Dave Schuler
May 21, 2018
As if in response to my question yesterday, Michaela Frai and Alex Entz have an article at the Weekly Standard on what should be done about Venezuela. As with so many of the genre it does a much, much better job of stating the problem than of devising a solution. Let’s skip straight to the solutions:
To start, a consortium should be arranged between the United States and like-minded OAS countries with the general principle of isolating Maduro as much as possible. The formation of such a consortium lends broader regional legitimacy to what would otherwise be perceived as unilateral U.S. actions.
The consortium could direct relief to Venezuelan refugees and provide any support possible to the International Criminal Court’s nascent investigation into the regime. Additionally, the consortium should create and publicize a roadmap detailing an off-ramp for the Maduro regime. This plan could promise relief in exchange for concrete steps toward re-establishing democracy and allowing international aid organizations into the country. This would provide a credible commitment that may tilt Venezuelan domestic politics, turned increasingly desperate by economic ills, toward engagement with the outside world. In this vein, the United States and its allies should support the Venezuelan opposition’s ongoing attempts to bring democracy and humanitarian aid to their country.
Hyperinflation and a sovereign debt crisis will squeeze Maduro’s legitimacy and endanger his reign. The country’s oil production is its lowest since the 1980s, and is set to fall further; the country’s foreign reserves are at a 15-year low, and also are expected to fall. To quell hyperinflation, Venezuela slashed three zeros from its banknotes by executive fiat, as Zimbabwe once did, but Maduro has no serious, credible plan for fiscal stabilization or monetary restraint. (His only opponent in the next election has suggested adopting the U.S. dollar). In light of such weaknesses, the consortium should apply more economic pressure. For example, members could pool intelligence resources to help identify foreign bank accounts maintained by senior officials under false names, which could then be frozen. A unified stance against corrupt Venezuelan officials would lessen the odds of illicit financing for the regime.
Lastly, defaults by the Venezuelan government and by its national oil company, PDVSA, have opened the door for unpaid creditors to seize assets. ConocoPhillips recently seized a PDVSA facility in the Caribbean, and a Canadian firm is angling for a similar judgment on CITGO, a PDVSA subsidiary based in the United States. The Trump administration should support the claims of creditors while ensuring that no assets in the United States end up controlled by a hostile foreign power. Venezuela is clearly worried about losing desperately needed capital via asset seizures; this month alone, PDVSA redirected nine shipments of crude oil to avoid seizure.
Do you believe that all of those measures, implemented with perfect efficiency and timing, would have much effect at all on the situation in Venezuela? Me, neither. I don’t even think they’d protect the U. S. from the run-on effects of collapse of the Maduro government.
And that doesn’t even include their highly problematic desire to insulate American companies from the adverse effects of their own bad choices.
Dave Schuler
May 21, 2018
In an article at Project Syndicate Harold James lists eight lessons to be learned from Germany’s experience with the disastrous Weimar Republic. His list includes:
Fifth, a political culture in which leaders demonize their opponents erodes democracy. In the Weimar Republic, that pattern began before the Nazis became a significant force.
and
Eighth, incumbents can survive by buying off a discontented populace for some time, but not forever. In the Weimar era, the German state provided generous municipal housing, local government services, agricultural and industrial subsidies, and a large civil service; but it financed those outlays with debt.
To his list I’d add two more. The U. S. should never have entered World War I. Our entry allowed the victorious Allies to impose damaging terms on the vanquished Germany and those terms are among the factors that led to the critical loss of confidence in the Weimar government. The second is that just as Germany should not have financed its war effort with debt so the Weimar Republic should not have financed its ambitious social programs with debt.
Dave Schuler
May 21, 2018
I’m wondering what the party line on this:
In this year’s edition of our Best Cities For Jobs survey, we found that six of the 10 metropolitan areas with the fastest job growth are either mid-sized (150,000 to 450,000 total nonfarm jobs) or smaller (less than 150,000 nonfarm jobs). They also account for 18 out of the top 30. Smaller metro areas dominated job growth in a number of sectors, including manufacturing (all the top 20), information (all of the top 10) jobs and, less surprisingly, natural resources, construction and mining.
These trends are also reflected in the new U.S. Census Bureau metropolitan area population estimates for 2017, which show a significant increase in domestic migration away from the 53 major metropolitan areas with populations over a million and toward the 54 middle-sized metro areas in the 500,000 to 1 million range. In 2017, the midsize metro areas gained 271,000 more net domestic migrants than the major metro areas. (The biggest two, New York and Los Angeles, had an enormous net loss of 209,000 — 0.95% of their combined populations).
noted in Joel Kotkin’s piece at Forbes, will be? Should this pattern persist, cue pleas for policies targeted at helping “our cities”. As the 53 major metropolitan areas gentrify they’ll be decreasingly sympathetic targets for bailout but possibly better able to secure them.
Dave Schuler
May 21, 2018
In his post at RealClearMarkets Joseph Calhoun questions the present objectives of monetary policy:
I don’t know if we can accomplish the goal of a stable dollar and more stable commodity prices without a gold standard. I’m not even sure we want to; there were still monetary problems under a gold standard although it may be that, like democracy, it is the worst system except for all the others that have been tried from time to time. Maybe we could use a more general commodity index or add some element of asset prices to the Fed’s mandate. I don’t have the answer. But I’m damn sure that what we are doing now is unfair and ineffective. As someone said a few years back, the rent is too damn high. I’d add gas and groceries to that list.
What he’s questioning is that the rate of inflation that the Federal Reserve attempts to control through interest rate adjustments doesn’t include food, gasoline, or rent. There are good reasons for that. They are “volatile” meaning they go up and down quite a bit for reasons that are only very indirectly influenced by monetary policy.
Take gas prices, for example. Those have been rising lately but I don’t think much of the increase has anything to do with monetary policy. I’d say it has more to do with other government policies including environmental policy, trade policy, and foreign policy. Not to mention demand factors. Or food prices. Food prices are almost certainly more affected by gas prices, demand factors, and trade policies than they are by interest rates. I don’t know what it’s like in the rest of the country but here in Chicago tax policy is a major factor in rent increases. So I’d say the most important factors behind rent increases are tax policy, demand factors, and zoning. On a side note I’ve been amused in a perverse sort of way lately by New Yorkers who are nostalgic for the good old days when Times Square was a sewer and you couldn’t walk down the street without getting mugged. At least there were a lot of rent-controlled apartments.
So, while I’m favorably disposed to defining welfare as being more dependent on price stability in food, gas, and rent than iPads, let’s extend the discussion of government policy beyond monetary policy to all of government policy, even those under the control of the do-nothing Congress. In fact to those three I’d add health care prices and the price of education. Our attempts at controlling those have been tragically inadequate and their price increases are little related to interest rates.
Dave Schuler
May 20, 2018
There is a very good observation in Robert Weissberg’s modest proposal for taking the wind from the sails of college activists at Minding the Campus:
The impulse to “do good†is particularly common among the young, so it should be no surprise that millions of college students rally on behalf of what they believe to be a “good cause.†What has changed over the last half-century is that the cost of doing “good†has sharply declined. A do-gooder version of Moore’s Law– the number of transistors that can be put on a single integrated circuit (now about 7 billion) would double every two years (or 18 months)—now applies to “doing good.â€
So, for example, a 19th-century do-gooder might volunteer at a soup kitchen, an effort that was personally time-consuming and reflected a limited, locally available charitable options. Merely carrying an “end world hunger†sign hardly counts as “doing good.â€
Over time, the cost of campaigning to end world hunger has declined dramatically. Now just drop off a box of spaghetti at a supermarket collection point or send a check to the Salvation Army. Still, there is some tangible cost, however modest in this doing good. Even an ambitious humanitarian can write more than a few checks or otherwise feed the hungry.
By contrast, contemporary campus-based social justice warriors can be a Dervish on steroids at “saving the world†at minimal cost per cause. All it takes is concocting a list of “good ideas†and announcing it in public. No matter that this make-it-up-as-you-go-along jumble is pure theatrics and the candidates are almost limitless.
That failing isn’t limited to college activists and it’s something I’ve commented on here before. Paying your taxes is not an act of virtue. Supporting political candidates who campaign on platforms of helping the poor is not an act of charity. Being reimbursed at Medicaid rates does not satisfy an ethical obligation to provide care regardless of the ability to pay. The list is endless.
I’m not sure how we twisted ourselves into the pretzel of thinking that being virtuous can be cheap, easy, or comfortable. Is it because we’ve watched too much television? We’ve become consumers rather than participants?
Dave Schuler
May 20, 2018
I recommend you read this interview of Iran scholar Kenneth M. Pollack by Tobin Harshaw at Bloomberg. The subject is what’s next with Iran now that we’ve abrogated Obama’s “Iran deal”? Here are two snippets, the first on Iraq:
Iraq is harder, but just as important. It is one of the most important Arab states and the vast majority of Iraqis hate Iran, but we have allowed Iran to become the most influential external power there out of sheer neglect. If we are willing to maintain a sizable American military presence there (as we should have in 2011) and are willing to make a long-term commitment to help Iraq economically (say $1 billion to $2 billion per year for five years) we will be in a position to help nationalistic Iraqi leaders who have tried to stand up to Tehran but failed largely because they did not have our help. That remains true even after Iraq’s recent elections.
I think that’s wishful thinking. Whatever Iraqis think, because of its Shi’ite majority it will always be viewed as leaning towards Iran by the Gulf Arabs. Regardless of the truth our policy will always be colored by that. IMO the truth is more that Iraq is a threat to the Iranian mullah regime than the other way around.
But his remarks on Yemen ring true to me:
Yemen is harder still. There the most important things are to get our Saudi allies unstuck and convince the Houthis to evict their Iranian advisers. In a nutshell, the best prospect we have to do both is to help the Saudi-led military coalition to take the port of Hudaydah, the last and most important under Houthi control. Then, with that military victory in hand, convince them to offer a generous political deal to the Houthis, one largely along the lines of what the Houthis demanded at the start of the civil war. In return, we/they would demand an end to the war and an end to the Iranian presence.
What we need to keep in mind is that Iran’s influence on the Houthis has always been highly exaggerated. Absent Saudi aggression in Yemen would there be Iranian advisors there?
Dave Schuler
May 20, 2018
If you’ve ever had any doubts about just how environmentally benign electric vehicles are, this article by Jonathan Lesser at Politico should tip you over the edge:
All of this might make sense if electric vehicles, as their supporters claim, were truly likely to reduce air pollution and tackle climate change. But are they?
To answer that question, I used the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s most recent long-term forecasts for the number of new electric vehicles through 2050, estimated how much electricity they’d use, and then figured out how much pollution that electricity would generate, looking at three key pollutants regulated under the U.S. Clean Air Act—sulfur dioxide (SO2), oxides of nitrogen (NOX), and particulates—as well as CO2 emissions. I compared them to the emissions of new gasoline-powered vehicles, using the EIA’s “real world†miles-per-gallon forecast, rather than the higher CAFE standard values.
What I found is that widespread adoption of electric vehicles nationwide will likely increase air pollution compared with new internal combustion vehicles. You read that right: more electric cars and trucks will mean more pollution.
and he doesn’t even get into the total environmental impact of electric vehicles compared with internal combustion. I guess this, too, is just another exercise in navel-gazing. The push for electric vehicles is mostly a gigantic exercise in NIMBYism. It doesn’t matter what their total environmental impact is as long as they reduce the emissions in Marin County and make its residents feel good about what they’re doing to reduce global warming.
Want to reduce vehicle emissions? Put steep tolls on all interstates.
Dave Schuler
May 20, 2018
If there is a more concerted exercise in navel-gazing than this article at Center for International Maritime Security on how China’s claim to the Spratlies is just an honest mistake, I don’t know what it would be. Here’s the conclusion:
Although the Chinese government likes to say that it has an ancient and historical claim to the reefs and rocks in the South China Sea, a detailed examination of evidence shows that it actually emerged in the first half of the twentieth century. It also changed during a 40-year period 1907-1947. The whole process was filled with confusion and misunderstanding. A few mistakes by a small number of poorly-informed Chinese officials and academics back in the 1930s have created lingering confusion that still poisons the politics of Southeast Asia to this day.
Folderol. What poisons the politics of Southeast Asia are China’s expansionist policies and their propensity to use even the most far-fetched pretext in defense of them, cf. Tibet. As one yardstick can you imagine Xi’s government announcing that it’s all been an honest mistake and they’ll withdraw from the area immediately, renouncing all claims, etc.? Me, neither.
Dave Schuler
May 20, 2018
The Justice Department and its agency the Federal Bureau of Investigation are under the executive branch of the federal government and are run by political appointees. There is no way to maintain what is somewhat bizarrely referred to as a “Chinese wall” between Justice and the FBI and the executive branch of government. It is the executive branch of government. Keep those things in mind as you read Glenn Greenwald’s remarks at The Intercept on the reports that the FBI maintained an “informant” in the Trump campaign from its earliest days.
Did they have probable cause? A warrant? If so, why has that not emerged from the Mueller investigation? So much else has. Do they secure “informants” in every presidential campaign organization as a matter of course?
I disagree somewhat with Mr. Greenwald’s assertion that “THERE IS NOTHING inherently untoward, or even unusual, about the FBI using informants in an investigation”. I think if it’s not inherently unusual to use informants in the investigation of a political campaign, it should be.
IMO this looks very much like it meets the definition of a “seditious conspiracy” in 18 U.S. Code § 2384.
Dave Schuler
May 20, 2018
I want to encourage you to read an article at the New York Times on the decline of Time, Inc. The article is an “oral history”, i.e. it consists of a series of brief quotes from former researchers, writers, and editors. Very informative.
The print versions of Time and Life were fixtures in our house when I was a kid. My dad maintained subscriptions to two newspapers, Time, Life, National Geographic, and Consumer Reports. I recall being astonished at the stupidity of Time’s acquisition of AOL. I suspect that those with more inside knowledge felt pretty much the same way about Time’s acquisition of Warner’s.
My impression is that publishing in general not just newspaper and magazine but book publishing, too, tends to be extremely conservative. Not politically but in terms of business attitudes. Walking into McGraw-Hill’s executive offices in the 1980s was like a portal into the 1930s if not 1900. This article tends to support that view.