The Times and Journal Respond

In reaction to the missile strikes on Syria by the United States, Britain, and France the editors of the New York Times point out:

Under the United Nations Charter, there are two justifications for using force against another country without its consent: in self-defense and with the United Nations Security Council’s permission. The former does not apply in this case, and the latter would be impossible, given Russia’s veto power in the Council.

Under the Constitution, war powers are divided between Congress and the president. In the view of most legal scholars, America’s founders wanted Congress to decide when to go war, except when the country is under attack. Since World War II, presidents from both parties have pushed the boundaries of executive authority and carried out many military operations without congressional authorizations, as Mr. Trump did last year when he ordered 59 cruise missiles fired against Syrian targets after a sarin gas attack on the rebel-held town of Khan Sheikhoun.

The War Powers Act in 1973 was supposed to allow Congress to reclaim some of its clout, but its record in circumscribing the president’s authority to use military forces in hostilities overseas is mixed. In recent years, executive branch lawyers have concluded that presidents may act unilaterally if they decide that a strike would be in the national interest and that it would fall short of an all-out war involving ground troops. Congress has largely acquiesced.

Two notable exceptions are the Authorizations for the Use of Military Force that were passed in 2001 and 2002 after the Sept. 11 attacks to cover American-led operations in Afghanistan and Iraq, respectively. The 2001 legislation was aimed at Al Qaeda and the Taliban; the 2002 legislation focused on the threat from the Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein.

Since then, President Barack Obama and now Mr. Trump have used those same authorizations at least 37 times to justify attacks on the Islamic State and other militant groups in 14 countries, including Yemen, the Philippines, Kenya, Eritrea and Niger, according to Dan Grazier of the Project on Government Oversight. This has allowed the Republican-led Congress to avoid public debate — and any responsibility for sending American men and women into battle.

This interpretation of the law gives a free hand to the volatile and thoughtless Mr. Trump, which could prove even more dangerous if he were to decide to attack North Korea or Iran.

After a relentless push by Senator Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat, Bob Corker, who is the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and a Tennessee Republican, is soon expected to propose a new authorization to deal with military operations against nonstate actors like ISIS.

But legislation should also set limits on a president’s ability to wage war against states like Syria. Without that, Congress would be once again abdicating its responsibility and ceding broad powers to an impulsive president with dubious judgment.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal caution

The military strike by the U.S., France and the United Kingdom Friday night was a necessary response to what President Trump appropriately called “barbarism” in describing the use of chemical weapons by the Bashar Assad regime in Syria. The question going forward is whether this is another one-time attempt to punish Assad or if it presages a larger strategy to counter the attempt by the Assad-Russia-Iran axis to dominate the Middle East.

“The purpose of our actions tonight is to establish a strong deterrent against the production, spread, and use of chemical weapons. Establishing this deterrent is a vital national security interest of the United States,” President Trump said in a speech to the nation. He’s right, but a one-time strike won’t have the deterrent effect he wants. Assad, and above all his Iranian and Russian patrons, have to know that they will pay a price for supporting Assad’s behavior.

The extent of the punitive action wasn’t clear as we went to press, though it appeared to be more extensive than the strike a year ago that attacked a single Syrian airfield. Mr. Trump said Friday night that the attack last year eliminated 20% of Syria’s air force, but the rest was quickly up and running again.

Mr. Trump made a point Friday of asking Iran and Russia: “What kind of a nation wants to be associated with the mass murder of innocent men, women, and children?“ A good question, but we hope the President doesn’t expect the Kremlin or Tehran to listen based on a one-time missile attack. They have too much invested in Assad to pull back unless they believe they will pay a larger price.

Administration briefers suggested the coalition is prepared for further strikes if need be, and if not Vladimir Putin can rest easy. The Assad axis is counting on the U.S. having limited staying power. The allies will have to be on guard for Mr. Putin and Iran to look for openings to strike back—from the Mediterranean to the Baltics. But it’s possible they will merely shout in protest and wait for the U.S. to lose interest. To truly deter barbarism and protect U.S. interests, Mr. Trump will need a larger strategy than one military strike.

2 comments

Peaceful Settlement of Disputes

Chapter VI of the United Nations Charter says:

Article 33

  1. The parties to any dispute, the continuance of which is likely to endanger the maintenance of international peace and security, shall, first of all, seek a solution by negotiation, enquiry, mediation, conciliation, arbitration, judicial settlement, resort to regional agencies or arrangements, or other peaceful means of their own choice.
  2. The Security Council shall, when it deems necessary, call upon the parties to settle their dispute by such means.

[…]

Article 37

  1. Should the parties to a dispute of the nature referred to in Article 33 fail to settle it by the means indicated in that Article, they shall refer it to the Security Council.
  2. If the Security Council deems that the continuance of the dispute is in fact likely to endanger the maintenance of international peace and security, it shall decide whether to take action under Article 36 or to recommend such terms of settlement as it may consider appropriate.

The United States is a signatory to the UN Charter. In essence Chapter VI commits the signatories to eschewing the use of force against other nations without the express authorization of the Security Council.

Being a party to international accords means you don’t get to do whatever you want whenever you want to do it. The Charter has the power of law. An attack against another country without the authorization of the Security Council is a violation of U. S. law.

Further Article I, Section 8 of the U. S. Constitution reads in part:

The Congress shall have Power…] To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;

which means that the president does not have the authority to attack another country without the express direction of the Congress. Emergency circumstances allow the president to wage war without such authorization under his powers as commander-in-chief.

Russia has an enormous nuclear arsenal—enough to destroy the United States many times over and enough to lay waste to the entire world. Russia is Syria’s primary ally and Russian forces are aiding the Syrian government in putting down the war against it.

We don’t know for certain who used chemical weapons in Douma or even whether chemical weapons were used. For example, it is possible that bombing by the Syrian government released chemical weapons that were being made or stored in the area bombed. There hasn’t been a thorough investigation and we just don’t know.

Attacking Syria was lawless, reckless, and stupid.

2 comments

The CBO Forecast

At RealClearPolicy James Capretta, no fan of big government, apparently concurs with the CBO’s assessment of the impact of the latest tax cut on the budget:

The Congressional Budget Office’s latest forecast makes a convincing case that fiscal complacency is now dangerous for the U.S. economy. CBO projects the federal government will borrow an additional $12.4 trillion over the next 10 years. At the end of 2028, the federal government will have outstanding debt of $28.7 trillion, or 96 percent of GDP. Ten years ago, federal debt was equal to 39 percent of GDP.

In fact, CBO’s official projection is an optimistic scenario. It assumes Congress will let many of the tax-cutting provisions enacted in the recently passed tax legislation expire after 2025. It also assumes, even more implausibly, that the caps on defense and nondefense appropriations for 2020 and 2021 contained in the Budget Control Act of 2011 will remain in place, thus forcing deep cuts in federal spending. However, Congress just enacted a bipartisan agreement to raise the caps in 2018 and 2019 by nearly $300 billion over that two-year period. If the tax cuts are made permanent, and if discretionary appropriations grow with the rate of inflation after 2019, then the budget deficit over the next decade would be $15 trillion instead of the $12.4 trillion contained in CBO’s baseline forecast. In 2028, the annual budget deficit would widen to 7.1 percent of GDP, while total federal debt would reach 105 percent of GDP.

and there is very good reason to believe that so high a debt overhang itself is a drag on economic growth.

Tax cuts are no longer a viable strategy for encouraging economic growth. Our expenses are too high and our debt is too large. Since cutting taxes is the only thing on which Republicans can agree, it sounds as though they’re out of gas.

And here’s the risk posed by our large debt overhang:

If interest rates were to rise sharply and suddenly, lawmakers could find themselves needing to raise taxes or cut spending drastically just to cover spiraling debt service payments.

Interest on the debt is, what, the third largest line item in the budget? That’s a significant risk.

3 comments

Things Are Not Always As They Seem

I recommend you read Gary Abernathy’s anecdote about local Ohio politics in the Washington Post

As long as the investigation by Mueller and the actions of law enforcement stayed focused on their primary mandate, they were on solid ground. Now, after the raid on Trump’s personal attorney, it appears to many that they are merely looking for a win on something — anything.

It will be an ironic development if overzealous law enforcement officials manage to make Trump something that he seldom succeeds in making himself — a sympathetic character.

in light of its potential relevance to recent events in the ongoing soap opera of the Mueller investigation. You don’t need to be pro-Trump to think that the investigation may not have the outcome that many Democrats seem to want.

7 comments

Power

I’ve tried this before but this time I’ll just put it in a single post. The Speaker of the House of Representatives is the most powerful person in the United States government. After that comes the Chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee. After that the president. After that the Chief Justice of the U. S. Supreme Court. After that the Senate majority leader.

I touched on my reservations about Nancy Pelosi as Speaker in the comments of an earlier post. IMO she has a great temperament for House minority whip which, coincidentally, was the first party leadership role she filled. She then became House minority leader, then Speaker. As a Speaker she may be good for the party but that’s lousy for the United States.

Paul Ryan on the other hand was always a bad fit for any leadership role in the House. John Boehner on the other hand was an adequate Speaker. He managed to keep his fractious caucus together under very trying conditions, something that’s eluded Ryan.

This is something I’ve mentioned before, too, but I’ll touch on it again. The folks who created the Schoolhouse Rock short “I’m Just a Bill” 45 years ago have a lot to answer for. That’s how the Congress works on paper but not in practice and it would be enormously helpful if people knew how the Congress really worked. Maybe I’ll work on that some time.

I learned that at my family’s kitchen table. My dad came from a powerful St. Louis political family. His grandfather was a party boss; his uncle was Sheriff of St. Louis. He had lots of politician friends and acquaintances include the Chairman of the St. Louis Board of Aldermen (the St. Louis city council), judges, Congressmen, U. S. senators.

One of these, as it turns out, was at the time the Chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee. I learned a lot from him just listening to the casual dinner table conversation. It ain’t like Schoolhouse Rock.

0 comments

The Bottom Ten

I see that the senior senator from the great state of Illinois, Dick Durbin, is one of the ten senators with the lowest approval ratings according to the Morning Consult. Quick, have a baby!

Oh, well. His approval rate is higher than Rauner’s, so that’s something. It ain’t every state that can have its governor and one of its senators in the bottom ten.

3 comments

Annexation

Chicago’s population peaked in 1950 at 3.62 million people. By 2016 that had declined to 2.705 million, a decrease of about 25%. Chicago’s population has decreased in each of the last three years. It is the only one of the U. S.’s major cities to have a net population decrease.

In 1950 Chicago had about 6 homicides per 100,000 population. In 2016 it had 30 per 100K, its largest homicide rate since 1994.

Let me suggest a different way of looking at public employee pensions: they’re a way of reducing present day operating expenses, especially when the jurisdiction does not salt away enough money to pay for the pensions to which it has committed and there’s no way for it to escape that commitment. When a city’s population and its economy are growing that may make a perverse sort of sense. When its population and economy are shrinking it’s macabre. Fewer people are being compelled to pay for the services enjoyed by more in the past, in some cases, as with Detroit or St. Louis, many more.

Now I’ll turn the podium over to Ryan Cooper at The Week:

Many cities have begun to experience some urban revival after the nadir of the 1970s. But many are still struggling under a heavy burden of services without the tax base they logically deserve. There are also some signs that younger people, under pressure from sky-high rents in the most desirable cities, are once again moving back to the suburbs and exurbs.

It’s long since time municipal boundaries were re-drawn around actual organic communities — perhaps in line with Metropolitan Statistical Areas defined by the government.

Perhaps if such a reorganization took place, suburban denizens might even see the value of universal high-quality public services for themselves, including public transportation throughout the whole metro area. But ultimately, it’s only fair that economic and population centers should be governed as whole instead of one portion being stuck with all the burdens and another raking in all the benefits.

Why stop there? By that logic shouldn’t states like Illinois, Ohio, and Michigan that have experienced absolute declines in population annex parts of Florida, North Carolina, Texas, or California?

Let me return to Chicago’s example. The economies of the “collar counties”, as we call them, don’t actually depend on Chicago’s. Naperville, Oakbrook, Northbrook, and Schaumburg may once have been bedroom communities but that ended 30 years ago. Not nearly as many people commute into Chicago for work as was the case when Richard J. Daley was mayor and O’Hare Airport is a revenue source rather than an expense for Chicago not to mention that it’s a part of Chicago by courtesy only—it’s connected to the city by a strip a block wide in places.

Allow me to suggest a different strategy. There are reasons that Detroit, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, and Chicago have declined in population, they are not entirely geographical, and those should be addressed before we decide that annexation is the solution to declining cities’ problems.

4 comments

Beyond the Words

You might be interested in this article at Fortune on the paralinguistic features of Mark Zuckerberg’s testimony before the Congress. There’s more to communication than just words.

Raising pitch for emphasis appears to be a Millennial “thing”. I suspect there’s a master’s thesis if not a doctoral dissertation on intergenerational miscommunication via its paralinguistic features.

5 comments

All Roads Are Local

I have only one thing to say about Michelle Nellenbach’s complaint at Roll Call that “our roads…are falling apart”.

The federal government’s involvement in building roads is almost entirely in building new roads. Once built they are completely the responsibility of state and local government which continue to own them. That is something that is obvious to anyone who has ever driven from Illinois into Iowa.

I would add that if your dream is for someone else to pay for the road you use to commute to work, it will remain a dream. State and local governments are the entities best situated to identify and fund infrastructure priorities.

0 comments

Psychology and Mathematics Are Against Them

I found it very, very hard to get past the opening paragraph of Ady Barkan’s article at The Nation, “The Government Should Guarantee Everyone a Good Job”:

Progressives have begun to dream more boldly. We have graduated from a public option to single payer. From lower sentences to eliminating cash bail. From motor-voter to automatic-voter registration. From affordable to free college. And from a $15 minimum wage to guaranteed good jobs for all.

Note that they have accomplished exactly none of those things.

It might be just barely possible and tenuously maintainable for the federal government to provide a job for anyone who wants one. The jobs would need to pay just enough to support one and not so munificent that it would attract people away from other jobs, something that would require continuous tinkering, never America’s strong suit. The nature of the jobs would need to be changed repeatedly so as not to contend with the private sector for workers. Otherwise the deadweight loss would be disastrous. Providing good jobs? Fuhgettaboutit.

The ugly truth is that for many people the only good job is a high-paying sinecure. Making a job a good job is inside people not external to them. Happiness research has shown that with a proper attitude any job is a good job but without that attitude the same job may be drudgery.

The federal government can barely pay for and sustain the bare minimum of tasks required to maintain our society. The notion that it has the ability to satisfy every human desire is a free flight of fancy.

4 comments