Coming Together

In his latest New York Times column David Brooks proposes a model for unifying a United States that centrifugal force seems to be driving apart:

Last week I went to Houston to see the rodeo. That rodeo is not like other rodeos. It’s gigantic. It goes for 20 days. There can be up to 185,000 people on the grounds in a single day and they are of all human types — rural ranchers, Latino families, African immigrants, drunken suburban housewives out for a night on the town.

When you are lost in that sea of varied humanity, you think: What on earth holds this nation together? The answer can be only this: Despite our differences, we devote our lives to the same experiment, the American experiment to draw people from around the world and to create the best society ever, to serve as a model for all humankind.

Unity can come only from a common dedication to this experiment. The American consciousness can be formed only by the lab reports we give one another about that experiment — the jeremiads, speeches, songs and conversations that describe what the experiment is for, where it has failed and how it should proceed now.

One of my favorites of these lab reports is Walt Whitman’s essay “Democratic Vistas,” published in 1871. The purpose of democracy, Whitman wrote, is not wealth, or even equality; it is the full flowering of individuals. By dispersing responsibility to all adults, democracy “supplies a training school for making first class men.” It is “life’s gymnasium.” It forges “freedom’s athletes” — strong and equal women, courageous men, deep-souled people capable of governing themselves.

I honestly do not see how you can read “Democratic Vistas” and take from it the message Mr. Brooks is trying to beat into it. Here’s its kernel, not the fragments quoted by Mr. Brooks:

Did you, too, O friend, suppose democracy was only for elections, for politics, and for a party name? I say democracy is only of use there that it may pass on and come to its flower and fruits in manners, in the highest forms of interaction between men, and their beliefs — in religion, literature, colleges, and schools — democracy in all public and private life, and in the army and navy.* I have intimated that, as a paramount scheme, it has yet few or no full realizers and believers. I do not see, either, that it owes any serious thanks to noted propagandists or champions, or has been essentially help’d, though often harm’d, by them. It has been and is carried on by all the moral forces, and by trade, finance, machinery, intercommunications, and, in fact, by all the developments of history, and can no more be stopp’d than the tides, or the earth in its orbit. Doubtless, also, it resides, crude and latent, well down in the hearts of the fair average of the American-born people, mainly in the agricultural regions. But it is not yet, there or anywhere, the fully-receiv’d, the fervid, the absolute faith.

or, in other words, Whitman is calling for a flourishing of high culture. Note, too, that Whitman sees “the basket of deplorables” as the seed from which the America he envisions will grow rather than the bustling urban culture. When you look around you is that what you see? Or do you see a fervid overgrown jungle of popular and commercial culture, ephemeral, soon to be forgotten? That’s a basis for fragmentation into physical or virtual tribes not for national unity.

Returning to a common theme here, the only possible basis for national unity is a common commitment to the themes of our national holy scriptures—the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, Lincoln’s Second Inaugural, and a few others. In them you may search but will fail to find a call for self-realization, freedom from having your beliefs challenged, or the provision for every want but those are today’s rallying cries.

2 comments

Illinois’s Primaries

ABC News remarks on Illinois’s 2018 primary elections:

With over $160 million spent by candidates on both sides, the Illinois gubernatorial race has the potential to be the most expensive in American history, and with two ultra-wealthy businessmen expected to capture nominations Tuesday night, the heavy spending seems poised to continue.

There is no more vulnerable incumbent Republican governor in the country than Bruce Rauner. While he was able to buck Illinois’ consistent blue tint and unseat a sitting governor in 2014, Rauner faces an uphill race for re-election in 2018 in what could be the most expensive gubernatorial race in U.S. history.

Buoyed by the eye-popping $57.2 million of his own money that he gave his re-election campaign, Rauner is hoping to stave off a pack of eager Democrats eyeing the governor’s mansion in the nation’s sixth most populous state.

State Rep. Jeanne Ives is mounting a primary challenge to Rauner from the right, and just last week national Democrats tried to put their thumb on the scales. The Democratic Governors Association rolled out two television ads, one focusing on Rauner’s record on jobs and the budget and the other painting Ives as “too conservative” for Illinois in an attempt to boost Ives and energize the state’s more conservative voters against Rauner.

Just last week Rauner vetoed a gun control bill that passed the state legislature, a sign that he may be worried Ives could outflank him from the right on Tuesday.

On the Democratic side, J.B. Pritzker, the heir to the Hyatt Hotel fortune, is leading the pack for the nomination but is tangled in an expensive primary against State Sen. Daniel Biss and Chris Kennedy, the son of former Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy. According to campaign finance records, Pritzker has spent close to $70 million so far in his bid to unseat Rauner but has been dogged by his connections to former Democratic Governor and convicted felon Rod Blagojevich. Rauner has run an ad featuring a recording of Pritzker speaking to then-Gov. Rod Blagojevich in 2008 about who would replace then Illinois Senate and future President Barack Obama.

Much of the article is devoted to the race to determine who will be the Democratic candidate for the House seat for the Illinois 3rd District, a race I’ve commented on here. Today’s election will determine whether incumbent Dan Lipinski is out of touch with the district or national Democrats are. The winner of the Democratic primary will in all likelihood win the general election. At least I hope he or she will. The sole Republican candidate is by all accounts a neo-Nazi crank, an illustration of just how foolish and supine the Illinois Republican Party is.

0 comments

The Next to Last Phase

Yesterday afternoon my wife and I visited a friend on her deathbed, someone I’ve known for thirty years. We had been informed a day or two earlier that her health had taken a turn for the worse. We reached out to her daughter for up-to-date information and realized that she didn’t have long to live. We wasted no time and went to visit her yesterday.

She was a wreck. She was spending her last days in her daughter’s home. She was bedridden, pale, wasted, neither eating nor drinking, drifting in and out of consciousness. My wife made bright smalltalk, showing her pictures of dogs, a common interest. I stood quietly by her bedside, holding her hand. I would be very much surprised if she lives more than a day or so.

Life passes through phases. You learn to walk and talk. You attend children’s birthday parties. You graduate from high school, maybe college. You attend friends’ weddings, then the births of their children.

I have entered the phase of life at which, when friends gather, they talk about their illnesses and you attend friends’ funerals. It is the next to last phase.

1 comment

Unions vs. RTW

At RealClearPolicy Christos Makridis articulates the case for “right to work” laws:

I found that adoption of adoption of right to work laws is associated with increases in both life satisfaction and economic sentiment. In fact, the increase in life satisfaction is 14.2 percent of that experienced with the attainment of a college degree — remarkable given that college attainment is associated with a wide array of other benefits, like higher earnings potential.

Playing devil’s advocate, isn’t it possible that union dues prevent things from getting worse for unionized workers? Or that there are other unrelated factors that produce the “increases in both life satisfaction and economic sentiment”?

At any rate I think that evidence and reasoned consideration are preferable to threats of violence so you might want to take a look at the piece. I should add that I wish that unions would focus more on working conditions than on wages.

2 comments

Why Do They Hate American Workers?

In their latest editorial the editors of the Washington Post call, as they have for years, for increased immigration:

The Census Bureau’s latest report on the state of the U.S. population reminds us of this in dramatic fashion. “The year 2030 marks a demographic turning point for the United States,” the report notes. “Beginning that year, all baby boomers will be older than 65.” That is, 21 percent of the entire population will be on Medicare, Social Security or, in most cases, both. Just five years thereafter, in 2035, the number of 65-and-overs will surpass the number of Americans under 18 for the first time in the nation’s history.

In short, the dependency ratio — the percentage of non-working members of society who depend on the working members — is rapidly growing and will exceed 70 percent from 2030 on. Unlike in the last period in which the ratio was that high, 1960 to 1980, however, the majority of dependents will be elderly adults, not children. The Census Bureau doesn’t say so, but we couldn’t help noticing that the onset of these all-but-inevitable developments coincides with two other events that the Social Security and Medicare trustees recently forecast: the exhaustion of the Medicare trust fund in 2029 and the insolvency of the Social Security trust fund in 2034.

[…]

Without immigration, U.S. birthrates will not be sufficient to avoid even more rapid aging of the population and an even higher dependency ratio than the ones the Census Bureau forecasts. Meanwhile, Mr. Trump campaigned on a promise not to touch Social Security and Medicare, and without presidential leadership, not even a Republican Congress is likely to move on that issue.

The evidence that we have the problems of which the editors warn now is meager to non-existent. Very slow wage growth suggests that supply and demand in labor, other than in certain very narrow specialties, are in rough equilibrium. Increasing the number of legal immigrants now would have the effect of depressing wage growth for today’s workers, a consummation devoutly to be wished by American employers who’d just as soon pay less for the work they’re receiving.

As to how to ensure that there are enough American workers twenty years hence, there are ways of accomplishing that using tools that you probably have around the house. What we actually need are psychological, social, and economic incentives for people having larger families. The most important of these is hope.

3 comments

Breaking News from 2015

At USA Today Christian Schneider offers a column, “Democrats, it’s time for you to dump Hillary Clinton”. That’s timely advice for 2015. The 2016 presidential election pitted two candidates, each with the highest negatives in history, against one another. A better Democratic candidate, of whom there were many from which to select, could have made the difference. Here’s his analysis of Ms. Clinton’s latest jibes against a major segment of the American people:

At a recent conference in Mumbai, India, Clinton further cast aside her presidential façade and told the world what she really thought of “middle America.” She boasted that she had won “the places that are optimistic, diverse, dynamic,” and “moving-forward,” and noted she did best in “places that represent two-thirds of America’s gross domestic product.”

She suggested President Donald Trump’s appeal was mostly to white men who “didn’t like black people getting rights,” who disapproved of “women getting jobs,” and who begrudged Indian-Americans for their success. As a final ingredient to her toxic bouillabaisse, Clinton added that white women often voted for Trump because of “ongoing pressure to vote the way that your husband, your boss, your son, whoever, believes you should.”

If there were a Hall of Fame for irony, Clinton would have it named after her. In accusing weak-minded white women of blindly voting the way men told them to, she was proving exactly why white women were wise not to vote for her. It is a significant reason she has now had to play the role of failed presidential candidate twice.

I hope that people have the wit to recognize that “Hillary Clinton” is a synecdoche for the entire corrupt web of faux technocrats who, by virtue of their notional credentials, are cross-ruffing government and the private sector, particularly the financial sector, into wealth and power for themselves and ruin for the rest of us.

Judging by the incessant robo-calls I’m receiving in anticipation of the Illinois primary elections tomorrow, they don’t. The leading candidates for practically all races are those who represent that very group.

0 comments

Exchange in a Checkout Line

As I was in the checkout line picking up an item at my nearby Whole Foods store I had this exchange with the young woman who was the cashier while listening to the music on the PA:

Me: Interesting choice of workplace music.

She: I like it. It’s got a good, lively beat.

Me (singing): “I don’t wanna work, I just want to bang on the drums all day.”

She: Are those the words? Even better!

1 comment

Constitutionally Incapable

I missed this when it was first issued two weeks ago but it’s of sufficient importance that I think it bears highlighting. A technology audit by the Office of the Inspector General of the computer and software systems operated by the Department of Homeland Security found them woefully inadequate. From the report:

Specifically, since the Department’s inception in 2003, components have not effectively managed and secured their information systems. Components have continued to operate systems without ATOs [ed. Authority to Operate], used unsupported operating systems that expose DHS data to unnecessary risks, ineffectively managed the POA&M [ed. plan of action and milestones] to mitigate identified security weaknesses, and failed to apply security patches timely. Such repeated deficiencies are contrary to the President’s Cybersecurity Executive Order and clear indicators that departmental oversight of the enterprise-wide information security program needs to be strengthened. Until DHS overcomes challenges to addressing its systemic information security weaknesses, it will remain unable to ensure that its information systems adequately protect the sensitive data they store and process.

Translation: the department responsible for the country’s security is unwilling or unable to look after its own. This is not insignificant and IMO the federal government is incapable as structured to maintain adequate levels of cybersecurity. Funding mechanisms and levels are inadequate to enable departments to upgrade their systems on a timely basis or maintain them to bring them up to an adequate level of security. There are far too many homegrown experts and when outside resources are used there is insufficient ability or willingness to give them sufficient oversight.

The IG made five recommendations:

Recommendation #1: Pursue with the Under Secretary for Management alternate strategies for ensuring that components accomplish planned actions to address deficiencies in areas such as security authorization, weakness remediation, and continuous monitoring that have consistently lagged behind in key performance metrics on the monthly information
scorecard.

Recommendation #2: Enforce the requirements for components to obtain authority to operate, test contingency plans, and apply sufficient resources to mitigate security weakness for national security systems according to applicable policies.

Recommendation #3: Revise the information systems continuous monitoring strategy to include an up-to-date inventory of software assets and licenses used within the Department.

Recommendation #4: Implement controls and perform quality reviews to validate that information security data input to DHS’ enterprise management systems is complete and accurate.

Recommendation #5: Expedite the process for discontinuing the use of unsupported operating systems within the Department.

These are incredibly basic. Taken severally or corporately they do not constitute a plan for securing DHS. They’re recommendations that DHS formulate a plan. A decade from now some future IG audit will find the same deficiencies in the systems that replace the systems presently in use.

IMO there are only two courses of action that would render DHS secure. They could decomputerize; the present DHS is incapable of maintaining the pace and accountability required to maintain a proper level of security. That would be met with enormous resistance, not just from the DHS itself but from Congress and the electorate.

Alternatively, they could decentralize, increasing the number of targets while decreasing the target size, and diversify their information technology ecosystem. That would meet an even greater level of resistance and would be very expensive in dollars, time, and management attention.

What will actually happen is that very little will change and DHS will remain insecure. Make your plans accordingly.

Keep in mind that the Pentagon can’t keep itself secure and the military has the ability to order its personnel to do things and throw them in jail if they don’t comply, an alternative not available to the civilian branches.

5 comments

Futile Gestures

There’s a manifesto of sorts from an organization called the “Information Technology & Innovation Foundation” intended to allow the U. S. to address Chinese “innovation mercantilism”. In my opinion even if all of its prescriptions were adopted in toto they would have little effect on what is an actual problem.

I only have two remarks. First, Chinese “innovation mercantilism” is not new. Informed individuals were aware of it decades ago. When the company for which I worked wanted me to go to China as the chief technical officer of their forming operations there, as I turned them down I made them aware of three things, each of which seemed to come as a bolt from the blue:

  • They would be required to take a Chinese partner.
  • The Chinese wanted to and would raid their technology.
  • Since the Chinese currency was not convertible they would never be able to get their money out of the country.

Second, there are a number of ways we could respond to Chinese mercantilism. We could just tolerate it as our economy is hollowed out, one sector at a time. That is by far the most likely. We could stop trading with China. That could be accomplished in a variety of ways, the easiest being to impose tariffs that would make goods manufactured in China uncompetitive.

If we were really sincere about the idea of “intellectual property”, we would reciprocate for Chinese non-enforcement of theft of American intellectual property by China by not enforcing the taking of Chinese real property by Americans. Just a thought. Some 15 years ago when U. S. trade with China was significantly smaller than it is now, the value of Chinese appropriation of American intellectual property was thought to be roughly equivalent to our trade deficit with China.

1 comment

Blogiversary

As of last Thursday I had been operating The Glittering Eye for 14 years. I’ve outlived dozens of the blogs I read when I started; a number of the bloggers of 14 years ago are now writing columns for newspapers. Some have moved from blog to column and back to blog (or even tweet!) again. The Glittering Eye is and will remain completely non-commercial; I accept no advertising and support it completely from my own purse.

I plan to continue blogging as long as I have the energy to do so.

On the occasion of the 12th anniversary I collected a number of links to old posts of mine I liked and if you’re interested you can find them here.

7 comments