Mother’s Day, 2019

Mother’s Day is a distinctly sorrowful day here. My wife and I have no children. We were not so blessed. Both my mother and my wife’s mother have been dead for some years now. Mothers are in short supply here.

3 comments

The Real Real Agenda

I encourage you to read Matthew Continetti’s assessment of “the real Democratic agenda” at the Washington Free Beacon. I agree with some of what he has to say, for example:

Democrats have a problem. The base wants to impeach President Trump, ASAP, but the public does not. Indeed, Trump’s approval rating is the highest it’s been in the Gallup survey, right around Obama’s at this point in his term. The brute facts of public opinion suggest that the impeachment of Trump would look more like Bill Clinton’s trial than Richard Nixon’s. Not only would Trump remain in office; the backlash might deprive the Democrats of their 17-seat House majority.

For months, Nancy Pelosi’s solution has been to walk right up to the line of impeachment without actually crossing it. Unleash committee chairmen to fire their subpoena cannons in every direction. Make unrealistic demands of Attorney General Barr. Have Swalwell and Lieu and the rest of the cable gang keep alive the conspiracy theory that the Trump campaign was in criminal cahoots with Russia. Drag out the process into next year, when a weakened and bedraggled Trump faces the eventual Democratic nominee. That way Pelosi gets the political benefits of impeachment without the costs.

But I disagree categorically with his bottom line assessment:

This is not a serious party. It has abandoned policy for litigation, and common sense for fantasies of Medicare for All, Green New Deals, abortion after birth, and slavery reparations. The Democrats assume impeachment will be Trump’s Watergate. It may well turn out to be their Waterloo.

That’s a basic misunderstanding of the actual agenda of the Democrats who hold the reins of power in the party. They’re focused like a laser (to use a favorite Bill Clinton simile) on jobs—their jobs and those of their actual primary constituency: public employees. All of those other issues are just bright, shiny objects being dangled in front of their primary election voters to be forgotten as soon as the election is safely over.

1 comment

The War

The editors of the New York Times speak out against the war in Afghanistan:

The Trump administration has made missteps in its efforts to scale back the sprawling global war on terrorism. Its indecision on Syria left even staunch allies puzzled about American policy. For more than four months, the administration has lacked a secretary of defense, with the acting head, Patrick Shanahan, tapped for the permanent job only last week. Peace talks with the Taliban drag on — and Taliban attacks continue.

But the least that the Trump administration can do is be more open and honest with the American public about the unvarnished reality of the situation in Afghanistan. (The Pentagon hasn’t held an on-camera briefing in nearly a year.) Americans may have given up hope of “winning” the war long ago. But that doesn’t mean the full public accounting should halt.

To place our situation with respect to Afghanistan into perspective here are the U. S. casualties by presidential administration in the war in Afghanistan:

Administration Casualties
Bush 569
Obama 1,729
Trump 31

The number of civilian casualties has ballooned recently. Will increasing U. S. operational tempo increase, decrease, or have no effect on that? I think it will have little effect one way or another. Should Afghan civilian casualties be a factor in our calculus at all?

I voted for Obama in 2008, partially in the belief that he was a smart enough guy that he’d quickly figure out that his assessment of Afghanistan was wrong. It turned out that I was wrong. He wasn’t that smart.

No foreseeable president will ever want to be the president that lost Afghanistan. If you genuinely believe that we should leave Afghanistan, you should be eager for the conditions that will make that possible. I do not see how the passage quoted above does that.

There are multiple lessons to be learned from our experience in Afghanistan. One of them is that we should never go to war in a place in which we cannot supply our forces without transporting materials through a neighboring country that does not want us to succeed. A second is that we should not go to war to achieve the unachievable.

1 comment

U. S. Manufacturing Jobs

The purpose of my showing this graph is to expand on a point I made in comments. The graph tells us a lot. It tells us that a decline in manufacturing jobs was frequently a leading indicator of recessions. The number of manufacturing jobs peaked in the 1970s after they had increased sharply in the 1960s. Prior to the 1980s following economic contractions manufacturing jobs had generally returned to pre-recession levels. That pattern ended completely in the 1990s. There was a sharp decline in manufacturing jobs in the early 1990s and a precipitous drop in manufacturing jobs around 2000. Manufactuing jobs are recovering slowly now for the first time in more than 20 years.

Any number of different stories could be told to explain that graph. Here’s mine. The increase in manufacturing jobs in the 1960s is a story of global recovery. Not just here in the United States but all over the world economies were finally recovering from World War II. People had the money and wanted to buy more. American businesses wanted to sell more.

In the late 1970s globalization hit the U. S. economy like a ton of bricks. Japan began to encroach on what we had come to think of as “U. S. manufacturing jobs”, followed by South Korea. In the early 1990s China pegged the yuan to the dollar and that hurt us as well.

In the late 1990s granting China Most Favored Nation trading status and China’s admission to the the WTO did major damage to our manufacturing sector and there was no policy response as there might have been in earlier period. That was abetted by the conviction on the part of policy-makers, most of whom had college degrees or beyond, that a college education was the key to a bright economic future.

What happened in January 2010? I’m open to suggestions on whether Chinese or U. S. policies or both led to our increase in manufacturing jobs since then. The previous twelve years is strong evidence that the recovery in manufacturing jobs was not inevitable.

I don’t believe we will ever return to the number of manufacturing jobs we had in the late 1970s or their importance to our economy or that we should. I do think that we need a diverse economy that includes more primary production and more manufacturing.

9 comments

Pin the Tale on the Donkey

David Brooks has some pretty sharp criticism of Democrats in his latest New York Times column:

This constitutional crisis is just for show. Partly the Democrats want the show because it just feels good to bash the administration. “This has had a cathartic effect on the Democrats because we have finally been able to find a way to fight back at the obstructionism,” Representative Jamie Raskin told my Times colleague Sheryl Gay Stolberg.

Partly they are trying to appease the wing of the party that is calling for impeachment right away. The party leaders generally opposed impeachment for sensible reasons. It would be impossible to win a conviction in the Senate without some Republican cooperation and overwhelming popular support — which doesn’t exist. It’s much better for the Democrats if they focus media attention on their presidential candidates. A Trump vs. Nadler media war is exactly what Trump wants.

The problem with any policy of appeasement is that it rarely appeases; it only emboldens. And that’s what’s happening. You can feel the atmosphere in the Democratic Party changing, getting more passionate, getting more caught up in the back-and-forth combat with Trump, getting more whipped up into impeachment furor.

My advice to Democrats is that if they are going to impeach they should get about it as quickly as possible. It will not accrue to their benefit if this matter remains up in the air through 2020. If they are not going to impeach, they should not raise the expectation that they will.

1 comment

How Soon They Forget

Last week Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel (he leaves office May 20), as part of his tour to rehabilitate his reputation after falling on his face in Chicago, had an op-ed in the New York Times. I didn’t post on it on the grounds that he (and we) have suffered enough already but the editors of the Chicago Tribune have taken the trouble of fisking it:

In case you missed it, Rahm Emanuel penned a commentary for Thursday’s New York Times hailing his police reform efforts. With no disrespect for our Times colleagues: Had the mayor submitted his piece to the Tribune for publication, we would have performed heavier editing.

Emanuel’s column, titled “Lessons for police reform,” was the latest pit stop on his farewell tour. He leaves office May 20. The column spins furiously to his favor as he touts his insistence that law enforcement be consulted along the way. He compares Chicago and Baltimore, two cities that grappled with volatile cases of police misconduct and subsequent efforts to overhaul police protocols. Here, the catalyst for change was Laquan McDonald. There, it was Freddie Gray.

Does anyone seriously doubt that his office did not take an active role in suppressing the tape that eventually revealed the police murder that became a national cause célèbre. Thanks, Rahm.

Emanuel praises his embrace of police reform and notes a drop in homicides since 2016; they’re down 27 percent.

Left unmentioned is that between the time that Mayor Emanuel took office and the present, the number of homicides increased 50% (it doubled between the time he took office and 2016). That’s not an isolated instance of cherry-picking by Mayor Emanuel. It’s one of the things his administration was known for. Thanks, Rahm.

Since the fisking focuses on Mayor Emanuel’s wrapping himself in the flag of police reform, it doesn’t mention his presiding over the first teacher’s strike since 1987 then caving and giving the CTU everything they wanted or the sharp spike in property taxes (they’ve risen 35% while property values have remained flat) under his tenure or any of his other failings.

0 comments

Objects in the Rear View Mirror Are Larger Than They Appear

At RealClearPolitics Charles Lipson remarks on the trade deal with China. I wanted to bring attention to this segment of his post:

These failed policies don’t leave Washington with many options. The U.S. can either accept Chinese protectionism, as Europeans and previous U.S. administrations have, or it can make them an offer they can’t refuse. The terms are obvious:

  • Threaten China’s export-driven economy
  • Make that threat believable and sustainable
  • Offer China a reasonable deal
  • Make it costly for China to delay, and
  • Buttress the deal with tough enforcement mechanisms

While I agree with the general contours of that analysis I think he’s making one big miscalculation. China’s economy is no longer export-driven. That used to be the case but no longer. Today it is propelled by the domestic economy and fueled by debt, at the prefectural city and company level. Since the yuan is not convertible the debt is mostly denominated in dollars. That means China must hold many, many more dollars than should be the case.

China’s growth is not export-driven. It is dollar-driven.

I have no sympathy for the Chinese authorities. They have placed themselves in this conundrum.

We need to do what’s right for our own economy and otherwise let the chips fall where they may. In my opinion that means we should be producing a lot more of what we consume which means a lot more onshore manufacturing. That won’t mean a return to the “dark satanic mills” of the past. There should be a great increase in additive manufacturing and “lights out” manufacturing in general. We and the entire world will be better off for it.

10 comments

China Needs Dollars!

I will be interested in seeing how the trade negotations with China work out. If they’re successful they will place China in the odd position of needing both more and fewer dollars, as this post at Bloomberg makes clear:

China’s trade surplus with the U.S. expanded 10.5% (in yuan terms) in the first four months from the same period in 2018 – but for all the wrong reasons, as imports slumped by more than exports. Additional Trump administration tariffs would significantly curtail the trade balance, putting enormous strain on China to cope with U.S. dollar debts that need to be rolled over within the next 18 months.

Large swathes of the Chinese economy remain stagnant. Rapid growth in new total social financing and stalwart industries such as steel and real estate have ensured the headlines remain relatively upbeat. But trade is falling and consumer demand is weakening, with products from automobiles to appliances struggling. Official nominal GDP growth was 2.6 percentage points lower in the first quarter compared with a year earlier; unofficial data show even greater declines.

As long as Beijing refuses to make the yuan a freely traded currency, it will need to generate dollars. Beijing may not want to make a deal with Trump under these circumstances; it may have little choice.

Over the past nine years China’s foreign debt has increased four-fold and that debt is denominated in dollars. Yes, China’s GDP has increased, buoyed on the wings of debt, mostly corporate and local government debt. I’m genuinely not sure how it will all play out.

9 comments

The Foundations of American Liberty

Many people today are not familiar with the name of Orestes Brownson. Brownson was a respected American political thinker of the generation that followed Jefferson and Adams. His views on American democracy are compatible with and complementary to those of the more familiar Alexis deTocqueville. You might find this article at the Library of Law and Liberty on him interesting, in particular this passage, an indictment of our modern politics:

The main opponent of Brownson and the authors, however, is the theory of radical individualism, the human person understood too abstractly, merely as the individual with rights. It appears to be the congenital American bête noire. Brownson’s critique of Jeffersonian “Lockeanism” is remarkably relevant, as our authors show, and illumines today’s aggressive individualism, whether in economic life, in culture, or in law. In fact, later conservative arguments that dealt with the progressivism that emerged after Brownson, to the effect that radical individualism leads to collectivism, an increase in state power, and the marginalizing of intermediate institutions, receive fresh impetus from Brownson’s critique of the theory and practice of the autonomous individual. One especially acute irony was that Progressivism itself indicted “individualism” or “rugged individualism.”

The last point leads us beyond Brownsonian personalism to social and political and constitutional matters. The authors treat them all, some more than others; they do so, however, out of a recognition or apprehension that Lockean individualism is ascendant today and increasingly so. Several years ago Lawler coined a memorable phrase in this regard: it’s imperative to keep Locke in the locked box. The radically individualist view of man must not be allowed to become our authoritative public dogma. If it does, American liberty will be gravely impoverished and, predictably, tyrannical in its implementation.

Read the whole thing.

0 comments

God Said “No”

By all means read this column from John Kass in the Chicago Tribune. It’s about a story that made the news here of a newborn baby found on a garbage can and it’s very touching.

3 comments