A Question About Healthcare Policy

It’s an article of faith with many that a single payer healthcare system in the United States would solve the affordability problems with our system. How?

I think the reasoning is that since our European cousins’ healthcare systems are cheaper than ours (significantly cheaper: we spend 30-50% more than the next most expensive European competitor for the title) that their systems are cheaper because they have single payer systems (or full-on national health systems). I think that’s almost certainly wrong and that the causality goes in the other direction. One data element that supports that view: France, Germany, and the UK’s healthcare systems are getting more expensive, too. They’re just growing from a lower base than ours has.

So, perhaps someone can explain to me how a changing to a single payer system alone will stop the persistent cost increases we’re seeing here.

My own view is that changing to a single payer system, if it removed insurance companies from the picture entirely (that’s not necessarily the case: Germany has a single payer system and lots of insurance companies), it would create enough headroom that we could introduce the structural reforms that are required to make healthcare permanently less expensive here. But it would be a pretty short window. The whole shebang would need to be done in a single package, something that’s very unlikely given the way our poliltical system works.

IMO there are only two things that are dopier than believing that changing to a single payer system would ipso facto make our healthcare system affordable. The first is believing that we can introduce enough market forces into our healthcare system that we could make it affordable in a way that’s consistent with a reasonable level of public health. The other is that implementing the two shibboleths of the Congressional Democrats (community rating and guaranteed cover) will fix our healthcare systems’ cost problems.

5 comments

Barbecued Beef Short Ribs

I tried a new recipe yesterday and it was so successful that I wanted to pass it on, at least in simplified version. Beef short ribs are delicious but they’re something that I usually braise and wouldn’t think of barbecuing so I was interested in giving this recipe a try. Let me warn you: this is a leisurely, weekend-type recipe, not something for a busy weeknight.

The recipe is simple enough: rub the bone-in ribs with your favorite rub, place them in a baking dish large enough to hold the ribs in a single layer barely touching, rib side down, drizzle a few drops of red wine vinegar over each rib, seal it tightly with aluminum foil (I also covered mine), and bake in your oven at 300°F for about two hours until they reach a temperature of 160°F at the thickest point. That’s long enough that the collagen in the ribs that makes them tough is beginning to change into gelatin, rendering them luscious. The vinegar probably helps with that process, too.

Transfer the mostly-cooked ribs to your grill, rib-side down again, set to a low flame, no more than about 300° and cook them for another one and a half to two hours or until you can’t stand it any more, basting occasionally with your favorite glaze.

A quick rub can be made by combining roughly equal quantities of commercial chili power, garlic powder, salt, and brown sugar. I used a combination of garlic powder, salt, brown sugar, Hungarian paprika, cumin, and ground fennel.

I made a glaze with a quarter cup of Dijon mustard, a quarter cup of red wine vinegar, a tablespoon of brown sugar, and a teaspoon of the rub that I’d set aside for the purpose.

I started with about a pound of ribs for the two of us. As I’d suspected by the time the cooking process was complete that had shrunk to just a few morsels each—probably a quarter pound or less. For four I’d certainly start with five pounds of the meatiest ribs you can find.

One of the neat things about this recipe is that I’m pretty sure that it wouldn’t take me much more effort to make enough to feed a dozen people than it did to feed two—nearly all of the work is in just being patient enough to let the ribs cook slowly.

1 comment

No Dads

Fathers Day is always a rather lugubrious commemoration around here. My dad died nearly fifty years ago. My father-in-law died more than twenty years ago. I am not a father and at this point it’s pretty unlikely I ever will be.

I really could have used my dad’s wisdom, savvy advice, and boundless enthusiasm in my life. I can’t even begin to list the ways in which my life would have been different had he lived. He died just as I was beginning to have an adult relationship with him and I feel the lack of that relationship sorely.

0 comments

Learning When to Fight

In the Washington Post Joel Stein muses over whether a dad should teach his kid to fight:

Three years ago, I had a son. And after a lifetime of thinking that fighting was barbarism easily avoided, I found myself wanting him to know how to fight. I realized that not knowing how to defend myself has made me live in fear, or at least fear of going to biker bars, which I never really wanted to do anyway. But still, fear. And I don’t want my son to feel that way.

I knew that if I wanted to be a good dad, I had to change myself. I had to immerse myself in the foreign land of masculinity to learn its language. I wanted to show baby Laszlo that fears are just a list of things to be done. And I hoped to get to a point where I could say manly things like that out loud without cracking up.

I think that every kid, son or daughter should learn how to fight whether taught by their dad, mom, or by somebody else. They should have power, learn to control it, how to avoid trouble, and most importantly, when to fight to defend themselves or others.

I have some sympathy with Stein’s dad, a scarred-knuckled Brooklyn Jew, veteran of any number of street fights, in some of which he was probably the aggressor. I was born with rage. According to my mom I had to be restrained at birth to prevent my striking out at anything that come into range—the nurses, my mom, anything. As a kid I routinely picked fights, always with kids older and bigger than me. That ended when my parents enrolled me for judo classes at the “Y”, an activity that occupied my energy, interests, attention, and aggression for decades thereafter (I also practiced fencing, karate, taekwondo, aikido, and kendo).

All of that practice helped me in my lifelong contest with my most daunting adversary—myself.

5 comments

The Old Feminism

I’ve just realized that my ideas of feminism may be colored by the fact that my mom, grandmothers, and great-grandmothers all worked outside the home. Is that unusual? I don’t honestly know.

13 comments

This Is Not the Stimulus You Were Looking For

The big news in Chicago is the sword of Damocles hanging over the city’s head, a prospective teachers’ strike in the fall:

Chicago teachers countered Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s aggressive approach to school reform with the most powerful weapon in their arsenal, giving overwhelming authorization for a strike if contract talks continue to flounder.

Nearly 90 percent of Chicago Teachers Union members, some 23,780 city employees, voted to support a strike if one is called, the union said Monday. Union President Karen Lewis said the three-day vote was an “indictment” of the increasingly strained relationship between teachers and Emanuel’s hand-picked administration at Chicago Public Schools.

The teachers want a 30% wage increase.

Chicago teachers are already the highest-paid in the nation, the average teacher earning $76,000 for a ten month year. That’s double the median wage for Chicago.

Chicago already has the highest sales tax in the United States. Under state law the city doesn’t have the power to impose an income tax. Its only recourse is increasing the property tax:

Regardless of where Chicago teachers currently rank in salary, Civic Federation president Laurenence Msall said there’s one big roadblock to a big raise for teachers.

“It’s math. It’s not really politics, as much as it gets caught up in politics. The financial situation of the Chicago Public Schools is dire. The situation of the State of Illinois – that provides significant funding to the Chicago Public Schools – is dire,” he said. “The property tax payers in Chicago are beleaguered. They’re seeing a drop in their property values, and to be asking them to pay increased property taxes, so we can fund increased salaries for employees is something that’s gonna be a very tough political sell.”

Msall said there’ simply not enough money to support a significant pay hike for the teachers.

“The only way that they will find money to increase some teachers’ salary, is we’re going to have to reduce the number of teachers, and the number of employees in Chicago Public Schools,” Msall said. “There just is no other way to get around it.”

The only other possibility would be imposing a property tax hike.

A 30% pay increase for the 23,000 some-odd Chicago teachers would mean a tax increase of roughly a half billion dollars: $400 for every man, woman, and child in Chicago.

According to the Chicago Public Schools, their increasing budget which even without the pay increase for teachers is $712 million in the red, is growing for three reasons. In decreasing order of importance:

  • step/lane salary increases for teachers
  • healthcare costs
  • pension costs

The first two account for 90% of budget increases.

The president’s latest economic stimulus plan is aimed at staunching the flood of jobs from the public sector. Here in Chicago at least the reason that teachers are being laid off is almost entirely so that the contractual raises can be paid to other teachers and rising healthcare costs. Unless the underlying pathology is addressed more money is just temporary first aid.

Related—from Mickey Kaus:

It would be reductive and predictable for me to point out that all three of these Obama-era problems have a single cause: public employee unions, which helped delay the stimulus, which protect non-essential jobs along with essential jobs, and which negotiate unsustainable layoff-inducing benefits packages (because it’s easier to win a union leadership election if you increase the benefits of 90% of your members while laying off 10% than if you lower the benefits of 100% of your workers by 10%–and piss them all off).

The issue isn’t whether you’re pro-union or anti-union. It’s whether you’re pro-reality or anti-reality. As I have said before, professionals and particularly professionals who are employed by local governments must regulate their wage demands to the community they serve. It is both a professional responsibility and a practical necessity. It is the difference between being a public servant and viewing rent extraction as the sole purpose of government.

39 comments

Incentives Matter for Oil Production

You might want to take a look at oil economist James Hamilton’s exposition on why “peak oil” predictions have proven too pessimistic. Here’s his conclusion:

We like to think that the reason we enjoy our high standards of living is because we have been so clever at figuring out how to use the world’s available resources. But we should not dismiss the possibility that there may also have been a nontrivial contribution of simply having been quite lucky to have found an incredibly valuable raw material that for a century and a half or so was relatively easy to obtain. Optimists may expect the next century and a half to look like the last. Benes and coauthors are suggesting that instead we should perhaps expect the next decade to look like the last.

Or, alternatively, it might be the fact that it was cheap and so easy to obtain that resulted in its being so highly used.

9 comments

Modern Torture Devices

I may make this a recurring feature. Add this to the list of modern torture devices. Testifying before a Senate committee:

JPMorgan’s chief executive Jamie Dimon is appearing before the Senate Banking Committee in Washington, D.C. this morning to testify about the $2 billion trading loss the bank revealed last month.

On May 10th, JPMorgan disclosed a multi-billion dollar trading loss in the bank’s Chief Investment Office in London related to derivatives trades.

The Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Reserve, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the Justice Department and the FBI are all said to be looking into the trading loss.

The modern equivalent of the rack. It’s used to extract campaign contributions from Wall Street bankers.

It works! In aggregate the members of the Senate Banking Committee have extracted $877,798.00 in campaign contributions from JPMorgan alone.

10 comments

Phrase of the Day

The phrase of the day is from zerohedge. This phrase is used in describing our present political system:

kleptofascist crony capitalist system with socialist overtones

I don’t entirely subscribe to it but I do think it runs trippingly off the tongue.

0 comments

Transfusion as the Sole Form of Medical Attention

In a similar vein to my earlier post this morning Josh Barro hones in on why state and local governments are laying off employees. According to San Jose’s Democratic Mayor Chuck Reed, San Jose faces a budget problems because it has been:

1. Giving out raises faster than revenues were growing.

2. Giving out raises and increasing benefits when revenues were falling.

3. Giving out raises and benefits retroactively.

4. Allowing employees to cash out unlimited amounts of sick leave when they retire.

5. Providing lifetime health care for retirees.

Transfusion may be necessary emergency medicine but it doesn’t solve the underlying problems. In the case of state and local government unconditional cash transfusions also remove the incentives for addressing their underlying problems.

49 comments