Most Covered Songs

In the aftermath of my post on most important composers of popular song of a few days ago, I began researching the statistics on which songs have been the most “covered”, i.e. most professional recordings by different performers. My first reacton is that I don’t believe a lot of the reports. For example, I don’t believe there are as many covers of “I Can’t Get No Satisfaction” as are claimed.

However, the importance of John Lennon and Paul McCartney can hardly be exaggerated. While I don’t believe the claims of millions of covers, I do believe that “Eleanor Rigby” and “Yesterday” have each been covered more than 150 times.

I also think that any article that doesn’t include “Silent Night” among the songs that are most covered is probably a fraud. Just about every recording artist of any significance records a Christmas album (some do many of them) and nearly every Christmas compilation includes “Silent Night”.

2 comments

My Last Word on Brexit

Unlike the punditry I have not been fulminating on Britain’s decision to exit the EU, known as “Brexit”, for the following reasons:

  1. How much of the United Kingdom’s sovereignty to surrender is completely an issue to be decided by Britons.
  2. They had a referendum. They decided to leave the EU.
  3. Any movement to keep holding referenda until the desired result (stay) is reached is scurrilous.
  4. Liberal democratic government means doing what the people want at least some of the time. Even if you think it is stupid or harmful.
  5. If they want guillotines to start being erected in town squares, elites should just keep doing what they’re doing.

I don’t think there’s anything else to say. It’s not any of my business.

7 comments

What “Birthrate Crisis”?

I was prepared to detest Megan McArdle’s most recent Washington Post column, “Can immigration save the U.S. from its birthrate crisis?”:

The primary asset of any society is its people. That’s true in the lofty spiritual sense and in the crass financial one: Other people produce both the economic goods and the tax revenue that sustain the nation.

Like any other asset, this one needs to be replenished by continual reinvestment. A society that stops replacing itself is like a trust-fund kid dipping into the capital. The accounts empty at an accelerating pace, and a bill eventually comes due that cannot be paid.

Virtually the entire rich world is now in varying stages of that cycle.

but, as she acknowledges in the next sentence, the U. S. does not have a birthrate crisis. After considering U. S. policy she lands in the right place:

An immigration solution to the United States’ demographic challenge would probably mean a very different immigration policy, something like the points system used by countries such as Canada and Australia, which selects for migrants reasonably fluent in English and likely to be net tax contributors. Family reunification, which reinforces the United States’ historical bias in favor of low-skill migration, might well have to be curtailed.

While we do not have a birthrate crisis, we do have a pair of other crises, both of which are exacerbated by uncontrolled immigration. The first of these crises is a productivity crisis. Consider these two graphs. The first depicts labor productivity:

while the second depicts marginal labor productivity:

Take particular note of the circled sections on the righthand side of each chart. What they tell us is that there has been a change. The return on investment in labor is not growing as it once was. Indeed, if you could extend that chart all the way back to 1790 you would see how much has changed over the years. We don’t need more workers. We need fewer workers with low skills and more with higher skills. At its best higher education only addresses the second part of that equation and at that only if higher education actually brings more productivity which would require us to be more restrictive in the sort of higher education we’re subsidizing.

The other crisis is a crisis of social inequality which is being made worse by income inequality. But that’s a topic for another post.

One last thing that should not be neglected in this discussion. Japan has actual population decline, very low immigration, and no crisis. They have no crisis because labor productivity continues to rise and income equality is much greater there than here. In other words even with a birthrate below the replacement rate the welfare of the population can grow as long as productivity continues to rise and the benefits of that increase are spread across the population.

The basic question is what sort of society do you want? If you want a stratified society with a permanent underclass, just keep doing what we’re doing.

2 comments

These Are Our NATO Allies

First, an army without bullets. Now, per the National Interest, an air force without planes:

One-third of Britain’s military aircraft isn’t available to fly, according to British media.

“Figures unearthed by freedom of information campaigners show 142 of 434 of the air force’s planes have been sidelined,” said the British tabloid Daily Mirror.

Some planes and helicopters have been mothballed, while others are down for major maintenance. The problem spans numerous models, including the Royal Air Force’s flagship fighter, the Eurofighter Typhoon.

“Military top brass revealed 55 of the 156 Typhoon jets are in the RAF’s ‘sustainment fleet’ – and not in its ‘forward fleet’ ready to be deployed on operations,” the Mirror said. Even aircraft in the forward fleet, which should be available for operations, are down as “short-term unserviceable aircraft.”

In addition to the Typhoons, “five out of 20 Atlas A400M transport planes are in the sustainment fleet – despite the first of its type only being delivered in 2014,” said the Mirror.

We’re getting our wish. When you infantilize your allies, you shouldn’t be surprised when they behave like infants.

5 comments

Aux Barricades Mes Enfants!

I’m afraid that Gavin Mortimer is engaging in wishful thinking in his piece at the Spectator:

What France (and the rest of Europe) is witnessing is not a populist revolt but a politically incorrect one. People have had enough of being mocked and marginalised by what George Orwell described as ‘a dreary tribe of high-minded women and sandal-wearers and bearded fruit-juice drinkers who come flocking towards the smell of ‘progress’ like bluebottles to a dead cat.’

The difference between now and 1936, when Orwell wrote that pungent depiction, is that then the ‘dreary tribe’ had no influence. They were swept into cultural power in the 1960s but they are in the process of being swept back out in the second decade of the 21st Century. This will be hard to bear for progressives after a half-century of hegemony. The silent majority has found its voice and it demands it be listened to. A failure to do so will have dire consequences for Europe.

We’ll see. I think the “dreary tribe” has a much more secure grasp on power in Europe than it does here.

1 comment

Religious Tests?

Should the U. S. Constitution be amended to remove the “no religious test” clause from Article VI? Here it is:

All Debts contracted and Engagements entered into, before the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be as valid against the United States under this Constitution, as under the Confederation.

This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.

The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the Members of the several State Legislatures, and all executive and judicial Officers, both of the United States and of the several States, shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; but no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States.

6 comments

Why Worry About Iran?

In his Wall Street Journal column Walter Russell Mead remarks on the Trump policy with respect to the Middle East:

In seeking a reduced Middle East presence and retreating from expansive human-rights goals, both Team Obama and Team Trump have reacted to significant changes in American politics. Public support for U.S. military action and democracy promotion in the Middle East has all but collapsed, for two reasons. First, decades of engagement in the region have brought neither stability nor democracy. Second, as America’s dependence on Middle East energy recedes, many voters see less reason to prioritize the region. Pundits can argue that these reactions are shortsighted, but politicians must take them into account.

The Trump administration hopes that with limited American support, Israel, Turkey and the Sunni Arab countries can together contain Iran. If so, Mr. Trump can claim credit for improved Israeli-Arab ties and a more stable region even as he cuts back on American troop and aid levels. This is a sounder strategy in the abstract than the Obama team’s gamble on Iranian restraint. U.S. relations with the Sunni Arab powers, Israel and Turkey are sometimes difficult, but a policy based on continued cooperation with them is more feasible than subordinating their interests to chase after an improved relationship with the deeply hostile regime in Tehran.

Yet the Trump plan also has significant drawbacks. The first is that, as the Hudson Institute’s Michael Doran points out, it unites the president’s domestic critics. Many of Mr. Trump’s staunchest critics in the conservative foreign-policy establishment continue to support the George W. Bush strategy of muscular engagement and democracy promotion. They are appalled by both Mr. Trump’s desire to retreat from the region and his willingness to work with autocrats like Egypt’s President Abdel Fattah Al Sisi and Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.

Team Obama, meanwhile, may be out of power but remains influential among opinion makers and pundits. And it knows a Saudi alliance is America’s only alternative to the Iran outreach of the Obama era. The Obama lobby has therefore joined the neoconservatives in the hopes of using public horror at the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, revulsion at the humanitarian cost of war in Yemen and unease about the deplorable state of human rights in Mr. Sisi’s Egypt to disrupt the Trump administration’s Middle East strategy.

I understand the desire to reduce the U. S. footprint in the Middle East because I share it. However, I don’t see much to choose among Turkey, Iran, and Saudi Arabia. They’re all reprehensible Islamist regimes. I also don’t understand the particular burr under our collective saddle about Iran. The Iranians are self-containing for a simple reason: they aren’t Arabs. Any notion that the Arab Middle East will unite behind an Iranian banner is far-fetched in the extreme. I can understand why the Israelis hate Iran. All of that rhetoric is pretty frightening to a country that can be destroyed by one bomb. As far as I’m concerned the Israelis are entitled to their own country as long as they’re willing to defend it. They’re not entitled to expand into Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan.

If anything Dr. Mead understates how colossal a failure our Middle East policy has been over the last 25 years. We’ve succeeded wonderfully in promoting everybody’s interests but our own. That’s what the European outrage over the change in U. S. policy has been—they’re concerned we might pursue our own interests. The United States can only be trusted as long as it’s working against its own interests.

2 comments

Pay the Piper


The editors of the Wall Street Journal think Los Angeles teachers are being unrealistic in asking for higher pay:

‘Here we are on a rainy day, in the richest country in the world, in the richest state in the country, in a state as blue as it can be and in a city rife with millionaires, where teachers have to go on strike,” United Teachers Los Angeles president Alex Caputo-Pearl declared Monday. Here we are with another teachable moment in the failures of public union governance.

The 33,000-strong L.A. teachers’ union went on strike Monday as the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) slouches toward insolvency due to unaffordable labor contracts. Despite a putative $1.8 billion reserve, the district is spending about $500 million more each year than its annual revenues and will be broke within two years, which could prompt a state takeover and bankruptcy.

Los Angeles teachers earn on average about $75,000 per year—about $6,000 less than the statewide average—though compensation including health and retirement benefits exceeds $110,000. One problem is the region’s high housing costs make it harder to retain teachers while more and more money is diverted to benefits and pensions.

In this case the editors are wrong. I have said before that my opinion is that there should be some relationship between the pay of civil servants and income in the communities they serve. Consider the chart above. Median income in LA County has been rising sharply. It is not unreasonable for LA’s teachers to think their pay should rise as well.

I think that LA’s problem is that Prop 13 limits property tax revenue, the city cannot impose an income tax, and sales taxes are severely regressive. Incomes are very unequal in Los Angeles—it is the fourth worst metro area in the U. S. after New York, Miami, and New Orleans (Chicago is 15th). There are costs associated with the decisions that Los Angeles and California has made over the years. Pony up.

5 comments

Autres Pays

CNN reports that the Chinese government has sentenced a Canadian to death for drug-dealing:

Beijing (CNN)Relations between Beijing and Ottawa are at crisis point after a Canadian man was sentenced to death by a Chinese court, a former Canadian ambassador to China told CNN.

Canada’s foreign ministry issued a travel warning late Monday to its citizens in China over “the risk of arbitrary enforcement of local laws.” It came in the wake of the death sentence handed to Robert Lloyd Schellenberg during a one-day retrial in the city of Dalian.

Schellenberg had initially appealed a 15-year prison sentence for being an accessory in a plot to smuggle more than 222 kilograms (489.4 pounds) of methamphetamine from the northeastern port city to Australia in November 2014. But during the retrial, the court sided with the prosecution, which claimed to have uncovered new evidence proving Schellenberg’s principal role in the case.

I point this case out not to highlight how awful the Chinese regime is but as yet another example of different countries being different with different values and different laws. When you travel to another country, you should expect the laws and customs of those countries to apply to you and, in the case of countries in which the rule of law may be somewhat capricious, their arbitrary decisions apply to you, too.

That doesn’t just apply to Americans or Canadians travelling abroad. That pertains to Chinese and Saudis here in the United States as well. If you want your own country’s laws to apply to you, stay home.

0 comments

Higher Yet

There is a story I once heard about Frederick II, called “the Great”, of Prussia. According to the story in the midst of battle Frederick, who unlike many military commanders rode at the head of his army, and while wearing a uniform without identifying insignia, rested in a haystack. Next to him in the haystack was a sergeant. As they got to talking the sergeant proposed a game. He asked Frederick if he could guess his rank. “Private?” said Frederick. “Higher yet” replied the sergeant. “Corporal”. “Higher yet” replied the sergeant. “Sergeant?” “That’s it” said the sergeant, satisfied. Frederick then asked the sergeant to guess his rank. “Corporal?” “Higher yet”. “Sergeant?” “Higher yet”. “Lieutenant?” “Captain?” “Major?” “Higher yet”. “General?” “Higher yet”. The sergeant began to tremble. “Your Excellency is, a, a, Field Marshall?” “Higher yet”. The sergeant threw himself to the ground. “Your majesty! Forgive me! I did not recognize you”.

You may recall that back in 2017 there was a collision between the guided-missile destroyer Fitzgerald and a private vessel off the coast of Japan that took the lives of seven sailors. At the time I suggested a greater lapse of discipline. Well, the report has leaked out and it confirms what had concerned me about the story. From the Navy Times:

Obtained by Navy Times, the “dual-purpose investigation” was overseen by Rear Adm. Brian Fort and completed 11 days after the June 17, 2017 tragedy.

It was kept secret from the public in part because it was designed to prep the Navy for potential lawsuits in the aftermath of the accident.

Unsparingly, Fort and his team of investigators outlined critical lapses by bridge watchstanders on the night of the collision with the Philippine-flagged container vessel ACX Crystal in a bustling maritime corridor off the coast of Japan.

Their report documents the routine, almost casual, violations of standing orders on a Fitz bridge that often lacked skippers and executive officers, even during potentially dangerous voyages at night through busy waterways.

The probe exposes how personal distrust led the officer of the deck, Lt. j.g. Sarah Coppock, to avoid communicating with the destroyer’s electronic nerve center — the combat information center, or CIC — while the Fitzgerald tried to cross a shipping superhighway.

When Fort walked into the trash-strewn CIC in the wake of the disaster, he was hit with the acrid smell of urine. He saw kettlebells on the floor and bottles filled with pee. Some radar controls didn’t work and he soon discovered crew members who didn’t know how to use them anyway.

Fort found a Voyage Management System that generated more “trouble calls” than any other key piece of electronic navigational equipment. Designed to help watchstanders navigate without paper charts, the VMS station in the skipper’s quarters was broken so sailors cannibalized it for parts to help keep the rickety system working.

Since 2015, the Fitz had lacked a quartermaster chief petty officer, a crucial leader who helps safely navigate a warship and trains its sailors — a shortcoming known to both the destroyer’s squadron and Navy officials in the United States, Fort wrote.

Fort determined that Fitz’s crew was plagued by low morale; overseen by a dysfunctional chiefs mess; and dogged by a bruising tempo of operations in the Japan-based 7th Fleet that left exhausted sailors with little time to train or complete critical certifications.

To Fort, they also appeared to be led by officers who appeared indifferent to potentially life-saving lessons that should’ve been learned from other near-misses at sea, including a similar incident near Sasebo, Japan that occurred only five weeks before the ACX Crystal collision, Fort wrote.

LtJG Coppock has already been found guilty of dereliction of duty. The trials of the commanding officer and the officer responsible for the operations room of the Fitzgerald are still pending.

My reaction on reading this story was “higher yet”.

11 comments