That Inferior Feeling

I cannot for the life of me figure out why the Obama White House is dealing with the House Government Reform and Oversight Committee as it is. As I presume you know, yesterday the committee voted to hold Attorney General Eric Holder in contempt of Congress for failing to deliver the documents it had demanded of him. Whatever the White House thinks of the members of the Republican members of the committee and whatever their motivations, they are engaged in a legitimate inquiry and exercise of Congress’s oversight powers. AG Holder should have dumped the entire 180,000 pages on them eight months ago. Now he has a contempt citation from the committee, in all likelihood to be followed by a contempt citation from the the full House, with that followed by a civil case which a) the White House will lose; b) will keep this story in the headlines (something it has heretofore largely avoided) for the next several months; c) embarrass the White House more than releasing the documents would have done.

For background on the case I recommend this post from Meteor Blades and for background on the legal issues I recommend this one from Doug Mataconis at OTB. For background on executive privilege and the contempt citation see here.

Presumably, the calculation is that invoking executive privilege will be less embarrassing than what the committee will find in the papers they’re asking. A key problem with this is that the position previously held by the Justice Department, that the whole matter is one of lower level officials acting imprudently, is inconsistent executive privilege. It reminds me of this Benchley short:

The vignette I’m thinking of is about six minutes in and involves Benchley checking into a hotel with his wife, a distinguished-looking matron, and looking so guilty and hesitant in the process as to convince the desk clerk that he’s up to something. He couldn’t be more nervous if he were checking in with a streetwalker.

There’s something that all parties in this should keep in mind. The branches of government are co-equal. The Congress is not subordinate to the executive nor vice versa. However, their responsibilities are not symmetrical. Congress has a constitutional responsibility to oversee the executive but the president has no comparable responsibility. Further, the president is there to do the people’s business. Not his party’s business. Not the business of those who voted for him or contributed to his campaign but the business of all of the people.

The members of the Congress are there to do their constituents’ business. Consequently, the president has a heightened responsibility to work with the Congress however oppositional the Congress might be.

Update

My intent is not to try to make a case that ATF, the Justice Department, AG Holder, or the White House are completely innocent. I simply don’t know. They might be pure as the driven snow or guilty as sin. My point is that if the White House is trying to appear innocent they’re not doing a very good job of it.

8 comments

What Do You Mean “We”?

Matthew Stoller has pointed out something interesting—that the conclusion that since 2007 we have lost all the accumulated over the last 18 years:

The recent Federal Reserve analysis of the effects of the Great Recession on household wealth and income was a doozy, showing that median income dropped 7.7% and median net worth fell by 38.8% from 2007-2010. But that may not be the whole truth – the Fed might actually be leaving a very significant group of people out of the sample – the top 400 wealthiest people, or the 0.0000035%.

Since the wealth of the top 0.0000035% of income earners has grown so dramatically over that period, that sounds to me like a significant omission.

26 comments

It’s Easy to Predict the Future

When you can do so retrospectively. It’s Krugman (2012) vs. Krugman (1982) at EconLog:

So if he’s saying that what happened in the 1980s was “quite literally, a confirmation of the validity of textbook Keynesian economics,” is he saying that he didn’t buy into “textbook Keynesian economics” back then? Or is it just possible that what happened in the early to mid-1980s doesn’t confirm Keynesian economics?

2 comments

The Devil U. S. Made Us Do It!

The EU commission president has identified the reason for the euro’s crisis:

The opening day of the G20 summit was threatening to deteriorate into a fractious row between eurozone countries and other non-European members of the G20, notably the US, as EU commission president José Manuel Barroso insisted the origins of the eurozone crisis lay in the unorthodox policies of American capitalism.

As Europe’s leaders came under intense pressure to act decisively to cure the euro’s ills, and a campaign gathered pace to relax some of the austerity programmes laying waste to countries with unsustainable debt levels, Barroso said Europe had not come to the G20 summit in Mexico to receive lessons on how to handle the economy. Asked by a Canadian journalist: “Why should North Americans risk their assets to help Europe?” he replied: “Frankly, we are not here to receive lessons in terms of democracy or in terms of how to handle the economy.

“This crisis was not originated in Europe … seeing as you mention North America, this crisis originated in North America and much of our financial sector was contaminated by, how can I put it, unorthodox practices, from some sectors of the financial market.”

Since Canada has not experienced the crisis in its financial sector seen here and in Europe and its financial sector is relatively tiny anyway, he is unquestionably blaming the United States for the euro’s woes and tarring Canada with the same brush. Left unmentioned by Mr. Barroso are how the greed of U. S. bankers forced French and German banks to make excessive loans to Ireland, Portugal, and Greece, how it forced Ireland, Portugal, and Greece to borrow, how it created housing bubbles in Ireland and Spain, how it forced Germany to run permanent trade surpluses with Greece and Greece to run permanent trade deficits with Germany or how that bilateral trade situation could be continued without German banks lending to Greece to keep the balls in the air.

Also left unmentioned is how precisely the crisis the euro faces could have been widely predicted as it was at its inception.

Far be it from me to defend the heads of the big U. S. banks. I think that in a just system most of them should be in the jug from violations of Sarbanes-Oxley at the very least. But, if there is any truth in the idea that the road to recovery begins with acknowledging that you have a problem, searching for a solution to the euro’s problems may be premature.

7 comments

Preparing the Battlespace

Juan Williams outlines a course of action in the event that the ACA AKA “healthcare reform” is overturned by the Supreme Court:

The Democrats have a nuclear option in this political game if the high court throws out the healthcare law as unconstitutional.

That blowup-the-system button, not pushed since FDR’s attempt to stack the court with Democrats during the New Deal, is for Obama to use the bully pulpit of the White House, and the national stage of a presidential campaign, to launch a bitter attack on the current court as a corrupt tool of the Republican right wing.

It is a move that could energize Democrats and independents even as Republicans celebrate a major legal victory.

Some Democrats, sensing a political windfall, can’t wait to start the offensive.

9 comments

Discussion Questions

Every year roughly 90,000 men and women receive doctorates in the United States. Of these roughly 19,000 are doctors of medicine, DOs, etc., roughly 45,000 are JDs (lawyers), and the remainder are PhDs, ScDs, and other doctorates.

Something between 60% and 70% of all healthcare spending is by the federal, state, and local governments. Government at all levels employs a lot of lawyers directly and provides various subsidies to lawyers via credentialing and statutory prosciptions against practicing law without a license. I haven’t been able to identify what proportion of PhDs are employed by public institutions but I have been able to identify the number of public degree-offering institutions: there are about three public degree-offering institutions for every private institutions, something like 20,000 in all.

My main question is what’s the relationship between government and higher education? What should it be? Is the government-higher education deadly embrace a self-licking lollipop? I.e. does it produce more people with advanced degrees who demand more government jobs to produce more people with advanced degrees who can then hold government jobs? Or government-subsidized jobs? Over time how can this work? Is higher education a solution to our economic problems or an aggravating factor to our economic problems? Both?

25 comments

The Cliff Notes Version

Keith Hennessey has produced a detailed outline of President Obama’s speech on the economy that he gave in Cleveland on Thursday. To my eye it appears pretty fair-minded.

0 comments

The Wisdom of Lew Archer

I don’t know. I think, as Ross MacDonald’s Lew Archer put it, that it’s a good thing when if, as you get older, the girls you like get older, too.

5 comments

From the General to the Specific

In his latest op-ed in the New York Times Tyler Cowen argues that for the federal government to engage in more fiscal stimulus will require lengthy confidence-building:

We often hear the argument that our government should borrow and spend more money because the real rate of return on government borrowing is so low, as evidenced by bond yields. Maybe, but those yields are low because alternative investments are perceived as so risky, and people want a haven for their money.

Should government double-down on these risks by borrowing more money and pursuing more investment? After all, such a policy is supposed to be self-validating because of the accompanying economic stimulus. But will it be seen that way? Will government protect us from the risks of its potential mistakes?

That’s not an easy debate to settle here, but suffice it to say that without more trust, it won’t happen on a large scale.

I’d like to go from the general, fiscal stimulus, to the specific.

Could someone explain to me how money from the federal government to enable the city of Chicago to give its public school teachers a 30% raise without laying off enough teachers to do it without raising taxes will solve Chicago’s economic problems?

0 comments

Where I Agree With David Plouffe

I agree with David Plouffe that President Obama’s executive order to concentrate illegal immigration enforcement on areas other than on young people brought here as children by their parents is not political. However, making the announcment on what would otherwise might have been an uninteresting administrative step in the Rose Garden to great hoopla was political.

3 comments