What Causes Political Polarization?

I strongly recommend you read David Blankenhorn’s article at The American Interest on the causes of political polarization. He lists fourteen of them and I’ll quote just one of them, habits of mind and heart:

14. The growing influence of certain ways of thinking about each other. These polarizing habits of mind and heart include:

  • Favoring binary (either/or) thinking.
  • Absolutizing one’s preferred values.
  • Viewing uncertainty as a mark of weakness or sin.
  • Indulging in motivated reasoning (always and only looking for evidence that supports your side).
  • Relying on deductive logic (believing that general premises justify specific conclusions).
  • Assuming that one’s opponents are motivated by bad faith.
  • Permitting the desire for approval from an in-group (“my side”) to guide one’s thinking.
  • Succumbing intellectually and spiritually to the desire to dominate others (what Saint Augustine called libido dominandi).
  • Declining for oppositional reasons to agree on basic facts and on the meaning of evidence.

These ways of thinking constitute the actual precipitation of polarization—the direct and immediate causes of holding exaggerated and stereotyped views of each other, treating our political opponent as enemies, exhibiting growing rancor and aggression in public life, and acting as if common ground does not exist.

There are other factors I would add to those he lists, not just in the quoted part above but in his entire piece which I encourage you to read. For example, the trend away from the written word as a means of expressing thought towards more visual media encourages a more agonistic mode of expression which in turn provokes an oppositional response.

And there is one reason for political polarization I do not believe should be forgotten. Political polarization benefits some people personally or financially, in particular the media and national political leadership. Nearly every incumbent in Washington benefits from polarization. Conflict attracts viewers while amicable disagreement doesn’t. It’s working for them. They’ll promote more of it.

7 comments

TCM’s Theme

Turner Classic Movies, a cable channel that shows movies from the vast Warner, MGM, and Twentieth Century-Fox catalogs, frequently links the movies it shows during the day in a common theme. Today the movies it’s showing include

The Red Badge of Courage
Friendly Persuasion
Pride of the Marines
The Best Years of Our Lives

Highly appropriate.

0 comments

Poppies Are For Remembrance

It used to be Decoration Day and was a day reserved for decorating the graves of the Civil War dead. Now it’s Memorial Day in which we are to remember all American soldiers who’ve died in war. Poppies were originally for Armistice Day which is now called Veterans Day, inspired by the poem about the dead of the Great War, In Flanders Field, but they’ve now expanded to Memorial Day as well.

What should we remember on Memorial Day? We should remember that more Americans died killing each other and of disease in the American Civil War than in all our other wars put together. Let us not forget. We should remember that whatever our disagreements with each other we should settle them peacefully and never make war against our fellow countrymen ever again. Let us not forget.

We should remember that war must be reserved for preserving the Republic, not for advancing strategic objectives. Let us not forget.

6 comments

A Telling Argument

At RealClearEnergy Pınar Çebi Wilber makes an argument that I’m sure will ring true for many Americans:

The ISDS should be a keystone of a modernized NAFTA. It can help to safeguard U.S. investments in Canada and Mexico, create neutral and transparent venues for settling trade disputes, and pave the way for the free and open trade that President Trump continues to advocate. If the president truly wants to strike a good deal in favor of the U.S. — and if he wants Congress and the business community on board with a modernized NAFTA — he should ensure that ISDS keeps working to the benefit of American investors.

That’s the ticket. Don’t protect U. S. jobs. Protect American DFI in Canada and Mexico to protect Canadian and Mexican jobs. I’m sure that’s an argument that will resonate with most Americans.

Just as a small hint, if investors assumed they bore no risk, that’s on them. I feel no need to indemnify them against the consequences of their folly.

6 comments

The Dummies Are the Changers

Somewhat to my surprise, in his piece on the practice of regime change at Foreign Policy, Stephen Walt is not completely unhinged. Here’s the meat of the article:

I could toss in America’s failed efforts to manage political transitions in places such as Yemen or Somalia as well, but you get the point. And lest you think I’ve just cherry-picked the biggest disasters, more comprehensive studies of the full universe of “foreign-imposed regime changes” have shown that it rarely produces the beneficial outcomes that its advocates predict. Given this sorry track record, you’d think outside powers would understand that “regime change” is a Pandora’s box that is best left firmly closed.

The reasons aren’t hard to understand.

First, toppling a foreign regime puts other regimes on notice, and they begin to take action to avoid a similar fate. It is not surprising that Iran and Syria both intervened to thwart U.S. efforts in Iraq, for example, because they knew they were next on the U.S. hit list if the Iraq adventure had succeeded. And it is equally unsurprising that North Korea sacrificed much to get nuclear weapons, or that Iran has seriously considered doing so, given that the United States has repeatedly called for their demise. The more the United States makes regime change a staple tool of its foreign policy, the more resistance it is likely to face.

Second, toppling a foreign government isn’t the end of the job — it’s when the hard work really starts. Removing an existing regime creates winners and losers, and the latter are usually willing to take up arms or do other unpleasant things to try to regain their former positions. Instead of a thriving and stable democracy, with political competition regulated by well-established and legitimate institutions and norms, the more likely result is a failed state and civil war.

Third, once installed in power, the new government is rarely the compliant tool that regime-changers expect. Hamid Karzai was hailed as the ideal leader for post-Taliban Afghanistan, but he proved to be a recalcitrant and uncooperative politician who refused to crack down on corruption or take the advice of the Americans on whom his government depended. Iraq’s post-Saddam leaders have hardly been reliable U.S. clients either, and some of them, such as former Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, were more sympathetic to Iran from the start. Even when you help bring someone to power, they have to govern with their own interests and political survival in mind, and that often means doing things that Americans won’t like. This is especially true in the Middle East, where the United States is broadly disliked (and not without reason).

Compounding this problem is ignorance: Foreign powers that intervene to topple a local government rarely know enough about the society they are entering to make smart decisions about the new order that must now be created. They won’t know which local leaders are reliable or honest, or have sufficient cultural understanding to devise institutions that will be seen as legitimate by the local population. No matter how bad things were before the old regime was toppled, the situation is likely to be even worse once the old order has collapsed. Regime-changers always claim they will be greeted as liberators, but the more likely outcome is a population that is quickly disillusioned and soon becomes resentful and violent.

Lastly, no population likes taking orders from well-armed foreign occupiers, no matter how benevolent their original intentions might have been, and heavy-handed measures to deal with pockets of resistance will ignite nationalist passions and generate new sources of opposition. That’s been the story nearly everywhere the United States has intervened in recent years, and the U.S. experience is far from unique.

I wish he had been more explicit in enunciating the most important reason that regime change should be eschewed as a tactic: to replace a regime you need near-metaphysical certitude that the new regime is an improvement (at least in your terms) over the old. That’s the reason that regime change in Syria was is, was, and will be lunacy. The only viable alternatives are actually worse than Assad.

How much of the present chaos in the world is a consequence of regime change, successful or unsuccessful? Look at the hot spots: Syria, Afghanistan, Congo, Venezuela—there is regime change, attempted or effected in all of their pedigrees.

0 comments

Lessons Not Learned

Speaking of not learning lessons, take a look at this post by Jeffrey Dorfman at Forbes on our lack of meaningful reforms after the financial crisis of 2007-2008:

All the features of the mortgage market that contributed to the mortgage crisis still exist. No new regulations put in place since the recent recession have done anything to prevent a recurrence of a financial crisis. The incentives for mortgage originators still favor volume over systemic risk management. Borrowers are getting deeper into debt again after paring back following the recession.

This is not a case of those who don’t know history being doomed to repeat it. Virtually everyone in the financial industry remembers what happened and understands at least many of the causes. Yet, we still may repeat the last housing crisis because we are currently busy duplicating all the conditions necessary for another mortgage market meltdown. If we don’t change paths soon, we will pay a price for failing to learn the lessons of the recent financial crisis.

I disagree with his interpretation of Dodd-Frank. I don’t believe that Dodd-Frank was intended to reform anything. I think it was intended to demonstrate to the voters that the Congress was doing something. However, to paraphrase Upton Sinclair, never underestimate the ability of people to avoid reform when their livelihoods depend on not reforming.

I would hope that in reaction to the next financial crisis and there will be a next financial crisis we have the good sense to let the big banks fail. The consequences can hardly be worse or last longer than what we actually did. And a good bit of those consequences will fall on those whose imprudence caused the problem in the first place rather than on those who couldn’t have done anything to stop it.

4 comments

The Year of Decision

Do you remember the post I linked to last week in which the author took the position that there’s still time for us to turn back the clock and do everything we’ve done wrong in Afghanistan right this time? Well, he’s back at Small Wars Journal, unchastened, although apparently he received some pushback. Here’s the opening of his new piece:

This article is in response to feedback on my previous article Going Back to the Future: It is Time for Change in Afghanistan. I want to thank all that took the time to comment and for their insightful thoughts and feedback. The feedback ranged from:

  1. There is no political will or military patience to go back to bottom up constructs
  2. You cannot win in Afghanistan without Pakistan’s support in the sanctuaries
  3. What have we been doing for the past 17 years and where is the accountability
  4. A broken diplomatic approach
  5. Not setting conditions for reconciliation
  6. The detour to the Iraq War
  7. Inability to understand all politics is local
  8. Failure to understand how Afghanistan’s secures itself
  9. And an over investment in ministries that exacerbate corruption

All valid and great observations. As in the previous article, I am not going into the minutia of the problems as there have been millions of dollars spent on studies diving into the deep end of the minutia pool and they have been largely ignored. I will however, endeavor to point out critical missteps that we seem to keep investing in despite the negative consequences of doing so.

Note that he doesn’t like the gravest problem: counter-insurgency is completely unworkable in Afghanistan, at least in a form that can be practiced by the United States.

There is no right way to do counter-insurgency in Afghanistan. We did have alternatives. For example, we could have engaged in a significant punitive strike and then, having proved that we’d “done something”, gone home to tighten our own defenses. Alternatively, having deposed the Taliban government we could have set up a permanent base in Afghanistan, established a perimeter, ensured that there was peace and safety within that perimeter, maintained a spoiling force in Afghanistan with the missions of preventing Al Qaeda or similar groups from establishing the sort of base they’d had in Afghanistan ever again there, and otherwise allowed Afghanistan to go to hell in its own peculiar way.

But insisting that if we’re just smarter, more patient, spend more money, etc. we can make what we’ve been doing work there? You don’t know whether to laugh or to cry.

1 comment

Helping Yourself

Another piece I want to commend to your attention is this one by John McWhorter at The American Interest. In it he traces the rather bizarre turn that race relations has taken:

By the age of 50, you have lived long enough to remember being a mature adult in what is now a distant era. I recently recalled a conversation I had as a graduate student in 1991 that demonstrates a key change in America’s “conversation” on race over the past 30 years.

A white humanities graduate student was a member of a campus organization that had brought black activist and filmmaker Marlon Riggs to campus to give a talk. The student recounted that in his critique of racism, Riggs had leveled some potshots at the students themselves. This surprised and hurt her, as she had supposed that Riggs would consider her and her friends on his side in having invited him to speak.

Today, that same graduate student would be much less likely to take remarks like Riggs’s that way. Rather, today’s “woke,” educated white people would quite often lap up being apprised of the racism inside of them by a black speaker they paid, lodged, and fed. That speaker as often as not today is Ta-Nehisi Coates, who charismatically limns America as a cesspool of bigotry in his writing and in talks nationwide, and is joyously celebrated for it by the very people he is insulting.

Again, read the whole thing.

I don’t think that anyone under about the age of 70 can possibly appreciate quite how terrible things were in the United States, particularly in the Deep South, or how much race relations have improved over the years. Those who deny it are simply too young to remember. Perhaps we need a Shoah Project dedicated to race relations.

Over the period of the last 70 years we have passed through a number of phases but sometime in the 1980s I think things began to take a wrong turn. Now the exercises in self-flagellation, courses in white privilege and other like consciousness-raising exercises have ceased to be about improving the conditions for blacks in the United States so much as to demand recognition of how virtuous its white practitioners have become. It’s about recognition not about improvement. I don’t for a minute believe that 10 million or 50 million or 150 million white folk decrying their white privilege will do a darned thing to stop black kids from killing each other on the South Side of Chicago and I don’t see how anyone else can, either.

0 comments

Why Do They Do What They Do?

Here’s an interesting piece of scholarship from Phillip D. Waggoner at American Politics Research. Are the bills sponsored by a Congressional legislator constituent service?

Here’s the answer which I presume will surprise practically no one:

Through numerous tests across several issues spanning the 109th to 113th Congresses, I find a largely indirect effect of preferences on sponsorship through employment proxies, yet no consistent direct impact from constituents, opposite expectations of the delegate model of representation.

In other words, no. I’d very much like to see a related study investigating whether the bills a legislator sponsors are donor service. As might surprise many, I think the answer to that is negative as well.

I think that our legislators don’t do what they do as constituent service or donor service or for reasons of sincerely held conviction. I think almost all of what legislators do is what the party leadership tells them to do and it’s in service of somebody else’s constituents or somebody else’s contributors. Is it barely possible that it’s in service of the interests of the party leadership itself?

0 comments

Where’s the Beef?

At The Federalist Saritha Prabhu thinks she’s being “gaslighted“:

By Saritha Prabhu
MAY 24, 2018
I am an ordinary voter living far from the Beltway who feels gaslighted by our political and media establishments regarding the Russia investigation. Our current Yanny versus Laurel political moment is probably confusing even for professional political commentators. But for ordinary Americans it is a bewildering, disorienting spectacle.

Which is it: Is Donald Trump a threat to the republic, or is the deep state the threat? Was the Russia investigation legit, or was it concocted by an out-of-control Federal Bureau of Investigation and Central Intelligence Agency? Was it an FBI “informant,” or was it a “spy”?

Has America become Venezuela, as Republicans say, because the Obama administration spied on the campaign of a political adversary? Or has it become Venezuela, as Democrats say, because our current president is attacking his investigators?

The answers to the above questions depend on which camp one is in. In our hyperpartisan times, each side has its own narrative.

Read the whole thing.

I continue to support Robert Mueller’s investigation but, as the late Mayor Daley used to say, let’s look at the record. So far no compelling evidence has been produced that a single vote was cast fraudulently or even one voter convinced by Russian meddling in our elective process. Might it have happened? Sure. But the preponderance of the evidence available publicly fails to support it.

The Mueller investigation has produced a handful of indictments, mostly on charges arising from the investigation itself. Might those who lied to federal investigators have been concealing collusion with the Russians? Sure. But the preponderance of the evidence available publicly fails to support it.

To date no compelling evidence has been produced of a criminal conspiracy between Donald Trump and the Russian government to swing the election in his favor. Might it have happened? Sure. But the preponderance of the evidence available publicly fails to support it.

There are some who want the investigation to continue as long as the Trump Administration does in retaliation for overreach on the part of Republicans during Bill Clinton’s presidency or Barack Obama’s presidency or both. As Ms. Prabhu notes, that is not a “good look” for Democrats. They’re ignoring similar behavior by Democrats during the Nixon, Ford, Reagan, and W. Bush presidencies. Rather than seeking revenge why not model the behavior you’d like to see in others? Do-unto others, etc.? The maxim of reciprocity goes back at least 4,000 years. It is traditional wisdom that continues to be valid.

5 comments