The Last Charge

Lieut. Col. Edwin Price Ramsey, commander of the 26th Cavalry Regiment of the U.S. Army who conducted a guerrilla campaign against the Japanese after the Japanese invaded the Philippines, has died:

Historians have said that losing the Philippines in the early stages of World War II was a defining event in the career of Gen. Douglas MacArthur.

The same could be said of Edwin Ramsey. But Ramsey couldn’t admit defeat.

After MacArthur’s retreat in early 1942, Ramsey, an officer in the 26th Cavalry Regiment of the U.S. Army, joined the Philippine resistance. He eventually headed a guerrilla force that grew to 40,000 enlisted men and officers, supplying crucial intelligence that helped lay the foundation for MacArthur’s triumphant return more than two years later.

In January of 1942 as a lieutenant, Ramsey commanded what was to be the last cavalry charge the U. S. Army mounted against enemy forces:

As the Japanese Imperial Army landed thousands of soldiers near Manila Bay in January 1942, the 26th Cavalry was ordered into the fray to delay the enemy’s advance. Ramsey, then a lieutenant, led 27 riders to the strategic coastal village of Morong.

The village was still as Ramsey entered, but a Japanese advance guard soon shattered the silence with guns blazing. When Ramsey spied hundreds more Japanese troops wading across a river toward him, he knew his men had only one hope for survival.

He raised his pistol and, like a long line of cavalrymen since Custer’s time, hollered, “Charge!”

“Bent nearly prone across the horses’ necks, we flung ourselves at the Japanese advance, pistols firing full into their startled faces,” he recalled in “Lieutenant Ramsey’s War,” a 1991 memoir co-written with Stephen Revele. “A few returned our fire, but most fled in confusion…. To them we must have seemed a vision from another century, wild-eyed horses pounding headlong; cheering, whooping men firing from the saddles.”

After repelling the invaders, Ramsey and his platoon held their position for five hours under heavy fire until reinforcements arrived.

“This gallant little band of horsemen had maintained the best traditions of the American Cavalry,” Gen. Jonathan Wainwright, then a senior field commander under MacArthur, wrote in his official report on the battle. “I doubt if I could have successfully made that withdrawal” without them.

He and his men endured incredible privations as they successfuly eluded the Japanese for years, until MacArthur’s return. He was to say later that he did not expect to survive the war but that his temperament made it impossible for him to surrender.

1 comment

Irish on St. Patrick’s Day

It’s been a few years since I’ve written a St. Patrick’s Day post. As has been my custom, I’ll explain that despite my Swiss-German surname, I’m between a quarter and three-eighths Irish, entirely from my mother’s side. I honestly don’t know for sure—I haven’t been able to track the Blanchards back to Europe. My maternal grandfather Blanchard claimed to be Irish but my intuition is the Blanchards were French but that his mother and Blanchard grandmother were both Irish so he identified as Irish.

The Irish surnames in my family that I know about are Flanagan (Westmeath), McCoy (probably Armagh), Dunn (?), and Rogan (or, possibly, Grogan—I don’t know where in Ireland they were from, either).

My wife’s more than a quarter Irish. Not sure how much more. Her maternal grandmother’s maiden name was Russell and her parents were born in Ireland. Her paternal grandmother’s name was McCormick. I’ve traced the McCormicks back to Ireland in the 17th century. I strongly suspect they were Scots-Irish Protestants.

What if I tell one of my wife’s favorite Irish jokes this year? Bridget and Mary were chatting with some of their friends. When Bridget told the group that her husband had just died, they were all suitably sympathetic. “And what did he die of?”, one of them asked. Bridget responded, “He died of the gonorrhea.” When the others had left, Mary, surprised, asked Bridget “And why were you sayin’ that Sean died of the gonorrhea when you know he died of the diarrhea?” To which Bridget responded, “I’d rather he be remembered as a bit of a sporting man than for the sh*t that he was.”

Previous St. Patrick’s Day posts:

Irish on St. Patrick’s Day, 2007
Irish on St. Patrick’s Day, 2006
Irish on St. Patrick’s Day, 2005
Irish on St. Patrick’s Day, 2004
Colcannon (Irish recipe)

2 comments

Walking Down Alleys

When I walk the dogs, a multiple times daily event, we frequently walk down the alleys that run in back of the houses in this neighborhood. You can learn a lot by walking down alleys. The people who throw all of their yard waste into the alley, creating a habitat. That’s a violation of city ordinance. The people who throw all of their dog waste over the fence into the alley, a tasty snack for vermin. That’s a violation of city ordinance, too.

Then there are the houses that are immaculate from the front but whose alley fences haven’t been repaired or replaced in thirty years until they resemble something you might see in a Third World slum. Slats missing, rotting, leaning precariously.

People throw away some pretty interesting things. Practically a history of technology. CRT-type monitors are a pretty commonplace find these days. On occasion I’ve found boxes of perfectly good, nearly pristine books. Not text books, either. This morning I found a small stack of dishes, Homer Laughlin. Judging from the style they were probably better restaurant or hotel dinnerware of the 1950s.

One day behind the house of a man, woman, and child I found a stack of burned men’s clothing. I don’t recall seeing the man after that. His car certainly wasn’t parked in the alley car park any more.

You can learn a lot by walking down alleys.

10 comments

The Three Laws

Seventy years ago in his short story Runaround, science fiction writer Isaac Asimov introduced the “Three Laws of Robotics”. They are:

  1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
  2. A robot must obey the orders given to it by human beings, except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
  3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Laws.

In an op-ed today in the Wall Street Journal Robert H. Latiff and Patrick J. McCloskey lay out the case for restraint in developing autonomous robots with the ability to kill:

These machines will bring many benefits, greatly increasing battle reach and efficiency while eliminating the risk to human soldiers. If a drone gets shot down, there’s no grieving family to console back home. Politicians will appreciate the waning of antiwar protests, too.

The problem is that robotic weapons eventually will make kill decisions on the battlefield with no more than a veneer of human control. Full lethal autonomy is no mere next step in military strategy: It will be the crossing of a moral Rubicon. Ceding godlike powers to robots reduces human beings to things with no more intrinsic value than any object.

When robots rule warfare, utterly without empathy or compassion, humans retain less intrinsic worth than a toaster—which at least can be used for spare parts. In civilized societies, even our enemies possess inherent worth and are considered persons, a recognition that forms the basis of the Geneva Conventions and rules of military engagement.

I would go farther than the authors of the op-ed do. I would contend that developing robotic weapons with “full lethal autonomy” is inherently a war crime. Gen. Latiff and Mr. McCloskey do not mention the “Three Laws” in their op-ed but I think it’s time to bring them back into the discussion.

War is death and destruction. The trend of the last forty years in the United States has been to lower the transaction costs of war through air warfare, guided missiles, the volunteer army, and, now, unmanned drones. There should always be a presumption against war but, as the transaction costs of war grow lower, the internalized prohibitions in law, politics, and social conscience must become greater.

Human beings, unfortunately, do not come with the “Three Laws” built into them. We should strive to make our creations better than ourselves in that respect.

20 comments

Go and Repair My House

Quite a few people, including Peggy Noonan, are referring to Bonaventure’s Life of Francis. The famous anecdote about Francis hearing a voice coming from a cross directing him to “Go, and repair my house, which is falling into ruin” is from Bonaventure’s Life.

Bonaventure could not have known Francis personally—Francis died when Bonaventure was a small child. It’s likely he was acquainted both with Brother Leo and Thomas of Celano. How well is not known.

Bonaventure’s Life of Francis is frequently given as a primary source on Francis but I’m skeptical. It’s too much the life of a saint. It’s too much a legend. As important a work as it is, I consider Bonaventure’s Life of Francis to be a secondary source and, since my post yesterday focused on the historical Francis, I omitted it there.

12 comments

Hope

Raymond de Souza remarks on what the election of Francis I means to the Church:

How will he lead the Church? It is too early to tell, but he sent two clear signals last night, unmistakable to papal Rome. He appeared in the simple papal cassock, declining to wear the accompanying red shoulder cape that his predecessors have always worn. Benedict XVI’s preferred liturgical style thus did not survive the first minutes of the new pontificate.

Additionally, he declined to use the term “pope emeritus” for Benedict, referring to him instead as “bishop emeritus,” thereby taking sides in a dispute within the Vatican about what Benedict should be called. Small things? Yes, but deliberate choices from an experienced pastor.

Rome has a new bishop. The world has a new pope. Pope Francis has a new program for his pontificate.

We can always hope.

38 comments

Francis

Much is being made of the newly elected pope’s taking of the name “Francis”. It’s been suggested that the name jointly invokes Francis of Assisi and Francis Xavier, one of the first Jesuits. I thought I’d take this opportunity to make a few remarks about Francis of Assisi. Many people have seen the familiar portraits of him, frequently surrounded by animals, but I thought I’d talk about the historical Francis.

Francesco di Pietro di Bernardone, born in 1181 in Assisi, a small, ancient town smack dab in the middle of the Italian peninsula, must have been a truly remarkable human being. He attracted an enormous following, mainly by force of personality, and created institutions, the Franciscan Order, the women’s Order of St. Clare, and the Third Order of Saint Francis, that have survived for a millennium dedicated to serving the poor and preaching the Gospel in conditions of extreme austerity without the ostentation of some austere religious movements.

He is, perhaps, one of the earliest important religious figures that we can have confidence actually existed. The portrait in this post, from the Sacro Speco in Subiaco, has been authenticated as having been painted from life when Francis visited there in 1216.

In the past skepticism about historical sources and figures, particularly from the ancient past, has been a common theme here. I think that we have very good reason to believe that Francis lived and that he did many of the things attributed to him. Some of his writings and writings about him by people who actually knew him have come down to us with solid provenances, something rare in very old historical materials.

Francis’s writings that have come down to us consist mainly of a few prayers, some letters, three rules he wrote for the religious orders he founded, his testament, and an odd little piece called “Perfect Joy”.

Francis’s Testament, written shortly before he died in 1226, is an account by Francis of his life, calling, and works.

Perfect Joy is an anecdote recorded by his early companion, Leo. It gives an idea of how severe a model Francis set.

Of the writings by Francis’s close associates among the most significant and informative about Francis are the “Mirror of Perfection” and “The First Life of St. Francis”.

The Mirror of Perfection is a polemic, written by Leo, recording Francis’s responses and reactions to errors which had crept into his order. I find it rather tough sledding but, again, it gives you the idea of how severe a model he set.

The First Life of St. Francis was written by an early follower of Francis’s, Thomas of Cerrano. Thomas had met Francis but probably did not know him well. He had access to many of Francis’s earliest followers and closest companions. The Life was written shortly after Francis was canonized a saint in 1228. It suffers by being, clearly, the life of a saint. I don’t find quite the vibrancy or vitality in it I see in Francis’s own works and those of his close associates.

I find reading Francis’s works and those of his close associates a very emotional, moving, even difficult experience. It makes me recognize how mean, trivial, and imperfect a person I am.

Here’s Francis’s blessing for his associate, Leo:

May the Lord
bless you and keep you.
May He show His face to you
and be merciful to you.
May He turn His countenance to you
and give you peace.

I don’t know that any human being in history has better exemplified than Francis the prescription of the prophet Micah: “Do justice. Love mercy. Walk humbly with your God.”

15 comments

James Hamilton on Debt

I want to draw your attention to an interesting if wonkish post by James Hamilton summarizing his findings on the economic impact of external debt and Paul Krugman’s criticism of Dr. Hamilton’s recent WSJ op-ed. Here’s his retort:

It is true that you won’t find statistical confirmation of the nonlinearities reported in equation (3) if you confine yourself to recent experience in the major non-eurozone advanced economies. There’s a simple reason for that– these countries have not yet reached the tipping point in the dynamics of fiscal debt loads.

Are Krugman and O’Brien claiming that they never could? Do they maintain that U.S. debt could become an arbitrarily large multiple of GDP with no consequences for yields? If they acknowledge that there is a level of debt at which these effects would start to matter for the United States, what is their estimate of that level, and how did they arrive at it?

In our paper we offer our answer to these questions. We conclude that a country’s debt limit depends on its borrowing rate, its economic growth rate, and the fraction of GDP that the public is willing to commit to maintaining a permanent primary surplus– that is, government revenues minus spending on all items other than interest expense. If Krugman, O’Brien, or anybody else thinks they have some other answer, let them articulate it clearly and cleanly.

Whether a country is able to borrow in its own currency is completely irrelevant for the above calculation. Yes, it means the country likely won’t technically default on the debt, and could always create new money to pay off the creditors. But as Reis (2013) and Leeper (2013) have recently explained, printing money does not generate any magical resources with which to resolve a real fiscal shortfall. The central bank could create some more inflation, but anticipated inflation does nothing to alter the above determination of the limits on government debt.

20 comments

White Smoke

After what is to me a surprisingly short period of time, the College of Cardinals has elected a new pope:

VATICAN CITY — Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina was elected pope Wednesday, becoming the first pontiff from the Americas and taking the name Pope Francis I.

Appearing on the balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica a short time later, the new pope greeted a vast crowd gathered below in St. Peter’s Square with salutations in Italian and led a prayer for his predecessor, Benedict XVI.

“As you know, the duty of the conclave was to appoint a bishop of Rome, and it seems to me that my brother cardinals went to fetch him at the end of the world,” he said. “But here I am.”

There are number of interesting things about Francis I. First, he’s the first non-European to become pope in over a millennium. The last was in 731 AD, a Syrian.

Second, he’s a Jesuit. If he’s 76 now that would make him a bit younger than the youngest of my high school teachers. Nonetheless, I suspect being a Jesuit provides some insight into the habits of mind we might expect from him. Like all ordained Jesuits he has received an advanced degree, presumably a doctorate in theology.

Third, he’s 76. That’s just about the same age as Benedict XVI was when he became pope, significantly older than John Paul II was when he became pope, and a bit older than Paul VI when he became pope.

Fourth, he’s not part of the Vatican bureaucracy.

He is reputed to have a close relationship with the people of his archdiocese and to live a simple, even austere lifestyle. He’s no a scholar like Benedict XVI or an intellectual like John Paul II. By reputation he is a hands-on pastor.

His election to the papacy is clearly a departure from the past. What else it implies is the wildest of speculation. We’ll just need to wait and see.

1 comment

The Wave of the Pasture

Todd Woody, generally sympathetic with alternative fuels, notes that alternative fuels have been having a very bad couple of years:

The numbers are in on 2012 and it was not the best of years for renewable energy, according to a report released today by market research firm Clean Edge.

After years of breakneck growth, the value of global wind industry installations rose by just $2.3 billion from the previous year to $73.8 billion in 2012. Worldwide wind capacity jumped to a record 44,700 megawatts, but that was only about 8% up on the previous year.

The value of photovoltaic installations actually fell for the first time, from $91.6 billion in 2011 to $79.7 billion in 2012, as solar panel prices continued to plummet and Chinese manufacturers grappled with overcapacity. Total solar capacity hit a record 30,900 megawatts in 2012 but revenues fell for the first time in a dozen years.

Biofuels were the one bright spot, with the market growing to $95.2 billion in 2012 from $83 billion the previous year.

Generally speaking, “biofuels” is another way of saying “turning food into fuel”. In that context I’m not sure that “bright spot” is a good way of characterizing increased sales of biofuels.

Let’s tentatively file this story under the department of “Whatever Can’t Be Sustained Won’t”. Alternative energy benefited by enormous amounts of government subsidy from the United States, Germany, Spain, and China, just to name a few. When the subsidies dried up, there were no ready replacements waiting in the wings and they can’t stand on their own.

That might be possible some time in the future. But it doesn’t look very likely now.

3 comments