I tend to stay away from what I perceive as partisan bickering and that’s why I haven’t written anything about the “Nunes memo”. My friends at Outside the Beltway have certainly been posting incessantly about it. At this point I honestly don’t know what to believe. The folks at Talking Points Memo emphasize these points:
- It tip-toes around how much the Page warrant relied on Steele dossier
- It undercuts the GOP narrative that the dossier prompted Russia probe
- Most of Trump’s top FBI and DOJ targets just so happen to crop up in it
- Strzok and Page are not the anti-Trump partisans they’ve been made out to be
- Some omissions of context are obvious
which obviously are damning condemnations from their point of view. Harper, one of the paleocons at Pat Lang’s place and not a Trump supporter says this:
It is one thing for people in government service to have political views and biases, it is another thing for those biases to infect the workings of our law enforcement and intelligence agencies. Likewise for the House Select Committee on Intelligence, which had been one of the last bastions of non-partisan work on Capitol Hill (the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence appears to have preserved some semblance of bipartisan collaboration). That above-politics commitment has been trashed and it may never be restored. And it began with Adam Schiff, who seems to have spent half his time on CNN and MSNBC since the Trump election.
While the entire Mueller probe may have been the result of the fruit of a poison tree (the salacious Steele allegations, which even the FBI admitted were never corroborated), I doubt that the Mueller probe will be shut down before completion. Mueller moved quickly to dismiss Strzok and Page once the amorous emails were turned over to him in July 2017 and somewhat insulated himself from their bile.
If there was credible evidence of Russian attempts to interfere in the 2016 elections—outside of the toxic claims in the Steele dossier—that is a fair subject for counterintelligence investigation. But it is becoming more and more clear that the inclusion of President Trump in the Mueller probe derived almost 100 percent from the Steele product. FBI Director James Comey read the documents and was reportedly so horrified that he threw himself fully into the scheme—along with Obama partisans John Brennan and James Clapper—to stop Donald Trump from taking office.
That, IMHO, is criminal. Comey, Brennan and Clapper are legitimate targets for Federal investigation. Only by getting to the bottom of the abuse of the awesome powers of the Federal law enforcement and intelligence services can we hope to ever restore credibility and non-partisanship, two hallmarks of a genuine republic.
while Michael Goodwin, in his column at the New York Post, sees the memo as confirmation of many of the harshest claims of Trump’s supporters:
Because of the memo and previous revelations, we know that swamp creatures are embedded in the top of the FBI and the Department of Justice. Some used their power to try to tip a presidential campaign based on their personal politics.
They conducted a sham investigation of the Democratic candidate and misled federal judges to spy on at least one associate of her Republican challenger.
To block exposure of their misdeeds, these officials falsely claimed that national security would be damaged. Add that despicable lie — issued in the name of the FBI itself — to their shameful records.
Thanks to the battle over the memo, we also know with 100 percent certainty that the mainstream media is part of the swamp. The efforts by The New York Times and The Washington Post, among others, to keep the memo from ever seeing sunshine were appalling.
Here’s my truth, as the kids are saying these days:
- The Steele dossier had no place in an application for a FISA warrant and the FBI knew it.
- The FBI’s conduct with respect to the Clinton campaign, the Trump campaign, and the events related to them went well beyond zealous enforcement of the law.
- The Russians wanted to discredit our political process. They’ve largely been successful.
- Russian interference probably didn’t result in a single fraudulent vote or the falsification of the results. It didn’t change the outcome of the election.
- Republicans have seriously overhyped the memo.
- The partisan sniping that has ensued has obscured the serious issues that are being revealed.
I remain content for the Mueller investigation to work its way through.
However, I’m open to being convinced otherwise on any of those points so I’m relying on my readers to tell me what I should believe. Please provide evidence and avoid ad hominem arguments, particularly but not limited to those directed against me. These include insults, impugning my motives, etc.