At Atlantic Derek Thompson writes about the awful truth that neither Democrats nor Republicans want to talk about: good things can happen in a Donald Trump presidency. Let’s turn to his conclusion first:
Democrats don’t want to talk about low-income wage growth, because it feels too close to saying, “Good things can happen while Trump is presidentâ€; and Republicans don’t want to talk about the reason behind it, because it’s dangerously close to saying, “Our singular fixation with corporate-tax rates is foolish and Keynes was right.â€
But good things can happen while Trump is president, and Keynes was right. “Tighter labor markets sure are good for workers who work in low-wage industries,†Bunker told me. “This recovery has not been spectacular. But if we let the labor market get stronger for a long time, you will see these results.â€
and then to the meat of the article:
So, let’s play a game of wish-casting.
- Imagine a world where wage growth was truly stagnant only for workers in high-wage industries, such as medicine and consulting.
- Imagine a labor market where earnings growth for low-wage workers, such as those who work in retail and restaurants, had doubled in the past five years.
- Imagine an economy where wages for the poorest Americans were rising twice as fast as hourly earnings for high-wage earners.
It turns out that all three of those things are happening right now.
I’m skeptical that Keynes has anything to do with it. What Keynes wrote was that a shortfall in aggregate demand can be countered by government spending by issuing credit. There is presently no shortfall in aggregate demand.
But two factors do have something to do with it. The first, as I have been saying for years, is a tighter labor market. There are only three sources for low-wage workers:
- Turn high-wage workers into low-wage workers. We have been doing that for thirty years with our self-destructive trade policy.
- New workers without experience or marketable skills come into the work force endogenously. They’re born and then mal-educated. We’ve been doing that for decades, too. In Los Angeles a quarter of all students fail to gradate on time. The same is true in New York City. It’s the same in Chicago.
- Immigration, particularly illegal immigration.
Regardless of who is president in 2020 or 2021, we need to keep doing the things we’re doing now to tighten the labor market. To do otherwise is unconscionable.
The other factor is the cut in the corporate tax rate. Polling information from the National Federation of Independent Businesses show that small business owners, despite having to offer higher wage to attract workers, are willing to carry on because of lower corporate taxes.






