Hostess to Shut Down

The strike by the members of the Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers International Union that began last week has broken Hostess Brands, producer of many familiar products including Ding Dongs, Twinkies, and Wonder Bread:

Hostess Brands Inc., the bankrupt maker of Twinkies and Wonder Bread, said it had sought court permission to go out of business after failing to get wage and benefit cuts from thousands of its striking bakery workers.

Hostess, which has about $2.5 billion in sales from a long list of iconic consumer brands of snack cakes and breads said it had suspended operations at all of its 33 plants around the United States as it moves to start liquidating assets.

There are two sides to every story:

Union President Frank Hurt said the company’s failure was not the fault of the union but the “result of nearly a decade of financial and operational mismanagement” and that management was trying to make union workers the scapegoats for a plan by Wall Street investors to sell Hostess.

I have no first-hand experience of Hostess or the baking industry in general. My impressions about what’s going on here are that Hostess has been unable to adapt to a changing market, the company is probably worth more to the investors dead than alive, and what the workers expect to receive on unemployment or disability might well exceed what Hostess was willing to pay them.

Over the period of the last several decades small independent bakeries have practically disappeared, there’s been a tremendous growth in franchises, and there’s been a move to healthier (and fresher) products. One of the biggest changes is the move towards in-store baking in groceries and specialty stores. Even my little independent grocer, Happy Foods, bakes some products in the store.

Hostess relied on a business model that’s been around since the Great Depression—a network of regional industrial-style production facilities with local distribution. That’s a setup that’s a lot more amenable to organization than the model of commercial baking that I see emerging.

I think the union has made a major miscalculation. They should have been going for equity for a long time. Many of the Hostess brands will be acquired and continue to exist but the new owners of those brands probably won’t have any use for Hostess’s production facilities.

With 20,000 employees Hostess is a major player in the baking industry. That’s just a bit smaller than Chicago-based Sara Lee, a likely candidate for taking over some of the brands. A lot of those union workers will in all likelihood never work in the baking industry again. Grupo Bimbo, the Mexican-owned largest bakery in the U. S., probably doesn’t need them.

When Hostess closes its doors its pension obligations for its salaried employees will go to the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation, i.e. you and me whether we have pensions or not, while the pensions of its union members will go their unions. I don’t have hard statistics but I strongly suspect that the membership of the BCTWGMIU has been shrinking for decades and is about to shrink again.

10 comments

My Mom’s Birthday, 2012

Today is my mom’s birthday and I didn’t want to let the day get away without posting a picture of her along with a few thoughts.

This is one of the earliest pictures of my mom. She was less than a year old in this picture, all dolled up and ready to go on stage with Dad, as everybody called my grandfather. Her clothes were probably made by my grandmother who, along with being the lead soprano (“The Irish Nightingale”), doubled as costume maker for the troupe. It wasn’t too long after this that my mom was getting her own billing: “Baby Colleen”. I still have her first contract and the first dollar she ever earned working on stage.

She’s been gone three years now. I still miss her keenly. Life is surreal without her.

4 comments

Rationalize This!

The decline in retail sales in October 2012 is being attributed to Hurricane Sandy:

Retail sales fell in October as American consumers pulled back after a three-month shopping spree and superstorm Sandy slammed into the East Coast, shutting malls and auto showrooms.

The 0.3 percent drop followed a 1.3 percent increase in September that was larger than previously reported, Commerce Department figures showed today in Washington. While it was able to collect information from the affected area, the agency said it couldn’t quantify the impact of the biggest Atlantic storm.

Companies such as General Motors Co. (GM) and Ford Motor Co. (F) said last month’s storm-related sales slump will probably reverse as brighter job prospects, rising home prices and sturdier finances boost household confidence. At the same time, today’s report showed Americans bought fewer non-essentials, which may reflect mounting concern over possible tax changes and limited wage growth that pose risks for the biggest part of the economy.

“Some of it is due to hurricane taking away some discretionary sales,” said Jonathan Basile, director of U.S. economics at Credit Suisse in New York. “Spending still seems subpar, and consumers are facing headwinds on their paychecks and incomes. They’re also faced with uncertainties about taxes going into year-end.”

I’m trying to get my head around this. Tropical storm winds and rain striking the South-East of the United States on October 25 through 27th and the hurricane the East Coast on October 29 reduced retail sales by 0.3%? Wouldn’t stocking up and moving purchases forward in anticipation of the storm have offset this? Wouldn’t the additional buying in Florida, Georgia, the Carolinas, and Virginia to repair the damage done by the storm have offset the closing of stores in the Mid-Atlantic on the 29-31st?

At least we can rejoice in November’s figures (seasonally adjusted) being much, much better due to all of the economic good the destruction will produce.

Update

ZeroHedge sees the result about the way I do:

The just announced October retail sales tumbled, with their worst miss of expectations since May 2010, and the first sequential decline since June: printing at -0.3% for both the headline and the ‘ex autos and gas’, on expectations of a -0.2% and +0.4% rise. Ignoring for a second that the Commerce Department said that Hurricane Sandy had both positive (remember those massive lines in various stores ahead of Sandy) and negative impacts on retail sales, it would be truly inconceivable for the sellside Wall Street consensus of diploma’ed PhDs, which knew about Sandy’s impact on retail sales well in advance, and thus could adjust its numbers, to actually, you know, adjust its numbers. Either way there is no way to spin the longer term major store sales trend (last chart), which shows that the US consumer, out of money, out of credit, and out of savings is entering the holiday season with little to zero disposable spending power.

Check out the graph illustrating retail sales slowing more or less progressively since March.

61 comments

The Next Recession

Perhaps it’s unfair of me but I find it difficult to struggle through an op-ed after the first poorly-informed statement. This morning I managed to make my way through Lloyd Blankfein’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal and I think it was worthwhile if only as a framework for commenting on our economic situation. In his op-ed, Mr. Blankfein, CEO of Goldman Sachs, lists four economic priorities for the Obama Administration in the coming months:

Remove the risk of a double-dip recession and give the economy a stimulative jolt.

This was the bullet point that nearly made me stop reading. There is no risk of a double-dip recession because the economy has now been expanding for more than 15 quarters. A double-dip recession is a recession that takes place within a quarter or two of a previous recession. The window during which a recession would be characterized as “double-dip” has passed. Another recession is inevitable. The business cycle has not been repealed and every claim of its repeal has proven false. A new recession becomes a little more likely with every passing day. I think it’s possible that the next recession could be ameliorated with Keynesian stimulus if the stimulus were timely, properly targeted, and of the appropriate size. Stimulus spending does relatively little good after an expansion has already begun and it does the most good in sectors that aren’t already at full production with substantial barriers to entry, e.g. healthcare. I think that block grants given to the states to help them live up to the unrealistic promises they’ve made to their public employees are unlikely to produce the level of stimulus that we’d need.

Unfortunately, Congress has not proven itself equal to the task of producing a timely, properly targeted stimulus of the appropriate size. It has, however, proven more than equal to the task of lining its own pockets, giving handouts to politically-connected cronies, and paying off contributors. I doubt that’s an efficient way of stimulating the economy.

Restore confidence in public finances.

By this Mr. Blankfein means a “grand fiscal bargain” and I suspect that none is on the horizon. I have no objection to the tax hike that the president is asking for, indeed, I thought the “Bush tax cuts” that the president and the Democratic Congress re-authorized were a mistake. However, I don’t think we should be under the illusion that $82 billion worth of tax increase, the largest estimate I’ve seen of the results of the tax hike, will offset a $1 trillion plus mismatch between revenues and expenditures. That’s only 8%. The Democratic Congressional leadership has already specifically precluded Medicare cuts from consideration. Much as I think we can reduce defense spending I don’t think we can reduce it enough to make up for the difference.

Even in the unlikely event of a “grand bargain” being arrived at would that restore confidence in public finances? I doubt it. I think we’d need an amenable process for resolving impasses of the sort we’ve had for some time to do that and that’s just too much to hope for. There is simply nothing on the horizon.

Keep marginal tax rates low.

We have among the highest marginal corporate taxes in the developed world. To keep them low we’d need to get them low and that appears to be unacceptable to the Senate Democrats. Even with the tax hike the president is asking for the marginal rates on individual income taxes are among the lowest in the developed world. I’m honestly not sure what Mr. Blankfein is advocating here. It’s either the impossible or the tautological.

Act like we need to compete and win—because we do.

This bullet point appears to be a catch-all for pursuing lower energy costs, immigration reform, and trade reform. Remember that the U. S. is the Saudi Arabia of coal. The Obama Administration appears to be pursuing its crusade against coal, a primary leg of energy production, even as it says it has no such crusade. Perhaps it’s a miscommunication between the White House and the EPA. Immigration reform is much in the news these days but most of the energy is being directed towards amnesty for illegal immigrants who are already here rather than immigration reform to allow more highly educated and otherwise qualified immigrants of the sort that Mr. Blankfein appears to be advocating.

I’ve been advocating trade reform right along but it does not appear to be an area in which anybody but me and, I guess, Mr. Blankfein has any interest.

7 comments

Made in China

China’s carbon production is growing faster than the West can shrink its own:

Worldwide emissions rose 834 million metric tons to 33.99 billion tons, IWR said today on its website. China’s releases of the greenhouse gas climbed 6.5 percent, offsetting declines in the U.S., Russia and Germany, the Muenster-based institute said.

“If the current trend persists, global CO2 emissions will go up by another 20 percent to over 40 billion tons by 2020,” Norbert Allnoch, the IWR’s director, said in the statement. Countries’ emission levels should be tied to mandatory investments in climate protection such as renewable energy, the IWR said.

Economies including Brazil, China and India are raising investments in renewable technologies to help meet their growing energy demand. The projected surge in low-carbon sources won’t be enough to meet the United Nations goal of limiting global warming since industrialization to 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit), the International Energy Agency said yesterday.

China was the biggest polluter, with emissions of 8.9 billion tons. The U.S. produced about 6 billion tons of carbon dioxide and India was the third-biggest emitter with 1.8 billion tons, the IWR data show.

I’m not sure how China can bring its increasing production under control. After energy production, particularly via burning coal, and transportation, both of which are growing fast in China and for which they have no ready alternative, the next largest producer of greenhouse gases is cement production in which China leads by nearly two orders of magnitude.

As I’ve been saying for some time to whatever extent carbon production is a serious problem the only real hope for dealing with it is by various geoengineering approaches. Artificial trees. Capturing the carbon dioxide and turning it into methanol (as I wrote about a couple of weeks ago). Other similar approaches.

I also think we’ll be able to tell when those warning about greenhouse gases are really serious when a) they start behaving as though it were really serious and b) they start characterizing it as the moral equivalent of war.

2 comments

Demographics

I have about ten ideas for posts for every actual post I publish here. This is something I’ve been stewing about since the election. I don’t have the inclination to document what I’m going to say so I’ll just blurt it out.

Over the period of the next twenty years the composition of the electorate will change from 72% “white”, as it is now, to about 60% “white”. That’s a demographic certainty. Those aren’t scare quotes by the way. I’m using a definition of “white” other than the one I’d use: people who aren’t black, Hispanic, or Asian. I just don’t see it as that big of a deal.

I’ve never thought of Hispanics or Asians as anything but white. Note that in 1840, when my Irish ancestors arrived here in the States, they weren’t considered “white” and when my wife’s Sicilian grandfather arrived here just before the turn of the 20th century he probably wasn’t considered “white”, either. Jews weren’t considered “white” a hundred or, perhaps, 120 years ago. Being white is malleable in a way that being black is not. I didn’t make it that way but it clearly is that way.

Will Hispanics be as socially and politically cohesive as blacks have been? I honestly don’t know and I don’t think that anybody else does, either.

I think there’s something to bear in mind. Blacks comprise about 12% of the American population. They comprised about 12% of the population 200 years ago, 150 years ago, 100 years ago, and 50 years ago. Hispanics are about 20% of the population. If Hispanics remain politically cohesive and committed to identity politics, the losers won’t be whites but blacks. The way identity politics has worked out in Chicago, likely a bellwether for the rest of the country, is that the political fortunes of Hispanics are rising. After two black mayors (one elected, one appointed), Chicago’s mayors have been “white”.

Over a period of about ten years white Southern Democrats deserted the party in droves and became Republicans. They have dominated the Republican Party power structure for the last couple of decades. Former mainstays of the Republican Party, paleocons and libertarians, are now called “independents” which is another way of saying they have no power at all. My point is that these things can change very rapidly. The only thing that’s a law of nature is that 90% of everything is showing up.

50 comments

Unravelling

There’s a scene in the Three Stooges short, Hoi Polloi, in which Curly pulls on a thread of Moe’s dinner jacket and the whole jacket unravels. Something of the sort seems to be happening in the Petraeus scandal:

The scandal widened overnight. A Pentagon spokesman told reporters traveling with Defense Secretary Leon Panetta to Australia that America’s top commander in Afghanistan was also being investigated for “potentially inappropriate” communications with Kelley.

“On Sunday, the Federal Bureau of Investigation referred to the Department of Defense a matter involving General John Allen, commander of the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) in Afghanistan,” Pentagon press secretary George Little told reporters.

The allegations against Allen are said to involve emails between him and Kelley written from 2010 to 2012. Asked if they were of a “sexual nature,” a senior defense official would only say the messages were, “potentially inappropriate and they bare looking into. The Department is currently reviewing between 20,000 and 30,000 (pages of) documents connected to this matter.”

CBS News senior correspondent John Miller, a former deputy director of national intelligence, says the investigation into Allen “is fallout” from the FBI’s digging around in the inboxes of Petraeus and Broadwell.

He says the Pentagon realizes that if there is any indication of impropriety, they need it to come out now, not during Allen’s confirmation hearing to become the next NATO commander – a nomination which has now been put on hold.

Let’s recap the body count. We’ve got two high-ranking generals and one FBI agent caught engaging in hanky panky in this scandal so far. I honestly don’t giveadamn about what they do in their own time but, as I said on Sunday in what I sincerely hoped and believed would be my only post on this sordid topic, I see this as a workplace and national security issue. If the highest-ranking generals with the most responsibility insist on acting with the self-control and discretion of adolescents, they should be treated like adolescents. If they don’t like it, they should get out. They just aren’t that indispensable.

We have a right to better than the Three Stooges in the most responsible positions in the land.

29 comments

The Phantasm

I think that a lot of people are making more of this story:

The U.S. will become the world’s top producer of oil within five years, a net exporter of the fuel around 2030 and nearly self-sufficient in energy by 2035, according to a new report from the International Energy Agency.

It’s a bold set of predictions for a nation that currently imports some 20% of its energy needs.

Recently, however, an “energy renaissance” in the U.S. has caused a boost in oil, shale gas and bio-energy production due to new technologies such as hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. Fuel efficiency has improved in the transportation sector. The clean energy industry has seen an influx of solar and wind efforts.

By 2015, U.S. oil production is expected to rise to 10 million barrels per day before increasing to 11.1 million bpd by 2020, overtaking second-place Russia and front-runner Saudi Arabia. The U.S. will export more oil than it brings into the country in 2030.

Around the same time, however, Saudi Arabia will be producing some 11.4 million bpd of oil, outpacing the 10.2 million from the U.S. In 2035, U.S. production will slip to 9.2 million bpd, far behind the Middle Eastern nation’s 12.3 million bpd. Iraq will exceed Russia to become the world’s second largest oil exporter.

than it deserves and drawing some unwarranted conclusions.

The country that effectively sets the price of oil isn’t the country that produces the most. It’s the country that can ship in volume with the lowest cost of production. Unless U. S. production is able to undercut the cost of Saudi production producing more won’t make a great deal of difference except to the companies that are drilling and pumping it.

The $64 billion dollar question is how much oil the Saudis will be able to ship in 2020. Not only is their production slowing but they’re consuming an increasing proportion of their own oil themselves, at least in part due to consumer subsidies.

Update

Ben Casselman explains in more detail (and from a slightly different perspective):

Why doesn’t more production mean lower prices? Two reasons: supply and demand.

Oil is a global commodity. What matters for prices is total supply and total demand — not where the oil is produced or consumed. That means that even if the U.S. relied only on domestically produced oil, prices would still be dictated by global market forces.

In terms of supply, politicians tend to distinguish between foreign and domestic oil. But for prices, a different distinction is more important: OPEC and non-OPEC.

OPEC is a cartel, meaning its members collude to try to keep prices high. When prices start to fall, OPEC countries agree to cut back on production in order limit global oil supplies, pushing prices back up. Higher prices, however, induce more drilling in countries outside of OPEC, such as the U.S., which limits OPEC’s influence. The more of the world’s production that comes from outside of OPEC’s clutches, the harder it is for the cartel to control prices.

Increased domestic oil production, then, matters mostly because it adds to non-OPEC oil supply. The trouble is that even as the U.S. is pumping more oil, many other countries are pumping less. The IEA expects a surge in non-OPEC production this decade due to newly tapped deep-water and shale resources in the U.S., Canada and Brazil, but after that the world will rely increasingly on oil from OPEC countries, especially Iraq.

The other half of the equation is demand. The U.S. and other western countries are using less oil due to improved fuel efficiency, increased use of renewable fuels and other factors. But soaring demand in China and other developing countries more than offsets that decline. The IEA expects global oil demand to hit 99.7 million barrels per day in 2035, up from 87.4 million barrels per day in 2011.

If the IEA is right, the equation is simple: More demand plus less (non-OPEC) supply equals higher prices. But higher prices aren’t inevitable. Under an alternative scenario looked at by the IEA in which countries adopt policies to limit consumption of oil and other fossil fuels, prices would stay flat or even fall over the next two decades.

All of this must be terribly disappointing to the “peak oil” folks.

Update 2

The big loser in increased oil production particularly increased U. S. production is Iran. Iran is the highest-cost producer of the major oil-producing and exporting countries countries, so high that oil must be priced at $150 a barrel for them to make money. Oil at $85 per barrel, as it is now, is ruinous to them. The Iranians have been banking on increased worldwide demand and decreased supply driving prices higher. And they’re in desperate need of capital improvements in their oil sector, something that’s been made increasingly difficult by the various sanctions imposed on them. As I’ve been saying for some time Iran’s nuclear program doesn’t really make financial sense as an energy program—they lose more energy by venting natural gas from their oil wells than they’ll produce with their nuclear power stations.

10 comments

Fall, 2012

That’s the view through my front window. The tree is a Japanese maple, var. Twombly’s Red Sentinel. As you can see, it has a more upright form and a denser cluster of leaves than the typical Japanese maple that you see. When I took this picture it was just at the perfect time of day at the perfect time of year. The sunlight pierces right through the leaves, turning the whole tree into a blazing torch of color.

4 comments

A New Old Broom Sweeps Clean Nothing

I hadn’t realized that Bloomberg had transmogrified itself into a humor magazine. William D. Cohan writes there on his picks for the economic team for President Obama’s second term. It’s a side-splitter.

Apparently, the last four years haven’t been enough to convince him of what the priorities are.

0 comments