The States Have Perverse Incentives, Too

One of the big news stories of the last half dozen years is the startling growth in the number of people on disability. That doesn’t seem to have happened because people are getting sicker or older.

As it turns out the states have powerful incentives to move people from the welfare rolls, where they pay a big share of the tab, to disability where they pay none of it. The incentives are so powerful that they’re willing to pay companies to get the job done.

7 comments

The Arc Doesn’t Bend At All

For those of you who think that public opinion trends in an ever-more-liberal direction and that all that needs to happen is for some old, white people to die, you might want to look at the trend in public opinion on abortion over the last 40 years as determined by the Gallup organization. You may struggle to find more acceptance of abortion in that graph but what it actually shows is that any change is just noise—within the margin of error.

If anything, I think the United States is likely to become less socially and economically liberal over time. One of my favorite posts of mine is on the effect of immigrants on American political thought. Their beliefs are the one thing that immigrants are certain to bring with them when they arrive here. For the last generation or so the immigrants we’ve been importing haven’t been European social democrats. They’ve been Third World social conservatives. The demographics of Latin America and the Caribbean suggests either that future immigration to the United States will be much slower than it has been for the last three or four decades or that it will come from sub-Saharan Africa. Over time I think we’re likely to become less like Sweden and more like Mexico than the other way around.

Now it may well be true that over very long periods the arc of the moral universe bends towards justice. I doubt that I’ll live to see it.

24 comments

Bricks Without Straw

Once again the main themes emerging in the blogosphere and in the major media outlets are pretty slim pickings. Yes, President Obama is turning his attention to the situation in the Middle East. Practically every president in my lifetime has done so. The president won’t have any more success than his predecessors did because the problems there are just not that sort of problem.

The Supreme Court is hearing its two cases on the subject of marriage between homosexuals. I strongly suspect that the Court will strike down the Defense of Marriage Act and uphold the Ninth Circuit’s findings on California’s Proposition 8, in both cases by votes of 5-4. That would be, unfortunately, both incoherent and highly divisive. It would be incoherent because the two decisions taken together would require the states to define marriage (rather than the federal government) and prohibit them from doing so. By comparison Roe v. Wade was decided 7-2. Nothing I write will inform anybody or convince anybody or change anything. Why bother?

Nothing will change in domestic policy—whether we’re talking about the economy, healthcare, the environment, or anything else—until we change our assumptions. Any change in our assumptions will require the Powers-That-Be to surrender something so I strongly suspect they’ll fight like hell to prevent the change we need.

1 comment

The Scribe’s Cat

I love this picture. We don’t know much about the medieval Croatian scribe who transcribed that manuscript but we do know that he had a cat:

While pawing through a stack of medieval manuscripts from Dubrovnik, Croatia, University of Sarajevo doctoral student Emir O. Filipović stumbled upon a familiar set of splotches marring the centuries-old pages. Years ago, a mischievous kitty had left her ink-covered prints on the book.

1 comment

Cost Reduction Without Preservation of Function

Here’s a story that I found fascinating. Wal-Mart apparently can’t keep its shelves stocked because it doesn’t have the employees to do it:

It’s not as though the merchandise isn’t there. It’s piling up in aisles and in the back of stores because Wal-Mart doesn’t have enough bodies to restock the shelves, according to interviews with store workers. In the past five years, the world’s largest retailer added 455 U.S. Wal-Mart stores, a 13 percent increase, according to filings and the company’s website. In the same period, its total U.S. workforce, which includes Sam’s Club employees, dropped by about 20,000, or 1.4 percent. Wal-Mart employs about 1.4 million U.S. workers.

Other problems cited include long checkout lines, lack of customer assistance, and general disorganization.

And the problem may actually be getting worse:

Last month, Bloomberg News reported that Wal-Mart was “getting worse” at stocking shelves, according to minutes of an officers’ meeting. An executive vice president had been appointed to work on the restocking issue, according to the document.

At the supercenter across the street from Wal-Mart’s Bentonville, Arkansas, home office, salespeople on March 14 handed out samples of Chobani yogurt and Clif Bars. Thirteen of 20 registers were manned — with no lines — and the shelves were fully stocked.

Three days earlier, about 10 people waited in a customer service line at a Wal-Mart in Secaucus, New Jersey, across the Hudson River from New York, the nation’s largest city. Twelve of 30 registers were open and the lines were about five deep. There were empty spaces on shelves large enough for a grown man to lie down, and a woman wandered around vainly seeking a frying pan.

Wal-Mart’s restocking challenge coincides with slowing sales growth. Same-store sales in the U.S. for the 13 weeks ending April 26 will be little changed, Bill Simon, the company’s U.S. chief executive officer, said in a Feb. 21 earnings call.

Wal-Mart stock has risen sharply over the last couple of years after being flat for most of the last decade. The formula that the company hit one, increasing the number of stores while decreasing the number of employees, does not appear to have been a happy one. Except for the major stakeholders: the members of the Walton family purportedly own 43% of the company’s stock and I presume that stock dividends are their main source of income. That’s a powerful incentive to cut costs whatever the outcome.

26 comments

Will Jobs Ever Recover?

Quite a few people are taking note of a recent report suggesting that the unemployment/underemployment that has come in the wake of the Great Recession may be permanent. From the report itself:

While there has been substantial debate over this question in recent years, we believe that considerable added insight can be derived by focusing on changes in the labour market at the turn of the century. In particular, we argue that in about the year 2000, the demand for skill (or, more speci cally, for cognitive tasks often associated with high educational skill) underwent a reversal. Many researchers have documented a strong, ongoing increase in the demand for skills in the decades leading up to 2000. In this paper, we document a decline in that demand in the years since 2000, even as the supply of high education workers continues to grow. We go on to show that, in response to this demand reversal, high-skilled workers have moved down the occupational ladder and have begun to perform jobs traditionally performed by lower-skilled workers. This de-skilling process, in turn, results in high-skilled workers pushing low-skilled workers even further down the occupational ladder and, to some degree, out of the labor force all together.

The Wall Street Journal observes:

David Autor, an economist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who has studied issues of skills and education, called Mr. Beaudry’s thesis “provocative” but also “speculative.” There is no question, Mr. Autor said, that the wage premium enjoyed by college graduates hasn’t grown as quickly during the 2000s as in earlier decades. But whether that is the result of a glut of degree holders or some other explanation isn’t yet clear.

James Joyner remarks:

The advantages of superior intelligence and higher education have continued, even expanded. But more and more of those people have moved into positions that previously didn’t require those advantages, displacing those who would otherwise have held those jobs.

I think that Dr. Beaudry’s hypothesis is interesting but raises some questions. Why did employment continue to rise throughout the 2000s, only declining in 2007? Why is employment still growing in some sectors but not in others?

My own view is somewhat different from Dr. Beaudry’s. I think that

  • Since the great decline in employment didn’t take place until 2007, technology doesn’t explain it.
  • There’s been a lot of thrashing in technology but the biggest changes over the last ten years are the growth of social media and the rise of the smartphone. Those don’t explain the loss of jobs or their failure to recover.
  • The number of people unemployed or underemployed since 2007 is around 20 million. If technology is the reason, why aren’t 50 million unemployed/underemployed? Why aren’t 80 million? Why, following Maxine Waters, aren’t 150 million?
  • If technology has permanently eliminated jobs, why do some many manager complain they can’t find the people they need?
  • The reason that jobs haven’t recovered is that economic activity is too slow for the number of jobs to grow.
  • The reason that economic activity is too slow is that we’ve been throwing too much money at finance, healthcare, and education.
  • Finance, healthcare, and education produce fewer jobs per dollar input or per output than any number of other sectors.
  • Infrastructure spending (defined as building roads and bridges) produces relatively few new jobs. The contractors already own plenty of equipment and can execute the work with the crews they have.
  • Healthcare and education in particular have been quite successful in preventing technological change from resulting in lower wages.

just as a start. In future posts some related topics like where will the jobs of the future come from and what happens if technology actually has eliminated a large number of jobs.

Let’s not conclude we’ve jumped into the 23rd century too fast.

12 comments

What Recovery?

I’m reading a lot of crowing about a housing recovery based on the year-on-year improvement in the Case-Shiller index as of January 2013. Quite a few people are reproducing one of the charts from that post, the one that shows a sharp recovery in the percentage increase over time.

The same release, linked above, has another chart in it and I’ve reproduced that one here. As you can see it shows the increase in housing prices from 1987 to date. Does that look like a recovery to you? Prices are back where they were in 2003. Whoopee. Happy days are here again. Of course, the value of the dollar as measured, say, in how much healthcare or education you can buy with it isn’t quite the same as it was in 2003.

Another aspect of the chart bears mentioning. To my eye it looks as though we can trace the housing bubble to some time in 2002 (there’s an arguemnt for the late 90s, too). That would mean that housing potentially has another twenty or thirty percent to give up before the effects of the bubble are fully dissipated. Offhand I’d say that the only thing that would save us from that would be the increase in the population over the last decade. Of course, today’s first time home buyers don’t have nearly as much money to spend as the typical seller. That couldn’t possibly put any downwards pressure on prices, now could it?

37 comments

Rise Stevens, 1913-2013

Rise Stevens (pronounced REE-zah), American operatic mezzo-soprano of the 1940s and 1950s, has died:

Rise Stevens, an American mezzo soprano celebrated for her earthy interpretation of “Carmen,” whose career also encompassed television and movie appearances alongside matinee idols Bing Crosby and Nelson Eddy, died Wednesdayof natural causes at her home in New York. She was 99.

Her death was confirmed by her son, Nicolas Surovy.

Stevens sang for the Metropolitan Opera for more than two decades beginning in 1938. She was known for her sensuous voice, described by the International Dictionary of Opera as “pure velvet.”

She was most famous for her portrayal of the central character in Georges Bizet’s “Carmen,” a role she performed 124 times for the Met with tenor Richard Tucker, her frequent co-star, playing Don Jose.

Here she is in an appearance singing the “Habañ” from Bizet’s Carmen in what I believe is a Met performance broadcast on PBS in 1951:

That may have been the same performance as was shown in motion picture theaters in 1952. I’m not really sure.

Here she is with Nelson Eddy in the finale of The Chocolate Soldier (1941):

Most of the those who know of her nowadays probably remember her performance in the Bing Crosby perennial Going My Way.

One of the great talents. She was 99 years old.

2 comments

Confused About Intelligence

I was actually saddened by this article on animal intelligence:

Who is smarter: a person or an ape? Well, it depends on the task. Consider Ayumu, a young male chimpanzee at Kyoto University who, in a 2007 study, put human memory to shame. Trained on a touch screen, Ayumu could recall a random series of nine numbers, from 1 to 9, and tap them in the right order, even though the numbers had been displayed for just a fraction of a second and then replaced with white squares.

I tried the task myself and could not keep track of more than five numbers—and I was given much more time than the brainy ape. In the study, Ayumu outperformed a group of university students by a wide margin. The next year, he took on the British memory champion Ben Pridmore and emerged the “chimpion.”

since it very clearly suggested that neither its author nor the researchers referenced knew what in the dickens they were talking about. They aren’t testing intelligence. They’re comparing the memories of chimps with those of literate and post-literate human beings.

We don’t need to have good memories. We have libraries. And Google. It would be amazing if we had really good memories.

However, our ancestors who were primarily oral had excellent memories. How else do you think that Greek bards could remember the Iliad? Or Hindu poets the Ramayana?

I do think that non-human animals are more intelligent than most give them credit for. Or, more accurately, that humans aren’t as much more intelligent than other animals as we give ourselves credit for. Or, more accurately still, that there isn’t human intelligence on the one hand and animal intelligence on the other.

4 comments

A Dissertation on Sauerkraut

Tonight we’re having sauerkraut, knockwurst, and mashed potatoes for dinner. My recipe is pretty simple. Chop a small onion, core, peel and chop a small apple, and put them in a pot with a pound of sauerkraut and a bottle of beer. Add caraway if you like caraway. Simmer for about twenty minutes. Add two knockwurst and simmer for an additional 15 minutes. That’s it.

Whenever I eat sauerkraut it invariably occurs to me that it’s probably the only thing that kept my ancestors alive in the wintertime. A smallish 100 gm. serving of sauerkraut has nearly 20% of your daily requirement of vitamin C. You won’t get scurvy as long as you’re eating sauerkraut.

There’s nothing magical about sauerkraut. It’s basically just pickled cabbage. The sour taste comes from lactic acid, the natural product of fermentation. If you can get ahold of some unpasteurized sauerkraut, generally sold in jars, you can get a sourer taste from your homemade sauerkraut by inoculating it with unpasteurized sauerkraut you’ve bought, a sort of sourdough process.

Although it’s generally associated with Germanic cultures, sauerkraut in one form or another is made and eaten wherever cabbages grow, from Ireland to China and as far south as Italy and the Balkans. Not all sauerkraut is chopped. Whole pickled cabbage is great if you can get it. Nothing like it for making stuffed cabbage leaves.

7 comments