How to Draw Districts

Impelled no doubt by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s gerrymandering decision, Sean Trende has an excellent post at RealClearPolitics on the ins and outs of drawing districts. He doubts that Penn’s SC’s decision will have much actual impact:

Who knows what mapmakers will come up with in a week or two dedicated to nothing but this question. My goal here isn’t to be exhaustive. Rather, it is just to emphasize that the court didn’t mandate fair districts, but rather ordered compact ones, and that these are two very different things. Moreover, there are important implications to this distinction, and they don’t necessarily work in Democrats’ favor in every environment.

One of the many problems with gerrymandering, even for defensible purposes, is that neighborhoods change faster than incumbents do. Take the Illinois 4th Congressional District. It was draw with more or less its present boundaries almost 30 years ago to ensure that a Hispanic Congressman would be elected from Chicago. It gerrymandered the two Chicago neighborhoods in which most Hispanics lived at the time to achieve that goal. Luis Gutierrez has held the seat ever since.

But Chicago and its Hispanic population has changed over that period. There are many more Hispanics, they live all over the city, and, importantly, there are many more Hispanic voters than there used to be and fewer blacks. IL-4’s boundaries protect Luis Guitierrez but they dilute Hispanic voting power in the city. There might actually be more Hispanic Congressmen in Chicago if the IL-4 weren’t so gerrymandered.

4 comments

Always a Bridesmaid

If the draft of an infrastructure plan that leaked out and was published at Axios is any gauge of the plan that may ultimately be passed, there are some aspects that leap out. Here’s the definition of the scope:

Applies to: surface transportation, airports, passenger rail, maritime and inland waterway ports, flood control, water supply, hydropower, water resources, drinking water facilities, storm water facilities, Brownfield and Superfund sites.

That is a list that is backward-looking in the extreme. No mention is made of the power grid or communications. No mention is made of nuclear, solar, or wind power.

Additionally, the weighting system for proposals only gives 5% to the utility of the program:

6. Evidence to support how project will spur economic and social returns on investment (5%)

which will tend to favor the projects of high-taxing states.

The value of the project over the life expectancy of the infrastructure asset being funded should receive more consideration. How well do you think we can predict our surface, air, and ocean transport needs over the period of the next 50 years? I think that automation is likely to reduce those needs if anything. What do you think?

My contrarian view is that we’re overbuilt if anything and that an infrastructure building plan is unlikely to provide a great deal of economic benefit other than for those actually involved in the building—not a very great number due to the way these projects are executed today. This draft doesn’t make me feel more favorably disposed to a massive infrastructure spending program.

8 comments

Rogoff’s Call

I strongly recommend that you read this interview with Kenneth Rogoff in Finanz und Wirtschaft. As you presumably know Dr. Rogoff is best known for his scholarship on financial crisis. Topics in the interview include the state of the economy, where the next financial crisis will issue from (China), why interest rates are so low, and Bitcoin.

3 comments

The Wisecracks Write Themselves

In reaction to the news that former FBI Director James Comey will be teaching an ethics class at the College of William & Mary, the editors of the Wall Street Journal propose a course outline:

Week One case study: The FBI is investigating a presidential candidate for mishandling classified emails as Secretary of State. The director decides on his own to violate Justice Department rules and exonerate that candidate in a public statement to the media, letting an aide replace the legally potent phrase “grossly negligent” in a draft of his statement with “extremely careless” in the final version.

Students will examine when a public official can choose to ignore rules and standards of conduct for what he considers to be higher purposes. Required reading: Former Deputy Attorney General and federal Judge Laurence Silberman’s February 2017 speech to the Columbia Law School chapter of the Federalist Society.

Breakout session topic: Having exonerated that candidate, the FBI director intervenes in the campaign again only days before Election Day, saying new evidence has required him to reopen the email case. Two days before the polls open he says that the new evidence turned out to be nothing of consequence. Was the FBI director protecting the rule of law, or his own reputation?

Ethical guides Huma Abedin and Anthony Weiner will visit each breakout session to steer the discussions. (Thanks to the federal prison system for letting Mr. Weiner appear by video from Federal Medical Center Devens.)

Week Two: Amid the post-Enron political frenzy, a prosecutor indicts an investment banker not on bank-related charges but on obstruction of justice based on a snippet of an ambiguous email. The first trial ends in a hung jury but the prosecutor wins on the second try only to be overturned by an appellate court.

Students will explore the ethical demands of prosecutorial discretion. Guest lecturer: Frank Quattrone.

Week Three: FBI director Robert Mueller and the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York are convinced that the man behind the 2001 anthrax mail attacks is a government virologist. They spend years pursuing him and destroying his reputation through the media, only to concede years later that they had fingered the wrong man.

Students will examine the ethics of trial-by-media and the risks to the fair administration of justice from prosecutors who ignore contrary evidence. Visiting scholars: Nicholas Kristof and Steven Jay Hatfill.

Week Four: A deputy attorney general handpicks a personal friend and godfather to one of his children, Patrick Fitzgerald, as a special counsel to investigate who leaked the name of CIA official Valerie Plame. Within days Mr. Fitzgerald learns that the leaker was Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage, a fact he then keeps secret for years.

Instead of closing the case, the deputy AG expands Mr. Fitzgerald’s mandate. After a three-year investigation that turns up nothing new, Mr. Fitzgerald indicts a White House aide for perjury to salvage something from the effort. Reporter Judith Miller, whom Mr. Fitzgerald sent to jail for 85 days to force her testimony that was crucial in convicting the White House official, later says she testified falsely after Mr. Fitzgerald withheld crucial information from her.

Students will consider the ethics of special counsels without effective supervision, and whether Mr. Fitzgerald showed loyalty to lasting values and the truth by keeping the name of the leaker secret from the public and President George W. Bush. Special guest (invited): Scooter Libby.

It’s like shooting fish in a barrel. I could propose any number more. Under what circumstances would a government official, appointed or hired, be ethically obligated to resign his or her position? Does it matter whether the official was appointed? If the standard for what is ethical is what can be proved in a court of law, would that produce a good and decent society? How much law enforcement would such a society require?

21 comments

Reforming the Congress

I disagree with Hugh Hewitt’s prescription, published in his op-ed in the Washington Post, for reforming the Senate:

What the Senate needs is an overhaul of its rules, one that preserves the rights of the minority in some cases — key legislation, for example, and perhaps appointments to the Supreme Court — while also reflecting the speed at which the world moves today. Simple majorities on appropriations and time limits on debate over minor nominees are two obvious reforms. They could be traded for agreement on the high court vacancies, formalizing the modern precedent established by McConnell of no nominations in an election year but consideration and votes on nominees from the year prior such as Anthony M. Kennedy. The same deal could also include changes to the “Byrd Rule,” which gives the Senate parliamentarian broad sway over what is allowed under budget reconciliation — an extraconstitutional expansion of the parliamentarian’s powers that makes sense only under a Cubist understanding of how the Senate is supposed to operate.

since I don’t believe those measures would actually do much or at least not what was needed. I think we need a single-subject Constitutional amendment. No more omnibus or “comprehensive” bills. It’s too easy to hide things in them and, inevitably, no one really knows what’s in them.

3 comments

Line of the Day

I think I’m going to tentatively award the Line of the Day to David Brooks. From his New York Times column criticizing the Senate Democrats for their strategy:

When Democrats get all excited, they go into a hypnotic trance and think the entire country is the Middlebury College faculty lounge.

There are any number of wry comments in the piece. Read the whole thing. There’s also one serious observation:

The Democrats are the party that believes in government. It doesn’t do them any good to make the federal government look dysfunctional.

Fortunately, they don’t have to try. The strongest argument against technocracy is technocrats. And this:

Racially tinged conflict has been the defining feature of the Trump era. Most of the outrage has been caused by the president picking at the nation’s wounds. But by now both parties have racial identity wings, which believe that political life is inevitably a power competition between identity groups. Both parties build their coalitions by magnifying racial identity and exploiting racial difference.

But there are some of us who are uncomfortable with the whole identity-politics drill. We believe that while racism is the central stain on American history, racial conflict is not inevitable. By reducing inequalities, by integrating daily life, we can eventually make our common humanity more salient and our racial difference less so. We believe that America has already made strides in this direction and that it’s everyone’s responsibility to make racial diversity a creative spark and not a source of permanent hostility.

Although this view is roughly congruent with mine, I suspect the details are different. I think that governmental attempts to maximize welfare or economic inequality will inevitably fail. I’d rather see the emphasis on maximizing freedom.

7 comments

Moral Question

I think it would be an act of clemency to allow the young people who were brought to the United States illegally as children by their parents to remain with some sort of legal status. I don’t think there’s a moral obligation to do so as some are claiming.

Could someone please articulate the case that there is a moral obligation to allow them to remain?

1 comment

Obsession

If, as is reportedly claimed by Attorney General Jeff Sessions, FBI official Strzok and Page exchange 50,000 texts over the six month period from December 14, 2016 to May 17, 2017, I’m not sure how they had the time to do anything else. I doubt that I’ve sent 1,000 text messages over the period of the last 10 years.

Let’s see. 6 months X 30 days per month X 2 people = 360. 50,000/360 is about 140 texts each per day. That’s about three times the average for 18 year olds. I certainly hope somebody misunderstood what was being said.

3 comments

I Wonder…

I wonder how many Americans realize that when people talk about “the global 1%” they’re talking about them? It only takes an income of about $50,000 to be in the global 1% of income earners. In other words about half of Americans are members of the global 1%. And we’re not exactly lighting our cigars with $100 bills.

12 comments

Why They Do What They Do

If you’ve been wondering why your dog eats poop, this article at Scientific American might provide you with an answer. I won’t quote it, at least not this close to breakfast.

My own opinion is that it’s because your dog has a sweet tooth.

7 comments