It Always Looks Darkest…

just before it goes completely black. Remember all of those estimates of difficulty the Chicago Public Schools will face in paying this year’s expenses let alone the new, improved, higher expenses called for in the new contract with the Chicago Teachers Union? In all likelihood it’s going to be even more difficult for the CPS to pay its bills than I thought. Moody’s has just lowered the rating on its bonds:

Sept 27 (Reuters) – The credit rating for the Chicago Board of Education was cut to A2 from A1 by Moody’s Investors Service on Thursday, which cited the “moderate” increase salaries for teachers under the new labor accord that has yet to be ratified.

The school system, the nation’s third largest, has not budgeted for those pay rises, Moody’s said.

The outlook on the debt – about $6.4 billion – remains negative.

Other factors cited in the downgrade include spending down its reserves, the overhang of unpaid pension fund installments, and the state’s fiscal problems which will probably decrease, delay, or both the state’s contribution to the CPS’s revenues, roughly a third of the total.

The article goes on to substantiate nearly everything I’ve been saying for some time, e.g. raising the property tax rate must be approved by the voters.

6 comments

Vote “No” for President

Conor Friedersdorf of The Atlantic makes a pretty good argument against voting for either Romney or Obama for president:

Tell certain liberals and progressives that you can’t bring yourself to vote for a candidate who opposes gay rights, or who doesn’t believe in Darwinian evolution, and they’ll nod along. Say that you’d never vote for a politician caught using the ‘n’-word, even if you agreed with him on more policy issues than his opponent, and the vast majority of left-leaning Americans would understand. But these same people cannot conceive of how anyone can discern Mitt Romney’s flaws, which I’ve chronicled in the course of the campaign, and still not vote for Obama.

Don’t they see that Obama’s transgressions are worse than any I’ve mentioned?

I don’t see how anyone who confronts Obama’s record with clear eyes can enthusiastically support him. I do understand how they might concluded that he is the lesser of two evils, and back him reluctantly, but I’d have thought more people on the left would regard a sustained assault on civil liberties and the ongoing, needless killing of innocent kids as deal-breakers.

That’s just the opening. It gets better and more specific from there.

At this point I’m leaning “No”.

78 comments

I Think We Need to Define Our Terms

As I was betwixt and between this morning I heard a clip from President Obama’s appearance on ABC’s program, The View, that caught my attention. Here’s a transcript of the part that caught my attention. In response to the question “What would be so bad about a Mitt Romney presidency?”, the president said:

I’ll give you a very clear example. Yesterday Governor Romney on “60 Minutes” was asked, does he think it’s fair that he pays a lower tax rate than somebody who’s making fifty thousand dollars a year, and he said yes, I think it’s fair and I also think that’s the way you get economic growth, the notion being that if people at the top have more income, they’ll invest and they’ll create jobs. I’ve just got a different vision about how we grow an economy. I think, Barbara, that you grow an economy from the middle out, not from the top down, and that when the teacher and the bus driver and the receptionist and the office manager — when they’ve got a little money in their pockets, when they’re doing well, then that means business has more customers, that business makes more profits, they hire more workers, and that’s been the history of our country, we grow fastest when the middle class is doing well and when folks who are trying to get into the middle class have ladders of opportunity. So that’s a different vision about how we move the country forward, and ultimately it’s going to be up to the American people to make the decision about who’s got the better plan.

The emphasis is mine. The reason that caught my attention was the definition of “middle class” implicit in the president’s example.

The president cites four occupations: teacher, bus driver, receptionist, and office manager. Two of those are public employees (teacher and bus driver), two are either public or private employees (receptionist and office manager). In Chicago where the median household income is $38,000, teachers (who start at $48,000 and range from there to low $100K area) and bus drivers (who start at $38,000 and peak at $58,000) are middle class if you define middle class as middle income and they’re sole providers in their households. However, if they’re married with both spouses employed, they’re clearly in the fourth or fifth quintile of income earners in Chicago—upper middle income. IMO when bus drivers are paid at that rate they are grossly overpaid—the compensation reflects being unionized public employees.

Are receptionists and office managers really middle income jobs these days? Must have happened while I wasn’t looking. Every office manager I’ve met in the last dozen years is what we used to call “a secretary” and is paid commensurately however vital her work is to the operation.

From the standpoint of the work done, I would only characterize teachers as being middle class among that group. Bus drivers and receptionists are working class. Office managers would be either working class or middle class.

My point is this. “Helping middle class people” really means dramatically different things depending on what you mean by middle class. If your definition is public employees earning above the median income, raising their pay is how you help the middle class. If your definition is practically everybody else in the middle class, you help them by cutting their taxes and for many of them the most important tax they pay is FICA.

It also occurs to me that another way of helping middle class people is ensuring that there are enough middle class jobs to fill.

I’m not advocating a position on either helping middle class people or ways and means in this post. Just trying to point out the implications.

14 comments

Recession Watch

There’s a lengthy and informative commentary by ECRI’s Lakshman Achuthan at The Big Picture. For some reason or other it doesn’t show up when I go through TBP’s regular user interface but it’s hosted there all right. The commentary outlines the reasons that Achuthan’s organization has been calling a recession by the end of the year, why it continues to do so, and why he thinks we’re already in recession:

In our experience, too, monitoring business cycles is often humbling.

In March 2001, 95% of economists thought there would not be a recession, but one had already begun. And we do not recall anyone outside our shop predicting the 1990-91 recession beforehand.

Hardly any economists recognized the severe 1973-75 recession until almost a year after it started. Indeed, that recession began with the ISM at 68.1, and payroll jobs growth did not turn negative for eight months.

In 1970, unaware that the economy was nine months into recession, none other than Paul Samuelson said that the NBER had worked itself out of a job, meaning that improved policy expertise had made recessions very unlikely.

The key point here is that it is really difficult to know that a recession has already begun – until long after the fact.

Reports of the business cycle’s demise are greatly exaggerated.

12 comments

A Child’s Garden of Econblogosphere Commenters

It must be humor day in the econblogosphere. Noah Smith offers a delightful illustrated bestiary of various different commenters. Among those skewered: libertarians, post-Keynesians, Republicans, MMT-ers, market monetarists.

5 comments

Good Investments?

Barry Ritholtz has an amusing post that looks at the bailouts of AIG, GM, Chrysler, Citigroup, and Bank of America from the point of view of an investment counselor looking at the portfolio of some new clients:

George and Martha, a wealthy older couple, comes into my office. They are not happy with their current stockbroker. Concerned about their future, they ask if I would have a look at their portfolio.

Certainly, we do these reviews all the time. As it turns out, this review would be very different from what I am used to. We sit down to discuss their investments, and perusing their 12-figure account, I almost fall out of my seat. The portfolio is festooned with every risky stock of the past five years. I have to restrain myself from sarcastically asking “What, no Facebook IPO shares?”

Instead, I simply say “Please tell me a little bit about yourselves.”

“We grew up hardscrabble, were self-reliant, always helped out our neighbors.” They are hard working people, and their wealth was accumulated after the war. They tell me they diligently built a portfolio of hard assets – gold, real estate and bonds. They took appropriate risk, were frugal in their spending, and diligently saved money.

It was perplexing. What they were describing about their approach to saving and investing was nothing like the portfolio mess I was looking at.

And oh, what an unholy mess it is: Many of the highest risk, lowest return assets ever to grace a broker’s pitchbook fills their portfolio. Sketchy private equity deals, dubious preferred stock, low rated corporate bonds.

Read the whole thing.

Of course, the bailouts weren’t executed as prudent investments seeking return but to prop up failing companies for fear that their failure would take out other, healthier companies along with them. Minimizing loss rather than maximizing gain.

I do think that the firm of Paulson & Geithner Capital Management has a lot to answer for. Were the claims of imminent disaster exaggerated? (That’s what Sheila Bair says.) Most importantly, was the means selected to bail out the various companies the only or even the most efficient? Judging by performance I don’t think that the strategy that was pursued was sufficiently tailored to the nominal objectives, particularly in the cases of GM and Chrysler. It’s a persistent belief of mine that human beings are complicated but that you can make reasonable inferences about somebody’s relative priorities based on what they’re willing to settle for in a deal.

What does that say about the objectives of the Bush and Obama Administrations in bailing out the two auto companies? Obviously, it wasn’t getting a financial return on the investment. Equally obviously it wasn’t securing the interests of investors or preserving employment in the industry, either.

5 comments

There Can Be Only One

Does anybody think that Steve Jobs would have let the Apple Maps app out the door in its present condition? I don’t.

In related news the iPhone 5 sold 5 million units in its first weekend of release. That’s on optimistic expectations of 10 million units. Apple stock has dropped. Looks like the iPhone 5 won’t be providing that GDP boost some were predicting.

While I’m on the subject of Apple, Foxconn has shuttered its plant temporarily after a riot broke out there. Bet Apple is thinking about second sourcing right about now.

3 comments

Missed Marketing Opportunity

My Cuisinart food processor is 35 years old, older than most Facebook users. It’s still in excellent shape, works like a champ. Or, at least it did. A couple of months ago the main food chopper blade broke. It wasn’t the steel blade itself but the the plastic “hub” that fits over the shaft of the processor motor and enables it to spin that broke.

I dragged my feet on dealing with the problem, as I frequently do. Much to my delight I found that replacement blades, even for very old models, were available and reasonably priced.

Imagine my surprise when I used the new blade for the first time at how much better a job it did. After years of use the old blade had obviously become dull and with a new, sharp blade my food processor was operating better than it had in years.

And people wonder why Cuisinart went bankrupt in 1989 (the brand was acquired by another company). They should have been actively marketing replacement blades. Replace your blade every five years! Every year! The ads practically write themselves.

That’s a missed marketing opportunity.

2 comments

Sideways

It’s pretty typical for op-eds, editorials, and blog posts to be lackluster during the month of August. People go off on vacation (or haven’t returned to school yet as the case may be) and output and quality drops. Like the economy the quality of opinion writing seems to be going sideways. The typical August doldrums have extended into September.

Partisans of both major parties are convinced that their candidate will win decisively. At least one of those grouips must be wrong, seriously wrong. I think they’re both wrong. Most of what I’m seeing in the blogosphere these days is at the intellectual level of “Oh, yeah?”. My eyes glaze over when I read things that blame all of our problems on Republicans or “the Left”.

Blog posts are inspired by newspaper articles, editorials, op-eds, and other blog posts. With such lousy material to work with it’s hard to get inspired.

Maybe I’m just going through seasonal adjustment.

Lately there are a number of ideas I’ve had for posts I just haven’t been able to get fired up about. For example, I started working on a lengthy historical and policy defense of public education. Regardless of how necessary it may be it’s difficult to get worked up enough to spring to the defense of something that’s so bad.

I also thought about posting on religious tolerance. What it is and what it isn’t. What Richard Dawkins and the guy who produced the movie trailer that’s causing so much furor around the world do may be offensive to adherents but it’s not intolerant. However, religion (like race) is a topic that I find signally unrewarding to write about. There’s just no upside. Whatever you write it won’t result in greater understanding for anybody.

As should be apparent to anybody who hasn’t covered his eyes with a blindfold and plugged his ears with his fingers, singing “La, la, la”, the economy is going sideways. No measure proposed by either President Obama or Gov. Romney is very likely to change that.

The world situation is just awful. Europe is just desperate to maintain the present order of things but it’s the present order that has to go. Blaming the debtors is fashionable but the lenders are at least equally at fault for the present state of affairs and they have benefited mightily by the present arrangement. That’s why they’re so reluctant to see it go. Sideways is now their best case scenario.

The tensions between China and Japan are really worrying and show some signs of spilling over into a a general Boxer-style anti-foreign fervor. The U. S. ambassador was attacked driving into the U. S. embassy. Some of the protesters were chanting “Return the money!” which demonstrates a remarkable lack of understanding of the relationship between China and the U. S. Things are not going sideways in China. They’re deteriorating.

The mutual saber-rattling between Israel and Iran continues unabated. Sideways moves us ever closer to war.

We should have left Afghanistan (at least) two years ago. Our departure now or, heavens forfend, in two years will bring back memories of our departure from Saigon nearly 40 years ago. The Obama Administration does not seem to have recognized yet that the president’s dream of a successful conclusion there through applying more force was an illusion.

32 comments

Why Is There Air?

In its most recent post Melinda Pitts of the Atlanta Fed examines some of the various theories on why the recovery in employment has been so weak during the recovery. The first is an examination of the relation between the unemployment rate and the labor force participation rate. I honestly don’t think that a coherent discussion of that can take place without considering the effects of two-income households and reduced mobility due to, for various reasons, being stuck with a home that the owners are unable to sell or unwilling to sell at the price they would receive.

The second explanation, that

the ongoing decline in the demand for less educated men in manufacturing has generated a negative trend in labor market outcomes for these workers for three decades. This trend continued unabated during the years after the 2001 recession but was masked by the housing boom, which lifted employment for less-skilled workers for another five years. This observation is relevant for how one interprets the time series changes in labor market outcomes. If we view the housing boom as an aberration that is unlikely to resume, it is inappropriate to compare current labor market outcomes with those just preceding the onset of the Great Recession.

fits neatly with my last post. My only cavil would be that I strongly suspect that demand for “higher-skilled” workers is itself an artifact. Note that the demand for new law school graduates has crashed since the financial crisis. Without the extraordinary level of government spending on healthcare and education I really wonder how strong that demand would be.

The third considers the barbellization of the U. S. job market—more jobs at the ends of the income distribution than in the middle. In my view that’s a consequence of policy and the folks at the high income end of the barbell will fight like hell to keep it that way.

Another idea is an interesting attempt at quantifying and measuring uncertainty as a factor in the lack of growth in employment.

The final idea is a discussion of the role of tax and regulatory disincentives on employment growth.

Food for thought.

3 comments