Curve-Fitting

I want to draw your attention to this post by Eli Dourado. In the post Mr. Dourado makes the point, too frequently neglected, that the operative timeframe for short term solutions is the short term and we’re not in the short term any more:

The case for stimulus is based in monetary non-neutrality. If we double the money supply, the real productive capacity of the economy does not increase—real productive capacity has nothing to do with monetary factors. However, because people are tricked, and because some wages, prices, and contracts don’t adjust instantaneously, output may go up briefly. Business owners see an increase in nominal demand for their products and mistakenly assume that it is an increase in real demand. They see this as a profit opportunity, so they expand production. As prices, wages, and contracts adjust to the new money supply and their assumption is revealed to be false, they cut back on production to where they were before.

If we view the recession as a purely nominal shock, then monetary stimulus only does any good during the period in which the economy is adjusting to the shock. At some point during a recession, people’s expectations about nominal flows get updated, and prices, wages, and contracts adjust. After this point, monetary stimulus doesn’t help.

He cites three different areas as evidence that the short term window has passed: corporate profits, duration of unemployment, and household debt service payments as a percentage of disposable income. I’ve seen links to this post in a half dozen different places in the econblogosphere lately and I think it’s worth a glance.

Mr. Dourado reproduces graphs from the St. Louis Federal Reserve in support of his observations. I’ll use those as the point of departure for my comments, more riffing on his post than a critique. Rather than considering the timeframe 1997 to present, the timeframe Mr. Dourado elects for his graphs, I’m going to open them up to the full duration supported in each case.

The graph illustrates after-tax corporate profits adjusted for inventory from 1948 to the present. I actually see two different curves. There’s one curve, increasing exponentially presumably with inflation, from 1948 to about 1990. After 1990 it’s off to the races with a brief decline during the recent recession.

I can only attribute that to automation indirectly. What I really think it reflects is the impact that just-in-time inventory systems have had on the return to capital. JIT systems preceded the Internet period (which I’d suggest is about 1996 to the present) and enabled companies to stock considerably less inventory. They’ve really taken hold during the Internet period. It’s truly amazing how “transshipping” has grown. Transshipping is when the end customer places the order with a retailer, the retailer places an order with a wholesaler, the wholesaler places the order with the manufacturer, and the product is produced and shipped directly to the customer by the manufacturer (or some variant of that scenario). Little or no stocking of inventories. Amazon.com is a combination transshipper and retailers service company.

I suspect that some other factors, like China’s pegging the yuan to the dollar and changing policies with respect to the taxing of capital gains, may also be operative. But I don’t see a continuous transition in operation with the present just a continuation of past trends. Something really changed in the 90s and only accelerated in the Aughts.

This graph illustrates the mean duration of unemployment from 1948 to the present. In this graph I do see the present continuing the past trend: peak mean duration of unemployment, subsequent to economic downturns, has been increasing as has been the trough mean duration of unemployment, which has occurred just before the start of a downturn. Yes, the data is a bit noisy. But I think there’s a persistent trend going back sixty years.

The greatest anomaly represented is the present. Even assuming that peak mean duration of unemployment has increased exponentially over time today’s duration of unemployment seems very long to me. Something else must be happening.

This graph illustrates household debt service payments as a percent of disposable personal income. I think I see a long term trend here, too: people take on more debt during booms and pay it down during busts. However, here, too, the period of the Aughts is an anomaly. There was no paying down of debt following the downturn of the early Aughts, only an acceleration.

I conclude with two observations. First, I think that focusing too closely on the period 1997 to the present is an error. It assumes that the early part of that period was normal while the later part of the period has not been. I would need a lot more evidence to support that supposition. Quite to the contrary I think that 1997 to 2006 is a great departure from the past while the last five years more closely resembles a return to trend.

Second, Great Moderation my Aunt Fanny. Grand Illusion, more likely.

8 comments

Keeping Blasphemy Safe, Legal, and Rare

Should we add standing up for American values to the list of jobs that Americans won’t do? There’s a good quote in James Taranto’s post:

In any case, Americans have an unqualified right to disrespect religion. “It is not the business of government in our nation to suppress real or imagined attacks upon a particular religious doctrine, whether they appear in publications, speeches, or motion pictures,” Justice Tom C. Clark wrote in Joseph Burstyn Inc. v. Wilson (1952).

7 comments

Why Didn’t the Banks Collapse?

According to Sheila Bair, former head of the FDIC, the reason that the banks didn’t collapse during the financial crisis was not, as the present wisdom would suggest, because of swift and prudent government intervention, first by the Bush Administration and subsequently by the Obama Administration, but because they were never in any real danger of collapsing.

Excerpts from her book. Get them while they’re hot.

The reason that the Bush and Obama Administrations leapt into the fray was political damage control. They didn’t want to take the risk that the banks would collapse on their watch and they’d get blamed for it. If they didn’t collapse and they did intervene, they’d get credit for it. That’s a formula for ever-increasing intervention.

44 comments

More, Cheaper Energy

There’s an interesting article over at the Christian Science Monitor you might want to take a gander at. That it supports a point I’ve been making here for some time is purely a coincidence. The author, Gail Tverberg, an actuary interested in energy, notes the close relationship between growth in employment and energy consumption:

Since 1982, the number of people employed in the United States has tended to move in a similar pattern to the amount of energy consumed. When one increases (or decreases), the other tends to increase (or decrease). In numerical terms, R2 = .98. (Click on Figure 2 above.)

I have written recently about the close long-term relationship between energy consumption and economic growth. We know that economic growth is tied to job creation, so it stands to reason that energy consumption would be tied to job growth1 . But I will have to admit that I was surprised by the closeness of the relationship for the period shown.

This close relationship is concerning, because if it holds in the future, it suggests that it will be very difficult to reduce energy consumption without a lot of unemployment. It also would seem to suggest that a shortage of energy supplies (as reflected by high prices) can lead to unemployment.

She looks at the relationship in an interesting way. As oil prices go up faster than wages, as has been the case for many years, a greater proportion of disposable income is used paying for oil which leaves less for everything else.

She goes on to suggest that rapidly rising oil costs resulted in lower real wages for most workers, particularly male workers. One of the great under-reported stories of the last century is how declining real wages forced women into the workplace.

Read the whole thing.

10 comments

The Election Isn’t Today

Check out Sean Trende’s analysis of why Mitt Romney will win the presidential election. It boils down to a) no incumbent has ever won with as small a lead at this point as Obama has, b) Romney hasn’t started spending yet and he’s got a lot to spend, and c) everything else is just smoke:

Had pollsters turned on their likely-voter screens throughout, Romney and Obama probably would have been trading leads throughout the spring and summer. After all, Romney’s poll numbers would have been two-to-three points higher (given the average movement we saw when pollsters activated their likely-voter screens), and Obama’s lead fluctuated between 0.2 points and 3.8 points.

As I have been saying for some time, it’s going to be very, very close and I honestly think that’s what both campaigns believe as well. That’s why we’re seeing the hyperbolic reports of voter fraud and voter suppression from the Republicans and Democrats, respectively. Both are real but both represent very, very small numbers of votes, only significant when the outcome is too close to call.

21 comments

It’s Just Pining for the Fjords

The economy isn’t dead, especially as a political issue. It’s just been drowned out by the Chicago teachers’ strike, the riots in the Middle East illustrating more than anything else how easily manipulated the people there are, and the outrage of the day (I will not post about Mitt Romney’s latest gaffe. I will not post about Mitt Romney’s latest gaffe. I will not…). I don’t always agree with Mort Zuckerman but a lot of what he says in his most recent op-ed is right on the money:

Nobody is entitled to blow a trumpet because the unemployment rate for August can be headlined at 8.1 percent, down two digits from July’s 8.3 percent. That’s a drop brought about not by more jobs but because 360,000 people left the workforce. It muffles the fact that 5 million people have now been out of work for 27 weeks or more. That’s roughly 40 percent of the unemployed. Another 2.6 million people were marginally attached to the labor force, and over eight million people have given up looking for a job, so they are not counted because they had not searched for work in the prior month.

Are they lazy good-for-nothings? Maybe a handful, but most are decent Americans eager to work. The average period of unemployment is close to 40 weeks. Imagine the sense of futility that must overcome people who month after month fill in forms, go for interviews if they’re lucky, and end up as they started—with nothing to show because there are approximately 4.5 unemployed workers for every job. Fewer Americans are at work today than in April 2000, even though the population has grown by 30 million people since then. Think about that.

He also notes, correctly, that the claim that the labor force participation rate is due to workers over 60 taking early retirement is complete hooey. The labor force participation rate among those over 60 is the highest it’s been in decades. Older workers don’t have any other choice but to continue working. They don’t earn anything on their savings, the value of their home is decreasing, their taxes are increasing, and the prices of the things that they buy are increasing faster than the small amount of non-wage income they can eke out.

The unemployment and underemployment rates among young workers are particularly troubling as is the birth rate, at a 25 year low.

I’ll add just one more point: the business cycle has not been repealed. It is now more likely that the economy will slow its expansion rate or contract than that it will expand its expansion rate or expand.

Don’t miss the political cartoon that heads his op-ed. Too bad the Republicans weren’t able to field a better candidate.

2 comments

Sentence First!

In his recent column Harold Meyerson leaps from his premise to his conclusion, apparently without a casual glance at the facts in the course of the process:

Teaching, at least in major cities, is also a profession in which minorities are heavily represented; when reformers argue that we need to take down teachers unions to give more opportunity to minority youth, the argument veers perilously close to “We need to destroy the black middle class in order to save it.”

The premises appears to be that a large proportion of teachers “in major cities” are members of racial and ethnic minorities and that unions are champions of minorities. The implication is that opposition to public employees’ unions is motivated by racism. The truth seems to be somewhat more complicated. In Chicago:

Today, just 19 percent of the teaching force in Chicago is African American, down from 45 percent in 1995, the union says; organizers fear that shift means fewer teachers have deep roots in and passion for the communities where they work.

About 42 percent of the city’s 400,000 public school students are black and 87 percent are low-income, according to district figures.

The statistic that I’ve heard cited by representatives of the CTU is that about one-third of Chicago’s public school teachers are members of racial and ethnic minorities while more than two-thirds of the students in Chicago public schools are members of racial and ethnic minorities. Here’s a piece that cites 29% African American teachers, 47% white teachers. Whatever the actual numbers it appears pretty clear that the percentage of African American teachers has declined over the past 20 years.

The Chicago Teachers Union has been the exclusive representative of Chicago teachers since 1966. The reason for the decline in the percentage of African American teachers cannot, therefore, be lack of union representation and I also note that I saw no reports that inadequate minority membership was among the CTU’s grievances on which they struck.

In this post I’m not taking a position on whether more minority teachers would improve educational outcomes (the evidence appears to be inconclusive) or whether the schools should be instruments for affirmative action.

I’m just pointing out that Harold Meyerson’s “playing the race card” is not supported by the facts in Chicago which is the context of his column.

6 comments

My Contribution to “Talk Like a Pirate Day”

Dogs, like most mammals, have the ability to synthesize Vitamin C in their livers. That means that under normal circumstances dogs do not need to supplement their diets with Vitamin C. Since scurvy is caused by a deficiency in Vitamin C and dogs synthesize enough on their own to avoid it, “scurvy dogs” would be very rare, indeed.

Among mammals only simians (which includes us), bats, and cavidae (Guinea pigs and capybaras) lack the gene that produces the protein that enables them to produce ascorbate on their own. In us that gene has become a pseudogene. It’s there but it doesn’t produce anything.

So, “scurvy dogs”, no. Now, “scurvy bats” and you’d have something. Somehow that doesn’t have much ring to it.

2 comments

Chicago Teachers’ Strike Ends

Late yesterday evening the delegates of the Chicago Teachers Union voted to accept the CPS’s contract offer that was on the table and the strike is over:

More than 350,000 Chicago public school students returned to class this morning after union officials overwhelmingly called off a seven-day teachers strike.

Sixteen-year-old Jayton Howard, on his way to Paul Robeson High School on the South Side, summed up his feelings in a word: “Great.”

Parents were happy too. Some expressed hope that the new contract will benefit students in a district grappling with high dropout rates and poor performance.

“They’ll win from the strike,” said Leslie Sabbs-Kizer, whose children attend elementary school.

Delegates for the Chicago Teachers Union voted Tuesday to call off the strike, paving the way for CTU’s entire membership to approve a contract in the coming weeks that will secure them a double-digit salary increase over the next three years, including raises for cost of living while maintaining other increases for experience and advanced education.

Now comes the hard part: paying for what’s been agreed upon. The CPS is already broke. My intuition is that it will be much, much harder to give the teachers their average 17% raise than either they, the CPS, or Mayor Emanuel thinks.

What has been rejected from the new contract is most of the reform measures the CPS tried to put through have been rejected. They may have been misguided but where does that leave us? With a school system from which almost 50% of the students do not graduate on time and frequently come out having only notional reading and math skills. Only 8% of graduates from the Chicago Public Schools go on to a four year college degree. The CPS is quite obviously seriously in need of reform.

Analysts are quickly pointing to winners and losers. Here’s my pick for the biggest loser: Emanuel. He has not emerged from this whole brouhaha looking like a prudent steward of the city’s affairs. Another pick: the city’s taxpayers. It’s pretty obvious that they had no advocate in this dispute.

10 comments

Measuring Progress

I’m on a sort of random observation kick today and with the Chicago teachers’ strike and the role that teacher evaluation has played in it measuring performance is much in the news. How should President Obama’s performance be measured? By the results, how hard he’s tried, by how much opposition he’s received, or by what he promised? Something else? Some combination?

In foreign policy I don’t think the results have been too bad. He hasn’t started any new ground wars which is something. I wish he’d withdrawn from Afghanistan two years ago, gotten the Doha round of trade negotiations back on track, negotiated more free trade deals. I wish he hadn’t engaged in the air war that was instrumental in ousting Moammar Ghaddafi (not that I’m any friend of Ghaddafi’s). A few other things.

Measuring performance is even trickier on the domestic front. A lot depends on how highly you weight what you’re afraid might have happened. Using that yardstick President Bush was a pretty darned good president (which I don’t think he was).

12 comments