I have been cautioning Americans about this for decades but little did I realize that the canary in the coal mine would turn out to be the United Methodist Church. The shortest statement of the issue that I can come up with is that as society becomes more global it will become more socially conservative.
Let me quickly summarize events for you. In the United States the UMC has been losing members at the rate of about 100,000 per year while in Africa it has been gaining members at an equal rate. With increasing membership has come increasing influence over church policy. Most recently that has taken the form of a rejection of a liberalizing plan at the recent meeting of the denomination’s general conference last month.
Now I’ll turn it over to Methodist layman Mark Tooley, from his op-ed in the Wall Street Journal:
The surge in African growth has flummoxed America’s liberal Methodist elites. Ascendant for 100 years, they long assumed their denomination naturally would follow Episcopalians, Presbyterians, Lutherans, Congregationalists and others in liberalizing on sexuality. But every quadrennial conference since 1972 has affirmed sex as permissible only between husband and wife.
Liberals sometimes defy church law when making local personnel decisions. In 2016 United Methodism’s U.S. Western Jurisdiction elected a lesbian bishop married to a woman. The church’s top court ruled her election illegal but claimed to lack the power to remove her. In response to events like this, bishops called last month’s special conference to adjudicate a final church settlement on sexuality.
Most U.S. bishops touted the “One Church Plan,†which would have let local churches choose their own policies on same-sex marriage. This proposal resembled other liberalizing denominations, which have suffered schisms and accelerated membership losses after such moves. The Methodist delegates defeated this measure 55% to 45%.
In its place, by a vote of 53% to 47%, U.S. conservatives joined international representatives to pass the “Traditional Plan.†It enhances enforcement of current church teaching and allows liberal regions and churches to leave with their property if unwilling to abide. But it isn’t that simple: The United Methodist denomination owns its congregations’ buildings. Parts of the new plan, including the exit provision, may have to be refined next year at a conference in Minneapolis.
If we want the sexual, social, political, and economic mores we’ve been cultivating over the last century or so to flourish, it will need to be in a walled garden. Most of the world and particularly the parts of the world that are growing and from which we should expect our immigrants to come for the foreseeable future do not view them as good, right, or the way they think that anybody should live.
A globalized America will more closely resemble the worlds of Islam or conservative Christianity than it does Sweden. Increasingly, Sweden looks a lot less like Sweden.






