Comparing the Metro Tax Burdens

While researching various cities’ debt service statistics I stumbled across this handy table in an analysis of the Philadelphia budget:

As you can see, Chicago’s tax burden is higher than any other major U. S. city except for Philadelphia and Detroit. Good company. Since that table was prepared Illinois increased its personal income tax rate from 3% to 5% so I think it’s reasonable to suspect that our position has risen. In the sense of getting worse, I mean.

14 comments

Poisoning the Well

As expected last night the Stockton, California city council voted six to one to declare bankruptcy. Stockton’s will be the largest municipal bankruptcy in U. S. history:

(Reuters) – Stockton, California will become the largest U.S. city to seek protection from its creditors after its leaders approved a budget on Tuesday night based on the city filing for bankruptcy.

A Chapter 9 bankruptcy by the city of nearly 300,000 in California’s Central Valley, about 85 miles east of San Francisco, could come as early as Wednesday.

Stockton’s city council voted six to one in favor of the 2012-2013 budget after a contentious five-hour meeting where angry retired city workers pressed council members to reject the $155 million spending plan. It proposes eliminating retirees’ medical benefits to help fill a $26 million budget deficit.

The most significant factors in Stockton’s financial woes are debt service, pensions, and retiree healthcare benefits. Of those the last is the one rising fastest.

Stockton isn’t expected to be the last U. S. city to declare bankruptcy in the near future:

Peter Navarro, a professor of economics at the University of California – Irvine, says there is, “a long queue out there of cities like Stockton that are going to be doing the same thing.”

Navarro points to cities such as Vallejo, Calif. and Central Falls, Rhode Island, which also went bankrupt, largely because of unfunded pensions. Jefferson County, Ala. filed for Chapter 9 protection, sinking in $3 billion dollars worth of debt.

“This is not a story about Stockton,” Navarro stressed. “It’s a story about the failure of our national economy. And the reason is simply because we don’t make (manufacture) things (goods in the U.S.) anymore.”

Among large cities in financial distress frequently named for potential bankruptcy are Los Angeles, San Diego, Detroit, New York, and my own home, Chicago. Let’s take a look at Chicago’s finances and see if we can figure out where the problems are. As you might expect Chicago’s budget is byzantine. It could hardly be more so if it were deliberately intended to be misleading which it probably is.

Here are some of the highlights:

Item Amount ($ millions) Percent
Total budget $ 6,693 100%
Police 1,258 18.8%
Fire 550 8.2%
Fleet and facility management 299 4.7%
Streets and sanitation 240 3.6%
O’Hare and Midway 377 5.6%
Water management 255 3.8%
Pensions 476 7.1%
Employee benefits 485 7.2%
Debt service 1,437 21.5%

It should be noted that this does not include the Chicago Public Schools, a completely separate fiscal nightmare.

There are a number of different ways to divide this baby. I hope it is as apparent to you as it is to me that a very high proportion of Chicago’s budget (28.6% = debt service + pensions) comes from the city’s failure to deal with its fiscal issues prudently in the past. Unfortunately, there is very little the city can do about that now.

After that the biggest chunk is present employee wages and benefits, well over half the budget. That’s something the city can do something about.

I haven’t discussed the revenue side. Prospects for additional revenue for the city are bleak. Chicago already has the highest retail sales tax in the country. There are limits to how high and fast Chicago can raise property taxes. The city sold its parking meters. The city does not have the power to impose an income tax.

What about aid from the federal government? That brings me around to the title of this post. I strongly suspect that prospective bond investors are very wary of getting the federal government involved. Their experience with the bailouts of GM and Chrysler may encourage them to believe that in any bankruptcy in which the federal government comes in as a white knight they are very likely to be left with bupkis while the public employees’ unions come out unscathed. We might expect the unforeseen secondary effect of the GM and Chrysler bailouts to be higher financing costs for state and local governments and that does, indeed, seem to be the case.

I only see three potential avenues for the city:

  1. Really tough negotiating.
  2. Bankruptcy.
  3. A Wayback Machine.
9 comments

Stockton’s Broke

The city council of Stockton, California votes tonight on whether the city of 290,000 will seek Chapter 9 bankruptcy protection:

Stockton residents braced for a fateful City Council meeting on Tuesday night that could result in the city declaring bankruptcy.

The prospect of insolvency was generating national headlines Tuesday.

But on the Central Valley city’s largely African American south side, the spectre of Stockton becoming the largest U.S. city to file for protection from creditors raised little interest.

“Bankrupt? We’ve been bankrupt,” said the Rev. Dwight Williams of the New Bethel Baptist Church.

“This church works day and night to pay the PGE bill and keep the lights on. So many in our congregation have lost homes and jobs.

“But it’s in our DNA to take the bitterness of lemons and made sweet lemonade. We remain optimistic and we will continue to take care of one another but I think most people around here would laugh if you said Stockton was going to be bankrupt.

The Stockton City Council will discuss whether to seek protection from creditors under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code.

Stockton faces many of the same problems that cities, counties, and states do all over the United States but particularly in California. Its business plan depends on the revenue from property taxes and retail sales taxes rising faster than its past and present public employees’ healthcare expenses. That’s not a good assumption.

3 comments

The Structural Assumptions

Walter Russell Mead complains:

The biggest scam going in American financial life may be the collusive effort by Wall Street, the political class, and public sector unions to use union retirement money to prop up Wall Street speculation.

Step One: state politicians promise big pension and health care benefits to their unionized work forces, but don’t set aside enough money to fund those benefits when the bill comes due. This makes union leaders and unions look good, because they can point to the shiny new benefits they have negotiated with the politicians. Meanwhile, it makes the politicians happy because the unions support them with contributions and volunteers at election time, but because the unions don’t insist on full funding for the benefits, the politicians don’t have to raise costs or otherwise disturb the big majority of voters who don’t work for the government.

Step Two: Make aggressive assumptions about the rate of return on pension investment funds. This has two consequences: it covers the gap between promise and reality (for a while), thereby postponing the day when the politicians have to face the voters and the union leaders have to tell their members that those beautiful benefits were bogus from the start. But the other purpose, equally important, is that it forces America’s public sector pension funds into the deep end of the financial markets, leading pension funds to be major investors in hedge funds, derivatives and various other not-for-the-widows-and-orphans investments. If these work out, great — the funds hit their investment targets and the benefits, or at least some of them, get paid. If they go awry — as many did in the last few years — then the pension problem turns into a crisis.

The scandal is that the structural assumptions of these funds require them to have a 7 or 8% nominal rate of return. In a period, like now, in which real interest rates are negative, in order to accomplish a 7 or 8% nominal rate of return you’ve got to go up the risk ladder. When large domestic companies are sitting on big wads of cash for whatever reason rather than investing them in expanding their operations, developing new products, or making capital investments to reduce their costs of operations, it gets so you aren’t talking about blue chips any more. You start talking about Greek and Spanish bonds. Have a nice day.

The real scandal here is that politicians were allowed to talk about 7 and 8% rates of return without being held accountable for the fraud.

9 comments

Economics vs. Science

In the light of previous discussions here I found this remark from Scott Sumner very interesting. After observing that in a recent post he and John B. Taylor agreed almost completely about Fed monetary policy if you replace the word “accommodative” (used by Taylor) with “contractionary”, i.e. they believe things that are completely opposed. Here’s the remark:

How can this be? How can two economists disagree on something so fundamental? It would be like two physicists disagreeing on whether a rising bar of mercury in a thin glass tube indicates rising or falling temperatures. No, it’s even worse. It would be like one scientist saying it indicates rising temps, and arguing that’s why ice is melting, and the other arguing that it indicates falling temps and arguing that’s why ice is melting. I.e. that H2O has the property of melting when things get really cold.

So the next question is; who is the crackpot who thinks a rising bar is colder temperatures, and who also thinks water melts when it gets really cold.

Obviously I don’t think either of us is a crackpot.

He goes on to explain why he thinks what he thinks. Isn’t it possible that, at least under some circumstances, nominal GDP can’t be influenced by monetary policy the way he assumes it can?

10 comments

FICA Killed the Recovery

I want to bring a genuinely fascinating post from Sean Trende at RealClearPolitics to your attention. He posts on the actual economic history of the 1930s in the United States.

You most likely know that the federal government decreased spending from 1936 to 1937 and again from 1937 to 1938. You certainly know that if you’ve been reading Paul Krugman over the period of the last half dozen years. You most likely do not know that federal taxes increased from 1936 to 1937 and again from 1937 to 1938 and revenues increased substantially more than outlays did, three times as much from 1936 to 1937 and by roughly equal amounts from 1937 to 1938. A major offender in the tax increase was the newly-imposed FICA AKA “payroll taxes”.

Meanwhile, the Federal Reserve compounded the problems by doubling the reserve requirements for banks.

The simultaneous monetary contraction and fiscal contraction lead to the “depression within a depression” of 1937.

Read the whole thing.

7 comments

I Do Know Some Dirty Words

I agree with Alan Blinder that “stimulus” is not a dirty word. But “waste” and “rent-seeking” are. Here are his prescriptions:

Unlike private investment, inadequate public investment is part of the problem. America’s infrastructure needs are so huge, and so painfully obvious, that it’s mind-boggling we’re not investing more. The U.S. government can now borrow for five years at about 0.75% and for 10 years at about 1.7%. Both rates are far below expected inflation, making real interest rates sharply negative. Yet legions of skilled construction workers remain unemployed while we drive our cars over pothole-laden roads and creaky bridges. Does this make sense?

[…]

Everyone knows that the returns to education, while large, are long delayed. That means we have no time to waste. We should be doing a much better job of building a better educated, more productive work force for the future. A Council on Foreign Relations task force co-chaired by former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and former New York City Schools Chancellor Joel Klein recently argued that better K-12 education is critical to American leadership in the world and therefore to our national security.

Dr. Blinder continues to live in a dream world in which the skills of homebuilders and roadbuilders are completely interchangeable and infrastructure projects are executed by cobbling together gangs of unemployed workers rather than being let to large, politically-connected construction companies that will drag them out as long as possible. He also apparently missed the tremendous run-up in real education spending without an appreciable effect on things like on-time graduation rates, test scores, or other measures of achievement.

Will an interstate that runs directly between Quincy and Peoria really increase U. S. productivity? Can that decision be made reasonably in Washington, DC? The unemployment and underemployment rates for recent college grads tops 50%. Will increasing that make us better or worse off?

We don’t really know how to cram more education into the skulls of the 50% of young people in Chicago, New York, and Los Angeles who don’t graduate from high school on time. Pointing to the benefits of doing so is an exercise in nihilism. We do know that simply spending more money isn’t enough.

The problem we face today is that the actual solutions to the problems we face run afoul of the preconceived notions and shibboleths of our elected officials on both sides of the aisle. Throwing more slogans at me doesn’t change that but it does bolster the case for waste and rent-seeking.

15 comments

I’m Listening

Legal theory distinguishes between acts that are malum in se, inherently evil, and those that are malum prohibitum, breaking the rules. For example, we do not believe that driving on the left side of the road is inherently evil (any more than the Brits think that driving on the right side of the road is inherently evil). We do believe that murder, rape, theft, are morally wrong.

The law is the minimum standard of morality. Laws aren’t limited to things that are malum prohibitum—we make laws regarding acts we regard as malum in se all of the time. We elect representatives according to a democratic process, they legislate morality, and the courts interpret the laws.

If you’ve got a better way of doing it, I’m listening.

My point here is that it isn’t the job of the courts to determine what is moral. It is the job of the courts to determine what is legal. It is the job of the legislatures to enact what we believe to be the minimally acceptable moral code into law. It’s not a perfect system but we don’t know of a way that’s better all of the time and over time.

24 comments

The Arizona Immigration Enforcement Law

The Supreme Court has ruled in favor of one of the provisions of Arizona’s controversial immigration enforcement law and preempted others:

The Supreme Court upheld a key part of Arizona’s tough-immigration law but struck down others as intrusions on federal sovereignty, in a ruling that gave both sides something to cheer in advance of November elections where immigration is a major issue.

The court backed a section of the Arizona state law that calls for police to check the immigration status of people they stop.

That section was one of four at issue before the high court. The others make it a crime for immigrants without work permits to seek employment, make it a crime for immigrants to fail to carry registration documents, and authorize the police to arrest any immigrant they believe has committed a deportable offense.

Five justices were in the majority choosing to strike down the three provisions. Dissenting justices argued that the whole law should have been upheld.

That’s a ruling that won’t make anybody happy.

Looks like ruling on the PPACA will come on Thursday.

11 comments

ZeroHedge’s Q&A

ZeroHedge has a pretty fair Q&A on the ACA, the Supreme Court’s options, and the likely fallout. Here’s the part I agree with most:

Congress seems unlikely to quickly intervene to “repair” whatever changes the Supreme Court might order. The most important obstacle is political–the original law was passed when Democrats held the White House and both chambers of Congress, including a 60-seat majority in the Senate for most of the time the legislation was considered. This allowed them to make policy changes beyond the scope of what appears likely in the foreseeable future, when neither party appears likely to have much more than a slim majority in either chamber of Congress and a divided government is very possible. A second obstacle is fiscal–if the court strikes the mandate or even the entire law, it seems likely that lawmakers will be more interested in deficit reduction and less focused on coverage expansion than they were when the legislation was first drafted in 2009.

2 comments