The War They Want to Fight

At RealClearWorld Phillip Orchard of Geopolitical Futures outlines U. S. military strategy as delineated by the latest National Defense Strategy report:

The Pentagon’s new National Defense Strategy articulated a profound shift in U.S. strategy, but one that has long been underway: Great power competition, not terrorism, is now the primary focus of U.S. national security.

According to the NDS: “The central challenge to U.S. prosperity and security is the re-emergence of long-term, strategic competition by what the National Security Strategy classifies as revisionist powers. It is increasingly clear that China and Russia want to shape a world consistent with their authoritarian model – gaining veto authority over other nations’ economic, diplomatic, and security decisions. Long-term strategic competitions with China and Russia are the principal priorities for the Department, and require both increased and sustained investment, because of the magnitude of the threats they pose to U.S. security and prosperity today, and the potential for those threats to increase in the future.”

He goes on to highlight those challenges I can’t help but be skeptical.

Over the period of the last 20 years the Pentagon has been preparing for, longing for, pining for near-peer high-tech warfare. Many present general officers have spent their entire careers promoting programs for such a war. Solutions intended for that sort of warfare haven’t been as effective in dealing with the actual problems we’ve faced which have been largely facing small groups of variously trained irregulars with improvised equipment. We haven’t had casualties due to superweapons but due to IEDs.

Rather than preparing for near-peer high tech war we need to be doing much, much more to avoid such a war. And, although I’m not a military strategist I’ll assert with some confidence that our future challenges are unlikely to be what the Pentagon wants to prepare for.

7 comments

The Crux

At City Journal John Michaelson’s post on our phlegmatic economy eventually gets around to the crux of the problem:

Averting a crisis was necessary. But the Fed and the Treasury did not stop there. They wound up bailing out huge Wall Street banks that contribute little to the productive “real” economy, along with insurers (AIG) and huge and inefficient industrial companies. Embarking on a new policy of “quantitative easing” to bolster the lending market, the Fed blew up its balance sheet by purchasing debt to keep interest rates down, certain that productive borrowing would ensue. Before the crash, at the end of July 2008, the Fed’s assets were $0.9 trillion. By July 2017, they had ballooned to $4.5 trillion (see graph above). These measures yielded little. Near-zero rates did not spur an expansion of jobs or of productivity-enhancing research. Instead, the easy money went to other uses, including the funding of mergers and acquisitions among giant companies and private-equity-sponsored, highly leveraged buyouts.

I expressed my opinion long ago. Rather than bailing out the big banks, they should have been broken up. Their capitalization was zero at that point. It could have been done without running afoul of the Takings Clause and as others, notably William Black, have written it was within the regulatory agencies’ ability to deal with.

Instead the decision was made to preserve them like national treasures and use quantitative easing, which used to be called “extraordinary measures” but have now become all too ordinary, to boost the incomes of the ultra-wealthy in the hope that they would invest enough in the real economy to ensure a robust recovery, something that did not transpire. And so we have the present situation in which more than a decade later thousands of counties still haven’t seen a recovery in employment, jobs, or output. A relative handful of counties have recovered nicely, however.

0 comments

Every Clerk Makes Policy

My reaction to this article at the Washington Examiner from Ilya Shapiro about an FDA employee without Constitutional authority issuing regulations is that if the rulemakers and those tasked with enforcing the rules aren’t going to follow the rules we should have far fewer rules.

I think what we’re seeing here are the consequences of negligent management. Unless the appropriate controls are put in place, every clerk makes policy. That’s true in your corner bar and it’s true in the federal government.

6 comments

Uninterested

I do not trumpet rises in the DJIA. I do not rend my garments over its declines. I think the relationship between the DJIA and the economy that I encounter every time I go to the grocery store, pump gas, pay my bills, or go to work is only tangential at this point—the DJIA has a life of its own and I have little to do with it.

In 1980 the DJIA stood at 824 and had been around that for more than 15 years. Now it’s at 25,000. The number of people who are employed hasn’t increased 30 fold, my house isn’t worth 30 times what it was worth then, and I’m not getting paid 30 times what I was in 1980. If I were I’d be in the top .1% of income earners.

In 1980 a 100 point decline in the DJIA would be catastrophic. Now a 1,000 point decline is merely nerve-wracking.

Update

Jeff Spross expresses somewhat similar ideas at The Week:

The stock market giveth, and the stock market taketh away.

After a year of booming valuations and record-smashing highs, the stock market has been tumbling for days. The Dow Jones Industrial Average, the S&P 500, and the Nasdaq all weakened last week, and then nosedived on Friday, with the Dow plummeting more than 660 points. It was the Dow’s worst day since the summer of 2016. It seemed like things couldn’t get much worse.

Then Monday rolled around, and stocks went into a catastrophic slide. The Dow absolutely tanked, diving 1,175 points for the day. At one point it was down more than 1,500 points, and somehow plunged 800 points in roughly 15 minutes before righting itself. By day’s end, all the gains of this new year had been erased. It was the Dow’s worst day in more than six years.

The January jobs report was positive on its face. Unemployment remains low. Nothing major seems to have changed in the last few days.

So what on Earth is going on?

4 comments

The Wicked Web

At Forbes Thomas Del Beccaro weaves together the threads of Hillary Clinton’s email server, the Trump campaign’s activities the prompted the Mueller investigation, and some of the major players in both at the FBI and DoJ involved with both into a timeline that looks pretty damning on the face of it. I presume there is a counter-argument. What is it?

What do I think about it? I think that Hillary Clinton, her advisors, and, possibly, President Obama were engaged in a conspiracy to evade the Records Act and multiple violations of the Records Act. I think that Trump’s close associates and, possibly, Trump himself have been involved in some pretty smarmy business dealings in Russia and, possibly, some ham-handed attempts at oppo research using Russian sources. I think that the FBI abused the FISA process.

There’s a lot I don’t know. For example, I don’t know if Donald Trump, his close associates, or the Trump campaign did anything illegal. That’s what the Mueller investigation is about.

I’m unhappy about all of it but I’m not as outraged by these shenanigans as I might be because I have a dour view of government in general, probably because I’m familiar with how it works. In government as in any large organization there are a lot of people just trying to do their jobs, there are a lot of people trying to avoid doing anything at all, and there are some people trying to benefit personally from it by doing whatever they can get away with.

7 comments

Markets, Maturity, and Smartphones

I couldn’t get any farther than the caption of James Joyner’s recent post at Outside the Beltway, “Have Smart Phones Gone the Way of the PC?”, without responding.

What does “the way of the PC” mean? In 2017 more than 262 million PCs were sold worldwide. That’s down from number of units sold way back in the heyday of PCs back in 2011 but it’s far from dead. I wouldn’t mind having .1% of that market.

To understand what’s going on let’s start with mainframes—those big dinosaurs of computers that were just about all that were sold in 1970. In 1970 IBM sold about $17 billion worth of mainframes; last year they sold about $2 billion worth. That sounds pretty bad until you realize that it was predicted that the last mainframe would be turned off for good in 1999, 19 years ago. I haven’t been able to discover the unit sales of mainframes. Clearly, there’s been an enormous drop-off but they ain’t dead yet. What’s actually happened is that the market for mainframes is mature, the number of prospective customers for mainframes has declined, and mainframe sales now follow the development and replacement cycle for mainframes.

A mature market is one in which all of the prospects for a product already has as many as they need. When that happens customers just replace the products they have when the old ones wear out or it’s more economical to replace the old model than to keep it.

In mainframe computers there’s a long development cycle and a long replacement cycle. They’re pretty durable and maintainable and people tend to keep them for as long as they can, for many years.

Now let’s turn to PCs. In 2011 the total market for PCs was 350 some-odd million and now it’s around 262 some-odd. The performance of the PC you bought in 2015 isn’t much different from the one you’d buy now so there’s no pressing reason to replace your existing PC. Sales of PCs have just about leveled off. I believe that the PC space has become a mature market.

It won’t disappear. Just as there are darned good reasons for some companies to keep using mainframes, there are things you just can’t do particularly well using your smartphone or a tablet. Will that change? It might but I believe there will be a substantial niche for personal computers, desktops and notebooks, for the foreseeable future.

What about the smartphone? I think it’s almost undoubtedly true that smartphones, too, have become a mature market. Increases in sales will depend on increases in the population and the development and replacement cycles.

Weirdly, the U. S. is sort of a backwater for smartphones for regulatory reasons and there may be some life in the U. S. market for smartphones yet. It depends on what our Lords and Masters see fit to let us have.

5 comments

Striking a Child

As I read this article about spanking by Noam Shpancer at Quillette:

Most American parents hit their little children. And most believe that they are doing something both effective and right.

But they are wrong.

The scientific case against spanking is one of those rare occasions in which, over a span of 50 years or so, a scientific controversy actually gets resolved, as various programs of increasingly rigorous research converge upon a consensus conclusion.

True, the issue has not been 100% mapped out. Waiting for social science to map any issue out 100% is like waiting for the perfect spouse. You’ll wait forever, pointlessly. Spanking, like any socio-behavioral phenomenon, is bound to have somewhat differing implications depending on multiple variables such as culture, timing, dose, gender, what definition of spanking is used, etc. Local skirmishes about this will continue.

I was spanked by my parents a handful of times and, particularly as I grew older, on those rare occasions I thought I deserved it. In general my parents believed that striking a child, whatever you called it, at the very best served to extinguish an immediate behavior and did nothing to inculcate the preferred behavior. More frequently the methods of discipline they used were ostracization (which suited me fine after about age 12) or serious talks expressing hurt and disappointment.

My wife tells me that her parents didn’t spank her, not for lack of occasion or inclination but because she bruised so easily.

I gather that my parents were exceptional relative to their peers but I have little basis for knowing the norm. I suspect it varies by region, ethnic background, and family culture. Is Dr. Shpancer’s anecdote typical or merely typical for the students at Otterbein University?

9 comments

Nota Bene

Please keep in mind that it is quite possible for the FBI to have interceded improperly or illegally on behalf of Hillary Clinton, have sought a FISA warrant to investigate a Trump campaign worker improperly or illegally, for the Trump campaign to have “colluded” with the Russians whatever that means, for the Russians to have interfered in U. S. elections, for the Mueller investigation to have known that the justification for its activities were on shaky or even fraudulent grounds, and for Donald Trump to have obstructed justice all at the same time. None of them justifies any of the others.

Neither two wrongs nor ten wrongs make a right.

5 comments

Nothing Up My Sleeve

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are kvetching about Illinois again:

At the request of state retirees, a University of Illinois math professor performed a crack analysis showing how the state could use interest-rate arbitrage to shave its pension costs. Under the professor’s math, the state could sell 27-year, fixed-rate taxable bonds and invest the proceeds into its pension funds. This would supposedly stabilize the state’s pension payments at $8.5 billion annually, save taxpayers $103 billion over three decades and increase the state retirement system’s funding level to 90% from 40%. Can the mathemagician make House Speaker Michael Madigan disappear too?

The professor based his analysis on pension obligation bonds issued under former Gov. Rod Blagojevich in 2003 with a 5.05% coupon that have earned on average 7.62% in the pension system. But that period included two bull equity markets, and even the state pension funds project only a 7% long-term return.

Illinois’s borrowing costs have also increased as its credit rating has slipped to a notch above junk from double-A. Last year the state’s taxable bonds due in 2035 traded at yields up to 7.2%. Investors may demand even higher rates because of the substantial interest-rate and credit risk given rising rates and the length of the 27-year bonds.

These magic bonds wouldn’t carry the state’s “full faith and credit” protection, for whatever that’s worth nowadays in Springfield. In effect, public workers’ pensions would be the bond security.

You can’t say it’s not well-deserved. It’s the assumptions, stupid. Illinois’s pension plans are founded on bad assumptions. For example, they assume 7% returns and in the recent past have assumed as high as 8%. They also assume a state with a growing tax base instead of, well, what Illinois has become.

The editors are right. This is sleight of hand, intended to shift the risk incurred by Illinois’s politicians mishandling of public employee pensions from public workers and retirees not to mention politicians to taxpayers and investors. Will the investors bite?

4 comments

Samuelson’s Plan

In his Washington Post column Robert Samuelson presents his plan for reforming immigration law:

Most of the “dreamers” would receive legal status, as would many other undocumented residents who had led law-abiding lives. In return, there would be tougher border security (including a “wall” or its equivalent) and a requirement that most employers check immigration status through an electronic network (such as E-Verify). These steps would dramatically reduce the number of undocumented immigrants.

As for legal immigration, there would be a ceiling of about 1 million annually, which until recently was roughly the level of admissions. But there would be a fundamental change in the criteria for legal immigration, from family connections to workplace skills. The better- educated immigrants are, the easier for them to adapt to a new society.

which, as you may notice, is pretty compatible with what I’ve been saying on the subject except that I’d also create a guest worker program for Mexican workers to allow significantly more Mexican workers to come into the United States on a regular basis than the obviously inadequate 10,000 work visas per year for which Mexicans are eligible.

He goes on to give his reasons which are that present law increases poverty in the U. S., it promotes lawlessness and repression, and that skilled immigrants are good for the economy. We’re in agreement there, too. But here’s

Third, skilled immigrants are good for the economy. True, they can’t single-handedly boost annual economic growth to 3 or 4 percent from the 2 percent-plus of recent years. But every little bit helps. One area where immigrants shine is entrepreneurship. In a study of new firms, the husband-wife team of economists William Kerr of Harvard University and Sari Pekkala Kerr of Wellesley College found that about one-quarter of company founders were immigrants.

There are several problems with that last statistic. It combines legal and illegal immigrants and it doesn’t tell us anything about the rate of founding of successful companies among immigrants. The overall level of entrepeneurship suggested is comparable to that among the native born.

He also omits my main criticism of present law: it injures the most vulnerable Americans to benefit the prosperous which I find unconscionable.

2 comments