Liberal Democracy Is Under Assault

I urge you to read Andrew A. Michta’s essay at The American Interest. Here is his peroration:

Unmoored from its cultural heritage and increasingly ignorant of its history, the West is fragmenting along racial, ethnic, and ideological lines. In the United States the process is well under way of transforming “e pluribus unum” into an American Balkans in which warring groups squabble over past grievances—real and imagined—and where a sense of patriotism and the mutuality of obligation so fundamental to a nation under a republican form of government is being purged from the culture. Here America is not alone, as similar undercurrents of unfreedom are deconstructing some of the oldest political traditions in Europe.

He cites some chilling statistics, e.g. that 90% of American colleges have speech codes that limit discourse and that 2/3s of Americans don’t think they’re free to speak their minds.

I don’t think that his concerns should be merely dismissed as insignificant.

3 comments

The Big Problem

The big problem with Ryan Cooper’s ardent defense of the Green New Deal, expressed at The Week:

If we consider climate policy realistically, then that would clearly involve considering how big the problem is, reasoning from there how fast emissions need to come down, and then what policies could get us there. If the scientists are overstating their case, then why, and by how much? If the greens are wrong about policies, which ones are better? But Stephens does not discuss details in the slightest, only gesturing vaguely towards “large-scale investments in climate resilience, such as better coastal defenses.” How about it, Bret: Would it be cheaper to decarbonize the economy, or abandon the whole of the Miami metro area to the rising seas?

But conversely, this is why the Green New Deal framework makes so much sense. It starts with the problem — greenhouse gas emissions — and sets up a goal to get them down in time, while making society more egalitarian in the process. The policy space, therefore, is ecumenical. Nothing that cuts emissions is ruled out — leaving space for a carbon tax, subsidies for zero-carbon transportation, enormous investment in zero-carbon energy (including nuclear), and moon-shot research investments to develop zero-carbon industry and agriculture that could then be adopted worldwide.

I daresay it’s a fairly pragmatic approach. If you study the conclusions of climate science even cursorily, the truth is that we have procrastinated so long that we pretty much have to go full-tilt at everything with a decent chance of getting emissions down. Penny-ante political moderation can not possibly get the job done.

is that no amount of ideological purity is a viable substitute for what works. It’s hard to make a confident statement about the GND, pro or con, in the absence of specifics but here’s a specific: we can’t maintain a global economy or modern agriculture on the basis of 100% renewables. Said another way 100% renewables means hundreds of millions of dead and dying people. Germany’s all-renewables policy thrust is resulting in its producing more carbon emissions rather than fewer. Here’s another: unless China and India stop emitting carbon nothing we do will make a damned bit of difference.

17 comments

Too Old

I agree with Richard Cohen’s assertion in his most recent Washington Post column. Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders are too old to be president:

Government statistics tell us that a man Biden’s age will live an average of 11 more years. He won’t, however, outlive Sanders, who is scheduled to kick five months later. These, though, are statistical averages, and neither Sanders nor Biden is anything of the sort. They are both white, middle-class by birth and not likely to overdose on drugs, drive drunk or get into a bar fight with someone wearing a MAGA hat, the dunce cap of our times. I am not sure if Sanders works out, but Biden sure does. I have been to the gym with him.

But while looking good may be the best revenge, it isn’t the whole story. The brain ages. It slows down. It forgets. I know men in their 90s — Henry Kissinger comes to mind — who seem as sharp as they’ve ever been, but they are not the rule. It is not necessary to have great mental energy to get elected — President Trump is an intellectual sloth — but it helps. Old age can turn the delight in doing certain tasks into a plodding burden.

The old seek their own comfort zones. I wouldn’t be surprised if Biden thought Snapchat was a breakfast cereal. I wouldn’t be surprised if Sanders thought Drake was the English pirate who defeated the Spanish Armada. (How’s that for being an influencer?) It’s fine not to know about these things, but it suggests an unfamiliarity with a world that is ever-changing. The zeitgeist is forever on the move. When you’re over 70, it may well have passed you by.

IMO all of the declared candidates have very serious flaws which their supporters would do well not to to dismiss. If whether Kamala Harris is “black enough” becomes a taboo topic, I think it brings up severe questions about whether the Democrats can win at all in 2020. And the same question may be asked of Cory Booker albeit for different reasons. Many of the candidates are lacking in relevant experience.

I like some of the candidates, e.g. Booker and Hickenlooper, for very different reasons. I can imagine myself voting for them. I can imagine myself voting for Biden. I hope that Democrats don’t make the mistake of thinking that they can throw any candidate against the wall and win in 2020. That’s not going to happen.

3 comments

The Opposite Side of the Coin

There is an obverse side of the coin I mentioned yesterday. Blacks are moving to somewhere. They’re not just leaving Detroit, Chicago, New York, and Philadelphia. In some cases blacks are moving from inner cities to the collar suburbs. From Woodlawn and Chatham to Maywood, Hazel crest, and Dolton. But about half are just moving away. They’re moving to Atlanta, Richmond, Columbia, Virginia Beach, Jackson, and, to a lesser extent, Houston, Miami, and Baltimore. They are likely to keep voting Democratic.

We already saw some of that in the 2018 mid-terms in which seats that were supposed to be easy wins for Republicans were hotly contested.

I don’t think that Chicago or Detroit will be able to stem “black flight”. They’ll just shrink. Whether Republicans can hold onto what used to be safe, Southern seats is in question. I doubt that they can.

The entire country is getting purpler.

3 comments

What They Have To Do

I am seeing quite a number of opinion pieces about what the Democrats need to do to win the 2020 presidential election. What the Dems need to do to win rural areas. What the Dems need to do to win the suburbs. What the Dems need to do to win the middle. And so on. So far I have found all of them unsightful and lacking in an understanding of basics which is why I’m not citing them here.

I daresay that a majority of the Democratic leadership believes they can win the 2020 presidential election without rural areas, suburbs, or the middle—solely on the basis of urban cores. IMO that is foolhardy and risky for a basic reason. The Democrats need a high turnout by black voters to win and they can’t just take black voters for granted. It’s less that they should worry about black voters suddenly becoming Republicans en masse. It’s that black voters may not turn out in numbers sufficient to ensure victory.

By 2020 in all likelihood a majority of the black vote will either be rural, suburban, or in the middle. I think that people will be shocked at what the 2020 decennial census reveals. For example, here in Chicago I predict that the number of blacks living in the city will have fallen below 30%, whites will be a majority, and the total population of the city will have fallen sharply—probably below 2.5 million. It may even have shrunk to a point where Houston is larger.

9 comments

Movies for St. Patrick’s Day

Here’s a list of what I think are some of the best Irish-themed movies for St. Patrick’s Day:

The Quiet Man (1952)

John Ford’s love song to Ireland. Its cast includes most of the members of the Ford repertory company (John Wayne, Ward Bond, Maureen O’Hara, his son-in-law Ken Curtis, his brother Seamus, etc.).

Top O’ the Morning (1949)

A charming romantic comedy vehicle for Bing Crosby. I presume that a Scot like Bing identified as Irish because of his Irish-American mother—ethnic identity tends to run in the maternal line.

Luck of the Irish (1948)

Tyrone Power visits Ireland and comes back with a leprechaun in tow.

Young Cassidy (1965)

From Sean O’Casey’s autobiography, with the lead played by Rod Taylor.

The Fighting 69th (1940)

The story of New York City’s Irish-American regiment during World War I. It features most of Hollywood’s “Irish mafia”, e.g. Jimmy Cagney, Pat O’Brien, Alan Hale, Frank McHugh, etc. They were the Rat Pack before the Rat Pack.

The Informer (1935)

John Ford’s version of the novel by Liam O’Flaherty about the Irish war of independence, starring Victor McLaglen. It has one of the most heart-rending endings in cinema. Ford won an Oscar as director and McLaglen as actor in this film.

My Left Foot (1989)

Daniel Day-Lewis does an incredible acting job as Christy Brown, a young Irishman born with cerebral palsy.

Waking Ned Devine (1998)

Ned Devine has won the Irish Lottery but Ned is dead. The movie is about the shenanigans as Ned’s neighbors attempt to claim his winnings.

The Siege of Jadotville (2016)

This movie is about an action during the UN peacekeeping mission in Congo, one of the few times (if not the only time) the Irish Army has faced combat.

This is not an encyclopedia. There are many, many Irish-themed movies, some good, some awful. Since I’m sure someone will mention them, there’s a group of horror movies with vaguely Irish themes (leprechauns, ghosts, banshees, Celtic paganism, etc.) Most are execrable.

8 comments

NATO Is 70

On April 4 NATO will turn 70. In honor of the event, The Economist opines:

Reaching 70 is an extraordinary achievement for the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation. Most alliances die young. External threats change; national interests diverge; costs become too burdensome. Russia’s pact with Nazi Germany survived for only two years. None of the seven coalitions of the Napoleonic wars lasted more than five years. A study in 2010 by the Brookings Institution, a Washington think-tank, counted 63 major military alliances over the previous five centuries, of which just ten lived beyond 40; the average lifespan of collective-defence alliances was 15 years.

“NATO is the strongest, most successful alliance in history”, says Jens Stoltenberg, the organisation’s secretary-general, “because we have been able to change.” It has expanded from 12 members at its birth to 29—soon to be 30 when North Macedonia joins, its dispute with Greece over its name now settled. Of the eight countries that made up its erstwhile rival, the Warsaw Pact, seven have become part of nato, as have three former Soviet republics. The eighth one, the Soviet Union itself, has ceased to exist.

They seem to view NATO expansion as a sign of success. I think it’s the opposite. NATO began as a mutual defense pact in which its members together were stronger than they were alone. Now each additional member renders mutual defense more fantastical. Against whom will NATO be defending Macedonia? With the single exception of Kosovo it is completely surrounded by other NATO members and, if it should be threatened by war, it is more likely to be by one of those. Rather than preparing to defend each other for most of its members NATO has become a means of avoiding military spending for their own defense, relying instead on U. S. military spending.

For the United States it provides an avenue for venue-shopping. Rather than a mutual defense pact NATO is now a vehicle for aggression and the violation of international law.

The reason for NATO’s longevity is that, unlike the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, there’s a buck in it for somebody. NATO has outlived its usefulness. Time for it to end.

3 comments

Christchurch and Islamist Terrorism

The main thing that the murders in Christchurch, New Zealand have in common with Islamist terrorism is that pundits in the United States and Europe blame both on the United States.

I doubt that anyone disagrees with U. S. foreign policy more than I but I’m not arrogant enough to think that everything is our fault.

3 comments

The Ultimate Issue Behind the College Admissions Scandal

You can open a new college but you can’t open a new elite college. There are twice as many people in the United States as there were in 1960.

3 comments

The Tribute Vice Pays

If you disapprove of President Trump’s disregarding of international norms, the necessary implication is that you disapprove of U. S. foreign policy over the period of the half century. At New Republic John Glaser outlines the U. S.’s routine ignoring of international law and standards:

The pundits, practitioners, and politicians that make up the foreign policy establishment have rarely respected the non-interventionist principles at the core of the United Nations, an institution exemplifying the liberal rules-based international order that the United States helped establish following World War II. Article 2(4) of the UN Charter says “All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state…” According to the Charter, which American post-war planners helped write, the use of force is illegal and illegitimate unless at least one of two prerequisites are met: first, that force is used in self-defense; second, that the UN Security Council authorizes it.

This prohibition against war is not some trivial aspiration. Non-intervention is the centerpiece of international law and the United Nations has repeatedly sought to underline its significance. In 1965, the General Assembly declared “No state or group of states has the right to intervene, directly or indirectly, for any reason whatever, in the internal or external affairs of any state.” Again in 1970, it unanimously reaffirmed the illegality of “armed intervention and all other forms of interference or attempted threats.” In 1981, the General Assembly further specified that the Charter’s “principle of non-intervention and non-interference” prohibited “any … form of intervention and interference, overt or covert, directed at another State or group of States, or any act of military, political or economic interference in the internal affairs of another State.”

The United States is currently engaged in active military hostilities in at least seven countries, namely Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Somalia, Libya, and Niger. That tally doesn’t include drone strikes in Pakistan, combat operations in Kenya, Cameroon, and Central African Republic, or other interventions of unknown magnitude. The true number might be closer to 14 countries. The White House is also explicitly threatening U.S. military action to change the regime in Venezuela and against Iran for a host of spurious reasons. Not one of these cases meets the prerequisites for legal military intervention (a plausible self-defense case can be made for the war in Afghanistan, but it expired a long time ago).

It includes Trump but it’s not limited to Trump. It includes Republicans but it’s not limited to Republicans. These norms have been violated by every U. S. president over the period of the last 60 years.

I’m wary of entering into treaties but that’s because I don’t think we should sign a treaty which we have no intention of honoring. I think that’s not only a violation of important norms but against U. S. interests.

3 comments