Blue Sky Dream

Does anyone think that James Barton is doing anything but fantasizing in his post at RealClearWorld:

For those who say that the Middle Kingdom’s economy will buckle under environmental restrictions, there is also the simple fact there is significant economic gain – not to mention well-being – to be had from lower pollution levels. In fact, Beijing largely started its anti-smog campaign due to economic considerations. According to China’s Ministry of Environmental Protection, pollution in 2010 cost the economy a whopping 3.5 percent of GDP. This is not surprising when one considers the health costs, lost productivity, and detrimental effects of pollution on sectors ranging from tourism to agriculture.

As it turns out, then, there is some good news both for Beijing and the world. Though some economic sectors may feel some initial and relatively muted impact from the environmental restrictions, over the long term, China may well be able to both have its cake and eat it too.

For China’s leaders the highest priority is their retaining their hold on the reins of power. They have shown that they believe that depends on continuing Chinese economic growth and keeping unemployment low. Coal miners are workers, too. When China’s economy was growing in double digits every year it was one thing. Last year it probably grew at half that.

It can’t be lost on China’s leaders that the decline in economic growth coincided with the very modest crackdowns on pollution.

1 comment

We Want Something Else

The editors of the Chicago Tribune are dismayed at the pool of candidates for Illinois governor:

On Jan. 19, six Democratic candidates for governor met with the Tribune Editorial Board seeking our endorsement in the March 20 primary. Days later, we met with the two Republican candidates, Gov. Bruce Rauner and state Rep. Jeanne Ives. The Democrats responded to our questions by acknowledging the perilous fiscal condition of state government and Illinois’ weak jobs economy. They were not in denial. Good. But neither did they animate us with their strategies to confront the state pension crisis, and Illinois’ onerous tax and regulatory burdens.

Those are the realities that give Illinois its reputation for being unfriendly to employers. From what we heard, the Democrats mostly see more tax revenue, in the form of progressive income tax rates, as the solution for the fiscal problem. They don’t have a compelling plan for job growth. Not good, and not good.

Rauner and Ives appeared more eager to reform state finances and lure employers. They understand that Illinois needs more taxpayers. That said, their ability to strategize is hamstrung by the fact that Democrats have an iron grip on the legislature. Ives said she believes she’d be able to cut deals on spending issues. She also believes she could win support to shift new government employees to a 401(k)-style retirement plan, which would provide some relief to the pension crisis. Rauner is gambling on two federal court cases that would loosen the power of unions and make Illinois more friendly and flexible to business.

All of these proposals fall short of what’s needed to restore Illinois to reasonable fiscal health. Not to put too fine a point on it but the Democrats are living in a fool’s paradise. Individuals and businesses are already leaving Illinois in alarming numbers, taking jobs and income with them. Ultimately, the reason for that may be uncertainty but proximately the reasons are rising taxes and the heavy regulatory burden. Attempting to solve the problems by increasing taxation alone creates a vicious circle of rising taxes and declining tax base. I would add that any candidate who says he or she will impose a graduated state income tax is lying. That would require amending the state’s constitution and there are just not enough votes for that.

But the Republicans have a fool’s paradise of their own. The Democratic leadership will never willing accept a 401(k) pension scheme for public employees. And, as is obvious from Rauner’s experience, the Democrats are completely unwilling to compromise. Their correct calculation is that all they need to do is wait. I never believed that Rauner’s program would do much to heal Illinois in the near term but I thought it was worth a try and that Democrats should have at least given him something.

In my view the only practical solution for Illinois is what is blandly referred to as “shared sacrifice”—slight increases in taxes and substantial decreases in spending and the regulatory burden. Decreases in spending can only be accomplished by cuts in public employee payrolls (numbers, pay rates, or both), tightening Medicaid eligibility requirements, and reforms in public pensions (changing the formula for new employees, eliminating “double dipping”, etc.)

Chocolate cake is a much easier sell than broccoli so no politician will ever propose such a program.

2 comments

Is Sensible Immigration Reform Even Possible Any More?

I’m largely in agreement with George Borjas’s views on U. S. immigration reform, as expressed in this op-ed at the New York Times. For example

The only way to truly curtail illegal immigration may require that all employers use an electronic system like E-Verify to certify the legal status of newly hired workers, accompanied by sizable penalties for employers who break the law.

and

A sensible immigration policy that generates economic benefits for Americans and for immigrants already here ensures that we can better adapt to the economic shocks that will visit us in the next few decades. And the best way to maximize those benefits is to filter the pool of persons who want to migrate.

Before jumping in to claim that such “filtering” is un-American, it’s worth remembering that anything short of open borders inevitably involves filtering. Between the 1920s and 1965, the filtering was done through national origin, giving preference to immigrants born in Western European countries. Since 1965, we have preferred immigrants who have relatives already living here. Filtering on the basis of economic potential ensures that immigration generates the largest possible economic gain for our country.

Right now the extreme positions dominate the national conversation. At this point the Democratic leadership won’t accept any form of “filtering”, as Dr. Borjas puts it, and, as he points out, that is de facto an “open borders” policy. The most vocal opponents of open borders want to eject all illegal immigrants (and some even all immigrants full stop).

Polling data suggest that the greatest number of the American people don’t support either of those extreme positions. They think that legal immigration of between 500,000 and 1 million per year is acceptable, that illegal immigration is not acceptable, and that some accommodation should be made for illegal immigrants who were brought here as children by their parents.

It would seem that there’s room for a compromise there but, frankly, I doubt it. As Josh Billings put it more than a century ago,

The wheel that squeaks the loudest
Is the one that gets the grease.

6 comments

Unwinnable

I’m not going to fisk this entire article at the New York Times, especially since I may agree with its conclusion. However, as my old business partner used to say, I may agree with what you say but I will deny to the death your right to say it. Consider, for example, this passage:

All options involve acknowledging the war as failed, American aims as largely unachievable and Afghanistan’s future as only partly salvageable. Their advocates see glimmers of hope barely worth the stomach-turning trade-offs and slim odds of success.

“I don’t think there is any serious analyst of the situation in Afghanistan who believes that the war is winnable,” Laurel Miller, a political scientist at the RAND Corporation, said in a podcast last summer, after leaving her State Department stint as acting special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan.

“No True Scotsman” watch! Also, compare and contrast:

September 5, 2015

The United States is committed to helping Afghanistan achieve enduring stability. We are pleased that so many of our partners have gathered here in Kabul to engage in this constructive conversation and show our collective support for Afghanistan’s stability, security and prosperity.

Together with others in the international community, the United States will continue to be a strong partner of the Afghan government, especially as it works to address daunting security and economic challenges. In recognition of the significance that Afghanistan continues to have on the international stage, the United States, in furtherance of our partnership with Afghanistan, will co-host with China and Afghanistan a high-level event on the margins of the UN General Assembly later this month. As one example of our continued extraordinary practical support for promoting Afghan prosperity, and following Afghan achievement of agreed-upon development results, we recently authorized the disbursement of the first $100 million in funding under the New Development Partnership announced by the White House during President Ghani’s visit to Washington.

The agreement we’ve reached today on a refreshed mutual accountability framework is a significant milestone in all of our relationships with Afghanistan. We are optimistic that this agreement will enable other donors to move ahead with incentive programs grounded in Afghan priorities. We congratulate the Afghan government for the progress it has made since the political transition last September and welcome the government’s report on its progress.

Afghanistan’s government of national unity, led by President Ghani with the support of Chief Executive Abdullah, has made progress in key areas over the past year: from government appointments and anti-corruption initiatives, to the establishment of the Special Electoral Reform Commission. We urge all stakeholders—domestic and international—to work together to ensure implementation of crucial reforms. The next round of polls should follow a meaningful and transparent reform process.

Read the whole statement at the web site of the U. S. State Department and weep.

Ms. Miller, when did you become a “serious analyst”? Obviously you weren’t one by your own definition on September 5, 2015. What developments since that time caused you to become serious?

Or this:

This may be why, even after thousands have died and over $100 billion has been spent, even after the past two weeks of shocking bloodshed in Kabul, few expect the United States to try anything other than the status quo.

From fiscal year 2009 to FY 2016 the U. S. spent upwards of $600 billion and incurred the greatest number of U. S. casualties in Afghanistan. Since then it has spent $5.7 billion. When did the NYT become cost conscious?

Or this:

Over time, ideally, Afghans might develop a functioning economy, then something like real democracy and, finally, peace and stability.

“But what we know from other cases is that this takes generations,” Ms. Brown said. “So the 18-month time frames we’ve always had for Afghanistan are not realistic.”

That’s what I said in 2002 as did any number of other genuinely serious analysts with credentials and everything. When did the NYT come to this realization? It must have been within the last year.

I just can’t fathom that level of cynicism.

7 comments

Disruption

Yesterday I attended a colloquium at the Executive Club of Chicago on prospects for technology (“Tech Outlook”) in Chicago. The rousing and energetic opening statement was by Howard Tullman of 1871, Chicago’s “Technology and Entrepeneurship Center”.

I guess I’m a dissenter. I don’t think anyone else in the room noticed that on one of his slides there was a list of “disrupters” none of which was making any money. I can only suppose that it’s easier to disrupt an industry than it is to make money doing it.

My hypothesis from the astronomical stock valuations we’re seeing these days is that there is far too much money chasing far too little opportunity.

I wish the panel had spent less time speculating whether Amazon would pick Chicago for its second headquarters or not. As I said to the chap sitting next to me, “It’s an honor just to be nominated.” The panel was divided in opinion. My general view is that when Amazon does, ultimately, announce its decision, it will give us a better idea of how Amazon sees its future. If it picks something in the neighborhood of Washington, DC, it will suggest that Amazon sees its future as being a government client, much like Tesla.

Sadly, I still have no better idea of the prospects for technology in Chicago over the next year, five years, or longer horizon than I did when I walked in.

5 comments

And the 17th Century French Went to the Moon

At Hakai Rebecca Boyle outlines the case that ancient Greeks made regular crossing between Europe and Canada:

The story of the European settlement of North America usually features a few main characters: red-headed Norsemen who sailed across an icy sea to set up temporary outposts, Spanish conquistadors, white-collared English separatists, French trappers, and Dutch colonists. Now a team of Greek scholars proposes another—and much earlier—wave of European migration: the Hellenistic Greeks, in triremes powered by sail and oar in the first century CE, nearly a millennium before the Vikings.

These ancient Greeks regularly visited what is now Newfoundland, the study’s authors say. They set up colonies that lasted centuries, and they mined gold. They made recurrent trips every 30 years. Some travelers would return home after only a brief stay, but for others the voyages were one way—they came to know the North Atlantic, not the warm Aegean, as their home waters.

Literary depictions without concrete evidence prove exactly nothing. Concrete evidence could include artifacts, corroborative testimony, or even genetic evidence. Without those the notion that ancient Greeks made regular visits to Canada is nothing but airy fantasy. The same argument could be used to prove that 17th century Frenchmen sailed to the moon.

Here’s another argument against: travelling to North America with sail power is one thing. Getting there by muscle power is something else again. Could they transport enough food to make the journey? Most of what they encountered along the way they wouldn’t even have recognized as food. There are many accounts of early European explorers starving to death in the New World even while surrounded by plenty because they didn’t recognize what they were looking at as food.

3 comments

The First Casualty

The earliest attribution of the observation that the first casualty of war is truth is to Samuel Johnson and although the notion gained currency during the run-up to World War I, nowhere is that observation more true than in the case of our ongoing war in Afghanistan. At LobeLog Derek Davison provides a frank status report on our efforts in Afghanistan:

  • terrorism is unabated
  • the prospect of negotiations is more remote
  • civilian casualties are slightly reduced but the proportion of civilian casualties produced by the U. S. has risen
  • conditions may actually be worse than are being reported

For example, although it’s being widely said that the Afghan government controls just under half the country, it may be more like one third.

I disagree somewhat with his closing assessment:

Perhaps the issue isn’t that Americans don’t know what their military is doing in Afghanistan, it’s that, after more than 16 years at war, they simply don’t care.

Ten or so years ago I did a quantitative assessment of public opinion on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and came to the conclusion that there was a threshold below which Americans were not unconcerned but tolerated the status quo. That threshold was about two U. S. casualties per day.

U. S. casualties depend primarily on two variables: total troops deployed and operational tempo. Those two factors are positively correlated with our ability to control the situation in Afghanistan. I believe there’s a sweet spot but we’re well below it.

More than anything else we’ve got to identify our objectives in Afghanistan and what we can or can’t do. If it is politically impossible for us to leave Afghanistan, whether due to its domestic or geopolitical implications, which certainly seems to be the case, then we should look with gimlet eye at what we can achieve in Afghanistan and what it would take to achieve it.

I continue to believe, as I have believed since 2001, that invading Afghanistan was an error. However, we can’t unscramble the egg. Let’s consider ways and means in Afghanistan honestly. If we can never leave, say so. If we can leave once certain objectives are met, say what they are and what it will take to accomplish them. Then put those resources in place.

If we can leave Afghanistan, do so and don’t second guess the decision in the light of subsequent events.

The worst choice is what we’re doing: staying forever without doing what’s necessary to accomplish any meaningful objectives.

3 comments

The Balance of Forces

It may not always be apparent but in many cases my linking to articles is prompted not because I agreed with them but because they moved me to reflect. That was very much the case with Ronald Dworkin’s post at American Affairs, “Capitalism’s Character Types”. In the article he opens with some interesting questions. How did Democrats come to embrace open borders, harmful as they are to important members of their coalition? Why do so many economic conservatives, in his words, “obfuscate” the reasons they support open borders? Here’s his observation:

For progressive Democrats, who supposedly distrust capitalism, the truth risks exposing them as shills for unrestricted capital and markets; for economic conservatives, who love capitalism, the truth risks their finding fault with what they love.

He goes on to consider some stereotypes that prevailed at certain moments in history: the Yankee Protestant, the “Organization Man”, and David Brooks’s “Bourgeois Bohemian”, explaining them:

First, each type captured the spirit of the American upper middle class at a particular moment. This is important because only the upper middle class has sufficient numbers, influence, and wealth to control culture. Second, each type rationalized the capitalism of its day.

Now I disagree with his interpretation of events but I do think he’s on to something important. Consider tossing a pebble into the air. When you throw a pebble into the air there is a moment when it appears to stop. But that’s an illusion, a consequence of two opposing forces, in this case the force of gravity and the force of your arm throwing the pebble. For just a moment the two forces balance each other out and the pebble appears to stop.

His notions about the upper middle class are absurd. They do have the podium because neither the ultra-wealthy nor the poor write books musing about the special moment in history that is the eternal today. But they don’t control the culture any more than historians control history. Historians just produce the historiography. History is under no one’s control. It’s the same reason that Denver is portrayed as having palm trees in television programs. Or that Omaha is portrayed as having mountains on the horizon. Whatever you see on TV, neither Denver nor Omaha is Los Angeles.

In reality “capitalism” is just one force among many, although it’s an important one. There are many other forces including the desire for approval and other aspects of human nature. The United States didn’t enter World War II because the Nazis were awful or because the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor. It was because the Nazis’ attack of the Soviet Union ended American socialists’ opposition to going to war and the attack on Pearl Harbor ended American isolationists’ opposition. The forces pushing us towards war that had been building for years no longer had countervailing forces.

What has given the #metoo movement critical mass if it indeed has critical mass? What is propelling modern feminism? Viewing them as the consequences of the interplay among competing forces will convey a different understanding than simpler explanations.

Mr. Dworkin’s Yankee Protestant, Organization Man, and Bobo were doomed by their own internal contradictions as well as the changing needs of international capitalism. The Organization Man couldn’t stand up against human nature and the great thrust of American culture.

5 comments

Retail As Benevolence

All of Amazon’s operating income in 2017 came from Amazon Web Services:

While the numbers from Amazon’s e-commerce operations were impressive, the cash cow remains Amazon Web Services. Consider:

  • Amazon’s North America e-commerce business delivered fourth quarter operating income of $1.69 billion on revenue of $37.3 billion.
  • International e-commerce sales were $18.04 billion with a operating loss of $919 million.
  • AWS had operating income of $1.35 billion for the fourth quarter with sales of $5.11 billion.
  • For the year, Amazon’s international e-commerce operating losses eclipsed the company’s North American operating profit. AWS had 2017 operating income of $4.33 billion on sales of $17.46 billion.
  • In other words, on an annual basis all of Amazon’s operating income derives from AWS.

or in other other words Amazon is a web services company that maintains an online retail site as a benevolent organization. That’s the reason I don’t think that Amazon will ultimately prevail in the retail space. The most likely candidate for that is Walmart.

9 comments

What Is Your Business Chemistry?

You might find this article at New Equipment Digest interesting. The article takes note of a framework used by Deloitte’s human resource management consulting unit for delineating different styles of “Business Chemistry”. They categorize workers as Pioneers, Guardians, Drivers, and Integrators:

Pioneers, who are risk-takers described as being outgoing, detail-averse, spontaneous, risk-seeking, adaptable and imaginative.

Opposite to Pioneers are Guardians, defined as detail-oriented pragmatists who are considered methodical, reserved, detail-oriented, practical, structured and loyal.

Drivers are experimental competitors who are quantitative, logical, focused, competitive, experimental and deeply curious.

Integrators are Drivers’ opposites, seen as empathic diplomats who exhibit qualities that characterize good team players and who tend to be traditional, relationship-oriented dreamers, intrinsically motivated and non-confrontational.

and there are generational differences in the styles that predominate within different age cohorts:

The research shows that close to 60% of Millennials identify with two of the four primary Business Chemistry types. Guardians, detail-oriented pragmatists, comprise 32%; while Drivers, who focus on outcomes and goals, make up 27%.

Only 23% of the Millennials in the sample are Integrators, the type that values connection and draws teams together, and 18% represent Pioneers, the most blue-sky thinking, spontaneous type.

In contrast, the study reveals that Baby Boomers are represented by Millennials’ opposing Business Chemistry types: the Pioneer and the Integrator. These are the two most nonlinear, ambiguity-tolerant and networked work styles. In addition, 29% of Baby Boomers identify as Pioneer, with an equal number identifying as Integrator, while 22% identify as Driver and only 20% as Guardian.

The article goes on to suggest strategies for managing Millennials.

I found that the article left significant questions unanswered. Is there actual empirical evidence to support these claims? Do the prevailing “chemistries” change over time within an age cohort? How would you go about determining that? What were the most common chemistries among the Baby Boomers when they were the age that the Millennials are now? What were the prevailing chemistries among the “Greatest Generation”? Their parents? Do these distinctions relate to the Four Turnings?

On a side note when I tried digging a little deeper into this subject I stumbled across an article from Deloitte itself that rankled me. Just for future reference there are no Baby Boomers in their 80s. People working into their 80s now are Silent Generation, not Baby Boomers.

Update

You can take Deloitte’s Business Chemistry 20 Questions test here. I’m a Pioneer-Integrator.

3 comments