What If…?

At RealClearPolitics Sean Trende rains a little on the Democrats’ parade. Comparing the Democrats’ situation now to that in 2006, when they successfully recaptured the House while a Republican sat in the White House, he writes:

By the summer of 2006, the Republicans were in dire shape. George W. Bush’s job approval sat at 36.4 percent; it improved to 39 percent by Election Day. Over the course of the month of May, the Democrats’ lead in the generic ballot was 11.4 percentage points, and was around 15 points for much of October before closing to around 10. The results were awful for Republicans. They lost 30 seats, including ones that no one had believed were vulnerable at the beginning of the year. They also lost control of the Senate.

So why might this model not be enough for Democrats? There are three reasons. First, at least for now, Republicans are polling considerably better than they were in 2006. As of today, President Trump’s job approval sits at 44 percent in the RCP poll average – nearly eight points higher than Bush’s – while the Democrats’ lead on the generic ballot is in the mid-single digits. This suggests that despite the similarities, Republicans tend to be performing at least somewhat better.

Second, 2006 can’t be analyzed without acknowledging that it involved a number of fluke-ish victories for Democrats. These include: Tom DeLay (resigned under scandal, Republicans were unable to place a different name on the ballot); Bob Ney (convicted in a coin-trading scheme shortly before the election); Don Sherwood (accused of choking his mistress); Mark Foley (accused of having sexual relationships with pages); Sue Kelly (caught on camera running into the shrubs to avoid questions about Foley); and John Sweeney (accusations of domestic battery arising shortly before the election). There were also a number of semi-flukes, such as Curt Weldon having his congressional office raided by the FBI before the election, or Richard Pombo, who was caught up in the Jack Abramoff scandal. Regardless, if one doesn’t count the six “clear” flukes, the Democrats’ actual gain was 24 seats, which would barely be enough for them to win the House today.

Finally, there is the issue of exposure. Put simply, if a party enters an unfavorable election environment holding a large number of seats that are dispositionally inclined toward the other party, they will probably suffer worse losses. This is why Bill Clinton’s and Barack Obama’s job approval ratings – which were in the mid-40s over the summers of 1994 and 2010, when their parties lost 54 and 63 seats, respectively – don’t provide the best guidance.

Unmentioned: presently the trends are all moving in the opposite direction they were in 2006. GDP was starting to rise more slowly, we were taking substantial casualties in Iraq. Not only was President Bush’s approval rating on election day lower than President Trump’s today, Trump’s approval rating is slowly rising. Although it may seem incredible to those whose opinions are formed by the continuous loop of anti-Trumpism dispensed by so many media outlets, it is quite possible that the Republicans may hold the House. We don’t elect representatives at large.

Mr. Trende doesn’t speculate on the likely political outcome should that eventuality happen but I will. If the Republicans hold the House, the volume and intensity of the complaints from the most virulently anti-Trumpers will increase. Ironically, that may actually strengthen Mr. Trump’s hand in 2020.

My view of the Democrats’ best strategy continues to be that they should support House candidates most likely to win and best able to represent the districts they’re running in regardless of how their views fit in with the emerging national ideology of the party. I trust they’ll ignore that advice.

2 comments

Pointing the Finger the Wrong Way (Updated)

I don’t have much to say about Roseanne Barr. Woman says and does obnoxious, provocative things over a period of thirty years. She gets a TV show and says and does obnoxious, provocative things. After the show’s run she keeps saying and doing obnoxious and provocative things. She gets a reboot of her 25 year old show. She keeps saying obnoxious and provocative things. She gets fired for it. Times and social media have changed.

I do want to make one comment about Roxane Gay’s op-ed in the New York Times about it, “‘Roseanne’ Is Gone, But the Culture That Gave Her a Show Isn’t”. The culture that gave her a show is ABC/Disney. You know, the same people who are gleefully destroying people’s childhoods by producing third-rate pap in imitation of the Star Wars movies of the 1970s. It’s still here, largely due to intellectual property laws.

Rather than breast-beating about racism in the country at large which as far as I can tell had nothing to do with Ms. Barr’s getting a reboot of her show, the teachable moment here is about the stupidity of mega-corporations. They knew what they were getting. They did it anyway. Why? (Hint: for the money.) Consider that before you buy Frozen accessories for your daughter.

Update

More thoughts in a similar vein from Reason:

Roseanne is crazy, and her disgusting remark about Jarrett is perfectly in character. No one is allowed to pretend that Roseanne finally went too far, or some such nonsense: the Jarrett comment—for which she swiftly apologized, to no avail—is hardly more offensive than any number of things she has said over the years. If people who say very bad things do not deserve to work in television, then Roseanne should never have been rebooted in the first place.

or, in other words, this whole thing is on Disney. They knew what they were getting when they hired her or at least should have if they’d done due diligence. Complaining about Roseanne Barr without complaining about ABC/Disney is just telling half the story.

If there is a culture of racism, it’s theirs.

10 comments

Growing Pains

In his Wall Street Journal column William Galston is skeptical that the United States’s economy is capable of growing as it did thirty years ago:

We need to make it easier for formerly incarcerated men to rejoin the workforce, for women to balance the demands of work in the home and in the market, and for older Americans to continue working well past what previous generations considered retirement age. We need to attack substance abuse—especially opioids—which thwarts too many men and women on the threshold of the workforce. And where there is solid evidence that poorly designed social supports discourage work, we should restructure them.

Although these changes would make a difference, they can do nothing to alter the reality that America is aging rapidly. Two thousand was the last year in which the entire baby-boom generation was of prime working age, and 2019 will be the first year in which none of it is. During the last two decades of the 20th century, the U.S. workforce expanded at an annual rate of about 1.5%. During the next two decades, it will expand at an estimated 0.5% annually. By itself, this slowing growth of the workforce will be enough to knock a full percentage point off annual economic growth. Productivity improvements that once yielded 3% growth will now yield only 2%.

There is no sign of a new baby boom on the horizon. On the contrary, the birthrate reached an all-time low in 2017, continuing six decades of decline. So there is only one way to boost the growth rate of the workforce: expand dramatically the number of working-age immigrants admitted each year. If the U.S. prioritized working-age entrants the way most other advanced countries do, it would increase annual labor-force growth by up to 0.3% without increasing the aggregate level of immigration.

I’ve said little about the other key component of economic growth—productivity—because most economists regard it as unpredictable. Between 1950 and 1973, it grew at 2.4% annually before collapsing to just 0.7% from 1974-81. It accelerated to 1.7% between 1982 and 1990, and to 2% from 1991-2001. But then, just when analysts began to hail a new golden age of information technology, productivity growth fell to 1.4% in 2002-07, and to 0.9% during the past decade.

We understand the basics of productivity—investment in the workforce, plant and equipment, research and development, and infrastructure, plus an environment that encourages innovation. But the pace at which new technologies and processes are integrated into the workplace remains mysterious. If a new generation of robotics and artificial intelligence yields a productivity boom, we could return to the growth of the postwar years. But we don’t know enough to bet on it.

I’m skeptical for a different reason. American managers don’t invest here the way they used to and I don’t believe they will accept the level of investment required to achieve that level of growth.

I look at things in terms of inputs and outputs. For a certain level of inputs broadly considered you get a certain level of outputs also broadly considered. There is no reason to believe that is linear over time and quite a number of reasons to think there are declining returns to scale. In 1900 a single guy working in a garage and making things that would change the world was, if not a commonplace, at least not unheard of. Now that’s incredibly rare. We’ve picked the low-hanging fruit and it will take a lot of investment to produce the next Big Thing. Maybe more than managers are prepared to make. Almost certainly more than their stockholders are willing to tolerate.

8 comments

Lies, Damned Lies, and Intelligence

These with a thousand small deliberations
Protract the profit of their chilled delirium,
Excite the membrane, when the sense has cooled,
With pungent sauces, multiply variety
In a wilderness of mirrors. What will the spider do
Suspend its operations, will the weevil
Delay?

T. S. Eliot, Gerontion

The trap that is a perpetual temptation to those who have made intelligence their careers has aptly been called the “wilderness of mirrors”. Lies, truth, good, bad are tangled and twisted beyond recognition. What to make of the remarks of former intelligence chief James Clapper? In his Wall Street Journal column Holman Jenkins remarks:

His latest assertion, in a book and interviews, that Mr. Putin elected Mr. Trump is based on non-reasoning that effectively puts defenders of U.S. democracy in a position of having to prove a negative. “It just exceeds logic and credulity that they didn’t affect the election,” he told PBS.

Mr. Clapper not only exaggerates Russia’s efforts, he crucially overlooks the fact that it’s the net effect that matters. Allegations and insinuations of Russian meddling clearly cost Mr. Trump some sizeable number of votes. Hillary Clinton made good use of this mallet, as would be clearer now if she had also made good use of her other assets to contest those states where the election would actually be decided.

Mr. Clapper misleads you (and possibly himself) by appealing to the hindsight fallacy: Because Mr. Trump’s victory was unexpected, Russia must have caused it. But why does he want you to believe that he believes what he can’t possibly know?

There’s been much talk about origins. Let’s understand how all this really began. James Comey knew it was unrealistic that Mrs. Clinton would be prosecuted for email mishandling but also knew it was the Obama Justice Department’s decision to make, own and defend. Why did he insert himself?

The first answer is that he expected Mrs. Clinton to win—and likely believed it was necessary that she win. Secondly he had a pretext for violating the normal and proper protocol for criminal investigations. He did so by turning it into a counterintelligence matter, seizing on a Democratic email supposedly in Russian hands that dubiously referred to a compromising conversation of Attorney General Loretta Lynch regarding the Hillary investigation.

My take: Mr. Clapper cannot be trusted. Nothing he says or does should be taken at face value. He doesn’t distinguish among lies, truth, facts, or opinion. He demonstrably does not recognize the limits of his own power or authority.

I have grave reservations about the allowable roles of an intelligence service in a free society, particularly one as foundationless as ours. We aren’t the Israelis.

2 comments

The Conservative Court and the Liberal Court

In its 2017 session, the session presently under way, the justices of the Supreme Court of the United States have issued opinions on, by my count, 40 cases. Of these 20 have been unanimous, 1 case has had a single dissenting opinion (Alito), and three with two dissenters (Thomas and Alito). In other words although there is a kernel of truth in the view that there is a conservative Supreme Court (Roberts, Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch) and a liberal Supreme Court (Ginsburg, Breyer, Kagan, Sotomayor) with Justice Kennedy providing a swing vote, it’s an exaggeration. Most decisions are not 5-4.

The notion of a bitterly divided Court serves the media and partisans but not the rest of us.

As I’ve said before here and elsewhere I would prefer a Court that decided all cases strictly on their legal merits. Turning the Supreme Court into a backdoor legislative body contributes to disunion. It is tyrannical. But the practical reality is that each of the justices is a human being complete with an agenda and closely held opinions and for each of the justices there are topics, frequently the “hot button” issues, on which they rather clearly become advocates. Those from member to member.

0 comments

Existential?

At Bloomberg it’s being reported that George Soros is warning of an existential danger for Europe:

A surging dollar and a capital flight from emerging markets may lead to another “major” financial crisis, investor George Soros said, warning the European Union that it’s facing an imminent existential threat.

The “termination” of the nuclear deal with Iran and the “destruction” of the transatlantic alliance between the EU and the U.S. are “bound to have a negative effect on the European economy and cause other dislocations,” including a devaluing of emerging-market currencies, Soros said in a speech in Paris on Tuesday. “We may be heading for another major financial crisis.”

I’m having some difficulty getting my head around that. If “destruction” of its alliance with the United States places Europe in “existential” danger, doesn’t that imply that European leaders, particularly German leaders, have been engaging in reckless, irresponsible brinksmanship for the last 30 some-odd years?

I know if my existence depended on remaining very, very friendly with somebody I’d be extremely nice to them. I don’t see many signs Europe has been treating us that way for, well, maybe ever.

8 comments

If Stupidity Were a Capital Offense

Did I miss the announcement? Is it National Cognitive Dissonance Day? Or is that every day these days? It certainly seems like it. Yesterday, Sunday of Memorial Day weekend, safely ensconced where no on would see it, the ever self-pitying Rod Blagojevich, the most recent but certainly not the last Illinois governor to crown his career with a prison term rather than the governorship, took to the pages of the Wall Street Journal with an op-ed, ghost-written and/or heavily edited no doubt, complains about his 17 convictions for corruption, a grave threat as he sees it to the rule of law:

The rule of law is under assault in America. It is being perverted and abused by the people sworn to enforce and uphold it. Some in the Justice Department and Federal Bureau of Investigation are abusing their power to criminalize the routine practices of politics and government.

I learned the hard way what happens when an investigation comes up empty after the government has invested time, resources and manpower. When they can’t prove a crime, they create one. Did you know that an elected official asking for a campaign contribution is the same as a dirty cop asking a motorist for a cash bribe to tear up a speeding ticket? I never did. Yet that’s what a federal prosecutor told the jury during my second trial on bribery and extortion charges in 2011.

Allow me to offer an alternative interpretation. Like his Republican predecessor, also-convicted George Ryan, Gov. Blagojevich did not realize that politics had changed and politics as he knew, always illegal, might actually get you thrown into jail today. Offering a quid pro quo was, is, and has always been illegal. Nonetheless Gov. Blagovjevich was captured on tape where any Tom, Dick, or juror could hear it doing just that. The problem is not some imagined threat to the rule of law but the enforcement of the law and that politics as he practiced it was illegal. When everyone carries a video camera and a microphone, assuming secrecy when you make those shady back office deals just isn’t as good an assumption as it used to be.

I don’t know whether to attribute Blagovjevich’s views to stupidity or arrogance or some combination of both. I do feel safe in saying that, if stupidity were a capital offense, he would have been hanged from a yardarm years ago.

10 comments

Cognitive Dissonance from the WaPo

Speaking of cognitive dissonance, the editors of the Washington Post seem to have succumbed:

Both the Obama and Trump administrations have offered limited support to the Saudi coalition, while trying to restrain reckless bombing and the exacerbation of the humanitarian crisis. When the Saudis imposed a crippling blockade on Hodeida last year, President Trump issued a statement calling on Riyadh to “immediately” allow “food, fuel, water, and medicine to reach the Yemeni people who desperately need it.” The blockade was soon suspended.

Now, as part of its stepped-up campaign against Iran, the administration is pledging more support for the Saudis and Emiratis; despite stiff resistance in Congress, it is seeking to sell another $2 billion in munitions to the allies. It ought instead to be insisting that the Saudis take the peace talks seriously — and that the Emiratis halt their advance on Hodeida.

I seem to recall that the Washington Post supported President Obama’s drone war which fomented this whole mess in Yemen to begin with. Recommending that we not expand the munitions we’re selling to the Saudis is pretty weak tea. There’s plenty of other alternatives. We could end our “limited support”. Stop giving them intelligence, military advice, and logistical support. We could stop selling them munitions entirely. We could create a “no-fly” zone. We could blockade Saudi Arabia to prevent them from being resupplied. We could start calling for regime change in Saudi Arabia. We could arm Shi’ite rebels in Saudi Arabia. We could bomb Riyadh.

This editorial is the journalistic equivalent of a stern démarche. It’s what you do when you want to be seen as doing something without actually having the guts or will to do anything.

0 comments

Crossing the Line

Is there a narrow line between charming naïveté and being dangerously deranged? If so in her most recent Washington Post column Katrina vanden Heuvel is teetering on its edge. In it she urges Democrats to give peace a chance:

In a sane world, Trump’s escalation of nuclear dangers would provoke a much louder outcry, especially from Democratic politicians who have taken up the mantle of resistance to the president. But Democrats, with a few notable exceptions, haven’t offered alternatives to Trump’s calamitous, con-man foreign policy. While there are a number of explanations for the party’s response, perhaps a central part of the problem is that, with less than six months until the midterms, Democrats still don’t have a coherent message on national security. Without control of the White House or Congress, the moment is ripe for Democrats to rethink the failed establishment approach that has guided the party for too long. But when potential 2020 contenders gathered recently at the Center for American Progress’ Ideas Conference, national security wasn’t even on the agenda.

Let’s look at the record. President Obama expanded the war in Afghanistan, attacked Libya, went to war in Syria, and killed more people with drones than his predecessor by an order of magnitude. Of the candidates for the two major political parties, who was the more hawkish? Hillary Clinton by a mile.

Liberal interventionists are hawks, too. Neither major political party offers anything other than endless war.

2 comments

Meritocracy Isn’t

In his latest column at the New York Times David Brooks rises to defend the concept of meritocracy. It’s only being practiced wrong:

The essential point is this: Those dimwitted, stuck up blue bloods in the old establishment had something we meritocrats lack — a civic consciousness, a sense that we live life embedded in community and nation, that we owe a debt to community and nation and that the essence of the admirable life is community before self.

The meritocracy is here to stay, thank goodness, but we probably need a new ethos to reconfigure it — to redefine how people are seen, how applicants are selected, how social roles are understood and how we narrate a common national purpose.

I, on the other hand, think that no meritocracy based on attending the right school or getting the right grades in elementary school is worthy of the name.

Let’s take the Supreme Court as an epitome of the sort of phony meritocracy that has come to prevail. All of the sitting Supreme Court justices attended Harvard or Yale Law. There’s a reason for that: the path to nomination lies through having been a clerk for a Supreme Court justice and clerks for Supreme Court justices are overwhelmingly selected from the law reviews for Harvard and Yale. In other words it’s circular. It’s a bunch of Harvard and Yale grads deciding that Harvard and Yale grads are peachy.

It hasn’t always been that way. As recently as 1980 a majority of Supreme Court justices had graduated from schools other than Harvard or Yale Law. IMO there has been a change of ethos (as Mr. Brooks might put it) in the Court and in the country and not for the better.

Here’s another example. My alma mater has been traded on more in the last four years than in the previous forty, not by me but by others. I had never even been asked where I had gone to undergraduate or graduate school prior to the interview with my present employer. How important is where you went to college fifty years ago? Isn’t what you’ve done since then a lot more important? Apparently not.

IMO Mr. Brooks should reflect on something. If the form that “meritocracy” has taken had prevailed thirty years ago, he wouldn’t be a columnist for the New York Times today. He went to a Midwestern school.

5 comments