David Goldman has an introduction to China “as it is” at Law & Liberty I found interesting. I agree with his observations materially. The TL;DR version is that by virtue of the Chinese language family, the orthography developed to express it, and history China is a natural technocracy. Those are my words not Mr. Goldman’s.
Since the introduction of the imperial examination 2,500 years ago and its modern successor, the Gaokao, the university entrance examination, China has been selecting the experts who will run the country. Here’s a snippet from Mr. Goldman’s piece:
Ambition is the glue that holds the polyglot, ethnically mixed Chinese empire. Napoleon invented the modern mass citizen army, saying that each of his soldiers kept a field marshal’s baton in his rucksack. That is, he awoke the ambition of the downtrodden peasants of France and made them into a force that crushed the professional armies of the European monarchs. The Chinese are more practical than the French. Every Chinese person carries flash cards for the Gaokao, China’s formidable university entrance examination taken by 13.4 million Chinese in 2024. The United States has just 3.8 million graduating high school seniors; I doubt that 5 percent of them could pass the Gaokao. China is a ruthless meritocracy. Top officials and billionaires can buy admission to Harvard for their children, but not to Peking University. For well over two thousand years, academic achievement has been the path to success for the Chinese. It should be no surprise that China now graduates more engineers than the rest of the world combined.
Chinese people are not as too many an American is struggling to get out imagine, “Americana is struggling to get out”. China’s emergent system has strengths and weaknesses. We must deal with China as it is not as we might imagine it to be.







