If the report of the “directive” of the Chinese government by the New York Times is accurate it highlights something important:
Islam has had followers in China for centuries. There are now 22 to 23 million Muslims, a tiny minority in a country of 1.4 billion. Among them, the Hui and the Uighurs make up the largest ethnic groups. Uighurs primarily live in Xinjiang, but the Hui live in enclaves scattered around the nation.
The restrictions they now face can be traced to 2015, when Mr. Xi first raised the issue of what he called the “Sinicization of Islam,†saying all faiths should be subordinate to Chinese culture and the Communist Party. Last year, Mr. Xi’s government issued a confidential directive that ordered local officials to prevent Islam from interfering with secular life and the state’s functions.
Critics of China’s policies who are outside the country provided excerpts from the directive to The Times. The directive, titled “Reinforcing and Improving Islam Work in the New Situation,†has not been made public. It was issued by the State Council, China’s cabinet, in April of last year and classified as confidential for 20 years.
The directive warns against the “Arabization†of Islamic places, fashions and rituals in China, singling out the influence of Saudi Arabia, the home of Islam’s holiest sites, as a cause for concern.
It prohibits the use of the Islamic financial system. It bars mosques or other private Islamic organizations from organizing kindergartens or after-school programs, and it forbids Arabic-language schools to teach religion or send students abroad to study.
The most visible aspect of the crackdown has been the targeting of mosques built with domes, minarets and other architectural details characteristic of Central Asia or the Arabic world.
Taken in isolation, some of these measures seem limited. Others seem capricious: some mosques with Arabic features have been left untouched, while others nearby have been altered or shut down.
But on a national scale, the trend is clear. Mr. Cui, the poet, calls it the harshest campaign against faith since the end of the Cultural Revolution, when so-called Red Guards unleashed by Mao Zedong destroyed mosques across the country.
Islam appeared in China during the Tang Dynasty not long after the religion was founded and has been a presence ever since, sometimes tolerated, sometimes repressed. Islam presents a challenge to the West but even moreso to China.
Islam is not just a religion. It is also an economic system and a political system. With the centrality of the Qur’an and the insistence that the Qur’an can only be read or recited in Arabic, “Arabization” is intrinsic to Islam. The interpretation of Islam that’s spreading around the world right now, heavily financed by Gulf Arabs, is particularly strict. For its adherents there is no such thing as “Islam with Chinese characteristics”.
The Chinese Muslims we hear most about these days are the Uighurs but the majority of Chinese Muslims are the Hui Muslims and there is antipathy between the two groups. The Uighurs are not Han Chinese and the Chinese government does not recognize the Hui as Han Chinese.
It would be no wonder if the Xi government were to “crack down” on Islam in China. Its emphasis is on the Han Chinese and Sinicization of non-Han peoples in China not the other way around.







