The word of the day is zomb-economy”.
It continues to amaze me that people are surprised that, having done everything the Japanese did, we are getting the same results the Japanese got.

The word of the day is zomb-economy”.
It continues to amaze me that people are surprised that, having done everything the Japanese did, we are getting the same results the Japanese got.
What’s the most expensive real estate in the world? At roughly $75,000 per square foot ($95,000 for a full page ad, one page running about 1.5 square feet), I’d say a page of the New York Times. Why is the most expensive real estate in the world being used to report on a story that finds that money can’t buy happiness?
Is it crazy to question how much money you need to be happy? The notion that money can’t buy happiness has been around a long time — even before yoga came into vogue. But it turns out there is a measurable connection between income and happiness; not surprisingly, people with a comfortable living standard are happier than people living in poverty.
The catch is that additional income doesn’t buy us any additional happiness on a typical day once we reach that comfortable standard. The magic number that defines this “comfortable standard†varies across individuals and countries, but in the United States, it seems to fall somewhere around $75,000. Using Gallup data collected from almost half a million Americans, researchers at Princeton found that higher household incomes were associated with better moods on a daily basis — but the beneficial effects of money tapered off entirely after the $75,000 mark.
Now, I happen to agree with the premise (money doesn’t buy happiness) but shouldn’t that paragraph cause us to do a double-take? Isn’t there a small conflict between “‘comfortable standard’ varies across individuals and countries” and “collected from almost half a million Americans”?
Let’s zoom in to the Times’s backyard. In Manhattan a $75,000 a year income (coincidentally, the average income there) will get you a studio apartment, to and from work via subway, and a modest lifestyle. BTW, if you need evidence that there are, indeed, two Americas you need look no farther than Manhattan. The median income for a white non-Hispanic family with children in Manhattan is nearly $300,000 per year while the median income for Manhattan, generally, is around $50,000 per year.
Contrast that with Baton Rouge, Louisiana. There the median income is around $30,000 and an annual income of $75,000 will buy a nice house with a nice yard in a dramatically less crime-prone environment. Both Manhattan and Baton Rouge are within handy distance of the ocean, although I strongly suspect that people in Baton Rouge are more likely to enjoy the prospect of sunning themselves on the beach there than Manhattan residents are on their shores.
How happy are they, comparatively speaking? Some evidence that the happiness of people in those two places is roughly comparable. There is also evidence (same link) of a correlation between happiness and income.
IMO people living in Manhattan and people living in Baton Rouge and living in different countries at least as much as people living in Manhattan and people living in London are. Maybe more so.
What brings happiness? I don’t know but I strongly suspect that we should be very cautious when trying to compare the happiness of different individuals. I’m reminded of the line from Cactus Flower: “Freedom is the most important thing in the world to me after I’ve eaten.”
I think that after you’re housed, fed, and clothed your happiness depends on a lot of things including the people you’re with, doing something you think is worthwhile, feeling as though you’re a part of something significant, and, importantly, the capacity for happiness you have created over the course of your life. Health is important, too. You don’t need to be an Olympic athlete to be happy (at least I don’t) but I think that being reasonably pain-free and not sidelined by some debilitating disease helps.
There are people who despite being sick, in searing pain, starving, clothed in rags, and exposed to the elements are nonetheless both sane and happy. But they are rare. We call them “saints”.
I think that undertaking responsibilities, doing things for other people, and having a broad base of experiences build a capacity for happiness. Two different containers may both be full but the larger container still holds the most.
I don’t generally like novels about the publishing business, plays about theater, or television shows about producing television shows. There are exceptions. The Dick Van Dyke Show was nominally about making a television show but The Alan Brady Show was just the MacGuffin. The show was really a showcase for the exceptional talents of the cast and about how funny ordinary human experiences can be.
I think that those are the things that writers write about when they don’t have any other ideas. The challenge isn’t in writing them. It’s in making the stories interesting to people who aren’t writers, playwrights, or in the television business. When you’re in the thick of something you may not realize that everybody doesn’t find it as fascinating as you do.
I did find this column from the Washington Post ombudsman interesting, however, for the spotlight it focused on a central problem facing professional journalism.
In the column Patrick Pexton responds to readers’ complaints that the WP didn’t cover the derecho, the line of fast-moving thunderstorms, that struck the area a week ago.
The Washington Post has long had a split personality. On the one hand the paper covers the nation’s capital, stories that have national importance. On the other hand it’s the dominant local paper for people living in Washington, DC and adjacent areas of northern Virginia and southern Maryland. Here’s the nub of the column:
The overall impression I got from readers, and from my own observations as someone who lost power for a relatively manageable 57 hours, is that The Post was okay but not great. Stories had too much officialdom, too little humanity. Coverage was not aggressive enough, and it had too little depth, breadth and creativity. It lacked verve and passion in covering what was, and is, a very big story affecting millions.
I think too few reporters were out in the neighborhoods, in their cars or on two legs, using their eyes, ears and noses to get the news from different perspectives. I didn’t see, for example, a single quote from an electric lineman.
That’s a milder restatement of what WP readers were complaining about. They were complaining that the Post was re-issuing press releases from officials. Ordinary people don’t need the Post for that any more. They can get the official story from the relevant agencies’ web pages, Facebook pages, and Twitter feeds without being filtered through a WP reporter or editor.
I think the problem is that the Post sees its competitive advantage as its official contacts and it values them too much. What is a WP reporter without official contacts? A blogger. However, he or she is a blogger with a press pass that allows him or her into places I wouldn’t be allowed. Whether I should be allowed there (or they shouldn’t) is a different question.
The line the Post should be treading is between being too adversarial and not adversarial enough with their official contacts. I don’t see that conflict playing out and I think I should. Without that tension the Post is just another outlet for official press releases.
The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.
–_blank
I want to return focus to the question I asked in this post, what measures would increase the rate of new business formation? As I wrote in the post, I’m skeptical that simply increasing the amount of consumer spending will do that. As an illustration of why that might be think about how many jobs would be created by a 10% increase in the volume of purchases at Amazon.com? My guess: none at Amazon.com although some Chinese manufacturers might need a few more employees.
I’ve given mine: reduce the cost of employment for new companies. One commenter suggested reducing regulations. I don’t disagree with that although suggestions of specific regulations would be nice. He also implied a moratorium on new regulations, i.e. reducing regime uncertainty.
Okay, I’ll make another suggestion: eliminate FICA, FUTA, and the corporate income tax permanently including their reporting requirement and pay the benefits of the Social Security system and federal unemployment benefits from the general fund. We’re already moving in that direction and there’s a decent body of scholarship that suggests that permanent measures have significantly more benefit than temporary ones.
Other suggestions? I want to concentrate on brainstorming rather than on criticizing the measures that are suggested.
In general I think we’re talking about measures that alter the balance between perceived risk and expected reward. Either the perceived risk can be reduced or the expected reward can be increased.
Others are complaining about the lacklustre Employment Situation Report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics so I may as well join in the fun. The report is all too familiar: roughly 80,000 net jobs were created last month, far too slow for any genuine recovery, with the most jobs being gained in professional and business services, particularly temps, manufacturing, and healthcare. Even these numbers are small enough to make no meaningful difference in the overall picture.
The merry band of commenters at OTB are responding pretty much as you might expect, jeering at “conservatives and libertarians” to propose their own solutions to the problem, pointing to the decline in public sector employment, and suggesting fiscal stimulus. I’m neither a conservative nor a libertarian but I’m happy to weigh in with my own views.
At least around here the reason that state and local governments are trimming payrolls is that their employment contracts require them to do so. Revenues are stubbornly low despite increases in tax rates, the only choices for increasing cash on hand are drumming up more revenues or borrowing and as their credit ratings fall borrowing is becoming more expensive for them, and, failing that, they must cut payrolls. Employment contracts do not allow them to reduce wages or benefits so they must reduce the number of employees. Why isn’t more ire being directed at “sticky wages”, inadequate flexibility?
What’s the proposed alternative? Federal aid? That’s only temporary first aid and, as I’ve pointed out before, lots of the workers in question are in the top decile of income earners rather than the lowest. That’s not nearly as sympathetic a case in my eyes.
Something I think that people proposing measures to spur consumer spending fail to take into account: there’s nothing in the General Theory that says that additional consumer spending in Manchester inevitably produces more economic growth in Manchester. The stimulus might well take place in London, Bristol, or Glasgow.
Stimulating consumer spending in the United States is as likely to produce increased growth in China, Japan, Mexico, or Canada as it is here. Probably more so.
Consumer spending and government spending are not the only kinds of consumption. Until relatively recently our economy was much more dependent on business spending than it is now. Unfortunately, more business spending, unless it’s targeted over here won’t produce more job growth over here, either.
What we really need is more new business formation. New jobs are created by new businesses. They’re certainly not created by large, established businesses who’ve been trimming their payrolls with tedious regularity over the period of the last 30 years. The number of hourly employees of GM, Ford, and Chrysler are a fraction of what they were 30 years ago. That’s a trend that we should not expect to change.
So, let’s brainstorm about the kinds of steps that might increase the rate of new business formation. Here’s one: a national healthcare insurance system paid from general revenues rather than from a tax on employers (and employees). A tax on employment will increase the cost of new employees and reduce the amount of money available for capital investment, discouraging new business formation.
Things that reduce the cost of starting a business, doing business, or adding employees.
How about some other suggestions?
I look forward to the Congressional Budget Office’s updated and revised estimate of the cost and effectiveness of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act AKA “ObamaCare”, due next week but which I suspect will be somewhat delayed. Especially in light of the developing situation governors of states that opposed the PPACA in Court declining to expand their states’ Medicaid systems as the Supreme Court ruled was their right. If Florida and Texas opt out, I would be very much surprised if that doesn’t cut a big chunk out of the additional people that the plan was supposed to insure.
Since George Will has weighed in on the conflict between the mayor and Chicago’s Teacher’s Union and the possibly impending strike, I may as well, too. Mr. Will hits most of the high spots of the in the discussion in his column: the mayor’s desire for a longer school day and school year, the teachers’ corresponding demand for 30% more pay, that Chicago has the shortest school day among major urban school systems. Unmentioned, however, is that Chicago also has a short school year compared with other urban systems and higher pay compared with other such systems.
There are several other factors that I think bear mentioning. Mr. Will is right that the mayor’s responsibilities and the head of the Chicago Teachers Union’s responsibilities are not the same. However, teachers are, at least nominally, professionals which means that they have a responsibility to the community that they serve not shared by, say, truck drivers, auto workers, or busboys. If the teachers disagree with the mayor’s plan for improving the schools, that obligation requires them to respond with their own plan, something not yet forthcoming. The adversarial relationship between industrial unions and management is not an effective model for the cooperative relationship that should exist between professionals and the city government.
Additionally, as I have previously pointed out, the Chicago median wage and the present median wage of Chicago teachers means that teachers are prominent in the city’s top 10% of income earners. Add police officers and firefighters, who will almost certainly demand their own wage increases if teachers receive a substantial wage increase, and it’s an even higher percentage. The constrained character of Chicago’s finances, already running a sharp deficit, and its present taxes, already high among major cities, means that any attempt to raise revenues will be like giving a blood transfusion from arm to arm.
If I were the mayor, here’s the deal I would strike: if the teachers curtail their wage demands, I wouldn’t crack down on the Chicago residency requirement.
John B. Taylor explains the persistence of the financial crisis as an imbalance in capital flows:
The Fed’s current near-zero interest rate policy, designed to stimulate the U.S. economy, has made it harder for other central banks to combat credit and asset price booms. A group of 18 emerging market central banks—including Brazil, China, India, Mexico and Turkey—held their interest rates on average as much as five percentage points below widely used policy benchmarks—and global commodity prices doubled from 2009 to 2011, a boom rivaling the excesses leading up to the 2008 financial crisis. This global, loose monetary policy was likely a big factor pushing up commodity prices. The current sharp slowdown in most emerging markets coincides with an inevitable bust of this easy-money induced boom, and the decline of foreign demand for American goods is now feeding back to the U.S. economy.
The Fed needs to pay closer attention to global capital flows and the reactions of other central banks to its decision to set interest rates very low for long periods of time. This does not mean taking one’s eye off the U.S. economy, but rather preventing booms and busts abroad from slowing growth at home precisely when we need it most.
I think he’s right but he doesn’t go back far enough. Is it really just a coincidence that the U. S. housing bubble began to take off in 1994 when China sharply tightened its peg to the dollar and that the bubble began to collapse in 2005 when it relaxed the peg?
Does the effectiveness of the U. S. healthcare system assume a substantial consumer surplus? Is there such a consumer surplus? Is there a substantial producer surplus?