The Coming Increases in Health Insurance Prices

This post from Bob Laszewski on why 30% or 40% increases in the price of private healthcare insurance are well within the realm of possibility is worth reading:

On average, expect a 30% to 40% increase in the baseline cost of individual health insurance to account for the new premium taxes, reinsurance costs, benefit mandate increases, and underwriting reforms. Those increases can come in the form of outright price increases or bigger deductibles and co-pays.

In states with the least mandates or for health insurance companies with the tightest underwriting now, the increase could be a lot more.

But when you add the impact of the requirement that older consumers can be charged no more than three times as much as the youngest consumers (the usual standard is now a five times difference), premiums increase dramatically for the youngest.

There ain’t no such thing as a free lunch.

He concludes: “I told them not to call this the ‘Affordable Care Act.'”

Considering that our healthcare costs are already dramatically higher than any other OECD country’s dramatically higher costs would not only be a crime but an outrage. As I’ve been saying for some time, we need healthcare reform.

52 comments

The Search for the Historical Santa Claus

Charlotte Allen outlines the case that Nicholas of Myra, the ancient bishop better known as St. Nicholas on whom Santa Claus is based, actually existed:

Nicholas of Myra is believed to have been born around 270 A.D. and died in 343. Unlike other church fathers, he left no writings, and the first mention of him dates from only the sixth century. In 325 he supposedly attended the Council of Nicaea, the gathering of churchmen that affirmed the divinity of Christ. There, according to legend, Nicholas was briefly imprisoned for slugging the heretic Arius in a fit of righteous rage. But the earliest lists of attendees don’t mention a “Nicholas,” and many historians of Christianity have concluded the saint never existed.

Mr. English nonetheless builds a convincing case that there really was a St. Nicholas. Around the middle of the fourth century, he points out, the name “Nicholas” (a combination of the Greek words for “victory” and “people”), hitherto virtually unknown in public records and ledgers and on tombstone inscriptions, suddenly became popular in Asia Minor and elsewhere. A still-extant tomb at Myra (modern Demre), a Mediterranean coastal town in southwestern Turkey, dates archaeologically to the right period. When the Seljuk Turks, who were Muslims, swept through western Asia Minor in 1087, Italian sailors transported the bones that were in the tomb to Bari, on the heel of Italy, where they are venerated to this day. The bones seem never to have been carbon-dated, but imaging tests conducted in 2004 revealed that they belonged to an elderly man who had suffered a broken jaw—perhaps as a result of that scuffle with Arius, or torture in the vicious persecution of Christians in the Roman Empire during the early fourth century.

If he didn’t actually exist, he should have.

9 comments

Question About Debts, Spending, Revenue, and Deficits

I have a question that I’ve been stewing over in considering the hassling over the “fiscal cliff” or, rather, a series of interrelated questions. Let me just blurt them out and then try to explain what I’m talking about a bit:

  • Is there a maximum percentage of federal spending to revenues, presumably as a percentage of GDP, which if exceeded produces a loss of confidence in the dollar?
  • An optimum?
  • What is it?
  • Does it matter whether the difference is resolved by selling bonds to the Federal Reserve or to others, e.g. private individuals, foreign banks, etc.?

I’ll answer the last question first. I don’t see any reason there should be other than that it should other than that the latter would be most costly.

As to the rest I think there’s some level at which the shortfall in revenue relative to spending, whether resolved as debt or simply by issuing credit, shakes public faith in the currency and produces hyperinflation. I have no idea what level that might be. I think there’s at least some reason to believe that spending could exceed revenue by 5% of GDP indefinitely. That’s how I read the historical record. During much of the postwar period we’ve run a deficit of between 2% and 5% of GDP.

Right now that’s around 10% of GDP. Can we do that indefinitely?

11 comments

Cognitive Dissonance

Something that continues to surprise me is how strongly President Obama’s most ardent followers disagree with him. For example, the president has repeatedly expressed his view that the reason for persistent unemployment is structural rather than due to a shortfall in demand. I’ve posted on this before—you can look it up yourself.

Here’s another example. The president has embraced what his supporters have been mocking as “the uncertainty fairy”:

“In conversations I’ve had with CEOs, what they tell me is, ‘We are ready to invest and we’re ready to hire, but we want a little bit of certainty out there,’ ” the president said during an interview with Bloomberg Television. “I think businesses are going to be ready to hire. We’re seeing pretty strong consumer confidence, despite weaknesses in Europe and even in Asia.”

I honestly don’t know what role uncertainty plays in our present economic doldrums. It may be a lot, it may be a little. I don’t think it’s nothing.

However, here’s my question. Will President Obama’s proposals for the avoiding the “fiscal cliff”, if adopted exactly as he’s proposed, produce more or less uncertainty? I think the answer is more because while it acknowledges a fiscal problem it doesn’t really address the full scope of the problem. That suggests there’s more to come, another shoe yet to fall.

52 comments

The Case Against Cliff-Diving

Alan Blinder states the case against going over the “fiscal cliff” and presents his counter-plan:

First, avoid the cliff by settling on the broad outlines of a budget agreement and then kicking some cans down the road. Specifics can come later. (By the way, please don’t kick all the cans to the same stopping point again.)

Second, as “earnest money” toward an eventual deal, join hands and enact something Republicans dislike and something Democrats dislike. It will show you are serious.

Third, extend the debt limit at least until the budget deal is completed, which could easily take months.

I don’t see how this plan, particularly the second step, can be reconciled with the idea of politics as a zero-sum game in which making your opponent lose is the object.

2 comments

W = Fd

Andrew Biggs and Jason Richwine are beating a dead horse in their attempts to demonstrate that public employees don’t work as hard as their private counterparts:

What we found was that during a typical workweek, private-sector employees work about 41.4 hours. Federal workers, by contrast, put in 38.7 hours, and state and local government employees work 38.1 hours. In a calendar year, private-sector employees work the equivalent of 3.8 more 40-hour workweeks than federal employees and 4.7 more weeks than state and local government workers. Put another way, private employees spend around an extra month working each year compared with public employees. If the public sector worked that additional month, governments could theoretically save around $130 billion in annual labor costs without reducing services.

We’ve excluded teachers from the full-year comparison because of their naturally shorter work year. But could public-private differences in work time be due to other occupational differences between the sectors? Large differences in work hours actually persist even when comparing workers with similar jobs and similar skills in each sector.

Based on the most detailed and objective data set available, the private sector really does work more than the public sector. This fact may hold different lessons for different people, but our own take is simple: Before we ask private-sector employees to work more to support government, government itself should work as much as the private sector.

They will never convince anyone who’s not already predisposed to agree with them of it. I can already hear the thousands of anguished cries about overworked civil servants.

Let me propose a simple example from physics. Work is measured by the distance moved in the direction of the application of force. If there’s no movement, there’s no work. It’s too easy to confuse being busy with working.

Endless meetings at which nothing is accomplished, endless filling out of forms that nobody will ever look at, and endless reports that no one will ever read are not work. They can keep you very busy, however. This is not a problem unique to government. I have yet to encounter any large organization in which there aren’t any number of people who are very busy and undoubtedly consider themselves overworked who are not actually working in the sense of producing motion. It’s true of companies, governments, not-for-profits, you name it.

15 comments

These Are the Maximum Offers?

The editors of the Washington Post have come around to the position I’ve been arguing here for some time. Neither the offer from the White House nor the offer from the House for resolving the “fiscal cliff” is adequate:

What’s worrisome, though, is that the two sides are slipping into a kind of tacit agreement to scale back the size of an ultimate debt-reduction package. The president billed his plan as $4.4 trillion worth of debt reduction over 10 years. But $2.4 trillion of that comes from lower interest payments, alleged savings from winding down overseas wars Mr. Obama never planned to fight and discretionary cuts that were legislated a year ago. Mr. Boehner’s letter similarly identifies only $2.2 trillion of new revenues and cuts.

It will take more than that to dent the debt. A new report from a Bipartisan Policy Center task force headed by former senator Pete Domenici, a Republican, and former budget director Alice Rivlin, a Democrat, suggests that it would take $2.8 trillion in fresh cuts and revenue to stabilize the debt at 69 percent of gross domestic product by 2022 — above historical levels but sustainable. It would appear that Republicans and Democrats must not only come together but also raise their sights.

Don’t tell me what you’re willing to do. Tell me what will solve the problem.

We have left the land of comfort, of what we’d like to do. It’s in the rear view mirror and there’s no turning around. Now we must, as Bill Clinton memorably put it focus like a laser beam on what we need to do.

0 comments

The Endless Bummer

Matt MIller wonders if we haven’t entered a period in which we have a stable political equilibrium that will induce a continuing series of “fiscal cliffs”:

Here’s the scenario. Recall that all this started in the summer of 2011, when gridlock in the debt talks and the later breakdown of the supercommittee led to creation of the cliff we now face. It seems almost certain that any new deal that is struck, either before January 1 or some time afterwards, will involve some minor near-term “action” or “down payment” combined with the creation of a new fiscal cliff of unpleasant consequences to be triggered sometime in 2013 if a broader deal on tax and entitlement reform is not reached.

This, because a divided Washington needs “a forcing device” to instigate action.

But what will have changed later in 2013 to produce a different outcome? Arguably nothing. And so we have the prospect of another deal with illusory progress later in 2013, along with the creation of the next forcing device. Which eventually forces the next sham deal and the creation of the next forcing device.

And so on. Endless forcing devices that force the creation of new forcing devices. Cliffs that bequeath future cliffs.

His solution: one party rule. That would be hunky dory if either party were proposing measures that would pull us back from the brink in some sort of sustainable way but they aren’t. Does anybody really believe that raising the marginal tax rates on the highest income earners to 99%, cutting defense spending to, say, Germany’s level, and subsidizing “green energy” companies and industrial unions will restore robust growth to the economy? How about cutting personal income tax rates, increasing defense spending, abolishing Social Security, and turning Medicare into a voucher program?

The whole would be greater than the sum of two sane, temperate parts. The sum of two radicalized parts, more interested in sticking it to their political opponents than resolving the country’s problems, is bupkis.

6 comments

Cliff Hanger

Stock market analyst John Hussman says that the U. S. is tipping into recession:

With industrial production, capacity utilization, real disposable income, real personal consumption, real sales retail and food service sales, and real manufacturing and trade sales uniformly declining in their latest reports, coincident economic indicators – having generally peaked in July – are now following through on the weakness that we’ve persistently observed in leading economic measures. We continue to believe that the U.S. economy joined a global economic downturn during the third quarter of this year.

While we use a broad range of signal extraction and noise-reduction methods in our own work, the economic data in recent months has required less and less sophisticated analysis, as many of the most reliable leading economic measures have turned clearly lower (e.g. Philly Fed Index, Chicago Fed National Activity Index, and the new orders and order backlog components of numerous regional and national Federal Reserve and purchasing managers surveys). Still, the leading/coincident/lagging relationships across these indicators remain important. Not surprisingly, analysts have now turned to the last refuge of the economic data, which is to focus on historically lagging measures such as payroll employment.

to which Alan Abelson adds:

While the past few weeks’ economic numbers have tended, not surprisingly, to trace the economy’s recovery from the superstorm, it emerges that consumers have turned parsimonious again. Their outlays, far from setting any worlds on fire, actually contracted a fraction or two, along with the size of their paychecks. Besides the littered legacy of Sandy, consumer-price increases, and the fear and loathing of the fiscal cliff merit a chunk of the blame.

Our precarious perch, which is a great place to watch the fiscal drama unfold, unfortunately provides no clear view of what might transpire between now and the end of the year, when the draconian fiscal measures are due to become law unless the fractious powers-that-be come up with some desperate plan that would win the nod to avoid the encroaching cliff and a conceivable lapse into recession.

I don’t know whether the economy will grow slowly, contract, or expand next year (Yuval Rosenberg suggests that it’s not a question of whether the economy will grow slowly but how slowly). I do know that recoveries don’t go on forever and, phlegmatic, even imperceptible to many of us as the present recovery has been, it, too, will draw to a close.

They say that step one is admitting you have a problem. Are we there yet?

21 comments

You Be the Judge

When my wife showed me this video

as a longtime choir director it, well, struck a chord with me. To get the full, awful magnificence of it you need to watch the whole thing, which takes a certain amount of sticktoitiveness. I turned back to her and said “This choir has the wrong name. It should be ‘The Unbearable Whiteness of Being'”.

I think the moral of this story is ‘Shoemaker, stick to thy last’. Or, as Dirty Harry put it, “A man’s got to know his limitations.” Not all material is suited to every choir.

12 comments