The Whiggish David Brooks

I have realized the major way in which I differ from David Brooks. He believes in “Whig history”. “Whig history” is a way of presenting events that suggests there is a continuous, ineluctable progression towards greater liberty and enlightenment. I think that’s Eurocentric and far too focused on the present day. Examples: there are probably more slaves today than at any time in human history. More people are being slaughtered in war than at any time in human history. The amount of carnage being wrought today exceeds Genghis Khan’s wildest dreams.

In his latest New York Times column Mr. Brooks divides “norm-breakers”, the bringers of cultural change, into five categories:

  • Namers
  • Confrontationalists
  • Illuminators
  • Conveners
  • Celebrities

Because we definitely want to take advice on how we should behave from the worst-behaved people in the society, cf. the recent scandal over corrupt college admissions.

To those I would add at least two more:

Provocateurs

Provocateurs don’t really care whether the norms they’re opposing are good or bad. Their motto is like Marlon Brando’s line in The Wild One
Mildred: Hey Johnny, what are you rebelling against?

Johnny: Whadda you got?

Profiteers

Profiteers have something to gain by tearing down the icons they choose. Is it really a coincidence that Harvey Weinstein is a supporter of abortion rights?

We are conditioned to think of the present day as a culmination of events. The evidence is less clear. Carl Sandburg put it well:
We are the greatest city,
the greatest nation,
nothing like us ever was.

Change may be good or bad or, most frequently, both. Tradition is, as G. K. Chesterton aptly described it, the democracy of the dead. We should listen to it more closely and understand it before discarding it.

4 comments

The Real Democratic Party

Presumably alarmed by the perceived tilt of today’s Democratic Party, Nate Cohn and Kevin Quealy have an article in the New York Times analyzing the actual political beliefs of Democrats and they’re somewhat different than the advance press might have led you to believe:

In reality, the Democratic electorate is both ideologically and demographically diverse. Over all, around half of Democratic-leaning voters consider themselves “moderate” or “conservative,” not liberal. Around 40 percent are not white.

Roughly a quarter of Democrats count as ideologically consistent progressives, who toe the party line or something further to the left on just about every issue. Only a portion of them, perhaps 1 in 10 Democrats over all, might identify as Democratic socialists, based on recent polls.

Traditional liberals — another relatively white, well-educated bloc of Democrats — are also overrepresented on social media. They’re united with the progressive activists on the issues that divide Republicans and Democrats. They split on whether American society is fundamentally and unacceptably unjust, with liberals optimistic about compromise and satisfied with a cautious approach, and progressives demanding bolder action to redress injustice in society.

The article has lots of eye-catching infographics.

Get that? About 30% of Americans consider themselves Democrats and about a quarter of those AKA 8% are democratic socialists. Quite a voting bloc.

I also think that the authors fail to appreciate just how conservative many black voters are. Assuming that black voters will simply salute and vote faithfully for whatever candidates the party puts forward is a dangerous strategy. That was reflected in the recent mayoral primary elections here. More black Chicagoans voted for the most conservative candidate running for mayor than for either of the two black candidates running against each other in the general election. Voter turnout was catastrophically low.

My explanation for low voter turnout is not disinterest but something more like resignation or even despair. Candidates who don’t really resonate with the Democratic rank and file will only carry the party so far.

24 comments

Corruption Is the System

The editors of the Chicago Tribune highlight the incredible corruption attendant to public pensions which, coupled with downright malfeasance on the part of elected officials, have put Illinois and the City of Chicago in the positions they’re in:

The Supreme Court continues to interpret the pension clause to the extreme.

The ruling upheld a controversial state law that allowed a lobbyist for the Illinois Federation of Teachers, David Piccioli, to become certified as a substitute teacher in December 2006 by working one day at a Springfield elementary school — and to buy pension credit for his 10 previous years working as a lobbyist. That sweet deal qualified him for a pension windfall from a teachers retirement fund that as of late 2018 carried an unfunded liability of more than $75 billion-with-a-B. Because he also draws a pension from a previous job as a House Democratic aide, Piccioli’s total pension income now rises to nearly $100,000. His pensionable income from the Teachers’ Retirement System is based off his salary from the IFT— another questionable pension loophole, which the Supreme Court upheld last year.

A pension bill signed by former Gov. Rod Blagojevich in 2007 allowed Piccioli to retroactively count his years lobbying toward a teacher pension if he taught for one day in the public schools. He bought service credits for his years lobbying and began collecting a pension when he retired from the IFT in 2012.

This case showcases many of the defects of present law: “double-dipping”, i.e. collecting multiple public pensions, a law allowing people who are obviously not entitled to a public pensions to collect them, and the straitjacket in which Illinois’s constitutional guarantee of the enforceability of public pensions puts us. I could name a half dozen additional abuses in the present system.

For both mayoral candidates, Lori Lightfoot and Toni Preckwinkle, even commonsensical reforms in public pensions were off the table. That’s particularly punitive for Chicago because, since Chicago teachers’ pensions are paid by the city while other Illinois teachers are paid by the state, we not only pay the pensions of Chicago teachers we pay the pensions of non-Chicago teachers as well. Under a just system what Chicagoans pay to the state for teacher retirement would be credited towards what we pay Chicago teachers.

There’s a “Cross of Gold” speech lurking here somewhere.

1 comment

Taxes

Over the weekend I prepared our 1040 for 2018, the first time in years I’ve done so this early. We owed very slightly less than last year. It was also probably the first time in my adult life in which I took the standard deduction.

My wife and I are by no means wealthy. We’re both fairly healthy. I think we’re what most people would call “comfortable”. We’d be a lot less comfortable if I stopped working. We have a few luxuries—our opera subscription and the dogs. Otherwise we are pretty frugal.

Our primary concern right now is that the State of Illinois and the City of Chicago will drive us from our home.

3 comments

Why Do They Hate Young, Black Men?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are quick to point out that raising New York’s minimum wage to $15 is producing precisely the results that many of us predicted:

Is it merely a coincidence that the city’s full-service restaurants have fallen into a jobs recession? Employment in January dropped 3.7% year over year, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. At the start of 2018, the Big Apple’s sit-down restaurants had 167,900 employees. This January, after the wage bump, it fell to 161,700, a three-year low. The preliminary February number is 161,000, even as overall city employment is up around 2% year over year.

The monthly jobs data can be noisy, but the trend fits what restaurateurs are saying. The New York City Hospitality Alliance surveyed 324 full-service eateries late last year. Nearly half, 47%, planned to eliminate jobs in 2019 to deal with higher labor costs. Three-fourths expected to cut employee hours, and 87% said they would raise menu prices.

Meanwhile, in a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper posted last month, three economists examined whether minimum-wage increases had any effect on crime from 1998 to 2016. “We find robust evidence,” they write, “that minimum wage hikes increase property crime arrests among teenagers and young adults ages 16-to-24, a population for whom minimum wages are likely to bind.”

Those hurt the most by these developments are young black men. The unemployment rate among young black men is almost 17% while their labor force participation rate is 57%, higher and lower, respectively, than other young people and much higher and lower, respectively, than the population as a whole.

Education is no solution to this problem—we aren’t creating enough jobs that require college degrees, either. Being unemployed with educational debt not dischargeable in bankruptcy is worse than just being unemployed.

1 comment

Spending Four Times As Much. For What?

Education is on Robert Samuelson’s mind, too. In his Washington Post column he points out the awful truth. Our educational policy isn’t working:

Already, at least two Democratic presidential candidates are pitching major educational proposals. Sen. Kamala D. Harris (Calif.) would give most teachers a huge pay raise, reportedly averaging about $13,500. Teachers, it’s argued, are underpaid. This makes good ones hard to recruit and retain. Meanwhile, ex-San Antonio mayor Julián Castro advocates universal pre-K classes to prepare children for school.

Both ideas sound sensible. But aside from the sizable costs, history suggests that creating gains in achievement and academic skills for the poor is extraordinarily difficult.

That’s the finding of a major new study. It reviewed test scores for Americans born between 1954 and 2001 to see how much the achievement gap had closed between students with low and high socioeconomic status.

The startling result: hardly at all.

“The achievement gap fails to close,” headlined an article in Education Next. “Half century of testing shows [a] persistent divide between haves and have-nots.”

The explanation is not that public policy wasn’t trying. The discouraging conclusion occurred despite the federal government’s decision to provide extra funding for poor schools under Title I of the Education and Secondary Education Act of 1965. Previously, public schools were funded mainly by localities and states. Corrected for inflation, overall spending per student nearly quadrupled from 1960 to 2015.

The problem really begins in high school and it cannot be explained by changes in demographics—the country’s racial and ethnic makeup. Gains that had been made K-12 evaporate in high school. Mr. Samuelson proposes getting the federal government out of education and allowing the states to rely on their own devices. That won’t work, either.

It not in our nature to spend our first quarter century of life preparing. By age 18 most people are ready to start building families of their own. Their energies aren’t devoted to their studies because they’re focused appropriately on the task of forming a relationship to promote that end. Nature didn’t intend for them to be in school in their mid-20s but to be rearing their children.

We need an educational, economic, and social system that’s conducive to human happiness. Forcing people educational, economic, and social systems that some people would like is a formula for unhappiness which is what we’re seeing. We’re spending four times as much to produce depression and suicide.

3 comments

There Are No Mountains

The subject of the day appears to be education, prompted, presumably, by the college entrance fixing scandals that have been in the news. In his New York Times column today David Brooks attempts to be profound but succeeds in showing us how crabbed and solipsistic his world is. He imagines life as consisting of two mountains:

On the first mountain, personal freedom is celebrated — keeping your options open, absence of restraint. But the perfectly free life is the unattached and unremembered life. Freedom is not an ocean you want to swim in; it is a river you want to cross so that you can plant yourself on the other side.

So the person on the second mountain is making commitments. People who have made a commitment to a town, a person, an institution or a cause have cast their lot and burned the bridges behind them. They have made a promise without expecting a return. They are all in.

I don’t believe he realizes that what he is describing is not life but an artifact of our educational and social systems, in particular of that tiny group of people in the elite elementary school-prep school-Ivy clique. Graduation, originally from Harvard or Yale but not from med school or a top business school, is the pinnacle of a mountain. That’s followed by an inevitable let-down. After 12 years of highly-structured existence you’re suddenly thrust into the much less-structured real world where, guess what? Even with maximum effort promotion isn’t automatic because there just aren’t as many positions as there are people seeking them. Some recover. Most don’t.

For most people life is much more quotidien and at its center are relationships. Relationships with your parents, siblings, neighbor kids, and then school chums. Then with your spouse and, likely, children. And so on. There are no mountains, no pinnacles. There are responsibilities and relationships. Just what used to be called “ordinary life”.

A life at school followed by the pursuit of self-gratification is lonely and unsatisfying. “Ordinary life” is becoming increasingly difficult because of a web of policies including educational, economic, and social which makes it that way. However boring “ordinary life” might be, it is what we have and how we’re built. Responsibilities are intrinsic to our happiness. The number of people who can live satisfying lives outside of olrdinary life is quite small.

1 comment

Where We Went Wrong

I encourage you to read this piece at Atlantic from retired U. S. diplomat William Burns on where we went wrong in managing our relationship with Russia following the collapse of the Soviet Union. Here’s a telling snippet:

In December 1994, on the eve of a visit by Vice President Al Gore to Moscow, I had tried to capture Russia’s domestic predicament in a cable to Washington. “Winter in Russia is not a time for optimists, and in some respects the popular mood here mirrors the descending gloom. Born of a mood of national regret over the loss of superpower status and an equally acute sense that the West is taking advantage of Russia’s weakness,” I wrote, assertive policies abroad had become one of the few themes that united Russians. Yeltsin wished to reaffirm Russia’s great-power status, and its interests in the neighboring post-Soviet republics.

President Bill Clinton tried hard to manage Russia’s post-traumatic stress disorder, but his push for the eastward expansion of NATO reinforced Russian resentments. When I left Moscow after my first tour, in early 1996, I worried about the eventual resurgence of a Russia stewing in its own grievances and insecurities. I just had no idea that this would happen so quickly, or that Vladimir Putin—then an obscure bureaucrat—would emerge as the embodiment of that peculiarly Russian combination of qualities.

That was precisely why I was so outraged that Russia was not invited to participate in the 50th anniversary celebration of D-Day. It would have cost us nothing and not inviting them demeaned the Russians and their contributions to the “Great Patriotic War” (which they believe they won). Over the course of decades we have routinely ignored, diminished, or opposed Russian interests. How in the world would we expect them to react?

3 comments

Cause or Effect?

When I read this post at RealClearWorld on U. S. policy with respect to Yemen:

Washington should also encourage partners to develop or restore relationships with individuals who have chosen to support the Houthis politically during the civil war but who might not entirely believe in their cause. Houthi adherents might include members of the former ruling party still in northern Yemen and northern-based families and tribes who have calculated that their political prospects and futures were better with the Houthis than with the loose-knit coalition opposing them. Splintering the Houthi movement in this fashion could begin to diminish the group’s influence in Yemen. Reducing the Houthis’ strengths would increase the prospects of an acceptable negotiated settlement to the war and a political resolution in Yemen.

I began to wonder about the relationship between the Houthi alliance with Iran and the feckless way in which the U. S. has conducted the War on Terror. Our first armed drone strike took place in 2002. Since then we’ve conducted 329 drone strikes, killing more than 1,200 people, many of them civilians.

Just as in Afghanistan we rely heavily on local governments for intelligence—we have very little human intelligence of our own in Yemen. How honest is the Yemeni government? I would suggest not very. They are highly motivated to point out enemies of the government (Houthis) as Al Qaeda whether they are or not.

Were the Iranians supplying the “Houthi rebels” prior to 2002? Or was the alliance created in self-defense?

0 comments

Vive la Différence

At Forbes Robert Rapier presents the evidence that Saudi Arabia’s breakeven price for oil production is closer to $40 per barrel than it is to the $10 per barrel that has been assumed for decades:

Saudi Aramco, the national oil company of Saudi Arabia, is by far the largest oil company in the world. The company produces around 13% of the world’s oil, but its business operations have been notoriously opaque for decades. It has often been stated that the company has plenty of low-cost legacy wells that drop its overall production costs to $10 per barrel, or even lower.

Because there was no way to audit this information, the world was left to guess at the actual breakeven costs for the world’s largest oil company. Today, Saudi Aramco lifted the veil on its financial condition in a bond offering for the company. (PDF link here).

That’s an enormous difference with huge geopolitical implications. The breakeven price of some shale oil production in the United States is $51 with its proponents claiming it will go even lower. A lot of Saudi influence depends on its being the low cost producer of oil with a lot of disposable revenue.

4 comments