China’s Steel

I’m really full of questions today. For example, this article at Bloomberg, basically an editorial against imposing duties on steel imported from China masquerading as a news article, fails to take something fundamental into account: nearly all of China’s steel is produced by state-owned companies.

Should we be importing steel from anybody’s state-owned companies? Should we be importing steel from Chinese state-owned companies? Which is freer? Imposing tariffs on subsidized imported steel or not imposing them? Can trade in state-owned and subsidized products be meaningfully described as “free trade”, particularly when the state is a monetary sovereign?

3 comments

Do We Need an FBI?

The news about the FBI’s having dropped the ball on the shooter in the Parkland massacre is one more bit of evidence that has emerged, not just recently but over the period of the last 20 years which, when considered in aggregate, suggest that the Federal Bureau of Investigation has organizational problems. Have we reached a point at which the FBI is chronically unable to execute its mission?

I don’t mean an end to federal law enforcement ability. Every federal agency now has its own enforcement wings. For goodness sake, there are presently at least 271 distinct tactical response (SWAT) teams in the federal government and most of them don’t fall under the FBI. Their use has doubled over the period of the last 15 years. The National Institutes of Health has a SWAT team.

So, here are my questions. Do we need an FBI? Is the FBI really dropping the ball a lot or does it just look that way because those are stories that receive attention? Should there be distinct armed enforcement arms for every government agency? Does the FBI need a change in focus?

14 comments

Question

Did the election of Donald Trump to the presidency foment the greatest crisis in American political history? Discuss.

15 comments

The Size of Texas

One of the things I got out of this report (PDF) from Strata on land usage for various energy sources was that for the U. S. to get all of its energy from solar power would require an area roughly the size of Texas be devoted to the purpose. Wind power would require nearly twice as much or about half the state of Alaska.

8 comments

The End of the Affair

At Breaking Defense James Kitfield posts a summary of developments in Turkey over the period of the last 15 years. Here’s the one sentence summary: Turkey isn’t our ally any more.

I would add one bit of analysis: the countries with a Muslim majority’s propensity to anything resembling liberal democracy is directly proportional to their distance from the Arab countries of the Gulf, distance measured either in miles or dollars.

0 comments

‘Splain Me

As you’ve probably heard, a number of Russians have been indicted on a variety of charges relating to the 2016 election. Included in the announcement was a statement to the effect that no evidence has been found of Americans knowingly working with them in their activities.

The interpretations of this are now flying fast and thick with Trump supporters saying it’s a complete exoneration and Trump opponents saying it puts the lie to Trump’s denials of Russian interference in the election.

I continue to be satisfied to allow the Mueller investigation to work its way through. I should also emphasize that I do not recall ever denying that the Russians interfered or attempted to interfere in our elections just as we interfere or attempt to interfere in theirs and in elections of many other countries. I have said that I don’t believe that Russian hacking resulted in any fraudulent reporting of votes.

How should I interpret the most recent news on this subject?

13 comments

Dial It Down

In their editorial on the Parkland mass shooting the editors of the Wall Street Journal contrast three different views:

All these events have two things in common: guns and mental illness. From that fact flows the demand, every time, that we “do something.” Saying it, however, is not the same as doing something that would in fact mitigate this recurrent carnage. Doing something in our system inevitably means putting in motion an array of actors toward this goal—elected or appointed public officials, the police, the medical community and not least parents.

Guns first. When a Parkland happens, the liberal half of America’s politics puts forth the same two-word solution: gun control. There is a simple causality to this argument—fewer guns, fewer murders. Always left out is evidence it would work.

Gun-control laws—for example, to regulate bump stocks, AR-15s or ammunition magazines—foundered because advocates have never offered credible evidence they would deter mass shootings. Because gun proponents believe, not without reason, that the left’s ultimate goal is confiscation, the political prospects for a gun control solution have been and will remain about zero.

with

Unlike gun control, medicine has ample evidence that appropriate medication or treatment can stabilize the violently mentally ill. The National Institute of Mental Health collects data on evidence-based approaches involving drugs, intense psychiatric treatment and intervention.

The argument here involves questions over what levels of therapeutic coercion should be permitted. For example, should courts be able to require the severely mentally ill to take treatment to avoid commitment to a hospital? With appropriate legal protections, we think the answer is yes. Advocates for this idea often include the patients’ distraught families.

For years, though, some mental-health activists and lawyers, with allies inside the federal bureaucracies, have fought the idea of involuntary institutionalization for violent patients who refuse treatment. Their approach clearly isn’t working. Treatment requirements, by the way, don’t need a federal law. States can enact civil-commitment laws if they wish.

and

There is one other possibility, suggested by President Trump in his Parkland statement Thursday: “Create a culture in our country that embraces the dignity of life.” The thought sounds self-evident. But on the available evidence, the idea of dignity in life looks more than ever to be in need of restoration.

Let me propose one additional idea: dial it down. Stop cranking the outrage to 11. Politics is not war. People with whom you disagree politically are not the enemy. When you raise the temperature high enough, it’s inevitable that some unbalanced individuals reach the boiling point and in a country of nearly 330 million people there are bound to be a certain number of unbalanced individuals.

5 comments

Divisions

Barton Swaim’s review of two books on the collapse of the postwar American political consensus at the Wall Street Journal prompted a number of thoughts on my part. Rather than quoting the article in full, something I’d need to do to share it with you because it’s behind the WSJ’s paywall, I’ll quote a few select passages. First, the opening:

In general, the right has worried more about the demolition of America’s postwar cultural consensus than the left. Some of the most penetrating books by conservative authors in recent years explain and lament the origins of America’s unraveling common culture— Charles Murray’s “Coming Apart” (2012), James Piereson’s “Shattered Consensus” (2015), Yuval Levin’s “Fractured Republic” (2016). Until very recently, liberals placed far more value on individual expressions of belief and identity than conservatives did. The rise of Donald Trump, though, seems to have given liberals a new appreciation for the virtues of that old commonality.

Neither Sam Rosenfeld, a professor of politics at Colgate, nor Amy Chua, a law professor at Yale, write as partisan or doctrinaire liberals, but both can fairly be said to represent the elite liberal worldview of early-21st-century America.

Is it true that “the right” has been more concerned about the collapse in political and cultural consensus than “the left”? Or have they been taking turns? I seem to recall a number of books and articles from the 1960s and 1970s from liberals on precisely that subject, particularly those written by Pat Moynihan. Has he forgotten What’s the Matter With Kansas? Additionally, the theme is certainly one aspect of books like Stephen Birmingham’s “Our Crowd”.

Then in his discussion of Ms. Chua’s book:

An impressive number of behavioral studies suggests that very young children instinctively trust and sympathize with people who look and act as they do, she notes, and this tendency manifests itself long before they’ve been “conditioned” by society. “Humans aren’t just a little tribal,” Ms. Chua concludes. “We’re very tribal, and it distorts the way we think and feel.”

other loyalties may be formed later in life but the notion those innate predispositions can be completely sublimated is an error.

Finally, the review’s conclusion:

Ms. Chua is certainly correct that our political travails are culturally generated, not the work of partisan manipulators in the political arena. But her insights about tribal loyalties are also, as conservative readers will instantly note, not quite as original as she suggests. Edmund Burke famously held that man learns to love mankind by first loving the “little platoon” he belongs to, and conservatives have long faulted radicals of various kinds for fixating on universal values and spurning local and familial allegiances. Even so, Ms. Chua has written a brisk and readable polemic in defense of common sense and deserves credit for insisting, pace her friends and colleagues, that tribal loyalties are vastly more powerful and complicated than today’s elites profess to believe.

Now my observations. These are more or less disjointed.

What role did the military draft play in producing political and social consensus? From 1942 to the mid 1960s the military draft was practically universal for men. During the 60s the number of student and other deferments rose dramatically. The draft, consequently, was less egalitarian than it had been. The shared experience must have had some results. I think it affected politics, businesses, and society at large.

Since the founding of the Republic our political parties have been what is known in the political science literature as “catch-all parties”. For some time both the Democratic and Republican Parties have been struggling to become what is known as the literature as “programmatic parties”. Complaints about the “Blue Dog” Democrats or RINOs are parts of that struggle. To my eye the Republicans have had more success. The Democrats are impeded in their efforts by the nature of the Democratic coalition. Additionally, there is the problem that programmatic parties are not well-suited to our form of government.

The notion that there are consensus within the political parties is an illusion albeit one held closely by coastal progressives and Southern conservatives. I attribute the belief to some combination of insularity and wishful thinking. So, for example, the Democrats are presently less than 50% progressives, about a third moderates, and about 10% conservatives. The illusion is fostered by a political class among whom there is consensus to a great degree.

I think the historic consensus is somewhat overstated, an idea one arrives at by ignoring racial, religious, class, and geographic differences. We’re more aware of our underlying differences now.

2 comments

Commonsense About Gun Reform

I own only two firearms, both long guns and neither of which have been discharged in living memory. One is the rifle that my great-great-grandfather bore during the Civil War. The other is a shotgun my father received as a kid from his grandfather. I’m a sentimentalist and family history buff but not a gun nut. I do know how to shoot. There was a firing range in my high school’s basement. You could barely attend the school, at the time the best high school in the St. Louis metropolitan area, without knowing how to shoot.

Every time some mentally ill or morally depraved young adult goes on a shooting rampage in a school or church there’s understandable grief and rage, nearly always accompanied by anger that we haven’t enacted the “sensible laws” that would have prevented these incidents. The nature of these laws is generally left vague. Blame is levied at the National Rifle Association and the “gun culture”.

The NRA is without question a populist movement. It has a very large membership and to the best of my knowledge none of the horrors have been perpetrated by NRA members. Its political contributions are far lower than those by medical doctors, educators, realtors, or public employees’ unions. Its power comes from the interests and votes of its membership as well as some skillful and focused lobbying.

I’m on record as being in support of gun laws that ban the personal ownership of firearms including a house-to-house search on the single condition that the police be disarmed at the same time. Admittedly, that’s not a “sensible” strategy; it’s extreme. I’d also support less strenuous measures like bans on large-capacity magazines. But I’m confused.

What are these sensible, obvious laws? I suspect that none of them would be effective in doing much other than preventing peaceful, law-abiding gun owners from owning guns and would do little to end the sorts of tragedies they’re purported to address.

Let’s have a national dialogue. Sadly, these days “dialogue” has become an auto-antonym. It now means “lecture” as well as conversation. In this case I mean a conversation. What sensible, obvious laws would prevent school shootings? What would it cost to implement and enforce them? Would they eliminate these shootings or just ensure that they were committed using illegally obtained or modified firearms?

To place all of this in a little perspective, last year twice as many Chicagoans were killed with firearms than the total number of people killed in school shootings. Many if not most of these Chicagoans were in the same age demographic as those killed in school shootings. Nearly all were killed using illegal firearms.

Note that there’s a racial component to this sad issue. Nearly all of the perpetrators of mass shootings and their victims are white; nearly all of the shootings of young people in large cities like Chicago, Baltimore, St. Louis, or Detroit have both perpetrators and victims who are black.

21 comments

Monopolies and the Ultra-Rich

Another article you might find interesting is David Dayen’s at The Nation on how Warren Buffett has parleyed monopoly companies into an enormous fortune.

A key problem is that the federal government as a matter of policy has just abandoned the elimination of monopoly power. Generally speaking, monopolies aren’t illegal but using monopoly power to gain dominance in areas outside your monopoly is. A key barrier in the enforcement of monopoly law is that frequently monopolies don’t hurt consumers but their business competitors.

And natural monopolies are actually pretty rare. Far more of them are created through various government fiats than by nature.

2 comments