Footnotes on Twinkies

While we’re obsessing over Twinkies, here’s an annotated list of the ingredients in them

Ingredient Note
Enriched wheat flour Enriched wheat flour is wheat flour from which most of the nutrients have been removed. We make a lot of it here but some is also imported from Canada, Australia, and elsewhere. Wheat prices have been rising lately.
Sugar We pay higher prices for sugar here than they do in most of the rest of the world due to the bans on trade with Cuba.
Corn syrup Use of corn in making ethanol as an additive to gasoline increases its price. We produce most domestically but some is also imported from Canada, Australia, and Thailand
Niacin Almost certainly imported from China
Water Domestic but, of course, highly subsidized
High fructose corn syrup See notes on “Corn syrup”, above
Vegetable and/or animal shortening – containing one or more of partially hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed and canola oil, and beef fat Probably domestic but too vague to research
Dextrose ADM is a major producer of dextrose but see above under “Corn syrup”.
Whole eggs We produce a lot of this here but we import some from China, too.
Modified corn starch See under “Dextrose”
Cellulose gum Produced from processed wood pulp or cotton cellulose. We produce some and import some.
Whey The dairy industry is massively subsidized and has been for more than 70 years. We are a major exporter of whey.
Leavenings (sodium acid pyrophosphate, baking soda, monocalcium phosphate) The major producers of baking soda are Church & Dwight and FMC Corporation, both domestic.
Salt Probably domestic
Cornstarch See under “Dextrose”
Corn flour Ibid.
Corn syrup, solids, mono and diglycerides Corn syrup, dextrose, modified corn starch, and corn flour are all produced under the heading “wet corn milling product”
Soy lecithin Most soy lecithin is produced in the United States, Western Europe, or Japan
Polysorbate 60 I believe the major producer of polysorbate 60 is ICI Americas, now owned by Akzo Nobel.
Dextrin See under “Dextrose”
Calcium caseinate is derived, ultimately, from milk. I think most of it is produced here.
Sodium stearoyl lactylate Much of it is produced by Niacet, in Niagara Falls, New York.
Wheat gluten Probably imported from China
Calcium sulphate  
Natural and artificial flavors Too vague to research but many of the natural and artificial flavors in use are produced in China.
Caramel color Almost undoubtedly imported from China
Yellow No. 5, red #40 Almost undoubtedly imported from China

Mmmmm. That should help your lunch go down well.

13 comments

Is Comedy Less Funny Than It Used To Be?

The Watcher’s Council Forum question today is

Generally speaking, are comedians and comedy less funny today than they were previously? Has America lost touch with its sense of humor?

My take is over there but the consensus among the Watchers is “yes”, I agree, and I don’t think it’s limited to the United States. My explanation is somewhat different than that of my fellow Watchers. Humor is born from misery. We aren’t as miserable as we used to be so, almost paradoxically, we aren’t as funny as we used to be, either.

Another factor may be consumerism. The nature of humor changes when it’s being produced for those who are purely consumers rather than for those who both produce and consume humor. Eventually, the stuff that’s mass-produced for a passive mass market just runs out of steam. We’ve now had more than a generation of comics who’ve confused novelty and outrageousness with being funny. It isn’t novel any more and it’s hardly ever been funny.

It may not be apparent from my writing but I am very funny in life. The repartee comes fast and thick around here—there are always wisecracks, jokes, puns, funny stories, ironies, and just plain silliness here. It sometimes baffles outsiders who aren’t used to living in the middle of a vaudeville routine. I attribute it to a number of factors. When you grow up in a household in a town with Southern affinities, self-identify as Irish, the neighborhood in which you spend your later childhood is Jewish, and your mother was in vaudeville, it comes pretty naturally. Everything is a story.

Some of my reaction is probably just nostalgia and curmudgeonliness but I don’t think that all of it is.

13 comments

Twinkie Reminiscences

Around 1960 my mom became a disciple of Adelle Davis, she discovered healthfoods, and things like Twinkies and Wonder Break disappeared from our diet, never to return. Before then Twinkies, Wonder Break, Hostess Cupcakes, Hostess Snowballs, and other highly processed and largely nutrition-free items were occasionally on the menu. I never much cared for Twinkies but I remember being quite fond of of Hostess Cupcakes. I don’t believe I’ve eaten any of them more than a half dozen times in the last fifty years. Other things that were on the banned list: Sugar Smacks, Sugar Pops, Frosted Flakes, Trix, all other heavily sweetened breakfast cereals, Jif or Peter Pan peanut butter or similar products. They were supplanted by whole oats, blackstrap molasses, wholegrain bread, freshly ground peanut butter, wheat bran, brewers yeast, and yogurt. As you might imagine no one ever wanted to trade for my lunch at school.

Something of which most people are not aware is that the original Twinkies of the 1930s were not filled with the familiar vanilla-flavored cream (or, perhaps, “imitation vanilla-flavored cream-like substance” would be more appropriate) but with banana cream. When bananas became scarce during World War II, the vanilla-flavored cream replaced the banana cream and the iconic Twinkie was born. I have no memories of those pre-war Twinkies but I have distinct memories of banana cream-filled Twinkies which makes me suspect that Hostess must have produced them occasionally in the 1950s.

10 comments

When Is It Okay for the President to Lie?

I have a question. When is it okay for the president to lie to the American people and/or Congress?

  • Never
  • Whenever he feels it’s necessary—it’s one of the things he was elected to do
  • When lives are at stake
  • Some other circumstances?
13 comments

Brainstorming Income Inequality

The title of the post at the blog of the Center for American Progress is “Why Income Inequality Has Skyrocketed In The Last 30 Years”:

American income inequality has skyrocketed over the last 30 years, as compensation for the wealthiest Americans has grown while wages have stagnated for the middle- and lower-classes. Incomes for the wealthiest 20 percent of Americans are now eight times higher than incomes for the bottom 20 percent, according to a study from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities and the Economic Policy Institute. The gap between the rich and poor has grown because incomes for the top 20 percent grew at an annual pace that exceeded the total growth of incomes for the bottom 20 percent over a 30 year period.

A better title might be simply “Income Inequality Has Skyrocketed In The Last 30 Years” because their answer to “Why?” is that the incomes of the highest earners has grown faster than those of the lowest earners which isn’t a great deal more than a restatement of the thesis. It leaves me wanting more. Why have the incomes of the highest earners grown faster than those of the lowest earners?

I think that increasing income inequality in the United States is deplorable for several reasons:

  • High earners have the ability and incentives to employ lobbying to get even more income.
  • Low earners have incentives to demand policies which will make matters worse.
  • A country with a relatively small number of very rich people, a large number of rather poor people, and not a great deal in between is not the country I grew up in, is not what I expected, and is not what I want.

In the interests of exploring the question in a little more depth, let’s brainstorm it. Please list the explanations you think are most likely explanations for increased income inequality. Don’t defend them (although you may be asked to defend them later) or criticize the explanations provided by others. If you don’t think that increasing income inequality is a problem, say that. If you think that increasing income inequality is a problem but nothing can be done about it, say that. This is brainstorming. I’ll start. In no particular order:

  • Poor people immigrating into the country.
  • Currency manipulation by the Chinese, Japanese, and others.
  • The amount of total compensation being taken in the form of healthcare insurance means that income is a misleading measure.
  • Large subsidies paid to the healthcare and financial sectors.
  • Barriers to entry in and protection to sectors and jobs in which incomes are rising.
  • Intellectual property law that is balanced in favor of owners rather than creators.
  • Regulatory capture.
  • Assortative mating.
19 comments

How Much Do Incentives Matter?

I think that there’s a kernel of truth in John Goodman’s op-ed at Forbes on the ways in which policies intended to help people who don’t have jobs may actually encourage them to stop looking:

A new book by University of Chicago economist Casey Mulligan explains that through a major expansion of the welfare state we are paying people not to work:

[I]n the matter of a few quarters of 2008 and 2009, new federal and state laws greatly enhanced the help given to the poor and unemployed — from expansion of food-stamp eligibility to enlargement of food-stamp benefits to payment of unemployment bonuses — sharply eroding (and, in some cases, fully eliminating) the incentives for workers to seek and retain jobs, and for employers to create jobs or avoid layoffs.

Mulligan gives the example of a two earner couple — each earning $600 a week. After the wife gets laid off she obtains a new job offer, paying $500 a week. But after deducting taxes and work related expenses her take home pay would be $257. Since untaxed unemployment benefits total $289, clearly she is better off not working.

All in all, Mulligan estimates that about half the precipitous 2007-2011 decline in the labor-force-participation rate and in hours worked can be blamed on easier eligibility rules for unemployment insurance, food stamps and housing aid.

I think that I would couch it differently: the jobs that are on offer don’t pay enough. Note, too, that the claim is that half the difference in labor force participation rates are due to policy rather than half the difference in unemployment rates.

He also cites the example of employers’ response to Obamacare of substituting part-time workers for full-time.

Economics is neither physics nor mathematics nor accounting although it may be informed by them. It is a science of human behavior and the sad reality is that humans respond to incentives and changes in behavior in response to incentives will inevitably be faster than compensatory changes in policy. Regulatory arbitrage, financial engineering that exploits the difference between regulatory policy and economic substance to avoid regulation or make money, is real and inevitable. The provisions in healthcare reform requiring employers to provide healthcare insurance to full-time employees or pay a fine has had the unexpected but foreseeable effect of reducing the number of full-time jobs which, I presume, will in turn cause the cost of the program to balloon past the estimates made when the plan was enacted.

I think that the estimate of the effect of policies intended to help the unemployed cited above is high. However, I do believe that the decline in labor force participation rate and the increase in the unemployment rate are the consequences of policy. Just not those policies. At least not those policies alone.

27 comments

Question About Labor Unions

The whole Hostess debacle brings up a question that’s been puzzling me. An assertion that you encounter with some regularity, say, in Paul Krugman’s columns or nearly anything produced for the Center for American Progress is that one of the reasons for stagnant wages among lower and middle income people is declining unionization. I think that’s a case of post hoc propter hoc reasoning, i.e. wages were rising in the 1950s and unions were strong in the 1950s therefore wages were rising because unions were strong. I think that, contrariwise, wages were rising and unions were strong because the demand for labor was high, something that hasn’t been the case for decades.

Here’s my question: how did that work out in the Hostess example? Follow-up: why wouldn’t increased unionization and more assertive unions result in fewer jobs?

Note that I have no particular animus against unions. I just don’t understand the argument that increased unionization and more assertive unions would result in increased wages for most Americans. Persuade me.

20 comments

The Mandate

About 51% of the voters that voted cast their votes for President Obama. Of eligible voters about 60% voted. That means that just over 30% of eligible voters voted in support of President Obama. Just slightly fewer voted for the other guy.

10 comments

Debate Question of the Day: the Generals

What with the multiple scandals involving generals and in the interests of closing the barn door after the cows have already bolted, Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta has called for a review of ethics training for generals and admirals:

WASHINGTON — Responding to a string of recent scandals that have tarnished the military, the Pentagon’s top two leaders, Secretary of Defense Leon E. Panetta and Gen. Martin E. Dempsey, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, served notice on Thursday that they would strictly enforce ethical standards for their most senior officers.

“The fundamental mission of the Department of Defense is to protect the nation,” Mr. Panetta said in a memo to General Dempsey ordering a review of ethics training for generals and admirals. “Any behavior that negatively impacts our ability to perform that mission is unacceptable.”

I have a better idea. Why don’t we start reducing the number of general and flag-level officers? My experience as a contractor has been that every guy above a certain rank has a pet project and he’ll continue to promote it, first as an active duty officer and after he retires as a consultant, until he dies.

Today there are roughly 900 general and flag-level officers with a total active duty military of about 1.3 million. In 1945 there were about 2,000 general and flag-level officers for a total active duty military of 12 million. The number of officers then was about the size of our whole military now. I think that a gradual reduction in the number of general officers would have little deleterious effect on force readiness (I hear an active duty noncom somewhere snickering), would reduce costs, and might actually keep the general officer corps on their toes.

For perspective see here.

6 comments

Taxation and Goat Farming

Charlie Musick has an excellent post on the effects of taxation on a goat farmer at RealClearMarkets:

For a goat farmer, government is necessary and does play a very worthwhile role. The government prevents foreign armies from invading and taking the goats (national defense), other people from stealing the goats (justice), or someone from running the goat farmer off the land he uses to raise goats (protect property rights).

In this example with goat farming, it does not matter whether the government is getting goats through taxing new ones(income tax), borrowing goats from the herd (deficit spending), or stealing the goats at night (monetizing debt). When the government takes goats by any means, it destroys wealth and lowers future tax revenues.

However, I think that I draw a rather different conclusion from his example than Mr. Musick does. Unlike Mr. Musick the move to “raise taxes on the rich” doesn’t “get my goat”. His example leads me to the conclusion that the impact of taxation varies based on the underlying economies of the enterprise and that one size does not fit all. What’s a reasonable tax on a banker may not be a reasonable tax on a goat farmer may not be a reasonable tax on a children’s book author may not be a reasonable tax on a doctor may not be a reasonable tax on a manufacturer. Perhaps we shouldn’t be taxing income (production) at all. Shouldn’t we be taxing consumption?

13 comments