The Canary In the Coal Mine

I have been cautioning Americans about this for decades but little did I realize that the canary in the coal mine would turn out to be the United Methodist Church. The shortest statement of the issue that I can come up with is that as society becomes more global it will become more socially conservative.

Let me quickly summarize events for you. In the United States the UMC has been losing members at the rate of about 100,000 per year while in Africa it has been gaining members at an equal rate. With increasing membership has come increasing influence over church policy. Most recently that has taken the form of a rejection of a liberalizing plan at the recent meeting of the denomination’s general conference last month.

Now I’ll turn it over to Methodist layman Mark Tooley, from his op-ed in the Wall Street Journal:

The surge in African growth has flummoxed America’s liberal Methodist elites. Ascendant for 100 years, they long assumed their denomination naturally would follow Episcopalians, Presbyterians, Lutherans, Congregationalists and others in liberalizing on sexuality. But every quadrennial conference since 1972 has affirmed sex as permissible only between husband and wife.

Liberals sometimes defy church law when making local personnel decisions. In 2016 United Methodism’s U.S. Western Jurisdiction elected a lesbian bishop married to a woman. The church’s top court ruled her election illegal but claimed to lack the power to remove her. In response to events like this, bishops called last month’s special conference to adjudicate a final church settlement on sexuality.

Most U.S. bishops touted the “One Church Plan,” which would have let local churches choose their own policies on same-sex marriage. This proposal resembled other liberalizing denominations, which have suffered schisms and accelerated membership losses after such moves. The Methodist delegates defeated this measure 55% to 45%.

In its place, by a vote of 53% to 47%, U.S. conservatives joined international representatives to pass the “Traditional Plan.” It enhances enforcement of current church teaching and allows liberal regions and churches to leave with their property if unwilling to abide. But it isn’t that simple: The United Methodist denomination owns its congregations’ buildings. Parts of the new plan, including the exit provision, may have to be refined next year at a conference in Minneapolis.

If we want the sexual, social, political, and economic mores we’ve been cultivating over the last century or so to flourish, it will need to be in a walled garden. Most of the world and particularly the parts of the world that are growing and from which we should expect our immigrants to come for the foreseeable future do not view them as good, right, or the way they think that anybody should live.

A globalized America will more closely resemble the worlds of Islam or conservative Christianity than it does Sweden. Increasingly, Sweden looks a lot less like Sweden.

5 comments

Pritzker’s Graduated Income Tax

Some details of Illinois Gov. Pritzker’s graduated income tax proposal have emerged. The Chicago Tribune reports:

If voters approve an amendment, Pritzker proposes lowering the tax rate to 4.75 percent for the first $10,000 of income for single and joint filers. Income between $10,000 and $100,000 would be taxed at 4.9 percent, and the rate would remain 4.95 percent for income between $100,000 and $250,000.

From there, the top rates would be 7.75 percent for income up to $500,000, 7.85 percent for income between $500,000 and $1 million, and 7.95 percent for all income if someone earns more than $1 million.

The governor also proposes increasing the current property tax credit by 1 percentage point, from 5 percent to 6 percent. He also would create a per-child tax credit of up to $100 for individuals earning less than $80,000 and joint filers earning less than $100,000.

Similar measures have been proposed in the past. None has ever gotten as far as the ballot because they’ve failed to garner the required three-fifths vote of each house in the legislature. I’m still waiting, as I have since the subject was first broached, for Gov. Pritzker to release the names of legislators who’ve committed their votes to the required amendment. I don’t think he has any.

Meanwhile, here’s a proposal that I do not believe would require an amendment to the state’s constitution. End the exemption to the state’s income tax for public employees receiving more than $150,000 in pensions from the state. That doesn’t run afoul of either the flat tax provision or the enforceability clause in the state’s constitution.

C’mon, governor. Put a down payment on your proposed reforms.

2 comments

Riddle Me This

I have a riddle for you this afternoon.

Q: What do Chinese imports and illegal immigrants have in common?

A: They both tend to increase when the U. S. economy is growing.

My preference would be to reduce both of those without relying on a poorly performing economy to do it for us. We can reduce Chinese imports by doing more primary production and manufacturing here even if we have to subsidize them. We can reduce the incentives for illegal migrant workers the same way the Canadaians and Australians do—by making it difficult for those without the proper authorizations to work.

0 comments

With Folded Hands

There’s an intriguing post on how the U. S., Russian, and Chinese militaries are approaching artificial intelligence at Foreign Policy. Here’s a snippet:

China, the United States, and Russia are each negotiating this fraught landscape differently, in ways responsive to their unique economic and military situations. Governments are motivated to pursue leadership in AI by the promise of gaining a strategic advantage. At this early stage, it’s tough to tell what sort of advantage is at stake, because we don’t know what sort of thing AI will turn out to be. Since AI is a technology, it’s natural to think of it as a mere resource that can assist in attaining one’s goals, perhaps by allowing drones to fly without supervision or increasing the efficiency of supply chains.

But computers could surpass humans in finding optimal ways of organizing and using resources. If so, they might become capable of making high-level strategic decisions. After all, there aren’t material limitations restricting the intelligence of algorithms, like those that restrict the speed of planes or range of rockets. Machines more intelligent than the smartest of humans, with more strategic savvy, are a conceptual possibility that must be reckoned with. China, Russia, and the United States are approaching this possibility in different ways. The statements and research priorities released by major powers reveal how their policymakers think AI’s developmental trajectory will unfold.

Since I was in grad school, “artificial intelligence” has been a grab bag of not particularly related technologies. Artificial neural networks have been around for nearly 80 years. Pattern matching algorithms for at least 60 years. Inference engines and expert systems for around 50 years. Data mining, too, is around 50 years old (although the term “data mining” is only around 30 years old). Indeed, there hasn’t actually been a lot of basic innovations in artificial intelligence.

What has changed is the cost of hardware and the ability of computers to share information. Many unsophisticated people confuse applying old technology using new hardware with new technology. Even some sophisticated people do that.

I think that a lot of how any country applies artificial intelligence to its military depends on two things: what it thinks of its military and how concerned they are about not getting there first. If you don’t think much of your military and you’re very worried about somebody else getting there first, I think you’ll use the strategy that China is. If you think highly of your military but aren’t as worried about somebody else getting there first, you’ll use the strategy that our military is.

0 comments

The Presidency and Foreign Policy

Article II, Section 2 of the U. S. Constitution defines the primary roles and responsibilities of the president:

The President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several States, when called into the actual Service of the United States; he may require the Opinion, in writing, of the principal Officer in each of the executive Departments, upon any Subject relating to the Duties of their respective Offices, and he shall have Power to Grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.

He shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur; and he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law: but the Congress may by Law vest the Appointment of such inferior Officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the Courts of Law, or in the Heads of Departments.

The President shall have Power to fill up all Vacancies that may happen during the Recess of the Senate, by granting Commissions which shall expire at the End of their next Session.

to which should be added the first sentence of Article II, Section 1:

The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.

Numerous things are not listed among the responsibilities of the president including:

  • Ensuring that all Americans have health care
  • Being an inspiration in times of national tragedy
  • Leading his political party

Those and many, many other things are accretions to the presidency, like barnacles on a boat. The things at the top of this post are the actual responsibilities of the president. They are the things I keep in mind when cast my vote for president. They are the reasons I voted for Barack Obama rather than John McCain in 2008. I disagreed too profoundly with McCain’s “national greatness” approach to foreign policy. They are also the reasons I did not vote for Barack Obama in 2012. He was egregiously wrong too much of the time on foreign policy.

That’s why I approve of these observations from William Galston in his Wall Street Journal column:

A presidential campaign is an audition for the most challenging job in the world. But the Democrats vying for their party’s nomination don’t seem to understand what that job really is. People with White House experience know that presidents spend more than half their time—often much more—dealing with foreign policy and national security. Thus far, Democratic candidates have had little to say about these issues.

and

Two decades of war without end have exhausted the patience of the American people. Mr. Trump has used this sentiment to attack the entire postwar consensus of American foreign and defense policy, and he has twisted anti-interventionism into a zero-sum choice between domestic and foreign interests. If working- and middle-class Americans are struggling, he argues, it is the fault of foreign trade, foreign wars and foreign invaders streaming unchecked across our southern border.

Democratic presidential candidates are not free to ignore this narrative. Whatever their strategists and pollsters may say, every presidential candidate should deliver at least one major speech answering some basic questions:

Do you think America’s longstanding alliances serve our national interests? If so, what will you do to preserve and strengthen them? How will you counter threats from Russia and Iran, as well as a surging China rapidly translating its economic growth into diplomatic clout and military might? Is the Middle East still vital to our interests, or is our engagement there a diversion from more important matters?

Is America’s military the right size, and does it have the right shape, to address core threats to national security? What is the relationship between national security and international trade? If the global democratic tide is receding, how much should we care and what are we prepared to do about it?

In domestic policy, voters often issue specific orders to their elected officials. In foreign policy, they give the president broad permission to act on their behalf. As they examine aspirants for our highest office, they are asking themselves, “Can I imagine this person as commander in chief?” Democratic candidates should give voters some basis to answer this question.

There will be many lessons to be learned from the Trump presidency but here are some that I hope will be learned. We can no longer delegate the prosecution of justice to the Justice Department. We can no longer delegate our foreign policy to the State Department. They cannot be trusted with those responsibilities. We need to elect someone to the presidency who can be trusted with those responsibilities and we won’t accomplish that by electing someone who simply isn’t interested in foreign policy. Foreign policy is something that happens to presidents. It’s the nature of the job. It cannot be escaped.

10 comments

Fix the National Emergencies Act

I agree with the editors of the New York Times about this:

Senator Charles McC. Mathias, a Republican from Maryland who was a chief sponsor of the legislation, called President Gerald Ford’s signing of the bill “a historic act of relinquishing powers of the presidency” and envisioned it would be a tool for “restoring constitutional democracy.”

But in the more than 40 years that the National Emergencies Act has been in effect, it’s been subject to few checks and balances. That Congress has never invoked its own authority under the act to rebuke a president until now is a sign of the statute’s weaknesses.

The resolution now before Congress serves mainly to nullify Mr. Trump’s border emergency declaration. But further reforms are called for to protect the nation from future excesses.

For one thing, the National Emergencies Act doesn’t define what an emergency is — a loophole that Mr. Trump took advantage of by declaring that there’s a crisis at the border, contrary to all evidence. Congress could set clearer parameters, allowing a president to declare emergencies only when threats to the national interest are imminent and based on observable facts.

The current law also lets the president extend emergencies for years on end, simply by notifying Congress. Lawmakers would be wise to vest in Congress, rather than the president, the ability to extend an emergency. And even then, the time period for an emergency ought to be capped — no more semi-permanent emergencies of the sort that are still lingering on the books from as far back as the late 1970s. If a crisis becomes a nonemergency still requiring legislative action, Congress can address it the best way it knows how — by passing a bill.

The current standoff also shows that the law must be clarified to explain that being denied congressional funds toward achieving a policy goal is not, in fact, grounds for declaring an emergency.

It is clear, at least to me, that the president’s ability to declare a national emergency that will never end on his sole authority for any reason he sees fit is an affront to our constitutional system and to the rule of law. Regardless of what motivated those who enacted the National Emergencies Act in the first place they clearly did not go far enough. It is long past time to remedy that. It’s already taken 40 years too long.

1 comment

The People’s Choice

At the Chicago Tribune Dahlene Glanton makes a similar point to the one I did about the Chicago mayoral primaries:

Voters on the South and West sides overwhelmingly supported Willie Wilson, a black self-made millionaire who never had a real chance of winning citywide support. But Wilson won 14 predominantly African-American wards.

Here’s the bottom line: In a race that drew only 34 percent of the registered voters to the polls, white people in Chicago decided that it was time to have an African-American female mayor. That has never happened in our city.

In other words Chicago’s black voters cast their votes for the real non-establishment candidate, Willie Wilson. Chicago’s white voters cast their votes for better known but not-quite-so-anti-establishment candidates. Who happened to be black.

That’s quite a change from the “Council Wars” Harold Washington days.

But it also is a warning shot across the bow for Democratic leaders. Take note!

1 comment

World History In Two Sentences

In an article at Worlcrunch about the present Chinese leadership by Andrej Mrevlje, there’s an excellent summary of world history over the last 20 years in just two sentences:

Joining the WTO helped China grow enormously. They were able to create their middle class while the West’s shrunk dramatically, and then U.S. voters vengefully elected populist President Donald Trump in 2016.

I’m also reminded of a quote, spuriously attributed to Lenin: a capitalist will sell you the rope you use to hang him.

1 comment

From Here to There (But There’s No Back Again)

David Brooks is worried, too, but his worries are about the path from our present health care system to a single-payer system. From his most recent New York Times column:

It sounds good. But the trick is in the transition.

First, patients would have to transition. Right now, roughly 181 million Americans receive health insurance through employers. About 70 percent of these people say they are happy with their coverage. Proponents of Medicare for all are saying: We’re going to take away the insurance you have and are happy with, and we’re going to replace it with a new system you haven’t experienced yet because, trust us, we’re the federal government!

The insurance companies would have to transition. Lots of people work for and serve this industry. All-inclusive public health care would destroy this industry beyond recognition, and those people would have to find other work.

Hospitals would have to transition. In many small cities the local health care system is the biggest employer. As Reihan Salam points out in The Atlantic, the United States has far more fully stocked hospitals relative to its population and much lower bed occupancy than comparable European nations have.

If you live in a place where the health system is a big employer, think what happens when that sector takes a sudden, huge pay cut. The ripple effects would be immediate — like a small deindustrialization.

Doctors would have to transition. Salary losses would differ by specialty, but imagine you came out of med school saddled with debt and learn that your payments are going to be down by, say 30 percent. Similar shocks would ripple to other health care workers.

The American people would have to transition. Americans are more decentralized, diverse and individualistic than people in the nations with single-payer systems. They are more suspicious of centralized government and tend to dislike higher taxes.

My worries are a bit different. The fiscal rationale of the entire scheme assumes that we will hold the line on reimbursement rates and that’s something I see no will to do. If the Congress had been willing to hold the line on Medicare reimbursement rates 50 years ago or even 20 years ago, we wouldn’t be in the fix we’re in now, spending significantly more than any other country in the world. If the consequence of “Medicare for All” is to raise all reimbursement rates to those of private insurance and continue to increase the reimbursement rates at a multiple of the growth of non-GDP annually, no foreseeable system of financing will render it affordable.

And keep in mind that once we’ve torn down the private insurance system, if the new system fails, there’s no way to get back. It’s like a parachute jump. If you miss the target, you can’t jump back up into the plane and try it again.

14 comments

Summers Against MMT

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Lawrence Summers expresses his worries about American politicians embracing Modern Monetary Theory:

First, it holds out the prospect that somehow by printing money, the government can finance its deficits at zero cost. In fact, in today’s economy, the government pays interest on any new money it creates, which takes the form of its reserves held by banks at the Federal Reserve. Yes, there is outstanding currency in circulation, but because that can always be deposited in a bank, its quantity is not controlled by the government. Even money-financed deficits cause the government to incur debt.

Second, contrary to the claims of modern monetary theorists, it is not true that governments can simply create new money to pay all liabilities coming due and avoid default. As the experience of any number of emerging markets demonstrates, past a certain point, this approach leads to hyperinflation. Indeed, in emerging markets that have practiced modern monetary theory, situations could arise where people could buy two drinks at bars at once to avoid the hourly price increases. As with any tax, there is a limit to the amount of revenue that can be raised via such an inflation tax. If this limit is exceeded, hyperinflation will result.

Third, modern monetary theorists typically reason in terms of a closed economy. But a policy of relying on central bank finance of government deficits, as suggested by modern monetary theorists, would likely result in a collapsing exchange rate. This would in turn lead to increased inflation, increased long-term interest rates (because of inflation), risk premiums, capital fleeing the country, and lower real wages as the exchange rate collapsed and the price of imports soared.

I think that Dr. Summers is missing a number of the subtleties in the idea. Because the dollar remains the world’s primary reserve currency there’s a lot more demand for dollars than there is for, say, the Venezuelan bolivar. That provides more leeway for U. S. spending than would otherwise be the case.

Also, as long as production outstrips spending I think it’s true that we can spend more than we take in.

Where MMTers and I disagree is that I think there’s more risk than many of them do, the risk may emerge suddenly and without warning, and the consequences would be catastrophic.

Where serious, sensible modern monetary theorists and I agree is that I don’t think we need to balance running a deficit in one year with running a surplus in some other year. As long as our deficits are relatively small we can run them indefinitely. However, talk of running deficits in the tens of trillions (without commensurate expansion of production) worries me, too.

3 comments