A 70% Marginal Rate

I wonder if those who are touting a 70% marginal personal income tax rate for the highest earners realize that such a thing would cement the very inequality and influence of the wealthy they claim to oppose? As was the case 60 years ago, very few would pay it. They would lobby to get exemptions and get them. Pay to play, baby.

17 comments

What’s An Acceptable Compromise?

If you do not think that the deal that President Trump offered to the Democrats to reopen the government was an acceptable compromise, what would be? If you oppose any compromise, please indicate that.

I think that a reasonable potential counter-offer would be a longer extension or even requiring that the legalization of the status of the so-called “Dreamers” be made permanent. They don’t have a mens rea. Demanding that they pay a fine or that citizenship be permanently foreclosed to them is not reasonable. Contrariwise, demanding that the deal be extended to the parents of the “Dreamers” is wrong, too. They do have a mens rea and there should be substantial consequences.

12 comments

Subsidies for the Rich

I basically agree with Ross Marchand’s post at RealClearPolicy about Tesla:

But when the going gets tough, Tesla knows it can at least count on subsidies from various governments. The company, for instance, is only midway through a gargantuan ten-year $1.25 billion tax credit deal with Nevada, and can continue to pay far lower taxes than its competition as long as it maintains some manufacturing and properties in the state. The state hoped to pay for the tax credits by ending tax credits for the film industry, but due to overly rosy projections on how much business the film credits were supposed to bring in, the revenues didn’t nearly offset. According to data from the Nevada Department of Taxation, the film tax credit wind down has so far only offset around half of Tesla’s use of $173 million in tax credits thus far.

But Tesla is at least having some production success in Nevada, in stark contrast to their failed Gigafactory 2 project in New York. Musk promised that, if New York agreed to give Tesla $750 million to build a solar panel plant in Buffalo, Tesla would create 1,500 jobs for the region. Yet only one production line has been set up, and the factory employs less than 1,000 workers, according to Tesla’s head of energy operations. The deal was originally inked for Musk-owned SolarCity, which then had nearly $3 billion in debt and was eventually folded into Tesla. The consolidation came amidst a huge downturn in solar installations. Bloomberg reports that, “The company’s solar deployments are down more than 60 percent from their peak under SolarCity, and Tesla has laid off thousands of solar employees around the U.S.”

When dealt a bad hand, Tesla doubles down and…departs for China. While it’s difficult to estimate how much money Tesla is receiving from the Chinese government, Teslarati reports that the company “does enjoy the favor of the Chinese government,” including the benefit of an uncontested bid for the 860,000 square meter plot of land needed for their new Shanghai car factory and special, low-interest loans to defray 30 percent of factory costs.

There is, of course, nothing wrong with setting up shop in new states or countries in response to market conditions. Over the past several decades, the liberalization of international commerce has amped up the pace of globalization, lifting billions of people out of poverty. But in Tesla’s case, relentless subsidy shopping has left taxpayers high-and-dry, ensuring that few jobs are created in exchange for sky-high bills. While it is too late for tax and subsidy bills to be taken back, policymakers should learn from the sorry case of Tesla and keep sweetheart deals to a minimum. If Tesla can’t thrive in an area without relying on government largesse, then the best company offering the best services to consumers should win the day.

Whatever the sales pitch we shouldn’t be subsidizing the purchase of status symbols by the well-to-do and I feel confident that relatively few of the lower middle class or working poor are buying $100,000 automobiles. I don’t know the precise terms of the subsidy but the sticker prices of the vehicles for which they are available should be capped at something closer to $30,000 than to $100,000.

My view of Tesla is that it is and always has been a rent-seeking company with a sideline making and selling stylish EVs to the well-to-do. I see no reason for it to exist if it can’t make it on its own.

4 comments

Do “Disruptive” Companies Have a Lifecycle?

At Forbes Stephen McBride makes some thought-provoking observations about Apple. The lowest price for the latest iPhone is $1,149—500% of what you would have paid for an iPhone eight years ago. Each year for the last several years Apple has been selling fewer phones. iPhones are two-thirds of Apple’s overall sales. Cutting prices won’t help them.

A publicly traded company that makes most of its money from selling phones is no longer telling investors how many phones it sells!

And its other business lines can’t pick up the slack for falling iPhone sales.

Twenty percent of Apple’s revenue comes from iPads and computers. Those segments are also stagnant.

Which means 86% of Apple’s business is going nowhere.

Could Apple go the other way and slash iPhone prices?

I ran the numbers.

If Apple cut prices back to 2016 levels, it would have to sell 41 million additional phones just to match 2018’s revenue.

The larger point that he raises is that there may be a lifecycle to these disruptive tech companies. Back in 2007 Nokia was cock of the smartphone walk. Its stock has declined 80% since then. Is it Apple’s turn now?

6 comments

About That Chinese Slowdown

A lot of people are remarking on the reported slowing of the Chinese economy. Here’s the Washington Post’s reaction:

The slowdown in the final quarter of the year was not quite as bad as many economists were expecting, reaching 6.4 percent.

But many economists take official Chinese figures with a large pinch of salt. Using a range of data to come up with a more reliable figure, Julian Evans-Pritchard, a China analyst at the Capital Economics consultancy, said that the growth rate probably slowed to 5.3 percent in last three months of the year.

Regardless of the number, the direction is clear, and the slowdown is being felt nationwide.

A few quicktakes:

  1. As noted, if the official number if 6.4%, the actual growth rate is probably lower.
  2. We’d be pretty happy with a 5.3% growth rate.
  3. It has been widely speculated that the Chinese authorities believed that a very rapid growth rate was necessary to preven unemployment and subsequent unrest. China’s working age population is declining and will do so for a number of years moving forward. Do they need as much growth as they did, say, ten years ago?
  4. There will be run-on effects. Expect the economies of South Korea, Japan, Vietnam, and Taiwan to slow as well.

Will China’s slowing economy spark a global recession? Will it spark an Asian recession? Stay tuned.

0 comments

My Only Remark on the Covington Story

We shouldn’t have to re-report stories.

13 comments

Kamala Harris Announces

California Sen. Kamala Harris has just announced her candidacy for the presidency. I will not vote for her.

5 comments

39th Ward Aldermanic Candidates

Chicago’s 2019 aldermanic elections will take place in two rounds, the first round to be held just about a month away on February 26 and the second on April 2. Our aldermanic elections are notionally non-partisan but practically single party. In the ward in which I reside, Chicago’s 39th Ward, all of the candidates running are Democrats.

Since the incumbent alderman of the 39th Ward, Marge Laurino, has elected not to run for re-election, for the first time in 50 years no member of the Laurino family will be running in the election. There are presently three candidates: Robert Murphy, Samantha Nugent, and Casey Smagala.

The Chicago Tribune asked a number of questions of the candidates:

  • What do you see as the city’s number one challenge in the next four years?
  • Do you favor or oppose a city-owned casino in Chicago?
  • Do you favor or oppose electing Chicago’s school board?
  • How should CPS respond to shrinking enrollment?
  • What’s your game plan for reducing violent crime?
  • What’s your strategy for dealing with the city’s pension crisis?
  • Should the use of TIFs continue or should they be phased out? Explain your reasoning.
  • How would you address the city’s problems with lead in drinking water?
  • If you believe Chicago needs new tax revenue, where do you think it should come from?
  • What should the city council do to make itself more independent from the mayor’s office?
  • What’s the most pressing issue facing the people of your ward and how would you address it?

Their answers may be found here. You’ll need to scroll down to the 39th Ward. Alternatively, they allow you to filter to just the 39th Ward. Apparently, their web designers are unaware of local anchors.

There was substantial agreement among the candidates on the issues. All mentioned public pensions as a major issue if not the #1 challenge. All favored a city-owned casino. All opposed increasing property taxes. Several mentioned marijuana legalization (in the context of increasing city revenue). None had a good answer for a more independent city council. A graduated state income tax was frequently mentioned.

I thought the best answer to the last question came from Robert Murphy:

What I hear most from residents of my ward is that they are not getting the services they pay for, and that they feel locked out of major decisions and have no voice. The other issues are strong local schools, fixing the city’s financial crisis and making sure we are investing in our neighborhoods, in our infrastructure and in our local businesses. I am running to bring better services to the ward and to create a transparent ward office and process.

Here in the 39th Ward we’re not opposed to paying taxes. If we were we wouldn’t be living in Chicago at all. We do think we should be receiving value for what we pay and, presently, that is not the case.

I have substantial disagreements with all of the candidates. For example, I wonder if they’re aware that every study of the effects of legalized casino gambling has shown that most of the revenue comes from local residents and that they function as a steeply regressive tax? Or that the revenue effects of marijuana legalization have been disappointing? Here’s the Kansas Fed’s assessment of Colorado’s experience:

As detailed above, much of the tax revenue collected from the marijuana industry goes toward costs incurred by the state related to the expansion of the marijuana sector. The additional revenue primarily funds education and the general fund. To put those revenue amounts in perspective, in total, the Colorado Department of Education received $90.3 million in marijuana tax revenue for the 2017-18 school year, or 1.6 percent of the state’s total K-12 education budget.xxii Revenues from the special sales tax on recreational marijuana have totaled about $108.4 million to date in fiscal 2018. Starting next year, the general fund will receive 15.56 percent of those revenues, which if applied this year would have equaled about 0.2 percent of general fund revenues to date in fiscal 2018.

Chicago cannot depend on gambling or marijuana tax revenues to solve its fiscal problems. The only thing that can do that is economic growth and that must be fostered by reducing corruption and crime, improving the regulatory environment, and holding the line if not reducing taxation. Doing those things simultaneously would be no mean feat—it would require a complete re-engineering of city government.

As the late Mayor Daley once said, regardless of how things look now somebody will be elected. I thought that Samantha Nugent’s CV was impressive and I was also impressed by Casey Smagala’s command of the details. At this point I’ll probably vote for Robert Murphy. I thought he had the best and most practical views. Sadly, I’ll believe in his independence from City Hall when I see it.

0 comments

Last Words

It has long been observed that a baby’s first word is typically “mama”. Infant language and child language have been studied in considerable detail for more than a century. As revealed in this piece at Atlantic by Michael Erard the last utterances of the dying have been much less studied:

Felix’s 53-year-old daughter, Lisa Smartt, kept track of his utterances, writing them down as she sat at his bedside in those final days. Smartt majored in linguistics at UC Berkeley in the 1980s and built a career teaching adults to read and write. Transcribing Felix’s ramblings was a sort of coping mechanism for her, she says. Something of a poet herself (as a child, she sold poems, three for a penny, like other children sold lemonade), she appreciated his unmoored syntax and surreal imagery. Smartt also wondered whether her notes had any scientific value, and eventually she wrote a book, Words on the Threshold, published in early 2017, about the linguistic patterns in 2,000 utterances from 181 dying people, including her father.

Despite the limitations of this book, it’s unique—it’s the only published work I could find when I tried to satisfy my curiosity about how people really talk when they die. I knew about collections of “last words,” eloquent and enunciated, but these can’t literally show the linguistic abilities of the dying. It turns out that vanishingly few have ever examined these actual linguistic patterns, and to find any sort of rigor, one has to go back to 1921, to the work of the American anthropologist Arthur MacDonald.

There have been records of dying utterances for millennia. Onw my favorites is what Charlie Chaplin was alleged to have said just before dying. After a priest performed the last rites, saying “May the Lord have mercy on your soul”, Chaplin is said to have responded “Why not? After all it belongs to Him.”

I think that most of the reported last words of the famous are fictions—words put into their mouths by others. As it turns out, hospice nurses have reported that what many people say at the end is “mama”.

4 comments

Wanted: Better Spokesmen

Nearly a century ago when asked if he were a member of an organized political party, Will Rogers responded, no, he was a Democrat and what I’ve been seeing today on the Sunday “talking heads” programs completely supports that view. We’ve seen it before: surrogates fan out to answer the press’s questions about one thing or another and that’s happening today. What I’m seeing today just reminds me of Casey Stengel’s lament about the 1962 Mets: can’t anybody here play this game?

One after another they’ve acknowledged agreement with every single one of the Trump Administration’s talking points while continuing to blame everything on Trump. They should get their stories straight.

One of the points on which the most spectacularly wrong statements have been made is the necessity of the Trump Administration’s going through the Democrats’ House leadership. They absolutely do not have to do that. All they need to do is get 25 House Democrats to vote with them. Unless they are very careful the House Democratic leadership may sideline themselves.

5 comments