Thinking About the Cholesterol Controversy

There’s an article at Science-based-Medicine on the controversies associated with cholesterol that I found interesting and wanted to commend to your attention. Unsurprisingly, it reaches the conclusion that high cholesterol is bad for you:

We have moved past diet studies for lowering cholesterol. Women are included in studies. There is a mortality benefit. Statins (and other medications) do work by lowering LDL. Statins are now generic. There are alternative to statins if you have side effects. The thing about the cholesterol controversy is that most of it has been settled.

Some issues remain. Maybe it is better to measure to non-HDL cholesterol or ApoB cholesterol instead of LDL cholesterol. But this is a subtle point, and finding a better way to measure something does not negate the underlying truth that high cholesterol increases the risk of heart disease.

There was a time when someone could be skeptical about the role of cholesterol in cardiac risk reduction. That time has now past.

but some of the other observation may (or may not) surprise you for example that diet studies are by and large terrible and that the populations in drug trials haven’t been random sample, indeed, have been very biased. I don’t think that the author addresses that issue enough. Historically, the participants in early drug trials have overwhelmingly been white middle-aged men, frequently from within single social strata.

Some other things that the author touches on but does not consider enough IMO are that we don’t know nearly enough about what is normal or about subgroups within populations.

5 comments

How Prices Are Set

I had to laugh when I read this article at Fortune about the prices charged by hospitals for pharmaceuticals:

A new study shows something many healthcare patients know all too well: hospitals are charging significant premiums on some of the most-used prescription drugs.

In a new study of 34 hospital systems, Wall Street firm AllianceBernstein found that the average drug prices in a hospital are three to seven times higher than what Medicare charges for the same medication, according to Axios, which obtained a copy of the study. Academic hospitals, which provide care and also train new doctors, had the highest markups on medications. AllianceBernstein also found that generic drug prices at all the hospital systems tended to be higher than brand-name medications.

Here’s the punchline:

Within the AllianceBernstein study, an unnamed CEO at a pharmaceutical company said that prices on oncology drugs, in particular, need to remain high. If they didn’t, the person said, “every hospital in the country will go broke.”

or, in other words, the prices charged by hospitals for pharmaceuticals have no relation to costs. They’re to pay the hospital’s “burden”—the wages of hospital administrators, physicians, nurses, techicians, maintenance staff, and so on.

What amused me about this was that I learned that the way real companies, particularly big companies, set prices is not what you learned in economics class. I’d be interested in a description of what kind of micromanaging government policy would remedy this situation without addressing the underlying problem. The problem is, as succinctly stated by the CEO of the Mayo Clinic some years ago, too many people making too much money.

5 comments

If We Don’t Do It

An article at PR Newswire supports a point I’ve been making for years:

WASHINGTON, Feb. 10, 2019 /PRNewswire/ — Cost recovery for electric sector cybersecurity investments and development of resilience metrics to gauge the industry’s progress are two of several recommendations unveiled today by Vermont Law School researchers who briefed the Critical Infrastructure Committee of the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC) on the findings of a six-month study of electric grid security.

The study, conducted for Protect Our Power by the law school’s Institute for Energy and the Environment (IEE), recommends that state utility commissions exercise their authority to increase the flow of confidential information regarding vulnerabilities and best practices. It also identifies the diversity of regulatory approaches to cybersecurity regulation by utility commissions across the country as a concern that warrants attention and improvement.

“Addressing anticipatory threats such as cyberattacks is a challenge that we are not fully meeting,” said Mark James, assistant professor of energy law and a senior research fellow, who led the institute’s research team. “As interconnections between and within distribution systems increase, the vulnerability of the electric grid also increases. Continuous communication between utilities and their regulatory commissions is the first step to improving the depth, quality and consistency of efforts to address cybersecurity vulnerabilities.”

Resiliency of the power grid is a public good (non-rivalrous and non-exclusionary) and it is not one that individual power companies will ever pay for. They would prefer to take the risk of a catastrophic failure and face the outcome in the courts than pay the substantial amounts required to prevent the catastrophic failure in the first place. If you need an example of that look at the recent brouhaha about PGE in California.

When infrastructure bills are discussed grid resiliency rarely makes the list. It’s too invisible to make a good candidate and those it would employ are the wrong people and there are not enough of them.

0 comments

Those Unwilling to Work

The idea of paying people who are unwilling to work might have more traction than we think. We have been paying the members of Congress for years.

1 comment

Standing

As might have been expected the editors of the New York Times are unhappy about President Trump’s designation of the situation at our southern border as an emergency, the better to make good on his campaign promise of building a wall without authorization or appropriations from the Congress:

In reality, the wall is not a done deal, and Mr. Trump has spent the past few months — the past two years, really — failing to convince either Congress or Mexico to pay for it. This week’s bipartisan spending bill, which contained no more wall money than the one over which Mr. Trump shut down the government in December, was a particularly humiliating defeat.

Desperate to save face, the president and his team cooked up a nonemergency emergency with the aim of seizing funds already appropriated for other purposes. Currently, the plan is to pull $2.5 billion from the military’s drug interdiction program, $3.6 billion from its construction budget and $600 million from the Treasury Department’s drug forfeiture fund. The White House plans to “backfill” the money it is taking from the Pentagon in future budgets.

The lawsuits challenging the president’s decision are already flooding the courts:

Even as he spun this as an act of strong leadership, Mr. Trump acknowledged that his declaration resolves nothing and creates a host of legal, legislative and political troubles. He predicted that the move would prompt swift legal pushback, which it did. Less than four hours after the announcement, a government watchdog group filed suit, demanding that the Department of Justice hand over “documents concerning the legal authority of the president to invoke emergency powers.” Soon after, the State of California announced its intention to sue. On Thursday, even before the announcement, Protect Democracy and the Niskanen Center announced plans to file on behalf of El Paso County and the Border Network for Human Rights. So the floodgates are open.

What drives me to the point of screaming are the bitter laments about abrogation of the rule of law. A bit late with that warning, chief.

Let’s consider the rule of law aspects of this issue a bit starting with national emergencies and ending with legal standing. There are presently thirty some-odd national emergencies presently declared in the United States and, presumably, still in progress, the oldest declared by Jimmy Carter and the most recent two declared by Donald Trump.

Of his own power the president does not have the authority to declare a national emergency and that authority cannot reasonably be inferred from the president’s constitutional authority. That authority was granted to the president by the National Emergency Act of 1977. I’ve read it. It is absurdly broad. It can be construed to give the president the authority to declare a national emergency any time he or she cares to for any reasons he or may see fit and do practically anything he or she cares to.

Here’s the rub. The Congress does not itself have the authority to enact such a law let alone delegate such powers to the president. You will search the Constitution in vain for that power among the Congress’s enumerated powers and it cannot reasonably be inferred from any of those actual powers. Depending on their state constitutions, the legislatures of the states may have the legal authority to allow their governors to declare state-level emergencies but that’s irrelevant to the issue of national emergencies.

The common law is pretty clear on this issue, too. “Emergency powers” cannot be construed in as broad a manner as the National Emergency Act does.

There are several clear remedies available. The Congress can repeal the National Emergency Act which would be my preference. If a case brought by an individual with proper legal standing were to make it through the courts, in theory the Supreme Court could declare the National Emergency Act unconstitutional which would be a fine outcome as well. If they were to reject the Congress’s ability to delegate its constitutional authority to the executive, that would be good, too. The likelihood of their of those outcomes is practically nonexistent.

To have legal standing one of three conditions must be met:

  1. The party must be directly adversely affected.
  2. If not directly adversely affected, the case must have some relation to the party’s situation.
  3. The law must give the party automatic standing.

I do not believe any of those conditions applies to any of the organizations that have filed suit to date. Indeed, it’s difficult for me to see what organization or individual would have standing. That is not to say that some court some where might not see legal standing for some one some how. But this post is about the rule of law not about the court’s ability to torture the law into arriving at a desired outcome. That’s not remotely the rule of law.

So, Congress, do your danged job. Repeal the National Emergency Act and start doing your own danged job. If anything less happens, let’s not whine about abrogation of the rule of law, shall we? What we’re seeing is the juridification of differences of opinion on policy.

Update

The editors of the Washington Post are no happier:

The emergency for Mr. Trump is purely political, impelled by expectations inflated by his campaign promises to build a border wall and force Mexico to pay. Having conflated a political crisis with a national one, Mr. Trump chooses to dodge, dissemble and lie. A self-respecting Congress would not let stand this manufactured emergency.

which approaches my position.

Shame on you, Congress. You created this debacle. Now fix it.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal point out that two wrongs don’t make a right:

Democrats cheered on Barack Obama’s legal abuses on immigration and so much more, and now many Republicans are cheering President Trump’s declaration of a border emergency to build his wall. Constitutional conservatives should be wary of both.

President Obama unilaterally expanded the rules for asylum and immigration, an abuse of authority. I thought the Congress should have acted to remedy that as well.

1 comment

Seeing It As I See It

I am glad to see that at least one person sees the problem with high-speed rail in the United States as I see it. That person is Jake Bacharach at HmmDaily:

American infrastructure is this costly because of immense, endemic, universal public-private corruption—systems of both direct and financialized graft at every stage of infrastructure development, from the planning to the ribbon-cutting to the use of deferred maintenance to ransack public transportation budgets for cash, year after year, after which the responsible authorities claim that fixing the century-old signals is just too damn pricey. This system of legal fraud begins with the bevies of project consultants, continues through ludicrous private contractor and labor costs, and continues when, years later, high-paid administrative fixers and new armies of consultants and contractors arrive to fix what broke because it was never maintained. It is a system of tolerated kleptocracy that may be the only thing that America still does better than anyone else in the world. It is baked into every assumption about building for the public benefit.

That isn’t true only of high-speed rail. It’s true of education, health care, the military, and every other action of government at any level in the United States. It will be true of a “Green New Deal” is such a thing were to be embarked upon. It is why we pay more for just about anything than anyone else in the world. Can we fix these things? Yes, we can. Will we? The smart money says “No”.

0 comments

Chicago Corruption

A recent report from a pair of scholars at the University of Illinois, Chicago, found that Chicago is the most corrupt city in the United States:

During 2017, the latest years for which figures from the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) are available, there were 25 public corruption convictions in the Northern District of Illinois, which includes all of Chicago and the northern third of Illinois. This is down from 30 in 2016 and down from an average of 33.6 per year over the last 10 years. There were a total of 34 cases of public corruption convictions in all of Illinois, proving that public corruption is not just a big city problem.

Statistics compiled by the DOJ’s Public Integrity Section show that from 1976 through 2017, a total of 1,731 individuals were convicted of public corruption in the Northern District of Illinois (Chicago). In the same time period, the Central District of California (Los Angeles) convicted 1,534; the Southern District of New York (Manhattan), 1,327; Florida Southern (Miami) 1,165; and the District of Columbia (Washington), 1,159. These five districts, Chicago, Los Angeles, Manhattan, Miami and Washington D.C. led all of the 93 federal judicial districts for the 47-year period since 1976.

The complete report can be found here (docx).

The same report found that Illinoisis the third most corrupt state but that’s misleading since they’re including Washington, DC as a state. Among actual states Illinois’s only real competition is Louisiana, a distinction of sorts since Louisiana is notoriously corrupt.

However, make no mistake Los Angeles, New York, and Miami are highly corrupt as well. Size and corruption go hand in hand.

It also bears mentioning that many of the candidates presently running to be Chicago’s next mayor have connections to the corrupt Illinois Democratic establishment and in all likelihood one of them will ultimately be elected. Short version: little future improvement is likely.

0 comments

You Get More of What You Subsidize

I frequently complain about subsidies around here and I thought I’d provide a few examples of it. The FAA and federal air traffic controllers are, effectively, subsidies to air travel and cities. They aren’t entirely funded by excise taxes and fees. About 15% of FAA expenses which funds both air traffic controllers and other FAA personnel are funded from general revenues. Part of TSA funding is paid by a $2.50 per passenger tax; the rest comes from general revenues.

The effect of this subsidization is to encourage air travel. If you want to discourage air travel, a good place to start would be by leveling the playing field and increasing fees and excise taxes to fund the FAA and TSA fully.

There have recently been proposals to subsidize renters, generally people who pay 30% or more of their incomes in rent, some of the proposals calling for the subsidies to include people who earn $100,000 per year. Such proposals would in general subsidize people who choose to live in high-rent areas, mostly in large cities. It would also take the pressure off cities to increase their population density. Note that the policies that lead to high rents are primarily under the control of state and local governments.

2 comments

On Deaf Ears

In her latest Wall Street Journal column Peggy Noonan pleads with Republicans to “save capitalism”:

The American establishment had to come to look very, very bad. Two long unwon wars destroyed the GOP’s reputation for sobriety in foreign affairs, and the 2008 crash cratered its reputation for economic probity. Both disasters gave those inclined to turn from the status quo inspiration and arguments. Culturally, 2008 was especially resonant: The government bailed out its buddies and threw no one in jail, and the capitalists failed to defend the system that made them rich. They dummied up, hunkered down and waited for it to pass.

Americans have long sort of accepted a kind of deal regarding leadership by various elites and establishments. The agreement was that if the elites more or less play by the rules, protect the integrity of the system, and care about the people, they can have their mansions. But when you begin to perceive that the great and mighty are not necessarily on your side, when they show no particular sense of responsibility to their fellow citizens, all bets are off. The compact is broken: They no longer get to have their mansions. They no longer get to be “the rich.”

For most of the 20th century the poor in America didn’t hate the rich for their mansions; they wanted a mansion and thought they could get one if things turned their way. When you think the system’s rigged, your attitude changes.

On the right the same wars, the same crash, and a different aspect. In the great issue of the 2016 campaign it became unmistakably clear that the GOP elite did not care in the least how the working class experienced immigration. The party already worried too much about border security—that’s the lesson the elites took from Mitt Romney’s loss in 2012, according to their famous autopsy. They appeared to look after their own needs, their own reputations: We’re not racist like people who worry about the border! They were, as I’ve written, the protected, who looked down on those with rougher lives. The unprotected noticed, and began to sunder their relationship with establishments and elites.

Donald Trump came of that sundering. He was the perfect insult thrown in the establishment’s face. You’re such losers we’re hiring a reality-TV star to take your place. He’ll be better than you.

Conservatives regularly attend symposia to discuss the future of conservatism. Republicans in Washington stumble around trying to figure what to stand for beyond capitalizing on whatever zany thing some socialist said today.

But isn’t their historical purpose clear? Their job—now and in the coming decade—is, in a supple, clever and concerted way, to save the free-market system from those who would dismantle it. It is to preserve and defend the capitalism that made America a great thing in the world and that, for all its flaws and inequities, created and spread stupendous wealth. The natural job of conservatives is to conserve, in this case that great system.

a plea I feel confident in predicting will fall on deaf ears for a simple reason: there is precious little capitalism to save. As documentation I submit the enormous degree of business consolidation. That consolidation hasn’t occurred naturally. It’s been abetted by government action or, at least in the United States, inaction.

Lately we’ve been hearing many bitter complaints contrasting capitalism and socialism but that’s largely misdirection. What we presently have are competing groups of rent-seekers and I see no prospects for anything different. Contrasting millennials with Baby Boomers is misdirection, too. The Congressional leadership like the political leadership in Illinois is preponderantly composed of members of the Silent Generation who accumulated power and fortune through systematic corruption. If they throw the baby out with the bath water you can rest assured that it won’t be their baby.

0 comments

Perpetual Emergency

It is being widely speculated that President Trump will declare a national emergency and start building his wall. From CNN:

Washington (CNN)President Donald Trump plans to sign a compromise border security measure Friday and then announce that he is using executive action, including declaring a national emergency, to spend $8 billion for border barriers, a White House official said.

The move will end, for now, a bitter standoff with Congress over his signature campaign promise. But it will likely spark a new constitutional dispute over whether the President is overstepping his authority.

The initial news of Trump’s decision came via Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, who said Trump would sign the bill to avoid a shutdown and then declare a national emergency at the same time.

The White House official says Trump is expected to announce that he will use executive action to draw on a variety of administration funding sources to help finance construction of his wall on the border. A national emergency declaration is expected to be one part of that.

An unnamed “White House official” is barely competent reporting let alone a castiron guarantee but, if Mr. Trump does goes ahead and build his wall, it will be anticlimactic. That has been speculated for months. The inevitable court challenges will be anticlimactic as well.

There is already a constitutional crisis under way but it’s been under way for more than a half century. The Congress has been delegating its powers to the executive branch with alarming and unconstitutional regularity. If the Supreme Court refuses to rule on delegation, as the past would suggest, it will continue our headlong march to autocracy, created by the refusal of the Congress or the Supreme Court to do their own damned jobs.

The editors of the New York Times declaim in preemptive reaction:

With his intention to declare a national emergency at the southern border, President Trump is planning to take executive overreach to dizzying new heights. The damage to American democracy threatens to linger long after his administration is no more than a dank memory.

Cornered into accepting a budget deal that lacked the $5.7 billion in border-wall funding he demanded, the president could not handle being labeled a loser by conservative commentators like Laura Ingraham and Sean Hannity. His solution: Sign the bill while simultaneously declaring a national emergency that, at least in his mind, would allow him to shift funds and order the military to start building his wall.

That the authority to do that may already have been delegated to the president by the Congress never seems to occur to them.

Update

President Trump issued his declaration of emergency this afternoon. Here is the text of the statement:

The current situation at the southern border presents a border security and humanitarian crisis that threatens core national security interests and constitutes a national emergency. The southern border is a major entry point for criminals, gang members, and illicit narcotics. The problem of large-scale unlawful migration through the southern border is long-standing, and despite the executive branch’s exercise of existing statutory authorities, the situation has worsened in certain respects in recent years. In particular, recent years have seen sharp increases in the number of family units entering and seeking entry to the United States and an inability to provide detention space for many of these aliens while their removal proceedings are pending. If not detained, such aliens are often released into the country and are often difficult to remove from the United States because they fail to appear for hearings, do not comply with orders of removal, or are otherwise difficult to locate. In response to the directive in my April 4, 2018, memorandum and subsequent requests for support by the Secretary of Homeland Security, the Department of Defense has provided support and resources to the Department of Homeland Security at the southern border. Because of the gravity of the current emergency situation, it is necessary for the Armed Forces to provide additional support to address the crisis.

NOW, THEREFORE, I, DONALD J. TRUMP, by the authority vested in me by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, including sections 201 and 301 of the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.), hereby declare that a national emergency exists at the southern border of the United States, and that section 12302 of title 10, United States Code, is invoked and made available, according to its terms, to the Secretaries of the military departments concerned, subject to the direction of the Secretary of Defense in the case of the Secretaries of the Army, Navy, and Air Force. To provide additional authority to the Department of Defense to support the Federal Government’s response to the emergency at the southern border, I hereby declare that this emergency requires use of the Armed Forces and, in accordance with section 301 of the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1631), that the construction authority provided in section 2808 of title 10, United States Code, is invoked and made available, according to its terms, to the Secretary of Defense and, at the discretion of the Secretary of Defense, to the Secretaries of the military departments. I hereby direct as follows:

Section 1. The Secretary of Defense, or the Secretary of each relevant military department, as appropriate and consistent with applicable law, shall order as many units or members of the Ready Reserve to active duty as the Secretary concerned, in the Secretary’s discretion, determines to be appropriate to assist and support the activities of the Secretary of Homeland Security at the southern border.

Sec. 2. The Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of the Interior, the Secretary of Homeland Security, and, subject to the discretion of the Secretary of Defense, the Secretaries of the military departments, shall take all appropriate actions, consistent with applicable law, to use or support the use of the authorities herein invoked, including, if necessary, the transfer and acceptance of jurisdiction over border lands.

Sec. 3. This proclamation is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States, its departments, agencies, or entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any other person.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand this fifteenth day of February, in the year of our Lord two thousand nineteen, and of the Independence of the United States of America the two hundred and forty-third.

IMO this is a bad precedent and the inevitable court challenges will be bad precedent as well.

3 comments