Investor of Last Resort?

Here’s Fareed Zakaria’s take on the case that the president has been making, I guess since 2009:

Obama has been making the case that the U.S. economy needs investment — in infrastructure, education, training, basic sciences and technologies of the future. Those investments, in the president’s telling, have been the key drivers of American growth and have enabled people to build businesses, create jobs and invent the future.

and, presumably, that investment must come from the federal government or federal government. How else to interpret it? Where has the emphasis been? On investment via federal works program and grant or on incentives to encourage private parties to do the investing?

From government as the employer of last resort to government as consumer of last resort and now to government as investor of last resort. I honestly don’t believe that John Maynard Keynes would recognize what’s being perpetrated in his name.

6 comments

Ink By the Gallon

Read John Kass’s reaction to President Obama’s latest populist push. Here’s a small snippet:

We didn’t go to movies or out to restaurants. Everything went into the business. Uncle George and dad never bought what they could not afford. The store employed people, and the workers fed their families and educated their children and put them through college. They were good people, all of them. We worked together and worked hard, but none worked harder than the bosses.

It’s the same story with so many other businesses in America, immigrants and native-born. The entrepreneurs risk everything, their homes, their children’s college funds, their hearts, all for a chance at the dream: independence, and a small business of their own.

Most often, they fail and fall to the ground without a government parachute. But some get up and start again.

These are the guys who don’t host $10,000 a plate campaign dinners.

4 comments

It’s All They Can Afford

For some reason this story on the report of the actuary of the California Public Employee Retirement System, remarking on the 1% return when their projections require 7.5%:

While the fund’s actuary recommended lowering the rate to 7.25 percent, the Calpers board said at the time that would burden local governments when they were already coping with financial strains.

reminded me of this exchange from the Woody Allen screenplay for What’s New, Pussycat?, back when Woody Allen was actually funny:

Michael James: Did you find a job?
Victor Skakapopulis: Yeah, I got something at the striptease. I help the girls dress and undress.
Michael James: Nice job.
Victor Skakapopulis: Twenty francs a week.
Michael James: Not very much.
Victor Skakapopulis: It’s all I can afford.

Considering that the reason that California local government have financial strains is largely due to high payrolls and employee benefits, it’s a bit circular, isn’t it?

6 comments

Vox Populi Lex Suprema Est

I’m not sure how you explain either the position of President Obama or that of his challenger, Gov. Mitt Romney, with respect to defense spending in the light of this:

Americans of all stripes have had enough of massive Pentagon budgets and want significant cuts in defense spending, according to new survey data released on Monday.

In Republican and Democratic districts across the country, 74 percent and 80 percent of respective voters said they want less defense spending, the study found.

On average, voters indicated that they wanted a budget for fiscal 2013 that would be nearly 20 percent less than current defense spending.

With $645 billion enacted for total defense spending this year, the average voter’s preferred budget for next year, an 18 percent cut, would translate into a $116 billion savings—money lawmakers trying to balance the budget could sorely use.

Both parties appear to be the captives of their most hawkish and interventionist members who, if this finding is to be believed, comprise a distinct minority of the voters.

3 comments

The Return of A&G

Bond chief Mohamed El-Erian warns of dire consequences if the Fed continues its present course:

Look for the Fed in the next few weeks to go further in revising down its job, growth and inflation forecasts for 2012. Given the institution’s dual mandate of price stability and maximum employment, this will inevitably raise expectations of additional policy activism.

Having exhausted long ago the effectiveness of traditional monetary policy tools, the Fed has no choice but to consider another mix of unconventional measures – specifically, additional purchases of securities, a lower interest rate on excess reserves, an even more aggressive communication policy, and enhanced access to the discount window.

But, more of the same will not have a durable beneficial impact, especially if other policymakers remain missing in action. Indeed, the advantages of another round of unusual Fed activism are declining while the risk of both collateral damage and unintended consequences is material and growing.

I’ve mentioned it before but this looks like a good time to remind you of it. Here’s an example of the “collateral damage”: the insurance industry is having serious problems due to the Fed’s actions. There are, essentially, two ways of making money in the insurance business. You can make money by investing the premiums you take in, usually in certificates of deposit or bonds, or you make money in the form of commissions. To increase the amount of money made in commissions premiums must rise. There are limits to how far premiums can rise without people dropping coverage, hence collateral damage.

This sounds like a good time to return to our old friends, Alphonse and Gaston:

Mr. El-Erian and Dr. Bernanke want the Congress to move first with fiscal stimulus. Congress wants Dr. Bernanke to move first with monetary stimulus. The obvious alternatives for fiscal stimulus, mostly “tax cuts for the wealthy”, are deeply distasteful to the Congress, particularly to the Democratic leadership who’ve obviously convinced themselves that increasing taxes will be good for the economy or, at least, that’s what they’ve been selling to their constituents.

There won’t be any action from the Congressional side until after November and the posture of the Fed appears to be watchful waiting.

16 comments

Why Does a Fireman Wear Red Suspenders?

if this post by Alex Tabarraok is to be believed, it’s to keep his pants up while he accompanies an ambulance. Interesting statistic: the number of fires in the United States has fallen by more than 40% while the number of career firefighters has increased by more than 40%.

Here in Chicago the median firefighter’s salary is around $65,000. However, the median amount of overtime paid is around $35,000 which pushes income up to around $100,000. That doesn’t include other benefits.

I think that’s well worth it for firefighting. However, it’s not nearly as worthwhile for non-firefighting duties which, as the linked post points out, are an increasing proportion of what firefighters actually do.

So, how much does a Chicago firefighter earn per year? I think the best answer is that nobody knows. I have yet to meet a firefighter who didn’t have a sideline business. Consequently, on top of the $100K that he or she earned from the job with the Chicago Fire Department there was whatever was earned from the sideline business. Are those conditions a perk of the job?

You usually say that the market clearing price or equilibrium price has been reached when the quantity supplied is precisely equal to the quantity demanded. There are thousands of people on the waiting list to become Chicago firefighters, possibly in the low five figures. I’m told that a ten year wait is not beyond the realm of possibility. What does that tell you about how much Chicago firefighters are paid?

17 comments

Pew Research Determines

that 2/3s of the people have no idea of what the heck is going on and have no idea that they have no idea. The number is higher among Democrats. A recent opinion poll finds this breakdown of opinions on raising taxes on individuals earning more than $250,000 a year:

Tax Hikes on $250K+
Would… Total %
Help economy 44
Hurt economy 22
No difference 24
Don’t know 11

 

To refresh your memories when the full set of tax cuts, both for individuals making more than $250,000 and those making less, were enacted the effects were very short-lived. Essentially, the tax cut had no effect.

IMO the smart money should be behind “No difference” with an honorable mention for “Don’t know”. I see no way it would actually help the economy but a lot of Americans and, particularly, a majority of Democrats seem to think it would.

4 comments

Clean It Up!

The Sun-Times reacts to the arbitrator’s report by demanding that Mayor Emanuel and the CPS clean up the mess they’ve created:

To date, CPS has been ruthless about taking bargaining subjects off the table. We support bargaining limited to core subjects but if CPS blindly sticks to this strategy, Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Schools CEO Jean-Claude Brizard will have to dramatically scale back or kill the longer school.

They simply cannot have it all.

There is also much for the teachers’ union to give on, including agreeing to plans to scale back an overly-generous severance package and moving away from automatic raises for earning an extra degree, no matter its usefulness.

In his report, arbitrator Benn said CPS “caused this problem by lengthening the school day and year to the extent it did when it was having serious budget problems.”

Benn is right, though CPS did it for good reason, to give schools the time that school and union leaders have long sought.

But good intentions are not enough. CPS and Emanuel created this mess. It’s time for them to clean it up.

I wonder why they think the Chicago Teachers Union would back down at this point?

1 comment

The Long Hot Fall

The second shoe has dropped in the battle of wills between Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel and the Chicago public school teachers. As is required by a law, the arbitrator has produced his report and it has not gone the mayor’s way, proposing an 18.2% raise this year and a 35% raise over three years:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel on Tuesday dismissed as unaffordable and “not tethered to reality” a fact-finder’s report that recommends an 18.2 percent pay raise for Chicago Public School teachers.

“If we were to follow that report, we would have to fire 4,000 teachers and dramatically increase class sizes, neither of which are realistic options. That’s why that report is not fiscally or educationally tethered to reality,” the mayor said.

Pressured by arbitrator Edwin H. Benn to choose between fiscal reality and his signature push for a longer school day and school year, Emanuel refused to blink.

The mayor said he would not agree to yet another contract with the Chicago Teachers Union that benefits adults who work for the school system, but leaves children “on the side of the road.” “I believe in a fair deal — one that’s fair to our children, one that’s fair to our teachers, one that’s fair to our parents,” he said.

“When you have the shortest day and the shortest year of any major city, you shortchange your children. I believe everybody should be properly compensated, but I don’t believe you have a system that doesn’t give our kids what they need because this is their future.”

This is the next step in the process that looks very much as though it will lead to a strike. Think the summer has been hot? Wait for the fall!

The leaders of the Chicago Teachers Union already have a strike authorization. At this point I think they smell blood:

Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis responded to the mayor’s hard-line by saying that Chicago’s first teachers’ strike in 25 years can still be avoided, but only if Emanuel bends.

“There are other ways to achieve these goals by looking at staffing — by looking at a variety of things other than lengthening the day to an arbitrary length he picked,” said Lewis, who has gone toe-to-toe with the mayor in public and in private.

“If he’s not willing to make any compromises, then he can’t have what he wants, now can he? You can’t have it two ways. This is up to him. We’re gonna do our part.”

Asked to predict whether there would be a teachers’ strike, Lewis said, “That will depend on the mayor. He doesn’t want a strike. But the question is, what will he do to avoid it? That’s the question that needs to be asked of him — not me. Our members have already spoken on the issue.”

The mayor has already inked an agreement calling for a 2% pay increase for the teachers next year. That’s as much as CPS’s budget will stand.

As I see it there are three outcomes:

  1. The mayor backs down on lengthening the school day and school year. That would result in a loss of face for the mayor and could potentially turn him into a lame duck. Temperamentally, Rahm Emanuel doesn’t strike me as a gracefully-backing-down sort of guy.
  2. The CTU backs down on demanding more pay for the additional time worked. Given that there’s already a strike authorization, I see little reason they would do that.
  3. Some face-saving compromise is found. The school year and day are lengthened a little less. The teachers get a little more pay. I think this is the most likely.

The problem with the most likely outcome is that Chicago is, as I’ve pointed out before, tapped out revenue-wise. The cupboard is bare. It’s even possible that raising sales taxes or real estate tax rates could lower total revenues.

I think it will be a long hot fall.

1 comment

The Devil Is In the Details

Scott Sumner explains market monetarism (and NGDP targeting).

9 comments