company called Amazon is downsizing. And just like Sears today, many will forget how much the Seattle-based company elevated the consumer experience and changed the nature of retail.

I don’t know what Amazon will be doing in 10 years let alone 50. Will it still exist? Will it still be in retail at all?

1 comment

Identity Mismatch

Here’s what I think is a useful concept—”identity mismatch”. From an article on the problems with worker retraining programs by Jeffrey Selingo at Atlantic:

So when you plug real people into the easy fixes designed by policy wonks, the situation suddenly becomes more complicated: Older workers who haven’t seen the inside of a classroom for decades are frightened by going back to school. Men don’t want to train for the jobs that are left in town, particularly in health care, because of the stigma of being employed in occupations traditionally filled by women—a phenomena that Lawrence Katz, a Harvard University labor economist, has frequently called an “identity mismatch,” rather than a skills mismatch. And in a country founded by people on the move, unemployed workers are unwilling to relocate to find work.

I’m not sure where you draw the line between identity mismatch on the one hand and stereotyping and bigotry on the other. Is the reason that there aren’t that many male kindergarten teachers because there aren’t many applicants for the jobs or because one reason or another is found to reject the applicants?

I think that identity is probably one of the components behind present joblessness but I don’t think it’s the only factor and maybe not the most important one. If we were creating a lot more jobs than we are, I’d be prepared to think it was a major factor.

Not everybody can be a doctor of medicine and it’s not just a matter of training. Other factors include the ability to master the subject material, personal culture and, frankly, preference. Similarly, I think it would be a mistake to try to train unemployed construction workers as kindergarten teachers. And, yes, one of the reasons for that is identity.

3 comments

The Best Welfare Program Is a Job

Here’s another post with which I largely agree. At City Journal Peter Cove reacts to the idea of a Universal Basic Income:

The fatal flaw of the universal basic income is the same one that hampers most existing anti-poverty programs: a lack of emphasis on encouraging work. Instead, these programs have sought to provide directly whatever poor people happen to lack. The result has been more than 50 years of massive public outlays, with little benefit other than making recipients dependent on government. The ongoing rise in worker’s disability claims follows a long string of recent expansions of welfare programs, such as food stamps, housing assistance, and even free phones to boost the standard of living among poor citizens.

In the long run, this transfer-focused approach to welfare does more than create a disincentive to work. In his book The Welfare Trait, British neurobiologist Adam Perkins argues that dependence on welfare creates work-resistant personalities, which are often passed on from one generation to the next. As one review of Perkins’s work puts it, the welfare state “becomes a production line for damaged kids” and encourages parents in unemployed households to have more children than families led by breadwinners.

More and more men have become absorbed in an entrenched lifestyle of joblessness, with bleak consequences. Male joblessness exceeds 20 percent in six states—Alabama, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, New Mexico, and West Virginia—and the number of fatalities from drug overdoses is well above the national average in each. According to economist Allan Kreuger, 44 percent of men who have left the workforce use pain medication—the fastest-growing form of substance abuse in the nation today.

There is no substitute for work, for gainful employment. We aren’t built for idleness. Jobs produce more than pay checks. They add meaning to lives. Even when the robots come for our jobs (something I think will not happen but whatever) we will still need to create jobs for people to do.

We would be much better off with a universal jobs program than with a universal basic income. IMO a UBI will produce crime, violence, and misery.

5 comments

Where I Agree

At Democracy Marcia Angell has produced a post on health care reform with which I agree more than I do with most of what’s written. Here’s an example:

Many liberals nevertheless saw Obamacare as a step in the right direction. But others (I was one of them) saw it as a step in the wrong direction, because it provided the illusion of a fix to our dysfunctional health-care system, and might thereby delay a real solution. Although that illusion appears to finally be collapsing.

I would go farther. It’s not just that it “might” delay “a real solution”. It inevitably would delay such a solution.
We do not engage in continuous fine-tuning of policies in this country, particularly health care policies. The process is so painful major reforms occur only take place once a generation at the very fastest.

Or this:

The fatal flaw in Obamacare is that it is inherently unsustainable. (Unfortunately, the Republicans are right that it is unraveling, but wrong about the reason, and certainly wrong that the solution is more market competition.) Obama made the mistake of trying to increase access to better health insurance without fundamentally altering the features of our health system that made it so expensive, inflationary, and inadequate in the first place. Thus he continued to rely on investor-owned insurance companies and even guaranteed them millions more customers, while he also relied on revenue-seeking providers, including hospital conglomerates (even if technically nonprofit), out-patient facilities, drug companies, and medical specialists paid to provide ever more and ever pricier tests and procedures.

Where we differ is that I see improved care as the objective rather than coverage and, consequently, I think the sine qua non of health care reform is cost control. Presently, the cost of care doubles roughly every 12 years. Only education experiences comparable growth. Regardless of who pays no system that doubles every 12 years can be affordable. Simple as that.

How to accomplish that? Your guess is as good as mine. I do think that the fee for services model presently in use is incompatible with better access to care for everybody. Part of our problem is that we’re always fighting the last war. The solutions being proposed today might have worked a generation ago but won’t now. So, for example, I think that in 1965 a VA-style system might have addressed the problems that Medicare and Medicaid were intended to address: better access to affordable care for the elderly and poor. And in 1992 a single-payer system might have provided the necessary reforms if accompanied by a commitment to cost control.

1 comment

You Can’t Be An Expert on Everything

I always find it frustrating when highly intelligent people with fantastic resumes reveal the limitations of their expertise when they venture outside their areas of expertise. I yield to no one in my respect for Mohamed El-Erian in matters of finance. Sadly, in his op-ed at Bloomberg View he reveals that his knowledge does not extend to politics or policy. Consider:

On the supply side, better infrastructure — addressing decaying parts such as roads, bridges, airports and ports, as well as expanding in new areas associated with the wider use of technological innovations, including artificial intelligence and mobility — enhances both private- and public-sector productivity. By also reducing the historically-unusual gap that has emerged over the last few years between the U.S. and some of its international competitors, particularly in Asia, this spending helps lift both the country’s actual and potential growth capabilities.

When the federal government builds a new highway, the federal government shoulders most of the expense. Once built the highway becomes the property of the state and the state is primarily responsible for its upkeep and maintenance. That’s why when you cross the border from Illinois into Iowa, Wisconsin, or Indiana the roads are so much obviously better maintained. Those states give higher priority to maintenance than does Illinois.

Additionally, how federal, state, and local governments spend money is rarely based on need but on political considerations. The squeaky wheel, etc. That’s why no matter how much we spend our roads and bridges never seem to get any better and never result in improved “private- and public-sector productivity”. It would be a remarkable coincidence if it did because that’s not the basis on which the money is spent.

Additionally, infrastructure spending programs are inevitably backwards-looking—devoted more to past needs than future ones. Unless nothing ever changes that means that such programs accomplish a lot less than they might.

I think that Mr. El-Erian is imagining a form of government that’s different from the one we actually have and that does not and never will exist. The question he needs to ask is why a mile of subway costs so much more in New York than it does in Paris or Tokyo. It isn’t because of how they’re designed. It’s because of how they’re executed.

5 comments