Politically Expedient Boondoggle

If one began enumerating present government boondoggles, there are so many and they are added so quickly I don’t think the list would ever be completed. And it is rare that one is ever eliminated. The National Helium Reserve was established in 1925 when dirigibles were operating in substantial numbers and it’s still going strong, having survived repeated attempts at putting it out of our misery. Of all of the government boondoggles, none is probably pragmatically worse or politically more expedient than the federal mandate for corn-based ethanol. Hank Campbell explains why at the American Council on Science and Health:

In the 1980s and ’90s, environmentalists touted ethanol as ideal renewable energy because it’s made from corn, which can obviously be regrown each year. They claimed it was equivalent in efficiency to gasoline and therefore superior to fossil fuels. The political and financial push for ethanol by greens was so strong that Vice President Al Gore broke a 1994 tie in the Senate to force an Environmental Protection Agency ethanol mandate as part of the Clinton administration’s Clean Air Act.

But there is nothing clean about it. It is energy and cost intensive to turn corn into fuel, which is why it cannot survive without government mandates and subsidies. Though 1994 made ethanol a reality for environmentalists, it was the Renewable Fuel Standard of 2005, by President George W. Bush and a Republican Congress, that really kicked the industry into high gear. The Renewable Fuel Standard gave EPA the authority to create quotas for ethanol. which forced its use even though it is less efficient than pure gasoline and results in lower miles per gallon. In 1993, before Vice President Gore allowed EPA to mandate ethanol, it account for less than one-tenth of 1 percent of fuel. It’s now 10 percent. President Barack Obama also did the environment no favors by turning over 5 million acres of land designated for conservation over to corn farmers to promote ethanol as “green” energy during his time in office, with another million acres of farmland that switched to corn because the profits were guaranteed by taxpayers.

Ethanol does not pass any standard for evidence-based policymaking and the Trump administration should end 24 years of government wishful thinking by his predecessors rather than increasing its use.

In all likelihood the Trump Administration will expand the ethanol subsidy rather than eliminating it. There are some subidies that are too big to be allowed to fail.

4 comments

Bait and Switch

If HR676 is any model for what House Democrats mean by “Medicare for All”, supporters of M4A should probably be careful of what they wish for. It isn’t Medicare for all. It isn’t much like the Canadian plan or the British plan or any of the Continental European plans that are praised so regularly by proponents of healthcare reform. It’s not like the Canadian system because that system is implemented by the provinces. It’s not like the British plan because practitioners wouldn’t be employed by the government. It’s not like any of the other plans because it renders private insurance covering anything the plan would deem medically necessary illegal.

2 comments

Alternative Alternative Approaches to Reducing Atmospheric Carbon

Over at the BBC there’s an interesting article on a IPCC report proposing “cheap ways to remove CO2 from the atmosphere:

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and others have all stated that extracting CO2 from the air will be needed if we are to bend the rising temperature curve before the end of this century.

These ideas are controversial with some seeing them as a distraction from the pressing business of limiting emissions of CO2.

But a new assessment from the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine says that some of these “negative emissions technologies” are ready to be deployed, on a large scale, right now.

The authors point to the fact that the US Congress has recently passed the 45Q tax rule, which gives a $50 tax credit for every tonne of CO2 that’s captured and stored. So their study highlights some technologies that are available at between $20 and $100 per tonne.

Among the proposals are:

  • Increasing the amount of carbon stored in shoreline marshes
  • Planting trees
  • Forest management
  • Changing agricultural practices
  • Biomass energy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS)

and not one of those proposals is draconian. As noted above there are people who oppose anything that isn’t draconian:

The report acknowledges that there is a significant “moral hazard” here.

“If you present the siren song of negative emissions, does it decrease humanity’s will to invest in the mitigation that’s needed to reduce emissions – this a concern we’ve discussed in every meeting,” said Prof Pacala.

What I think that people who oppose such measures are missing is that China and India will continue to use fossil fuels in increasing amount and there’s absolutely nothing we can do about it. Except not buy from China which, apparently, we’re not willing to do.

13 comments

Midterm Predictions

We’ve got about ten days until the 2018 midterm elections and I’d like to make a few predictions and elicit some from my commenters.

The Democrats will pick up a few governor’s mansions but Republicans will continue to hold significantly more.

I think that Republicans are likely to pick up a few seats in the Senate.

I don’t believe the battle for the House is quite what you may have heard. There are 435 seats in the House and all are of the seats are being voted on. Incumbents are running for re-election to about 370 of those seats and they will overwhelmingly be re-elected. Many are uncontested, effectively if not formally. Here in the Illinois 5th District, for example, although I know that Mike Quigley has a Republican running against him I haven’t seen any ads on television for either Quigley or his opponent and I haven’t received any mail adverts from the Republican candidate. I suspect that most of the people in the district aren’t even aware that a Republican is running against Quigley. That’s opposition in name only.

A few incumbents may be defeated for re-election but overwhelmingly they will be returned to office. That’s true of Democrats and Republicans alike.

The battleground is over the sixty some-odd seats. Some of those elections will turn on party affiliation and in most of the rest the better candidate will win. The degree to which the battle for the House is a referendum on Trump is greatly exaggerated.

When the dust has settled I think the Democrats will hold the House by a very narrow majority, considerably smaller than the Republicans’ present House majority. A lot less will actually have happened than you might have been led to believe.

There are a few things that could upset that calculation. It’s possible, just barely possibly in my estimation, that people are lying to pollsters to an unexpected degree, the election is in fact a referendum on Trump, and Trump is a lot more popular than the New York Times, Washington Post, and other major media outlets would lead you to believe. If that’s the case Republicans could actually pick up seats in the House. I’m skeptical but it could happen.

Maybe the Democrats will be able to make hay out of the archetypal Florida Man who sent a bunch of pipebombs through the mail to various nationally prominent Democrats. Unless Republicans make the mistake of keeping that idiotic whackjob in the news, it’s likely he will be forgotten by Tuesday. If he remains a topic, Democrats could pick up a few additional seats.

I think the Democrats are underestimating the significance of the caravan of asylum/job seekers making its way north through Mexico. If that caravan is in the tens of thousands and massing on the border on election day, it could swing some races towards the Republican candidates.

Some revelation in domestic politics could swing the vote one way or another. International events tend to promote a “rally ’round” effect that would help the Republicans. With Trump you just never can tell.

What do you think the outcome of the midterm elections will be?

17 comments

The Birth of a Metaphor

Good advice: don’t use blowtorches to kill spiders. From Gizmodo:

While this should seemingly go without saying, it turns out that “kill it with fire” is not a great idea when it comes to ridding your home of pests. Nonetheless, there is no shortage of failed cases of people attempting to kill spiders or insects with blowtorches, and it doesn’t often end well.

In what appears to be yet another example of such an incident failing spectacularly, a man house-sitting for his parents at their Fresno, California residence may have set their house on fire after attempting to kill some black widow spiders on an exterior wall of the home, though investigators are still looking into the cause of the fire. The incident occurred Tuesday in the Woodward Lake housing development and resulted in fire damage to the home’s second story and attic, according to ABC-affiliate KFSN.

Reporter Christina Fan of KFSN was on the scene at the fire and streamed her coverage in a Facebook Live video later shared to the Fresno Fire Department’s Facebook page. Calling the incident “one of the most bizarre fire stories I have heard,” she added:

He told firefighters that there were a lot of black widow spiders that were outside the home on the exterior wall. So he decided that he was going to try to exterminate these spiders with a blowtorch. They’re still looking into the cause; but it’s pretty clear, investigators say, that was likely the cause of this fire.

According to Fan, the incident was a two-alarm fire, and 29 firefighters reported to the scene. No one was injured, but as you can imagine, the firefighters didn’t seem too impressed with the man’s botched attempt at spider fire-murder.

Footnote: pointing out how bad an idea killing spiders with blowtorches neither denies the existence of spiders nor asserts that they’re all benign (although most are).

1 comment

Probability Zero

Here’s Peggy Noonan’s prescription for defusing the ticking time bomb of American politics from her latest Wall Street Journal column:

Everyone running for office should admit things have gotten too hot, too divided. Then they should try to cool the atmosphere. Next Tuesday will mark one week before the election. Candidates should devote the day to something different. It would be good to see every one give a speech or statement containing their most generous definition of the aims and meaning of the opposing party. A Democratic nominee might say, “Whether they always succeed or not, Republicans do want to protect the liberties that have allowed this nation become the miracle of the world.” A Republican might say, “At its best and most sincere, the Democratic Party hopes to help those in peril, and to soften disparities of wealth and opportunity.”

That’s a prescription I think has exactly zero likelihood of happening, particularly in an election year.

This is something I’ve been meaning to mention for some time but my personal firsthand experience of politicians in action is that presupposing that nothing they say is sincere is actually a pretty good first order approximation. Everything they say is said with one eye on the statement’s implications for getting votes.

But I also think that the downright hatred between those of the two major political parties is on the rises. Not only do I not think that Democrats and Republicans don’t think that those of the other party has the best interests of the people of the country at heart, I think that Republicans think that Democrats are crooks while Democrats think Republicans are only interested in seizing money away from the old, the sick, and the needy and giving it to the rich.

President Trump’s intemperate tweets or statements in speeches don’t help a bit.

That’s why my solution is not for Republicans to say nice things about Democrats and vice versa, Ms. Noonan’s prescription but to de-emphasize Washington, DC. Concentrating power in Washington just increases the heat. However, it is rare that, having tasted power, an individual is willing to relinquish it. That’s why we honor George Washington. And it’s also why my prescription is unlikely to be undertaken by the Powers-That-Be.

Something else that should be kept in mind: in a country of 330 million there will always be a few crazy people who take harsh words seriously and will act on it.

11 comments

Entrepeneurial Advantage

Here’s the thesis of Robert Samuelson’s Washington post column this morning:

Globalization strikes again. The latest target is entrepreneurship.

For decades, promoting start-up firms through venture capital and other methods of business investment seemed a peculiarly American strength. It has nurtured countless tech firms, including titans such as Facebook, Google and Apple. Americans have been duly proud. It reinforced a sense of national exceptionalism, because other countries couldn’t easily duplicate it, if at all.

No more.

He goes on to provide a bit of evidence. I don’t disagree with his thesis but I don’t think he has the right concerns. For one thing I think he’s looking at a snapshot rather than at a moving picture. What have the trends in capital investment and venture capital in particular been over the last thirty years rather than just the last couple of years?

I have the following questions for Mr. Samuelson.

  1. Has the U. S. changed, other countries changed, or both? I think it’s both but the most significant change is slowing capital investment in the United States.
  2. Why is global venture capital investment so concentrated in just ten cities? Does that itself suggest a problem?
  3. What is the role of government in the ten centers of venture capital investment you cite? My gut level instinct is that it’s substantial and that also explains the concentration.
  4. Of the 62% of total global capital investment concentrated in those ten cities, 36% is in the United States. Do we really have a problem?

I’d also like him to relate his observations to the nearly trillion dollars worth of capital flight from China over the last few years but I guess that’s fodder for a later post.

3 comments

End Support for the War in Yemen

Today Sen. Bernie Sanders takes to the pages of the New York Times with an op-ed urging the U. S. to end its support of the war in Yemen:

The likely assassination of the Saudi critic and Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi underscores how urgent it has become for the United States to redefine our relationship with Saudi Arabia, and to show that the Saudis do not have a blank check to continue violating human rights.

One place we can start is by ending United States support for the war in Yemen. Not only has this war created a humanitarian disaster in one of the world’s poorest countries, but also American involvement in this war has not been authorized by Congress and is therefore unconstitutional.

Welcome back to the fight, Sen. Sanders. It would have been nice for you to condemn U. S. support for the war back when Barack Obama was president and began our support for the war but better late than never, I guess.

In the op-ed Sen. Sanders hits most of the major notes—the violence of the war, our support, that the war isn’t a reaction to Iranian support for the Houthis in Yemen rather its cause. He fails to mention that one of the causes of unrest in Yemen was President Obama’s drone war but not every op-ed can be about everything.

1 comment

Does Chicago Need a Caravan?

One of the things that struck me in the article I mentioned below was the mention of Nicaraguans fleeing the more than 300 murders in the country since April. If that’s the case there are certain sections of the United States I would suggest they avoid. Chicago, with a third the population of Nicaragua, has had that many homicides over the same period.

Maybe Chicago needs a caravan.

5 comments

The Caravan

There’s a good, dispassionate, non-partisan, informative article on the caravan of people making its way from Guatemala and Honduras through Mexico presumably to the United States at The Guardian:

Thousands of Central American migrants, including men, women and entire families, are marching through southern Mexico, in the hope of reaching the US.

The group has grown steadily since setting out from the Honduran city of San Pedro Sula on 12 October, but the exact size is unclear as there is no single organizing group.

Mexico’s interior ministry put the figure at 4,500 on Tuesday; local officials in the town Huixtla estimated the number of participants at closer to 6,000, while UN officials said there were 7,200 migrants.

Read the whole thing. They do ask the most relevant question: what will the people in the caravan do when they reach the border?

Most of the people who make it to the border are likely to turn themselves in to US authorities and claim asylum, although a few – mostly younger men – have said they will attempt to cross illegally if that is not possible.

Trump has said he will not let caravan members in, but the US is legally obliged to consider the cases of asylum seekers.

I have no idea whether the caravan is spontaneous, a planned strategy, or some of both but it definitely has a whiff of Cloward-Piven about it—destroy the system by overwhelming it.

7 comments