Did anyone else notice that the picture of the power station in this article with the huge “smokestacks” with “smoke” pouring out them and the caption
Damage: Global warming has been caused in part by the CO2 emitted by fossil fuels. This image shows smoke billowing out of a power station
is a trifle misleading? There is, in fact, a smokestack in the picture. It’s in the upper left hand corner of the picture and there’s a bit of smoke coming out of it. There might be a smaller one next to it. The large, scary looking things with the plumes pouring out of them are cooling towers and the plumes are plumes of steam.
I have no comments whatever on the article itself or the study it cites. I was just amused by the picture. I’m guessing that the editors didn’t know any better but wanted some alarming power station pictures.
As you can see from the graph above, drawn from the invaluable FRED database of the St. Louis Reserve Bank, in 39 months of recovery the total number of jobs in the economy today remains below its pre-recession peak and, indeed, has barely returned to its level in 1999. Essentially, the net effect is that we’ve moved sideways for ten years. This has occurred even as the country’s population has increased by 10% over the period of the last decade.
A quick look at the Employment Situation Reports of the Bureau of Labor Statistics over the last dozen years reveals that of the increase that was seen over that period much was in just three sectors: construction, healthcare, and education. That construction jobs will likely never return to the heights seen at the peak of housing bubble and that healthcare and education spending are largely funded by unsustainable increases in public spending or, in the case of education, by unsustainable increases in public spending and unsustainable levels of private debt are discouraging.
Under the circumstances I thought it might be prudent to revisit what I believe is actually happening, explained as simply as I can.
Following the collapse of the housing bubble and the attending financial crisis, much of the attention of the authorities both in the government and the Federal Reserve has been devoted to what I believe to be mostly futile attempts at restoring health to the banking system. The fallacy in the strategy has been that although a healthy economy will revitalize an ailing banking sector, you can’t cure a struggling financial sector without a healthy underlying economy.
Let’s think about the role that the financial sector and all forms of consumption—personal consumption, government consumption, and business consumption—play in the economy and in job creation.
The various measures, especially QE1, QE2, and what’s now being referred to as QEx, do very little of themselves for the underlying economy. Any amount of money—billions, trillions, quadrillions—can be inserted into the banking sector and, as long as that money doesn’t leak out into the underlying economy in the form of private sector loans or spending, it will have little effect on the underlying economy and practically no effect on employment. That’s the point of the anecdote I’ve told several times here of the three shipwrecked merchants.
Even in the absence of a reluctance to lend (generally characterized as a “lack of credit-worthy applicants” which is circular) some money, of course, will leak out in the form of compensation for people working in the financial sector and executive compensation. That’s concentrated in relatively few hands, accounting for a lot of the increase in income inequality, and has had precisely the effects you would predict: prices for things that rich people buy have gone up a lot faster than the prices of things that the rest of buy. Consider the following graph:
Handily, Forbes Magazine keeps track of this stuff for us and has been tabulating a Cost of Living Exceptionally Well for some time. Here’s their latest report:
This year, 18 of the 40 good and services in our basket are more expensive. What went up? A Russian Sable fur coat (increase due to an international increase in demand for fine Russian sable skins), Turnbull & Asser shirts (due to an upgrade in their basic poplin quality), a Steinway & Sons concert grand piano (due to increased costs of the very best materials, especially woods), season tickets to the Metropolitan Opera, a Patek Phillipe watch and a pair of James Purdey & Sons’ Shotguns (12 gauge Side-by-Side) sold by Griffin & Howe in Bernardsville, NJ & Greenwich, CT.
A total of 13 CLEWI items remained stagnant in price. Caviar, chateaubriand, flowers, bedsheets, a face-lift, a swimming pool and a tennis court were the items that remained the same. Three items are cheaper this year. A Hatteras 80 MY motor yacht (with 1,550hp Caterpillar C-32 engines), priced at $5.1 million, is down 3% from a year ago. A dinner at La Tour d’Argent in Paris is down 6%, due to a stronger U.S. dollar. This restaurant, dating to 1582, has a nice view of Notre Dame, a leaning toward duck on its menu and an extensive wine list. The average price of a thoroughbred at the Fasig-Tipton Saratoga summer yearling sale is down 6% from last year. Dubai’s ruler Sheikh Mohammed has been the New York auction’s most powerful shopping force in recent years and a driving force on its performance. He curbed his spending this year by spending millions less than usual. As a result, prices dropped and most of the of money spent was American this time.
Price increases for luxury good are mostly due to scarcity. French wines have been at maximum production for a century or more. Caviar and sable production is declining, if anything, as wild stocks are hunted to extinction. The number of tickets available for a Metropolitan Opera season is, essentially, fixed. More money available to be spent on these things won’t result in more employment producing them. It just results in higher prices.
Additional consumption by people in the lower income quintiles doesn’t do much to create American jobs, either. The consumer goods that people buy are mostly food, automobiles, gasoline, apparel, and electronics.
Most of the grain (bread) and meat we eat are domestic. Nearly 20% of the processed food that we eat is imported. Roughly 20% of produce is imported and, importantly, nearly all of the increase in produce consumption over the last twenty years has been imported. See also here. Almost 100% of food additives (coloring, texturizing agents, vitamins, etc.) are imported. The amount of domestically produced food with 100% domestic contents we consume is surprisingly small—mostly fresh meat. Read the package. If it’s been flavor enhanced, color enhanced, texture enhanced, or nutritionally enhanced, it is virtually certain to have imported components regardless of what the manufacturer might say (they may not even know). If you drink apple juice or 100% juice products containing apple juice, the odds are that the concentrate used was imported from China and that includes juice labeled organic.
Increasingly, automobiles are manufactured overseas and assembled in the United States. A very large percentage of tires are imported. We don’t produce internal combustion engines for small cars here. If you drive a small car and it’s gas or diesel powered, its engine was imported. Presumably, it goes without saying that a lot of the oil for the gas that we buy is imported. Oil imports have grown from about 40% thirty years ago to 60% today.
Apparel these days is almost entirely imported—98% or more. Just twenty years ago it was 50%. Buying more clothing will produce jobs but the jobs will be in China, Vietnam, and the Philippines.
Do I need to explain that electronic consumer products are almost entirely imported and those that aren’t are assembled in the U. S. from imported components? Twenty years ago we had a domestic electronic consumer products industry. That’s no longer the case. There are a few design jobs left here but those are increasingly moving overseas as well and the electronics production engineering jobs have been gone for years.
Much of government spending these days consists of transfer payments, e.g. Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, for which the matching consumption has been discussed above. Most of the direct government consumption is defense-related. U. S. military spending comprises 41% of world military spending and ia larger than the military spending of the next dozen largest spenders combined. I don’t believe that increasing real U. S. military spending is either likely or desireable. That largely rules out government consumption as a creator of jobs.
There’s another component of GDP: business investment. Domestic business investment as a percent of GDP has been declining for decades and it is now at a post-World War II low. Uncertainty is one of the reasons for this but it primarily explains why business investment is so low now but it doesn’t explain why it’s been declining for the last thirty years. This is the area that I think must and will change.
In future posts I will consider direct and indirect production, the services economy, and suggest some of the things that we might change to improve our prospects.
In conclusion let’s review.
Money that remains within the financial sector doesn’t do much to produce new jobs.
We import too much of what the top decile of income earners consumes for expanding that consumption to produce many jobs and the production of much of what they consume doesn’t expand much with greater willingness to pay, anyway.
We import too much of what the lowest nine deciles of income earners consumes for expanding that consumption to produce many jobs.
Do we really want to buy more arms?
Businesses are in a sort of holding pattern for a variety of reasons. There’s room for expansion through exports and in select industries (e.g. energy production, mining, agriculture) but that’s blocked by trade barriers and regulations.
Last night’s vice presidential debate appears to have been a Rorschach test. If you went into the debate favoring the Obama ticket, you came out favoring the Obama ticket. If you went into the debate favoring the Romney ticket, that’s how you left. From Talking Points Memo, always a good gauge of the Democratic party line:
DANVILLE, KY — Democrats wanted an aggressive Joe Biden at the vice presidential debate here, and they got one. In stark contrast to President Obama’s listless performance against Mitt Romney in Denver on Oct. 3, Biden came out of the gate on the attack against Paul Ryan and stayed on offense throughout the 90-minute debate.
Biden’s central message to the audience watching: you can’t trust what the Romney-Ryan ticket says. On issue after issue, Biden told viewers to compare the two teams running for president and trust their instincts when it comes to who will look out for the middle class.
“Look, folks, use your common sense,†Biden said during a discussion of entitlements.
while Power Line equally good at expressing the solid Republican view had it:
Score this for Ryan: I’m certain that it was Biden’s plan to try to get under Ryan’s skin, drive Ryan off his core strength (his passionate wonkiness), cause him to make a mistake, lose his composure, or look too young and unready for high office. Biden utterly failed to do this. Ryan kept his cool throughout. I hate ever to agree with David Gergen, but Ryan won on style points. And style points count for a lot in these things.
Despite the obvious asymmetries between the two men that had conservative hearts palpitating that Ryan would crush the egregious Biden, I never saw it that way for a simple reason: the format of these debates is not congenial to Ryan’s strength as a wonk and an intellectual. If this was a formal Lincoln-Douglas style debate with set piece opening arguments and extended substantive rebuttals, it would be a different matter. Add to it the dynamic of last week’s debate face plant by Obama, and it was a sure thing that Biden would be at his egregious worst and that the media would run with the narrative that Biden had “turned things around†no matter how it went. As such, there were high risks in attempting to match Biden’s aggressiveness. Ryan was well-served by “staying within himself,†as they say in sports contexts.
The overnight polls suggest a draw.
True to my word I did not watch the debate. If you have any interest in it at all, I recommend, as I have before, listening to it with the sound off.
Last week Mr. Obama was weirdly passive. Last night Mr. Biden was weirdly aggressive, if that is the right word for someone who grimaces, laughs derisively, interrupts, hectors, rolls his eyes, browbeats and attempts to bully. He meant to dominate, to seem strong and no-nonsense. Sometimes he did—he had his moments. But he was also disrespectful and full of bluster. “Oh, now you’re Jack Kennedy!” he snapped at one point. It was an echo of Lloyd Bentsen to Dan Quayle, in 1988. But Mr. Quayle, who had compared himself to Kennedy, had invited the insult. Mr. Ryan had not. It came from nowhere.
Coaching. We call someone who “grimaces, laughs derisively, interrupts, hectors, etc.” and is disrespectful and full of bluster “Senator”. But the most incisive, I think, was this:
In terms of content—the seriousness and strength of one’s positions and the ability to argue for them—the debate was probably a draw, with both candidates having strong moments. But in terms of style, Mr. Biden was so childishly manipulative that it will be surprising if independents and undecideds liked what they saw.
National Democrats keep confusing strength with aggression and command with sarcasm. Even the latter didn’t work for Mr. Biden. The things he said had the rhythm and smirk of sarcasm without the cutting substance.
And so the Romney-Ryan ticket emerged ahead. Its momentum was neither stopped nor slowed and likely was pushed forward.
I think that’s right but why would Democrats, particularly those in the political class, identify aggression with strength or command with sarcasm? I think she’s right but I genuinely don’t know why that should be the case.
Confucius said:
When there is a preponderance of native substance over acquired refinement, the result will be churlishness. When there is a preponderance of acquired refinement over native substance, the result will be pedantry. Only a well-balanced admixture of these two will result in gentle manliness.
and IMO that’s what we had in the debate last night. Must we have a choice between churlishness and pedantry? Where is the balance?
There’s an amusing anecdote of disorganization in the Obama campaign over at the The Hill:
A prankster briefly jumped on an opening left by President Obama’s digital team on Thursday, setting up a Twitter account under a handle the campaign announced was theirs.
The Obama campaign early on Thursday announced that they would be tweeting responses to the evening’s vice presidential debate from a new Twitter account: @OFAdebates.
But that account did not exist. Then, shortly after 9 a.m. eastern, an anonymous Twitter user reserved the account @OFAdebates, using a photo of Macaulay Culkin from the movie “Home Alone” as avatar, with the location set as “Not Chicago,” an obvious dig at Obama’s Chicago-based campaign team.
An hour later, the account appeared to be safely back under the control of the Obama campaign, with an OFA avatar and website.
I don’t think that announcing the account before setting it up is the only lack of foresight here. How is “OFAdebates” or OFA for that matter pronounced?
The Supreme Court’s hearing of oral arguments in the case of Fisher v. University of Texas, a revisiting of affirmative action in education, has moved me to reflect on the matter. I find the idea of racial preferences of any kind distressing although I can understand the need for them to redress historic wrongs. That’s a need that is slowly evaporating with time. I have always thought the “critical mass” theory embraced by the Court in Grutter v. Bollinger was a crock, a thinly veiled argument for permanent racial discrimination.
The view I’m trying on for size right now is that the Court should abandon “critical mass”, return to correcting a prior history of racial discrimination as the sole basis for present systems of racial or ethnic preference, and subject any plan that is not race neutral to substantially more scrutiny than has been the case. For example, I think that any institution that has an admissions policy that is not neutral with respect to race should be required to make its admissions criteria public. I also think that redressing historic wrongs should be more narrowly tailored. So, for example, I believe that in order to qualify for such de facto quotas the individuals involved should be born in the United States of parents who are both members of the target race or ethnicity and born in the United States. I am aware that this would rule out many prominent beneficiaries of racial preference.
No matter how this divided court rules, what was missing from the arguments was any challenge to the idea that higher education has so few openings that it must dole them out through preferences, whether by race or – an alternative path – by income.
This notion of scarcity has long pervaded the ivy halls of academia. And yet it is being challenged today as never before. Universities are being forced to change by advances in online learning, by competition from for-profit schools, by a parent rebellion over tuition, and by cash-strapped governments demanding proof of skills learned.
Schools wouldn’t need to fight over issues like race if they would lift the perception of education as a limited good and adopt new ways to expand the pie of learning.
I’ve already made my suggestion for making higher education more available to all. How’s this for a more limited version? Have California, Texas, New York, Florida, and Illinois band together, produce a full, accredited online two year degree program with credits fully transferable to four year institutions in those states at no or low charge?
It may be the case that you can’t completely replace four year institutions with online instruction but I find it hard to belief that an online program could not be developed that would be better than a lot of the community colleges out there.
I’ve been thinking quite a bit lately about the charges of lying that are so frequently being leveled during the presidential campaign, not necessarily by the president or vide president or their opponents but with disappointing regularity by his supporters or the partisans of the other side. I see that the charges haven’t been lost on Daniel Henninger:
“Liar” is a potent and ugly word with a sleazy political pedigree. But “liar” is not being deployed only by party attack dogs or the Daily Kos comment queue. Mitt Romney is being called a “liar” by officials at the top of the Obama re-election campaign. Speaking the day after the debate in the press cabin of Air Force One, top Obama adviser David Plouffe said, “We thought it was important to let people know that someone who would lie to 50 million Americans, you should have some questions about whether that person should sit in the Oval Office.”
The Democratic National Committee’s Brad Woodhouse said, “Plenty of people have pointed out what a liar Mitt Romney is.” Deputy campaign manager Stephanie Cutter says Republicans “think lying is a virtue.”
Explicitly calling someone a “liar” is—or used to be—a serious and rare charge, in or out of politics. It’s a loaded word. It crosses a line. “Liar” suggests bad faith and conscious duplicity—a total, cynical falsity.
Politics isn’t beanbag, but politicians past had all sorts of devices to say or suggest an opponent was playing fast and loose with the truth. This week’s Obama TV ad, “How Can We Trust Mitt Romney?” would have been perfectly legit absent the Plouffe “liar” prepping.
Before we can move on to consider whether the charges are just or not I think we need to define our terms. Lying is the knowing telling of an untruth with the intent to deceive. It has four components: there must be an utterance, the utterance must be untrue, the untruthful utterance must have been made in the knowledge that it was untrue, and the person making the utterance must have intended to deceive someone hearing the utterance.
Let’s take an example, something very frequently asserted. Did Bush lie about weapons of mass destruction in Iraq?
I don’t believe so. He definitely suggested that Iraq did so I think we can reasonably conclude that there was an utterance. Was it untrue? We honestly don’t know. As someone else once said, “Absence of proof is not proof of absence”. We didn’t find large stores of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq but that does not prove they weren’t there at the time of the utterance or that the president knew that they weren’t there. Did the president make the statement in the full knowledge that it was untrue? I don’t think that’s the case, either. Finally, did he intend to deceive by the utterance? I find little evidence that was the case. Contrariwise, I think he was merely making as strong a case as he could for the course of action he’d decided was necessary.
My opposition to the invasion of Iraq had nothing to do with the presence or absence of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. I had other reasons which I don’t particularly want to go into now but I don’t believe that Bush lied.
Much has been made of the president’s promises to lower the deficit and Mitt Romney’s remarks about cutting taxes, with one person or another saying the the president or Mr. Romney is lying. I think the remarks are aspirational, of the “chicken in every pot” variety. They aren’t lies and they aren’t said with an intention to deceive. They’re wishes.
Differences of opinion, particularly in areas in which the item under discussion is not falsifiable, are not lying. When someone says they believe in the existence of God they aren’t lying. If God does not exist, they are wrong but, if God exists, they are right. The existence is neither falsifiable nor provable (although I have encountered professors of philosophy who found Aquinas’s proof of the existence of God dispositive).
Things like whether the stimulus actually produced economic growth or whether absent the actions taken by the federal government the economy would have collapsed are not falfisiable. They are matters of opinion and the empirical evidence on both is at best equivocal. I find pronouncing someone a liar because he does not hold the same opinion as you do reprehensible, particularly in an academic who has higher professional obligations.
Just say he’s wrong and provide your best proof. Don’t say he’s a liar.
Is the worst case scenario in the presidential election that the winner of the popular vote loses the election? If I had to predict the most dangerous scenario that might be it.
But worst case? Remember, as the late Mayor Daley once remarked, somebody will be elected.
As is my practice I don’t plan to watch the debate this evening. I’ll read the commentaries tomorrow morning and, if something interesting happened, I might even watch the video of the debate but I won’t watch it live.
It’s a remarkable turn of events when a presidential campaign may hinge on the debate performance of a seventy year old man with (minimal) brain injury. I cut Joe Biden a certain amount of slack when he blurts outrageous remarks out—his self-censor may have turned itself off. But there’s really no telling what will happen tonight.
I presume that both Vice President Biden and Rep. Paul Ryan will bring their A games to the debate and Biden’s an old hand. I seriously doubt that he will be bored, lose his temper, or melt down. Ryan might be wonkish enough for listeners to shut him out but I think he’ll be engaged and loaded for bear. As was my advice in the first presidential debate, look for the body language more than what they’re actually saying. That’s the key to understanding how most people will respond.
Their personal favorability ratings are just about the same, quite a different circumstance from the one Biden faced four years ago in which his personal favorability was substantially higher than Sarah Palin’s going into their debate.
What will be most interesting is how people respond and that’s what I’ll be paying attention to.
Today is my dad’s birthday. Even though he’s been gone for almost a half century I still miss him and he’s been much in my thoughts today. I regret that just as we were beginning to develop an adult relationship he was gone.
I have never found anyone whose opinion was so consistently good since.
I think the time has come to admit that the elected representatives of the people have become an intolerable encumbrance in making progress on the many problems we face as a nation. In recognition of the inadequacy of existing institutions I propose the establishment of a 15 member Independent Policy Advisory Board. The policy prescriptions of the IPAB will become the law of the land unless they’re voted down by the Congress.
In a spirit of selfless devotion to the country’s wellbeing, I volunteer to serve on this IPAB.