More on the Riots

Adam Nossiter’s New York Times article about the “yellow jacket” riots in France, completely supports the observations I’ve made here in posts and in comments. First, about those yellow jackets. In France they are legally-mandated driving equipment. Consequently, the jackets identify the wearers as drivers.

Second, unlike the riots of recent years these rioters are not North Africans and/or sub-Saharan Africans and their descendants living in the urban banlieux:

The “Yellow Vest” protests he is a part of present an extraordinary venting of rage and resentment by ordinary working people, aimed at the mounting inequalities that have eroded their lives. The unrest began in response to rising gas taxes and has been building in intensity over the past three weeks, peaking on Saturday.

With little organization and relying mostly on social media, they have moved spontaneously from France’s poor rural regions over the last month to the banks of the Seine, where they have now become impossible to ignore.

They are not left or right. They are anti-Establishment whether left or right:

None of the Guéret protesters expressed allegiance to any politician: Most said politics disgusted them.

“They are all the same,” Mr. Dou said.

When Guéret’s mayor, Michel Vergnier, a veteran Socialist with decades of connections in Paris, went to see the protesters, they were not welcoming.

“There’s a rejection of politicians,” Mr. Vergnier said. “They are outside all political and union organizations.”

I think they more closely resemble the pro-Trump voters in the United States than they do previous political protesters in France.

Anne Applebaum, after observing that these protesters met and organized using the Internet, remarks:

With their origins firmly in cyberspace, the gilets jaunes aren’t connected to any existing political parties, although several are already trying to claim them. François Ruffin, a “far-left” politician with a vitriolic dislike of the French president, Emmanuel Macron, has already appeared in gilets jaunes marches. Marine Le Pen, France’s “far-right” leader, has also leaped to their defense, and some suspect her followers — or maybe people with even more extreme agendas — may have been responsible for turning what had been peaceful protests in Paris on Saturday morning into violent riots on Saturday night. But any claims of affiliation are opportunism, because the movement itself has named no leader. It has instead appointed eight spokespeople, who come from a wide variety of backgrounds and can’t be characterized as belonging to a single party, or even to a single social group.

Rather than an ideology or a clear philosophy, the gilets jaunes seem to share a set of attitudes, as well as what might be described as an aesthetic. They are angry about the green taxes that have raised gasoline prices, and they don’t like the speed limits on French roads. They are angry more generally, and this is part of why a movement that didn’t exist a month ago became consolidated so quickly: Anger is one of the things that travels quickly on social media, a form of communication that favors emotion; it’s also one of the things that brings people together in a world where trade unions, church organizations and political parties are fading in importance. One of the protestors has declared, “All of you” — meaning the political class in its entirety, far-left, far-right and centrist — “are no longer needed.”

What if anything will result from this is difficult to say but it seems to me to be a very important development.

8 comments

We All Understand the Problems

One of the things I have repeatedly found frustrating is that every op-ed is able to state the problems very clearly and in a way with which most of would agree. Take this dissection of a campaign speech of Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren by Hal Brands at Bloomberg:

In her view, the pursuit of globalization after the Cold War was a disaster. It facilitated the rise of authoritarian rivals such as China; it devastated the American working and middle classes. After 9/11, moreover, an exaggerated fear of terrorism led Washington to wage “endless war” in the greater Middle East. Warren charged — and here she echoed any number of progressive critics of U.S. policy over the past century — that American statecraft has become over-militarized and self-defeating.

What is needed, then, is a mixture of reassertion and retrenchment. The U.S. must mobilize for a protracted ideological competition with the authoritarian powers by recommitting to vital practices the Trump administration has neglected. American leaders must revitalize the force-multiplying alliances Trump has strained; they must stand firmly with the world’s democratic leaders rather than the coterie of corrupt autocrats whose company Trump seems to prefer. Washington should also crack down on intellectual property theft, forced technology transfer, and other predatory Chinese economic practices. It should more actively highlight the corruption and despotism of authoritarian regimes. Reinvesting in diplomacy — another course correction from the Trump era — will be crucial to all of these efforts.

Yet if the U.S. should sharpen its approach to ideological competition, she argues, it should also recalibrate key aspects of its involvement in the world. The military dimensions of counterterrorism need to become less aggressive; the forever war in Afghanistan needs to be wound down so a peace settlement can be reached. Military spending should fall significantly to make budgetary room for domestic priorities; the U.S. should forgo expensive investments in updating its nuclear arsenal. Most importantly, the next president must put the promotion of better labor standards, environmental protections, and outcomes for the working and middle classes at the core of America’s trade agenda.

So far, so good. Hollowing out of U. S. manufacturing through ill-considered one-way trade liberalization? Check. Foolish Middle East nation building? Check. Futile forever war in Afghanistan? Check.

However:

As is often the case with campaign-season speeches on foreign policy, however, Warren’s vision also has its unresolved tensions and challenges. The senator is right that the working and middle classes have suffered in recent decades, yet most studies indicate that automation — not trade — is the primary culprit in the hollowing out of American manufacturing. Warren is equally right that the war in Afghanistan is going nowhere fast, yet if the U.S. begins withdrawing now it will probably undercut any chances of getting the acceptable peace agreement she claims to prefer.

More broadly, there is no arguing with the idea that the United States needs a limited-liability approach to counterterrorism. Decelerating too much, however, risks allowing ISIS, al-Qaeda and their various offshoots to reconstitute and operate in more dangerous ways. Additionally, in U.S.-Russia relations, verifiable arms control would surely be preferable to a new arms race with Russia. But absent the leverage re-investment in America’s nuclear arsenal will provide, how will the U.S. bring Moscow back into compliance with the arms control treaties it has systematically violated?

Finally, the idea of slashing military spending is more problematic than it may seem. Here, too, Warren is correct that there are plenty of parts of the defense enterprise that can be streamlined, and the Pentagon is certainly guilty of buying too many expensive legacy systems with limited relevance to future conflicts. The problem, however, is that the U.S. will find it devilishly difficult to succeed in the global competition Warren rightly identifies without significant new military investments. Contrary to what Warren argued, America’s conventional military superiority is no longer so overwhelming. It has eroded badly in Eastern Europe, the Taiwan Strait and other geopolitical hotspots, as Russia and China have developed capabilities meant specifically to deny the U.S. freedom of action.

and I consider this unadulterated poppycock:

The tenfold increase in the number of global democracies since 1940 has ultimately rested on America’s ability to deter aggression by authoritarian powers.

The increase he points to came despite repeated U. S. military interventions rather than because of them. The abortive attempts at democracy and liberalization throughout the world that are now retrenching came because of manifest U. S. economic success. Nothing succeeds like success. Everybody wanted to emulate what had brought U. S. prosperity. As U. S. economic growth slowed and wealth was manifestly being concentrated in ever fewer hands our system became less appealing.

Mr. Brands also need to take a look at the graph I put at the top of this post. The relationship between that collapse and China’s admission to the WTO is obvious. Less obvious is its connection with automation.

That challenge that Sen. Warren faces in enunciating an updated liberal foreign policy is how can you defend progressive values without interventionism? It has been a vital component of progressive foreign policy for a century.

This seems like a good place to repeat my view that increased inequality and loss of hope in the U. S. are a direct consequence of a triple whammy of ill-considered neoliberal policies: one-way trade liberalization, failure to prohibit mostly illegal immigration of low wage workers from Mexico and Central America, and the abuse of H1-B and L1 visas to push down wages for those in the four and lower fifth quintiles of American income earners. It will be interesting to see how Sen. Warren squares that circle. How she stands up for today’s progressive values in foreign policy while primarily arguing for lining the pockets of the elite at the expense of the middle class and the working poor eludes me.

4 comments

The Circus

Unlike Maureen Dowd in her most recent New York Times column:

I’m looking around Scotiabank Arena, the home of the Toronto Maple Leafs, and it’s a depressing sight. It’s two-for-the-price-of-one in half the arena. The hockey rink is half curtained off, but even with that, organizers are scrambling at the last minute to cordon off more sections behind thick black curtains, they say due to a lack of sales. I paid $177 weeks in advance. (I passed on the pricey meet-and-greet option.) On the day of the event, some unsold tickets are slashed to single digits.

I get reassigned to another section as the Clintons’ audience space shrinks. But even with all the herding, I’m still looking at large swaths of empty seats — and I cringe at the thought that the Clintons will look out and see that, too. It was only four years ago, after all, that Canadians were clamoring to buy tickets to see the woman who seemed headed for history.

It’s a sad contrast with the sold-out boffo book tour of Michelle Obama, who’s getting a lot more personal for the premium prices. But introspection has never been within the Clintons’ range.

I can’t fathom why the Clintons would make like aging rock stars and go on a tour of Canada and the U.S. at a moment when Democrats are hoping to break the stranglehold of their cloistered, superannuated leadership and exult in a mosaic of exciting new faces.

What is the point? It’s not inspirational. It’s not for charity. They’re not raising awareness about a cause, like Al Gore with global warming. They’re only raising awareness about the Clintons.

I do not feel a bit sorry for the Clintons. It was always about the Clintons. Never about anything else.

While the circus performance is going on it looks grand and is exciting but as the tents are struck and the equipment packed away just how cheap and tawdry and phony it all was becomes clear. It was always tawdry. It was just grand when the lights were on and the band was playing.

7 comments

No New Tariffs

Presidents Trump and Xi apparently reached an agreement at the recently-concluded G20 meeting that the U. S. would impose no new tariffs at least until February and China would expand its imports from the U. S. The BBC reports:

US President Donald Trump and his Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping have agreed to halt new trade tariffs for 90 days to allow for talks, the US says.

At a post-G20 summit meeting in Buenos Aires, Mr Trump agreed not to boost tariffs on $200bn (£157bn) of Chinese goods from 10% to 25% on 1 January.

China will buy a “very substantial” amount of agricultural, industrial and energy products, the US says.

Meanwhile, Beijing says the two sides agreed to open up their markets.

That was precisely the outcome that the editors of the Washington Post proposed. I wonder what their reaction to the news will be.

Meanwhile, I’m skeptical. The Chinese authorities have had 17 years to live up to the commitments they made when they were admitted to the WTO. Will they really do in just three months what they have refused to do for 17 years? Or will they make promises they have no intention of living up to, assuming that Trump will back down?

Update

From the South China Morning Post Chinese state media sources have confirmed the broad outlines of the agreement:

State-run China Daily and Chinese international broadcaster CGTN both said Trump and Xi agreed to not add additional tariffs “after January 1” – when Washington was set to raise the tariff rate on US$200 billion of Chinese imports from 10 per cent to 25 per cent.

Details of trade truce agreement, including what concessions China made, were not immediately available.

It will be interesting to see the details of this agreement if, indeed, there are any. Sounds like the Chinese got something for nothing to me.

Something I’ve mentioned before bears mentioning. China’s culture and political system practically guarantees that their leaders are smarter and tougher than ours. It’s no accident that we get snookered time and time again.

2 comments

The Kerch Straits Incident

I have refrained from commenting on November 25’s incident in which Russian naval vessels fired on and seized three Ukrainian naval vessels for, according to the Russian government, violating Russian territorial waters. The editors of The Economist remark:

The crisis did not emerge from out of the blue. It is the culmination of six months of growing Russian pressure on Ukraine. Having in 2004 annexed Crimea, Russia is now restricting access from Ukraine’s eastern ports to the Black Sea, and thence to the Mediterranean and the world.

To get to the Black Sea, ships must pass through the Kerch Strait (see map). On May 16th Russia opened a bridge across the strait that is too low for large ships. It also moved five naval vessels from the Caspian to the Sea of Azov. Russia’s coastguard has since then detained scores of Ukrainian and foreign merchant ships—more than 140 between May and August—for hours and even days at a time, in what amounts to an undeclared blockade.

An agreement between Russia and Ukraine in 2003, before Ukraine tried to break away from Russia’s sphere of influence, established joint control of the Sea of Azov. Now both sides of the strait that controls access to it are held by Russia. Immediately after the latest clash, Russia briefly parked a tanker across the waterway, to remind Ukrainians what Vladimir Putin’s promises are worth. Ukrainians fear that his next move will be to take control of the whole of the Sea of Azov—a huge strategic prize—and further endanger the port of Mariupol, Ukraine’s third largest.

The detentions, delays and uncertainty have already strangled eastern Ukrainian ports like Mariupol and Berdyansk. The new bridge has bottled up 144 Ukrainian ships that are too tall to slip under its 33-metre structure. Shipping in and out of Mariupol has fallen by a quarter.

Ukraine cannot fight back. It lost up to 80% of its navy when Crimea was annexed, since most of its ships were moored there and the Russians pinched them. Now, the most formidable vessel owned by Mariupol’s coastguard is an old fishing boat confiscated from Turkish poachers.

Sailing small military vessels from Odessa through the Kerch Strait last week was a “provocation” staged by Petro Poroshenko, Ukraine’s president, said the Kremlin, adding that he wanted to create a crisis and have an excuse to delay presidential elections due next year. Like all shrewd propaganda, it contained an element of truth. Mr Poroshenko, who is badly trailing his rivals in opinion polls, probably did want to rally popular support around the flag and buy himself more time. When Russia escalated the situation, he called for martial law in Ukraine—a move his critics decried as a political stunt.

I have heard other explanations, e.g. that the Ukrainian vessels were preparing to mine the bridge. It seems to me that the simplest explanation is that the Russian government is abrogating its 2003 treaty with Ukraine in which the Sea of Azov, only reachable via the Kerch Straits, at its narrowest point less than two miles wide, was to be under the joint control of the Russian and Ukrainian governments.

But that treaty was signed with a different, pro-Russian government. I condemn unequivocally Russia’s actions which amount to seizing the Sea of Azov. It is not unexpected. There is no conceivable way that Russia will surrender the Port of Sevastopol and even a passing familiarity with Russian history is enough to convince one of that. Russia’s actions in Ukraine were inevitable once U. S.-backed revolutionaries removed the previous government. Now we have a situation in which Russia is annexing Ukraine by degrees.

What should the U. S. reaction to the incident be? I believe that we should condemn it but otherwise not involve ourselves in the conflict between Russia and Ukraine. The present government of Ukraine are neo-fascists. We should not support them. Ukraine must come to a modus vivendi with Russia and arming Ukraine or otherwise supporting its conflict with Russia does not promote U. S. interests.

1 comment

Riots in Paris

Tens of thousands of people are demonstrating and thousands rioting in France. CNN reports:

More than 400 people were arrested and 113 injured in Paris on Saturday in clashes between police and protesters with the “gilets jaune” or “yellow vest” movement, who are protesting rising gas prices and taxes on polluting forms of transport.

An estimated 36,000 people demonstrated in Saturday’s protests across the country Saturday, marking the third consecutive week of such demonstrations, according to the French Interior Ministry. About 53,000 participated last week and about 113,000 the week before.

Griveaux said that between 1,000 and 1,500 people joined Saturday’s demonstrations “only to fight with the police, to break and loot.” He added that those protesters “have nothing to do with the yellow vests.”

Footage shared by French police on Saturday showed a few demonstrators striking a police vehicle and smashing its windshield. Other videos captured burning cars and police firing tear gas to disperse protesters.

French Interior Minister Christophe Castaner had mentioned a state of emergency, Griveaux said. French President Emmanuel Macron, the Prime Minister and the Interior Ministry were scheduled to meet Sunday morning to “take stock of what happened yesterday and the measures we can take to avoid it,” he said. “There is no way each weekend can become a ritual of violence.”

High gas prices and a recent round of gas tax increases, part of the French government’s campaign to reduce France’s use of fossil fuels, are the notional motivations behind the demonstrations.

However, make no mistake. These demonstrations are specifically anti-Macron and the perception that the metropolitan elite are prospering at the expense of the poor, particularly the rural poor. In other words these demonstrations are France’s reaction to the same issues and the same elite strategies with respect to those issues that led to the election of President Trump here.

The American press may love Macron but his approval rating in France is 29%, the same as Theresa May’s, lower than Justin Trudeau’s (40%), and significantly lower than Donald Trump’s (43%), or Angela Merkel’s (47%).

Update

Check out the photos and videos of the rioting in this article from the Daily Mail. For this to be the start of a revolution, as claimed by the protesters:

The centre of Paris was on lockdown tonight after masked protesters stole an assault rifle from police, clashed with riot squads and set fire to cars and Christmas trees on the Champs-Elysees in furious demonstrations against the French government.

Protesters said today’s actions were ‘the start of a revolution’ that would eclipse the mass strikes and occupation of universities and factories in1968 when the country was on the cusp of civil war.

Fires and clouds of tear gas covered the French capital from early morning until late in the evening, in some of the worst violence ever seen in the French capital as more than 5,000 demonstrators brought chaos to Paris for the second week running.

will depend on whether the protests are waxing or waning. For reasons unclear to me (but which I hope someone will explain to me) the recent history of significant French riots suggests that late November-early December is prime riot time.

These riots seem very different to me from the 2005-2007 riots or 2013-2017 ones.

3 comments

Cheaper Hydrogen Catalyst

ScienceDaily reports an interesting discovery:

“Electrochemical water splitting driven by electricity sourced from renewable energy technology has been identified as one of the most sustainable methods of producing high-purity hydrogen.”

Professor O’Mullane said the new composite material he and PhD student Ummul Sultana had developed enabled electrochemical water splitting into hydrogen and oxygen using cheap and readily available elements as catalysts.

“Traditionally, catalysts for splitting water involve expensive precious metals such as iridium oxide, ruthenium oxide and platinum,” he said.

“An additional problem has been stability, especially for the oxygen evolution part of the process.

“What we have found is that we can use two earth-abundant cheaper alternatives — cobalt and nickel oxide with only a fraction of gold nanoparticles — to create a stable bi-functional catalyst to split water and produce hydrogen without emissions.

“From an industry point of view, it makes a lot of sense to use one catalyst material instead of two different catalysts to produce hydrogen from water.”

Professor O’Mullane said the stored hydrogen could then be used in fuel cells.

Although wind and solar have a role in a diverse energy infrastructure, it seems to me that technologies like this are much more likely to enable us to reduce the use of fossil fuels. The most significant barriers to the adoption of fuel cells are distribution infrastructure, safety, and the cost of producing hydrogen. Technologies like this address the third of those barriers.

1 comment

Asylum Ain’t What It Used to Be

Well, well, well. A study from the University of Southern California’s CREATE program has found that by and large refugees and asylum-seekers from Central America are neither refugees nor asylum-seekers:

USC study looking at motivations of asylum seekers from El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras finds that family ties and economic opportunities are important motivators; evidence on the influence of crime and violence is mixed.

Completing a 12-month study on immigration from El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras to the United States, researchers found that juvenile migrants are primarily motivated by economic opportunities and reunification with family members, while economics have motivated adult migrants. The study found mixed evidence on the impact of crime and violence on migration from these countries.

exactly as I’ve been saying. It also supports another point I’ve been making. A more effective, smarter way to enforce our laws is at the employer level rather than building a wall. Universal biometric ID, an improved e-Verify system, and increased even criminal penalties for knowing violation will help us enforce our laws and take the pressure off the border.

8 comments

The Right Direction?

I think that John Micklethwait’s piece in Bloomberg, claiming that China is “inching in the right direction”, teeters between being maliciously wrong and just plain delusional:

Dec. 18 is the 40th anniversary of the third plenary session of the 11th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China, which was the moment in 1978 Deng Xiaoping started opening up China’s economy. Xi is likely to unveil a series of commemorative reforms; foreign banks that have been waiting to take bigger stakes in their Chinese joint ventures may well find the approval process is speeded up.

So China is inching in the right direction. Its task is made harder by Trump’s enormous unpredictability. His tweets do not just move markets, but also the heart rates of Chinese civil servants who have to interpret his intentions to President Xi.

So, Lucy, how is that football came coming along? China promised greater participation in its banking system 17 years ago and continues to yank the football away.

But I’ll bite. Precisely how is concentrating more power in President Xi’s hands “inching in the right direction”? Militarization of the South China Sea? Building a worldwide network of military bases? Enormously expanding its “blue sea” navy?

And is this true at all?

China’s biggest handicap is its public inability to admit that it has done anything wrong, when on issues like intellectual property it obviously has. This not only makes other countries and businesspeople cross, it leaves the Chinese mystified with what the famous British philosopher Monty Python might call the bleedin’ obvious.

That’s China’s biggest handicap? I would think that lack of a robust system of civil law, demographics, a banking system filled to the gills with non-productive loans, capital flight, and its self-undermining of its own environment were all bigger handicaps. Not to mention public corruption which in China’s case is not episodic but endemic.

3 comments

George H. W. Bush, 1924-2018

George H. W. Bush has died. From USA Today:

HOUSTON — George Herbert Walker Bush, the president who managed the end of the Cold War and forged a global coalition to oust Iraqi forces from Kuwait, has died at age 94. In a political career that spanned three decades, he lost his bid for re-election and lived to see his son win the Oval Office.

The death of Bush — nicknamed “41” to distinguish himself from son George W. Bush, “43” — was announced in a statement released late Friday.

“Jeb, Neil, Marvin, Doro and I are saddened to announce that after 94 remarkable years, our dear Dad has died,” his son, former President George W. Bush, said in a statement released by family spokesman Jim McGrath. “George H.W. Bush was a man of the highest character and the best dad a son or daughter could ask for. The entire Bush family is deeply grateful for 41’s life and love, for the compassion of those who have cared and prayed for Dad, and for the condolences of our friends and fellow citizens.”

I don’t have a great deal to say about the late President Bush. I voted for him in 1992 because I believe that foreign policy, the military, and the administration of the federal government are the primary responsibilities of the president, Mr. Bush was well-qualified for those tasks, and his opponents were neither qualified in the areas of primary presidential responsibility nor men of good character.

I didn’t vote for him without reservations. I thought the Gulf War was an error. That we continued to bomb Iraq over the period of the next 11 years supported that view. Leaving Saddam Hussein in power was the price that Mr. Bush paid for his coalition, a devil’s bargain.

I hope it is not lost on the editors of the New York Times and Washington Post, presently heaping encomiums on the late President Bush, that their endorsements of Bill Clinton in 1992 contributed materially to Donald Trump’s election in 2016. If you value character, you should reward it.

1 comment