Fiat Currencies vs. Trade

In his Wall Street Journal op-ed Sean Rushton makes a very important point about our trade deficit:

The U.S. dollar’s status as the global reserve currency is at least as responsible as any free-trade agreement or unfair practices. High demand for dollars has tilted the playing field against American exporters and workers.

but I’m skeptical of the solutions that he proposes:

First, to guide monetary policy, Federal Reserve appointees should commit to targeting the real-time prices of an index of commodities, plus foreign currencies and bonds. Such an approach would have prevented the Fed’s biggest recent errors. Easy money in the 1970s and 2000s led to large increases in world dollar holdings, price bubbles and crashes.

Second, the U.S. should invite other major currencies—starting with the second-largest, the euro—to stay steady with the dollar. A dollar-euro stability pact, later including Japan and other democracies, would stabilize demand for dollars. A recent International Monetary Fund communiqué expressed positive sentiments on this front: “We recognize that excessive volatility or disorderly movements in exchange rates can have adverse implications for economic and financial stability. We will refrain from competitive devaluations, and will not target our exchange rates for competitive purposes.”

Third and most controversial, the U.S. and other leading economies should establish a new international currency for pricing global commodities and settling trade accounts. Nations would keep their own currencies for domestic use, exchanging them for the international currency at fixed rates.

most importantly because the Congress considers their ability to spend more than we’re willing to pay for via the willingness of other countries to hold our bonds a feature rather than a bug. They would be very reluctant to relinquish the power it gives them.

My specific observations about the piece are:

  1. I wish he presented much more quantitative evidence than he does. I’m a quantitative kind of guy.
  2. He fails to note that Japan, South Korea, and China are all holding dollar reserves much higher than those determined by the IMF and higher than they’ve agreed to. If they don’t follow the international accords to which they are signatory now, why will they if his reforms are adopted?
  3. It’s high time the Fed and other central banks started using more modern tools. Spoiler alert: they will be reluctant because it will reduce their governors’ power.
  4. The gotcha in his third proposal are two words: fixed rates. What process would be used to set them and for how long? It sounds to me as though the arbitrage would vitiate the effectiveness of his reform.

but most importantly he fails to consider other alternatives. We don’t need Germany, Japan, or China’s permission to make their policy of running a permanent trade deficit with us impossible.

However, the critical point is that he teeters on the brink of an important realization but fails to embrace it fully. International trade really needs to be reconsidered in the context of a fiat currency. Many of the assumptions made about trade don’t really hold when everybody has their own fiat currencies.

1 comment

Don’t Stop With Gerrymanders

While the United States Supreme Court struggles over the issue of gerrymanders, a corrupt practice which I agree is undemocratic and harmful, let’s not forget the other electoral reform we need. The House of Representatives is far too small. In the past I have documented that the United States has far fewer representatives per capita than the United Kingdom, Germany, France, or other representative democracies.

Seats in the House floated with the population until the Apportionment Act of 1911 when they were fixed at 435. Present law means that the number of persons represented by one Congressional representative now exceeds 750,000, clearly far too many. If each representative represented 100,000 people, much closer to the average among OECD countries, we would have about 3,300 representatives.

It’s high time we start contending with the problems of a country as large as the United States rather than pretending we’re the size of France. A House of Representatives with a capped membership is as undemocratic and corrupt as gerrymandering if not more so.

14 comments

The Census

In the wake of the announcement that the Census Bureau would start asking a question about citizenship on the form used for the decennial census, an enormous amount of claptrap has been written about the census. The State of California is presently suing the federal government over it.

Here’s what the Constitution says about the census in Article I, Section 2:

Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons. The actual Enumeration shall be made within three Years after the first Meeting of the Congress of the United States, and within every subsequent Term of ten Years, in such Manner as they shall by Law direct. The Number of Representatives shall not exceed one for every thirty Thousand, but each State shall have at Least one Representative; and until such enumeration shall be made, the State of New Hampshire shall be entitled to choose three, Massachusetts eight, Rhode-Island and Providence Plantations one, Connecticut five, New-York six, New Jersey four, Pennsylvania eight, Delaware one, Maryland six, Virginia ten, North Carolina five, South Carolina five, and Georgia three.

What did the Framers mean by “enumeration”? Judging by the use of the word in the Constitution, Federalist, and other contemporaneous writings it meant a definition, a specification. Enumeration was distinguished from implied.

The first census, the Census of 1790, included by household the names of the heads of households, the number of free white males of age 16 or older in the household, the number of free white females of age 16, the number of other free persons, and the number of slaves. That was it.

The second census, the Census of 1800, further subdivided that into age groups. Various subsequent censuses have added other information including occupation, country of origin, etc.

George Washington, president at the time of the first census, thought it undercounted the population as did Thomas Jefferson, his Secretary of State. No adjustments were made to the census to correct that. It was an enumeration not an estimate.

To be strictly constitutional no other information other than the number of free and slave individuals in a household should be asked but additional information has been asked since the very first census. Decisions on what would be asked in the census have not been made by the Congress but by the Census Bureau itself. I think these deviations from the strict language of the Constitution are better characterized as extra-constitutional rather than unconstitutional.

Now consider two questions. First, do questions about citizenship on the census serve any significant legitimate government interest? Second, are estimates of population constitutional or unconstitutional?

10 comments

Klein vs. Harris

You might be amused at this email correspondence between blogger Ezra Klein and podcaster Sam Harris, published as a last futile act of defiance by Harris in the name of setting the record straight. Is it possible that Harris not know what a troll is?

4 comments

Irony Alert

Rather than getting into the weeds of Steve Rattner’s New York Times op-ed on how much simpler it would be if we operated like China, I would only say that we can’t control China’s behavior but we can control our own. We might think about that when reflecting on how to deal with whatever threat China poses to us. In other words I agree with Walt Kelly: we have met the enemy and he is us.

Meanwhile, discuss the irony in this sentence from the op-ed:

As a capitalist, I’ve never believed in excessive government intervention in the economy.

Maybe I should have titled this post “No True Scotsman Alert”.

3 comments

Why Is It Controversial?

In her op-ed in the Wall Street Journal Wendy Wang writes:

Brookings scholars Ron Haskins and Isabel Sawhill call it the “success sequence”: getting at least a high-school diploma, working, and then marrying before having children—again, in that order. But the message isn’t much discussed on this side of the Pacific—and when it is, it’s controversial. Liberals often dismiss it as a right-wing notion. They shouldn’t. Following the success sequence is associated with a much lower chance of being poor and much better odds of realizing the American Dream.

Tracking a cohort of young adults from their teenage years to early adulthood in the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, sociologist W. Bradford Wilcox and I recently tested how well the three success sequence “steps” work among the millennial generation. We found that at ages 28 to 34, 53% of millennials who had failed to complete all three steps were poor. The poverty rate dropped to 31% among millennials who completed high school, 16% among those who had a diploma and a full-time job, and 3% for millennials who also put marriage before the baby carriage. Among childless and unmarried millennials 28 to 34 who followed the education and work steps, the poverty rate was 8%.

In regression models that predict the odds of being in poverty after controlling for a range of background factors—including intelligence, childhood family income, race and ethnicity—the probability of ending up poor was reduced by 60% for millennials who married before having children and by about 90% for millennials who followed all steps of the sequence compared with those who missed all three.

Why is the “success sequence” controversial? Because it advises the poor to place limits on their own behavior? Because it means that poor people can make mistakes that blight their entire lives?

Should people be indemnified against the consequences of their own risky behavior? I don’t think we should do that in the case of the rich and I don’t think we can afford to do that in the case of the poor.

We are living in a period, unlike any other in world history, in which a tremendous number of people treat immediate gratification without consequences not merely as expected but as a right. I think that’s the reason that quite a number of people these days characterize themselves as spiritual but not religious. It doesn’t prevent you from acting as you please.

3 comments

Don’t Be Trump

In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal former World Bank president Robert Zoellick helpfully offers President Trump ten tips for negotiating with Kim Jong Un:

1. Identify the outcome Mr. Trump wants to achieve. That may seem simple, but consider the range of possibilities. The U.S. could seek progress toward the peaceful unification of a free Korea. Or it could accept the North Korean regime’s existence if Pyongyang gives up nuclear and other weapons of mass destruction, plus long-range missiles, while promising not to sell its technology. Mr. Trump could focus on North Korea’s threats or behavior—whether toward the U.S., South Korea, the region or the North Korean people. The U.S. could demand that North Korea return people it has abducted from other countries, especially Japan. The bargaining will take sharp twists and turns. Mr. Trump needs to know how he will frame America’s initial demands and what he wants to achieve over different time frames.

2. Assess, coldly and rationally, America’s actual leverage. What pressures and inducements can be brought to bear by the U.S., its allies, China and Russia? Mr. Trump will have to coordinate this leverage, which means the White House must be prepared for varying scenarios. Given the experience of past talks with North Korea, expect extraordinary demands, breakdowns, walkouts and reversals of positions. Getting China and Russia to go along will require Mr. Trump to consider trade-offs.

3. Bolster U.S. relations with South Korea and Japan. These two allies can help the White House achieve a successful negotiation—or deal with failure. (They are also the cornerstone of future U.S. policy toward China.) That means America must win and hold public support in both countries. Threatening to withdraw U.S. troops from South Korea and diminish American trade can hardly help.

4. Decide on the negotiating process. The U.S. could negotiate directly with North Korea. Or it could add South Korea, which would give America’s ally standing and reduce the risk of a split in the alliance. Or the U.S. could revive the six-party talks—including Japan, China and Russia—from previous negotiations. Mr. Trump must decide whether his secretary of state should lead or whether he wants to rely principally on officials a step below. The White House should know whether it wants to use a step-by-step process to turn paper negotiations into realities on the ground. The U.S. should look for ways to make North Korean reversals impossible, or at least difficult and costly.

5. Engage Congress. At a minimum, Mr. Trump needs lawmakers’ support as he embarks on this negotiation. He may even need their votes to approve a treaty or allocate funding.

6. Consider what Mr. Kim may want. The North Korean ruler will get an early bonus just by meeting as an equal with Mr. Trump, which legitimates Mr. Kim’s rule. North Korea will claim it is negotiating in good faith and therefore the U.S. and its allies should ease sanctions, offer piecemeal concessions, and hold off stronger measures. It will present itself as standing for Korean nationalism and South Korea’s leaders as Yankee lackeys. Mr. Kim could reach for unification on Pyongyang’s terms. He could demand a peace treaty to conclude the Korean War and an end to America’s alliance with Seoul. The U.S. should expect, at a minimum, that Mr. Kim will want to keep his nuclear weapons and missiles to deter any threat to his regime.

7. Decide what the U.S. is—and isn’t—willing to trade. Demands are just the start. Pyongyang may press Mr. Trump to concede security guarantees, economic openings, or even assistance from Seoul or others. On the other hand, the U.S. needs to decide whether its alliance with South Korea and the U.S. forces stationed there are nonnegotiable.

8. Decide the minimum the U.S. will be willing to accept from North Korea. Mr. Trump attacks the Iran deal for failing to roll back Tehran’s nuclear program, ignoring its missiles, lifting limits over time, and turning a blind eye toward its other aggressive behavior in the region. If he wants to avoid making a similar deal, the U.S. and its allies should agree on what will prompt them to walk away from North Korea.

9. Be prepared for no agreement. The U.S., South Korea and Japan should have a plan in case the talks fail. Should South Korea maintain its outreach to the North as a way to build confidence and ease tensions? Mr. Trump may prefer to isolate Pyongyang. The U.S. could press for tighter sanctions to choke North Korea or even threaten military action if Mr. Kim crosses “red lines.” If Mr. Kim can divide the U.S. from its partners, he will have achieved a great success.

10. Get Mr. Trump to agree that he won’t wing it. Attending a summit and making news are not the same as getting results. The president’s advisers need to run through this preparatory list—or a better one—with him.

To the best of my ability to determine Mr. Zoellick has never conducted a negotiation with North Korea, successful or otherwise. Consequently, unless you assume that negotiating with North Korea is exactly like negotiating with Germany or China, he has no more authority in his pronouncements on negotiating with Kim Jong Un than I would.

There is ample evidence that conducting negotiations with North Korea is very different than with most other countries. How many countries proclaim their leader as a god? How many other countries have been in a state of war with us for nearly 70 years? Exchanged fire with us on very nearly a weekly basis for much of that time? How many other countries have seized an American vessel on the high seas? Shot down an American military aircraft? How many countries have literally threatened us with nuclear weapons?

What the op-ed clearly demonstrates is that either Mr. Zoellick enjoys tilting at windmills, he doesn’t understand Trump’s transactional approach, or he doesn’t care. He is advising that Trump not be Trump, a futile exercise.

I genuinely don’t know what Mr. Zoellick intends to accomplish by the op-ed or who his intended audience is. It certainly isn’t Trump.

3 comments

The Oldest North African DNA

I found this article at LiveScience, about the results of analyzing the oldest African DNA successfully sequenced to date, very interesting:

Burials from a cave in Morocco have yielded the oldest human DNA evidence yet from Africa, offering new insight into Stone Age migrations.

The DNA samples come from one of the most ancient cemeteries in the world, the Grotte des Pigeons, near the village of Taforalt in northeast Morocco.

Beginning around 15,000 years ago, a culture of hunter-gatherers buried their dead with animal horns and other adornments inside this cave. Though burials were found as recently as 2006, archaeologists have been excavating the cave since the 1940s.

Spoiler alert. 15,000 years ago North Africans were very much as they are now—more similar to people from the Middle East than they are to modern Europeans or sub-Saharan Africans. That’s completely consistent with my views of late prehistory. People spread to most corners of the world a long, long time ago and populations have been established for millennia.

There are exceptions, of course, like the European colonization of the Americas that began in the late 15th century or the migration of South Africa by people whose origins were in the vicinity of Nigeria to Central and finally South Africa beginning in the 12th century. But those are exceptions.

0 comments

When Moore’s Law Fails

Moore’s Law, a rule of thumb about the increase in density of transistors on an integrated circuit over time, prevailed for decades but has now, effectively, come to an end. This article at Small Wars Journal considers strategies by which the military can address the problems produced by the end of Moore’s law:

This paper reviews ways to extend semiconductor technology in the near term, as well as technologies which have been sidelined, but are worth revisiting as a means of sidestepping the limitations of semiconductor technology. Technology recommendations will be put forth as lead, shape, or watch. The Army should lead core technologies when it is imperative and, when only the Army will or can lead, shape other technologies by leveraging industrial and academic work to meet Army specific applications and watch developing technology trends which may impact the Army mission. The following sections expand on technology areas that will have the potential to overcome the end of Moore’s Law.

but it applies to the private sector as well. #1 on the list? Better software. That’s a major problem. Today’s software developers don’t have the skills necessary to produce better software and may not have the ability. The emphasis over the last 30 years has been on portability, speed of development, user interface and the ability to produce software using programmers with lower levels of skill.

0 comments

Reaping the Harvest

I began reading this post at RealClearWorld in the hope of gaining insight into what has happened in Tunisia subsequent to the “Arab Spring” of 2010. In reading it I was struck by how closely the author’s observations apply to the United States, particularly Illinois and Chicago. For example, from the opening:

Disappointment surrounding Tunisia’s democratic transition abounds in the country, and the volatile economy adds a degree of difficulty to politicians’ agendas. Economic development is always a long and arduous process, but the current strategy is clearly inadequate. Tunisians call on the government to do more to pull the economy out of stagnation by increasing public investment, providing jobs, and undertaking infrastructure projects. At the same time, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the European Union (EU) insist the Tunisian government pull back government subsidies and increase taxes. Tunisia must balance the need to provide economic opportunity and governmental services against the demands of the IMF. The solution is not in pursuing economic reforms alone, but also political reforms that supplement and support a healthy economy. Increased transparency, accountability, and good governance are essential in improving the economy and satisfying the population’s desire for jobs, technology, and opportunities.

All of the basic factors are there: phlegmatic growth, popular dissatisfaction, flagging investment, and debt problems. Or this about education

Tunisia must review its current model of development, which has not been adjusted to account for social change since the 1980s. The existing model is based on cheap labor in most sectors, especially in manufactured goods and tourism. Due to demographic changes and headwinds of development in technology, innovation, and education, this approach has proved to be non-commensurate. Skilled jobs were not created at the same pace that the educational system churned out skilled workers. The outdated model of development does not perform to the satisfaction of a large number of citizens, the majority of which are university graduates who find the current job market unsuitable for their level of expertise.

I continue to think that higher education is primarily a con. A clerk’s job that requires a college education is still a clerk’s job. Jobs that need college educations are growing much more slowly than jobs that require college educations. Tunisia’s credit rating is suffering, too:

Since the 2014 presidential and parliamentary elections, the GDP of Tunisia has decreased by twelve percent, dropping from $47.6 billion to its current level of $41.6. At the same time, the debt-to-GDP ratio reached 61 percent in 2016. Moody’s Investor Service recently downgraded Tunisia’s credit rating to levels on par with countries like Nigeria and Cameroon, further deterring creditors from lending to Tunisia.

Corruption and inaction in government are having effects on Tunisians’ confidence in government:

Municipal elections are scheduled for early May, but much of the population has grown apathetic and doubtful that political engagement yields real change. This is especially true among youth. A recent survey conducted by the International Republican Institute (IRI) found that 40 percent of Tunisians reported that they are unlikely to vote in the upcoming municipal election, and “lack of hope” was cited as the largest obstacle to youth participation in politics. However, the same survey found over 50 percent of Tunisians also believe that local and regional councils will improve the economy in regions where they possess the power to decide how money is spent. Tunisians, therefore, believe in the potential of local governance in the case that local authorities are given power that they exercise fairly. Therefore, a potential political reform to fight lack of morale and increase confidence in the government, which will in turn revitalize the economy, is decentralization.

Participation in elections is dwindling here, too.

And, oh yes. Tunisia is experiencing heavy outmigration. So is Illinois and Chicago is the largest city in the U. S. experiencing a net decline in population.

I was born in the United States and have lived here nearly all of my life. When did it become a Third World country?

2 comments