Spend, Spend, Spend!

He who mounts a hobbyhorse dare not dismount. Dean Baker says “Only spending can save us now”:

There is nothing in the private sector that will replace the $1 trillion in annual construction and consumption demand that we lost when the housing bubble collapsed and the rest of the economy pretty much followed.

We can love the private sector to death, but businesses do not invest because politicians love them. They invest when they see demand. They don’t see it now and are not likely to see it any time soon. Consumers also will not go back to spending the way they did at the peak of the bubble for the simple reason that $8 trillion in housing-bubble wealth has vanished.

In this context, the government has the responsibility to fill the gap in demand. It can best do this through investments that will both create demand in the short-term and increase our productive capacity in the longer term.

The problem with this view is that it assumes that, despite all evidence, politicians will spend money wisely, productively, and efficiently rather than using it bolster their own positions, paying off friends, funding pet projects. It also ignores the reality that the only way for the government to spend enough fast enough is via the tax system which means doing the reverse of what was done last month, increasing the taxes of the highest income earners and reimposing the payroll tax.

Two words for Dr. Baker: explain Japan.

Here’s a wacky suggestion. Rather than thinking of the government as the consumer of last resort think of the government as the employer of last resort (as Keynes did).

I gather that Dr. Baker doesn’t believe the finding that debt to GDP ratios over 90% result in slow or no growth. Or, possibly, like the Chartalists, he believes that the government can issue credit virtually without limit without having an adverse effect on the private economy.

There are other solutions but there are no quick solutions. That’s why the fire sale, one time only ARRA was so unforgiveably stupid. The money was squandered, it didn’t create the headroom necessary to make the structural changes we need, there’s no appetite for structural change, and it kicked our debt payments into high gear.

8 comments

Social, Yes. Security, Not So Much

No country is as much in need of a system of social insurance as China. Traditionally, in Confucian Chinese society, children supported their parents in their parents’ old age. The “One Child Policy”, introduced in 1978 turns 35 this year along with the lonely singletons born under that policy. The parents of those children are nearing retirement age. Assume a couple with one child. Those two people also have the responsibility for as many as four parents. A family of six adults and one child is quite a financial burden for average Chinese paychecks. It’s even worse in rural areas.

In 2009 China introduced a system of universal social insurance for the very first time. Unsurprisingly, the system is already drastically underfunded to meet its obligations.

You might want to check out this interesting article at the NYT on China’s social insurance system.

If you don’t feel like clicking over there, here’s a shorter version: China doesn’t have the civil infrastructure for universal social insurance. Or for a lot of other things that Westerners take for granted. Like the ability to enforce international systems of intellectual property law, for example.

5 comments

Why ACOs Won’t Save Money

Shorter Christensen, Flier and Vijayaraghavan: Accountable Care Organizations, groups of healthcare providers providing coordinated care and accountable to patients and mandated under the Affordable Care Act, won’t save money because doctors and patients don’t want to save money.

4 comments

The Vision Thing

Let’s consider one phrase in FDR’s first modern State of the Union message:

I shall continue to regard it as my duty to use whatever means may be necessary to supplement State, local and private agencies for the relief of suffering caused by unemployment. With respect to this question, I have recognized the dangers inherent in the direct giving of relief and have sought the means to provide not mere relief, but the opportunity for useful and remunerative work. We shall, in the process of recovery, seek to move as rapidly as possible from direct relief to publicly supported work and from that to the rapid restoration of private employment.

Note the hierachy of values in the statement. Benefits paid by the government (“relief”) are a necessary evil. Publicly supported work is an explicit, temporary transition to the ultimate goal, private employment.

Is there a comparable vision at work now? I don’t see it. The closest I see is the Keynesians’ insistence on boosting “aggregate demand” to realize “potential GDP”, a substantial step of abstraction away from FDR’s statement of objectives.

That the effectiveness of boosting aggregate demand is predicated on there being unused production does not seem to enter into the thinking. My view, as I have said for some time, is that there’s a lot less unrealized potential GDP than many people seem to assume. Remember, GDP is measured in dollars, not in widgets or hours worked. That means that, when the price of widgets goes down, the GDP represented by that decrease is just plain gone.

17 comments

Tales of the Unbelievable

Can anybody seriously believe that the Pentagon is unable to cut $55 billion a year from its budget without compromising national security? Based on the prescriptions that are being offered, I see that a “firemen first” strategy is being employed, i.e. they’re proposing cuts where they will hurt the most rather than where they will hurt the least, hoping to build political support for a reprieve from any cuts at all.

Here’s my modest proposal for reducing costs: cut the number of general officers in half. That will do a lot more than just reducing the payroll by a few highly compensated individuals. For one thing, all of those general officers have their own spending priorities, some they’ve been advocating for decades.

8 comments

Not Whether But When

I actually agree with Robert Samuelson’s observation that the reason that job growth is so slow is a factor of changing psychology:

We have gone from being an expansive, risk-taking society to a skittish, risk-averse one. Before the 2008-09 financial crisis, the bias was toward more spending. The inclination was to surrender to immediate gratification. Want a new car? Sure, why not? More meals out? Great idea! Businesses behaved similarly. Banks made the next loan; companies hired the next worker and approved the next investment project. An ever-expanding economy justified optimism, and optimism supported an ever-expanding economy. Hello, bubble.

The psychology has now reversed. The bias is against extra spending. Eat out? Try leftovers. Remodel the basement? Oh, leave it alone. In the boom years, the personal saving rate (savings as a share of after-tax income) fell from 10.9 percent in 1982 to 1.5 percent in 2005. Now it’s edging up; from 2010 to 2012, it averaged 4.4 percent. It could go higher, imposing a further drag on the economy.

Where I disagree is on the matter of timing. I think that Mr. Samuelson misleads, maybe even misleads himself, by considering average rate of new firm foundation rather than the rate of new business formation by year and how that’s changed over time. That’s illustrated in the graph above, which uses Small Business Administration and Census Bureau data. As you can see beginning in the early 1990s the rate of new business formation declined sharply and has continued its decline since. If you look at the data going back before 1990 the pattern is even more pronounced. I’d’ve extended the graph to illustrate new business formation since 2007 but I didn’t want to frighten the children.

As I see things, a number of interacting factors have been at work:

  • Generational change
  • Opening China up to foreign trade
  • Currency manipulation by China, Japan, and South Korea (just to name a few)
  • Off-shoring
  • Mass shedding of jobs by large firms
  • Slower rate of new business formation
  • Mass immigration of low-skilled workers
  • Fed policy that encouraged asset inflation
  • Management that thought one quarter at a time
  • Vast subsidies given to relatively unproductive sectors, e.g. healthcare, education, and finance.

just to name a few.

The oldest Baby Boomers turned thirty in 1976; the youngest turned thirty in 1994. China officially ended its policy of autarky in 1979 and pegged its currency to the dollar in 1992. The auto manufacturers, just to give one example, have cut their hourly payrolls in half or more over the period of the last 30 years.

Over the years that I’ve been operating this blog I’ve produced dozens of suggestions for changing the dynamics the factors outlined above create. Let large firms fail. Retaliate against currency manipulators. Workplace enforcement to reduce the number of illegal workers, disincentivizing the immigration of low-skilled workers and forcing us to make the necessary change away from business models that rely on a continuous supply of low-skilled workers at low pay. Abolishing the corporate income tax to allow businesses to think farther ahead than one quarter at a time. Changes in corporate governance rules to the same end.

It’s not a question of whether our psychology has changed but when. Our psychology didn’t suddenly change in 2007. Thinking that drives you to the wrong conclusions about what’s wrong now. We’ve been heading towards the shoals for a long, long time. The direction in which we’re headed is unsustainable and we will inevitably make substantial changes. That’s not a case of whether but when, either.

20 comments

The Punch Line

My wife reminded me that I didn’t give you the punch line to my story about my learning to read. At the end of the summer we were on a family trip, one of the earliest of many we were to take over the years. We stopped for gas and a potty break. When I came out of the restroom, I asked my father “Daddy, what does ‘prophylactic’ mean?” He replied, “Something to keep you clean, Dave.” Then they knew I could read.

0 comments

Slouching Toward Bethlehem

There’s a lot to chew on in this column from Zachary Karabell. Here’s his peroration:

One day, we will look back on this era as a period of transition. The problem is that we don’t know what we are shifting to, or whether it is something we will perceive as better or worse.

Government will be one aspect of that transition. But it would be a mistake to see it as the axis of that transition. The current Washington debates ‑ about whether there will be a “sequester” or not, a drastic cut in spending or only a small one ‑ demonstrate that government is shrinking and the horizons of its ambitions narrowing. Given the limitations of what government can and cannot do, that is hardly something to mourn or decry.

Protecting the commons is something government must do and is. Singlehandedly managing the transition to the next economy is something is cannot do ‑ and should not.

I think the great political conflicts of today are over who is trying to do what. Does the president really want to institute a regime of technocracy, something which, as Mr. Karabell notes, is doomed to failure, maybe even catastrophic failure. Are the House Republicans trying to impose some sort of minarchist fantasy? If that’s not what either is trying to do what are they trying to do? When you do not express your vision or intentions clearly, you can hardly blame people for being mistrustful.

How can government best “protect the commons”? It’s an interesting question, one to which I do not know the answer. I don’t think that granting what are in effect perpetual copyrights is protecting the commons. I think it’s privatizing the commons. And not in a good way. Increasingly, this appears to be the role of government: granting royal patents to friends and allies.

What is government’s most effective role as the new economy slouches towards Bethlehem, to be born? Does it play the role of the wise men or of Herod?

17 comments

The Waste

I see that the editors of the Sun-Times understand the sorrow that I expressed when I learned of Jesse Jackson, Jr.’s plea deal:

The name alone guaranteed him a safe seat in Congress for life, a staging point from which to run for mayor of Chicago or the U.S. Senate.

In 1997, Newsweek wondered if he would be the first black president.

And what a terrific congressman Jesse Jackson Jr. promised to be. From the day he was elected in 1995 from the Second District, he was a star. He made a point of never missing a floor vote. He got a plum seat on the Appropriations Committee. Had he done nothing but stay in Congress, he could have built seniority, broadened his influence and one day run the show.

And make no mistake, Jackson Jr. had the chops to do it. He was smart and charismatic. He worked hard. He was his father’s son, yes, but much more. He had his own ideas, his own notions and ways.

And then he threw it all away. Starting in 2008, Jackson Jr. all but disappeared from public view, ducking the rumors and allegations that he had schemed to buy a Senate seat from Gov. Rod Blagojevich.

It really is the stuff of Greek tragedy. This is hubris at work, plain for all to see and in our own times.

As Lord Acton said, “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men.” He wasn’t the first to express such a sentiment—the idea goes back at least a century farther with similar statements having been made by William Pitt the Elder more than a century before. And yet we continue to insist that power be further aggregated rather than dispersed.

3 comments

It Started With Juvenile Science Fiction

I’ve mentioned it before but I may as well tell the story again. I didn’t learn to read in First Grade. It was probably because I despised the nun who was my teacher for most of that year.

First grade for me started well enough. My teacher was a young, cute, cheery nun named Sister Michael Mary and I was crazy about her. For reasons I’ve never known she was soon replaced by Sister Redempta, an old, ugly, harsh woman who struck our hands with rulers and our ears with her hands. She was the one (along with the coaches of the Khoury League baseball teams I played on) who made me ambidextrous, by striking me when I attempted to write with my left hand.

Whatever the reason, at the end of First Grade I couldn’t read. However, that summer, at least according to the story my mom told, something surprising happened. I took my dad’s old Fourth Grade Reader, disappeared behind the couch for much of the summer, and, when I emerged, could not only read but was reading at a sixth grade level.

It was right about then that I checked out the very first book I ever checked out from the library on my own without my mother having selected it. It was Red Planet by Robert Heinlein. In quick succession thereafter I plowed through every Robert Heinlein juvenile, Isaac Asimov (writing as “Paul French”) juvenile, Oz book, Mushroom Planet book, Tom Swift book, Hardy Boys book, and Roy Rockwell book I could lay my hands on. The next year when I went to the St. Louis Book Fair, I returned home with a huge trove of them, bought for a nickel or ten cents a piece.

In the interest of full disclosure I should probably mention that I was not prejudiced against “girl’s books”. I read all of the Nancy Drew books as well as the Judy Bolton series. I drew the line at the Cherry Ames or Trixie Belden books. I have never read the Bobbsey Twins books and you can’t make me but I did read all of Lucy Fitch Perkins’s “Twins” series books and enjoyed them.

I also read Edith Hamilton’s Mythology, received a copy of Bulfinch’s Mythology on my 9th birthday, and read every one of Andrew Lang’s “color” books of fairy tales I could find.

I discovered the “Andre Norton” juveniles and read all of those I could put my hands on. At the urging of my parish priest, I read C. S. Lewis’s Perelandra series (I didn’t discover the Narnia books until I was an adult). I read At the Back of the North Wind. Treasure Island. Kidnapped. The Swiss Family Robinson.

I exhausted those but, a year or so later, my mom gave me a copy of a collection of H. Rider Haggard novels when I had the mumps and my transition to adult fiction began. I finished all of the Haggard books I could find, devoured Jules Verne and H. G. Wells, and began tipping my toe into contemporary adult science fiction, fantasy, mysteries, and classic and contemporary fiction. But that’s another story.

Not only was all of this decades before online anything, paperbacked books were just starting to become available in quantity. What I liked to read went out of print rapidly and, in general, if the library didn’t have it, I had to haunt the used book stores to find copies. Reading was synonymous with collecting. To read you had to collect.

21 comments